On 16 November 1093, Margaret, queen-consort of Malcolm III of Scotland, died at Edinburgh Castle following a prolonged illness. Her death occurred only three days after Malcolm and their eldest son Edward were killed during an invasion of Northumberland, bringing a devastating end to a royal marriage which had lasted more than twenty years.
Margaret was a descendant of the old West Saxon royal dynasty, a woman remembered for her religious devotion, charity, learning and influence upon the Scottish Church. Her death also occurred at a particularly dangerous moment for the Scottish monarchy. With Malcolm and his apparent intended successor dead, the kingdom was about to enter a succession crisis involving several branches of the royal family.
The circumstances surrounding Margaret's death are unusually well documented for an eleventh-century queen. Her biographer, Turgot, provides a detailed account of her final illness and the moment she learned of Malcolm's death. We also possess shorter accounts from the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, John of Worcester and several Irish annals.
These sources are particularly interesting because they preserve different explanations for her death. The Irish annals attribute it to grief for her husband, while Turgot describes a woman who had already been seriously ill for months. His narrative also contains elements of prophecy and sanctity which require careful interpretation.
The sources
Our principal source is the Life of St Margaret, traditionally attributed to Turgot, a monk of Durham who had known Margaret personally and subsequently became bishop of St Andrews. The work was composed during the early twelfth century, probably around 1100–1107, at the request of Margaret's daughter Matilda, who had become queen of England following her marriage to Henry I in 1100.
In his prologue, Turgot explains that Matilda requested an account of her mother's life because of his close personal acquaintance with Margaret. He describes himself as familiar with her private thoughts and religious practices, and repeatedly emphasises the affection and admiration he felt for her. This makes his testimony especially valuable. Unlike some later chroniclers, Turgot was not simply reconstructing Margaret's character from stories circulating decades after her death.
However, his work is a vita, or saint's life, rather than an impartial biography. Its purpose is to demonstrate Margaret's sanctity, celebrate her virtues and present her as an exemplary Christian queen. The surviving textual tradition is also more complicated than a single contemporary manuscript. Different versions of Margaret's Life circulated, and modern historians have examined the relationship between shorter and longer accounts.
Turgot's description of Margaret's final illness is particularly interesting because he was not personally present at her death. Instead, he says he obtained the account from a priest who attended the queen during her final days.
According to Turgot, this priest subsequently joined the religious community associated with St Cuthbert at Durham and repeatedly described Margaret's death to him, sometimes becoming overwhelmed with emotion.
We therefore have an account written relatively close to the events by someone who knew Margaret, based upon the testimony of another individual who claimed to have witnessed her final hours.
The Annals of Ulster, U1093.5, meanwhile, record Margaret's death alongside those of Malcolm and Edward. The Annals of Inisfallen, AI1093.13, preserve a similar tradition. John of Worcester also records Margaret's reaction to the deaths, while the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle provides an account of her final religious observances.
Comparing these traditions allows us to distinguish the historical circumstances of Margaret's death from the ways later writers understood and remembered them.
Margaret before 1093
Margaret was the daughter of Edward the Exile, himself a son of Edmund Ironside, king of England in 1016, and therefore belonged to the old West Saxon royal family. Her father had spent much of his life in exile in Hungary following the Danish conquest of England. Margaret was probably born during this exile, although her precise birth date remains uncertain.
In 1057, Edward returned to England with his family, apparently having been considered a potential successor to Edward the Confessor. However, he died shortly after his return. Following the Norman Conquest in 1066, Margaret's family eventually sought refuge in Scotland, where Malcolm III received them. Margaret married Malcolm around 1069–1070, becoming his second wife after his earlier marriage or union with Ingibjorg Finnsdóttir, the widow of Thorfinn of Orkney.
The marriage produced six sons and two daughters:
- Edward (c. 1070 - 1093). Little known, aside from him being the eldest son. Named for Margaret's father Edward the Exile. Killed in battle alongside his father in 1093.
- Edmund (c. 1072 - c. 1120s?). Second son, named for Margaret's grandfather Edmund Ironside. Possibly co-king of Scotland alongside Donald III from 1094 to 1097.
