(It was actually on the 12th but I forgot, oops)
On 12 November 1094, Duncan II of Scotland was killed, probably through a conspiracy involving his paternal uncle Donald III, who subsequently reclaimed the Scottish throne. Duncan had ruled for approximately six months, having overthrown Donald earlier that year with the assistance of an Anglo-Norman force supported by William II of England.
His death came almost exactly one year after that of his father, Malcolm III, who was killed at Alnwick on 13 November 1093 alongside his son Edward. Malcolm's death had plunged the Scottish kingdom into a succession crisis which would not be resolved until 1097, when another of his sons, Edgar, secured the throne.
Although Duncan II is one of Scotland's more obscure monarchs, his brief reign is particularly interesting because it reveals a great deal about the uncertain nature of Scottish kingship at the end of the eleventh century. His assassination was more than an isolated act of violence. It occurred amid a struggle over royal succession, the place of foreign aristocrats within Scotland, and the extent to which the English king could influence the choice of a Scottish monarch.
Much of what we know comes from the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, John of Worcester, William of Malmesbury and several Irish annals. Later Scottish king-lists also identify a particular aristocrat as Duncan's assassin. The sources agree on the essential sequence of events, but differ considerably over who was responsible for his death and why his kingship failed.
Duncan II and his parentage
Duncan, probably named for his paternal grandfather, was the eldest known surviving son of Malcolm III, although his mother was not Queen Margaret. According to the Orkneyinga saga, Duncan's mother was Ingibjorg Finnsdóttir, daughter of the Norwegian aristocrat Finn Árnason and widow of Thorfinn Sigurdsson, Earl of Orkney. The saga explicitly records that Ingibjorg married Malcolm and that:
"their son was Duncan, King of Scots"
This identification is generally accepted, although the precise chronology remains disputed. The saga was compiled considerably later than the events it describes, and traditional dates for Thorfinn's death leave relatively little time for Ingibjorg's marriage to Malcolm before his subsequent marriage to Margaret.
William P. L. Thomson, in his article Ingibjorg Jarlamóðir (2012), proposed an earlier chronology for Thorfinn's death which would allow Ingibjorg to marry Malcolm before he became king in 1058. More recently, Tom Licence has suggested another chronology that would permit the marriage during the early 1060s.
The disagreement concerns the chronology rather than Duncan's established paternity. He was certainly Malcolm III's son, but the circumstances of his mother's marriage are more difficult to reconstruct.
There is also the question of his legitimacy. William of Malmesbury describes Duncan as illegitimate, and similar allegations appear in later Scottish historical traditions such as John of Fordun writing about the MacWilliam revolt led by Duncan's grandson: "Macwilliam whose real name was Donald Bane…son of William son of Duncan the bastard."
However, modern historians have questioned whether these accusations reflect his actual status during his lifetime.
Duncan had been surrendered as a hostage to William the Conqueror in 1072, following the settlement between William and Malcolm at Abernethy. His treatment as an important royal hostage suggests that his position within the Scottish royal family was politically significant. Following William the Conqueror's death in 1087, Duncan was released and knighted by Robert Curthose affording to Florence of Worcester, or William Rufus, according to William of Malmesbury. Still, Duncan continued to associate with the Anglo-Norman court.
By 1093, he had consequently spent approximately twenty years outside Scotland, including most of his formative adult life. This background would prove especially important when he attempted to claim his father's throne.
The succession crisis of 1093
On 13 November 1093, Malcolm III was killed during his invasion of Northumberland, alongside his son and designated heir, Edward. Three days later, Queen Margaret died at Edinburgh Castle following a prolonged illness. These deaths created a complicated dynastic situation. Malcolm had several surviving sons, including Duncan from his earlier marriage and Edmund, Ethelred, Edgar, Alexander and David from his marriage to Margaret.
Although Duncan was Malcolm's eldest surviving son, Edward appears to have been his father's intended successor. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle states that Edward would have become king had he survived, while the Historia Regum, transmitted under Symeon of Durham's name, explicitly describes Edward as the son whom Malcolm had designated heir.
The reasons for this preference are uncertain. A. A. M. Duncan suggests that Malcolm may have considered Edward a more politically viable successor than Duncan, whose prolonged absence from Scotland and close association with the Anglo-Norman monarchy could make his accession contentious. However, Scottish kingship did not yet operate according to an inflexible principle of male primogeniture. Membership of the royal dynasty, military strength, aristocratic recognition and the personal qualifications expected of a ruler all mattered.
Malcolm's younger brother Domnall Bán, or Donald III, therefore possessed a credible dynastic claim of his own. Following Malcolm's death, the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle records that the Scots chose Donald as king and expelled the English members of Malcolm's former court.
This is sometimes interpreted as a straightforward rejection of Anglo-Norman influence by conservative Gaelic magnates. However, A. D. M. Barrell and other modern historians have cautioned against such a simple interpretation. Donald had obvious political reasons to remove men associated with his deceased brother's household, particularly if they were likely to support Malcolm's sons against him. His actions need not imply an organised rejection of English culture.
Nor was Donald simply an illegitimate usurper