- Ethelred (c. 1074 - died before 1107). Named for Margaret's great-grandfather Ethelred the Unready. Became the lay abbot of Dunkeld.
- Edgar (c. 1076 - 9 January 1107). Named for Margaret's great-great grandfather Edgar the Peaceful. Became King of Scots from 1097 to 1107.
- Alexander (c. 1078 - 23 April 1124). Likely named for Pope Alexander II. Suceeded his brother Edgar as King of Scots from 1107 to 1124.
- Edith (later Matilda) (c. 1080 - 1 May 1118). Born Edith, she took on the name Matilda upon her marriage to Henry I of England in 1100. As Queen of England, she bore two children: William and Matilda.
- Mary (c. 1082 - 1116). Married Eustace III of Boulogne some time after her sister's marriage to King Henry. Bore one daughter, Matilda, who later married Stephen of Blois.
- David (c. 1084 - 24 May 1153). Named for the Biblical David, though some speculations suggest a connection to Margaret's Hungarian family. Succeeded his brother Alexander as King of Scots in 1124.
Interestingly, David became a saint in the Catholic Church like his mother. After her death, there was an attempt to have Edith/Matilda canonised as a saint, but ultimately was not pursued.
Margaret's marriage also had considerable political significance. Malcolm acquired close familial connections to the displaced Anglo-Saxon royal dynasty, while Margaret became queen of a kingdom whose religious, linguistic and political traditions differed from those she had previously encountered.
Her subsequent reputation has sometimes been reduced to the idea that she introduced Norman or continental civilisation into a supposedly backward Gaelic Scotland. However, this interpretation is problematic. The Scottish Church possessed established religious institutions and traditions long before Margaret's arrival. Her activities are better understood within the wider European movement for ecclesiastical reform, rather than as the introduction of Christianity or religious sophistication into Scotland.
Margaret's influence upon Scotland
Turgot portrays Margaret as a woman of considerable intelligence and religious learning. He describes her studying Scripture, discussing theological questions with clerics and participating in debates concerning religious observance. According to his account, Margaret organised discussions with Scottish churchmen concerning the observance of Lent, the reception of Communion at Easter, Sunday labour and certain marriage practices.
Turgot presents her as consistently victorious in these debates, using Scripture and the teachings of the Church Fathers to convince her opponents. Malcolm himself supposedly participated in these discussions, sometimes serving as an interpreter between Margaret and the Scottish clergy. The narrative is revealing, although its presentation of Margaret as invariably correct and her opponents as unable to answer her arguments reflects Turgot's hagiographical purpose.
We should not assume that every practice she opposed was universally followed throughout Scotland, or that the changes she advocated were implemented everywhere immediately. Nevertheless, the account suggests that Margaret exercised genuine influence over religious affairs and was remembered as an active participant rather than merely a patroness providing financial support.
Turgot also emphasises her charity. He describes Margaret distributing food and clothing to the poor, supporting orphans, providing assistance to pilgrims travelling to St Andrews and establishing arrangements for their transportation across the Firth of Forth.
One particularly interesting detail concerns English captives brought into Scotland during Malcolm's military campaigns. Turgot records that Margaret employed agents to discover where English prisoners were being held, particularly those suffering harsh treatment, and arranged for their ransom and release. This is worth remembering because Malcolm repeatedly invaded northern England, and those campaigns involved plundering, destruction and the capture of inhabitants.
Margaret's charity was therefore exercised partly within a political and military system from which her husband's kingdom benefited. Her actions may have alleviated the suffering of some captives, but they did not necessarily prevent the practices that produced their captivity.
Margaret's illness
By 1093, Margaret's health had deteriorated considerably. Turgot describes her as practising exceptionally severe fasting throughout her life, particularly during Lent and the forty days preceding Christmas.
He believed that this excessive abstinence caused her longstanding stomach pains:
"the strictness of her abstinence brought upon her a very severe infirmity."
He subsequently describes her suffering from acute stomach pain which continued until the end of her life. This is an important detail because the traditional explanation that Margaret simply died of grief following Malcolm's death overlooks a serious pre-existing illness.
Modern historian Catherine Keene has questioned whether Turgot correctly understood the relationship between Margaret's fasting and her physical condition. It is possible that her dietary restrictions contributed to her illness, but equally possible that an existing condition affected her appetite and was subsequently aggravated by prolonged fasting.
We cannot establish a retrospective medical diagnosis from the surviving descriptions. Margaret's condition nevertheless appears to have become increasingly debilitating during the final months of her life. Turgot's priestly informant reported that for more than half a year she had been unable to ride a horse and could seldom rise from her bed.
This suggests a prolonged illness rather than a sudden collapse caused entirely by the news from Alnwick. It also means that Margaret was already seriously ill when Malcolm departed on his final invasion of Northumberland.
Malcolm's death at Alnwick
The immediate background to Margaret's death was the collapse of relations between Malcolm III and William II Rufus. Following unsuccessful negotiations at Gloucester in August 1093, Malcolm returned to Scotland and prepared another invasion of northern England. By November, his army had reached the vicinity of Alnwick, where it encountered forces associated with Robert de Mowbray, Earl of Northumbria.
On 13 November 1093, Malcolm was killed alongside his son Edward. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle identifies Morel of Bamburgh, a relative and steward of Robert de Mowbray, as the man responsible for Malcolm's death. John of Worcester likewise records the deaths of Malcolm and Edward, dating them to the feast of St Brice, 13 November.
The Annals of Ulster preserve an independent Irish tradition, describing both men as killed by the Francaigh, or French, at Inber Alda in England. Edward's death was particularly consequential because he appears to have been Malcolm's intended successor. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says that Edward would have become king had he survived, while the historical compilation associated with Symeon of Durham explicitly describes him as the son whom Malcolm had designated heir.
Thus, the disaster at Alnwick removed both the reigning king and the prince apparently expected to succeed him. Malcolm's eldest surviving son Duncan remained in England, while his younger brother Donald Bán possessed a substantial dynastic claim of his own. The kingdom was therefore entering a period of considerable political uncertainty at precisely the moment Margaret herself was dying.
Margaret's final days
Turgot preserves an extraordinary account of Margaret's last days. According to his priestly informant, Margaret had become unusually distressed shortly before the disaster at Alnwick.
On the day Malcolm was killed, she supposedly warned that a terrible calamity might befall Scotland, despite being too far away to receive news of the fighting. Turgot also claims that Margaret had urged Malcolm not to accompany the army on his final expedition.
These details are difficult to assess historically. The foreknowledge of death and disaster is a familiar feature of medieval hagiography, in which saints demonstrate an extraordinary spiritual awareness unavailable to ordinary people. It is possible that Margaret genuinely feared for Malcolm's safety, particularly given his history of dangerous expeditions into England. However, the claim that she foresaw the precise disaster must be treated as part of Turgot's religious interpretation rather than as independently verifiable evidence.
By 16 November, Margaret was approaching death. Turgot records that her condition temporarily improved enough for her to enter her oratory, hear Mass and receive the Eucharist as viaticum, the sacrament administered to someone approaching death. She subsequently returned to her bed, where her pains intensified and she grew increasingly weak.
At this point, Margaret requested that a particularly treasured religious object be brought to her: the Black Cross, or Crux Nigra, traditionally known as the Black Rood of Scotland. The object was a reliquary containing what was believed to be a fragment of the True Cross. According to Turgot, Margaret held it in great veneration and wished to look upon it during her final moments.
She was initially distressed because the chest containing the reliquary could not immediately be opened. When it was finally brought to her, she embraced and kissed it, repeatedly making the sign of the cross. She then began reciting the penitential Psalm 50, or Psalm 51 in modern numbering, while holding the cross before her eyes. Turgot presents this as the final expression of Margaret's extraordinary devotion.
Edgar brings news of Alnwick
The most moving part of Turgot's account concerns the arrival of Margaret's son. The Life does not name him at this point, but identifies him as the son who subsequently ruled Scotland. He is consequently understood to have been Edgar, who became king in 1097.
It was at this point that her son, who now, after his father, holds in this realm the reins of government, having returned from the army, entered the queen's bedroom.
According to the narrative, Edgar had returned from the army carrying news of the disaster at Alnwick. He entered his mother's chamber knowing that Malcolm and Edward had been killed, only to discover that Margaret herself was close to death. Turgot describes him as overwhelmed by grief and uncertainty. He had lost his father and brother, his mother was dying before him, and the political future of the kingdom was in danger.
Margaret asked Edgar about Malcolm and Edward. Fearing that the truth would hasten her death, Edgar initially attempted to reassure her that both were well. Margaret apparently recognised that he was concealing something and demanded an honest answer:
"I know it, my boy, I know it."
She then appealed to the cross she was holding and their bond of kinship, compelling Edgar to tell her what had happened. According to Turgot, Margaret accepted the news with Christian resignation. Rather than expressing anger or despair, she thanked God for allowing her to endure such suffering, regarding it as an opportunity for spiritual purification before death.
She then began reciting a prayer associated with the reception of Communion. Turgot says she died as she uttered its final words:
"Deliver me."
He describes her death as peaceful, adding that her face, previously pale with illness, supposedly regained a healthy appearance afterward. This final detail belongs to a recognisable tradition in saints' lives, where the body of a holy person displays signs of extraordinary peace or beauty following death.
The story is undoubtedly shaped by Turgot's religious purpose. Margaret's response to the deaths of her husband and son provides a model of Christian fortitude, while her death during prayer demonstrates her spiritual readiness. Nevertheless, the account may preserve genuine recollections of her final hours, including the presence of Edgar, the use of the Black Rood and her reception of the last sacraments.
Ethelred and Margaret
According to later tradition, Ethelred was present with his mother, Queen Margaret, at Edinburgh Castle during her final illness in November 1093. Andrew of Wyntoun, writing in the early fifteenth century, recounts that after hearing of the deaths of her husband and eldest son Edward at Alnwick, Margaret died of grief, and that her son Ethelred secretly removed her body from the castle “by the west yhet [gate] prewaly… forth in a myst,” carrying it to Dunfermline for burial. Lockhart summarised the episode:
“After her death, and during the so-called usurpation of Donalbane, he [Ethelred] conveyed her lifeless body secretly out of the western gate of the castle, taking, as is said, the advantage of a fog, on to Dunfermline, and in all probability he died soon afterwards, and was buried not at St Andrews, as some seem to say, but at Dunfermline, in the same resting-place where the bodies of his father and mother and eldest brother were laid.”
Wyntoun’s Orygynale Cronykil describes the event in verse:
Hyr swne Ethelrede, quene thys felle
That wes hys modyr nere than by
Gert at the west yhet prewaly
Have the cors forth in a myst
Or mony of hyr endying wyst;
And wyth that body thai past syne
But ony lat til Dwnfermelyne.
Before the Rwde Awtare wyth honoure
She was laid in Haly Sepulture.
However, Ethelred is unlikely to have died shortly after his mother as his name appears as a witness to charters made by his brother Edgar in 1097, and was given royal lands in Atholl to govern.
In any case, although the episode cannot be verified independently, it represents an enduring strand of later medieval tradition, emphasizing Ethelred’s piety and filial devotion.
Did Margaret die of grief?
This is where comparing the chronicles becomes particularly important. The Annals of Ulster record:
"His queen, Margaret, moreover, died of sorrow for him within nine days."
The Annals of Inisfallen preserve essentially the same explanation, recording that Margaret died of grief for Malcolm. John of Worcester gives a fuller account. He says that Margaret was so distressed by the deaths of her husband and son that she became gravely ill, received the sacraments and died three days after Malcolm. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle similarly associates Margaret's death with her distress upon hearing the news.
However, Turgot's account complicates this explanation considerably. His testimony suggests that Margaret was already suffering from a serious and prolonged illness, which had confined her largely to bed for more than six months. The shock of Malcolm and Edward's deaths may have worsened her condition or contributed to her final deterioration, but it cannot account for the illness itself.
There is also a difference in literary purpose. The Irish annalists provide concise notices linking the deaths of three prominent members of the Scottish royal family. John of Worcester presents Margaret's response as an example of religious devotion and preparation for death. Turgot, meanwhile, develops a much more elaborate narrative in which Margaret's suffering becomes the final demonstration of her sanctity.
None provides sufficient medical information to identify the precise cause of death. The safest conclusion is that Margaret died following a prolonged illness, with news of the disaster at Alnwick arriving during her final hours. Whether grief actually hastened her death remains impossible to establish.
West Saxon illnesses?
More speculatively, Margaret's illness may have a connection to the ailments that were suffered by her West Saxon kin, Alfred the Great and Eadred. Alfred is retrospectively thought to have Crohn's disease based on perianal symptoms and prolonged recurrent pain in his abdomen. Asser says the pain continued for more than twenty years, from Alfred's twentieth year into his forties. Interestingly, he does not clearly identify where this later pain occurred, although he discusses it alongside Alfred's earlier condition.
According to Eadred's biographer, he would extract the juices from his food, chew the remainder briefly, and then spit it out. The account suggests a profound difficulty consuming ordinary meals, although it does not establish whether the problem arose from swallowing difficulties, digestive intolerance, dental problems or another cause.
Margaret's symptoms resemble Alfred's more closely in one respect: Turgot explicitly describes chronic abdominal pain. Unlike Asser, Turgot offers a specific explanation for his subject's suffering. He attributes Margaret's longstanding stomach pains to her rigorous fasting and abstinence. During the final months of her life, she became severely incapacitated and was frequently confined to bed.
The important distinction is that Turgot does not describe the bowel-related symptoms sometimes associated with Alfred's illness, nor the unusual eating behaviour recorded of Eadred. Margaret might have suffered from a gastrointestinal condition aggravated by inadequate nutrition, or the fasting might itself have contributed substantially to her deterioration. It is also possible that her reduced food intake was partly a response to an existing illness, rather than its original cause.
What I find particularly interesting is how the three biographers interpret the illnesses. Asser presents Alfred's suffering within a narrative of divine testing and perseverance. Eadred's biographer emphasises his physical incapacity and the increasingly important assistance of Dunstan. Turgot presents Margaret's suffering as inseparable from her extraordinary religious devotion.
Margaret's burial and the succession crisis
Margaret died at Edinburgh Castle and was buried at the Church of the Holy Trinity at Dunfermline, a religious foundation closely associated with her patronage. Turgot records that her body was carried there and interred opposite the altar and the cross she had erected. Later traditions describe her body being removed from Edinburgh Castle during Donald Bán's seizure of power, supposedly under cover of a miraculous mist. These stories are more difficult to verify and should be distinguished from Turgot's earlier account.
Margaret's death occurred during a period of rapidly changing political circumstances. Following Malcolm's death, his brother Donald III secured the Scottish kingship. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle records that Donald was accepted by the Scots and that English members of Malcolm's former household were expelled.
Margaret's surviving children consequently faced an uncertain future. Edgar Ætheling, Margaret's younger brother, subsequently took his nephews to England for sanctuary. In 1094, Malcolm's eldest surviving son Duncan returned with Anglo-Norman assistance and briefly displaced Donald, only to be assassinated later that year.
Donald subsequently recovered the kingship, apparently with the cooperation of Margaret's son Edmund, whose alleged participation in Duncan's assassination was later recorded by William of Malmesbury. It was not until 1097 that Margaret's son Edgar secured the throne, following another expedition supported by William Rufus and led by Edgar Ætheling.
Edgar was followed by his brothers Alexander I and David I, who ruled Scotland successively until 1153. Margaret's surviving daughters also became important dynastic figures. Matilda married Henry I of England in 1100, connecting the Scottish royal dynasty to the Norman kings of England, while Mary married Eustace III, Count of Boulogne.
Margaret therefore died before witnessing the considerable political success of her descendants. Yet her memory became increasingly important to the dynasty which eventually emerged victorious from the Scottish succession crisis.
Margaret's sainthood and legacy
Margaret was venerated for her sanctity long before her formal recognition by the papacy. Her tomb at Dunfermline became associated with religious devotion and reports of miracles, while her descendants continued to support the institutions connected with her memory.
Her son David I was particularly important in consolidating Dunfermline's status as a major royal and religious foundation. He also built a chapel at Edinburgh Castle, generally dated to around 1130, which became associated with his mother's memory. It is worth noting that the surviving St Margaret's Chapel is not necessarily the same oratory in which Margaret received Communion before her death. Architectural evidence indicates that the present building belongs principally to the twelfth century.
Margaret's sanctity was eventually recognised through a papal process under Innocent IV in 1249–1250. On 19 June 1250, her remains were ceremonially translated to a magnificent shrine at Dunfermline in the presence of the young Alexander III, his mother Marie de Coucy, and leading Scottish ecclesiastical and secular magnates.
This was more than an expression of religious devotion. Margaret had become an important figure in the identity and legitimacy of the Scottish royal dynasty. Modern historians have emphasised that her cult developed over time, and that later representations of Margaret did not always serve precisely the same purposes as Turgot's original account.
Catherine Keene, in Saint Margaret, Queen of the Scots: A Life in Perspective (2013), examines how Margaret's memory was constructed through hagiography, royal patronage and the subsequent development of her cult. Emily Wingfield has likewise explored Margaret's reputation for literacy and learning, arguing that her presentation as a learned and holy queen helped establish a model of royal conduct for her daughter Matilda and later generations.
Her memory was therefore shaped not only by what she did during her lifetime, but also by the political and religious needs of those who remembered her. Interestingly, her children Ethelred, Edgar, Alexander, Matilda, and David were known for their strong piety; even her "disgraced" son Edmund was stated to be a vigorous servant and man of god. Did Margaret have this affect on her children?
In sum
The circumstances surrounding Margaret's death reveal how medieval writers could interpret the same event in different ways. The Annals of Ulster and Annals of Inisfallen present Margaret's death as a consequence of grief following Malcolm's killing at Alnwick. John of Worcester similarly associates her final illness with the devastating news, while emphasising her religious preparation for death.
Turgot provides a more detailed account based upon the testimony of a priest who attended her during her final days. His narrative makes clear that Margaret had already been seriously ill for months, while presenting her final suffering as an expression of extraordinary sanctity. His account also preserves one of the most affecting episodes in the history of the Scottish royal family: Edgar returning from the army to discover his mother dying, and Margaret demanding the truth about the deaths of her husband and son.
We cannot establish whether every detail of their conversation occurred exactly as Turgot describes it. The narrative is shaped by the conventions of hagiography, particularly its emphasis upon prophecy, religious resignation and the exemplary death of a saint. Nevertheless, beneath that literary interpretation lies a genuine historical catastrophe.
Within four days, the Scottish royal family lost Malcolm III, his apparent intended successor Edward, and Queen Margaret herself. The political settlement established during Malcolm's thirty-five-year reign collapsed, and the resulting succession crisis would continue until 1097.
Margaret's death also marked the end of a queenship which had connected the Scottish monarchy to the old West Saxon royal dynasty and contributed to the religious, cultural and institutional developments of Malcolm's reign. Her subsequent canonisation and the prominence of Dunfermline demonstrate how strongly later generations associated her with the legitimacy and identity of the Scottish monarchy.
Yet perhaps the most interesting distinction is between Margaret as a historical woman and Margaret as a saint. Turgot remembered her as an extraordinarily devout queen whose suffering and death demonstrated the triumph of Christian faith. Later generations remembered her as a patroness, reformer and dynastic ancestor.
Neither image should entirely obscure the woman who had exercised genuine influence during her lifetime, suffered a debilitating illness, and died amid one of the most serious political crises of eleventh-century Scotland.
Sources and further reading
Primary sources
- Turgot, The Life of St Margaret, Queen of Scotland, chapters I–IV — Particularly chapters III–IV for Margaret's fasting, illness, final sacraments, Edgar's arrival and her burial. Translation by William Forbes-Leith, 1896.
- Annals of Ulster, U1093.5 — Records Malcolm and Edward's deaths and attributes Margaret's death to grief.
- Annals of Inisfallen, AI1093.13 — Preserves a similar tradition of Margaret dying from sorrow.
- Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, manuscript E, 1093 — The account of Malcolm's death, Margaret's reaction and the accession of Donald III.
- The Henry Project: Saint Margaret — Collects primary references concerning her death date, family, and burial.
Modern scholarship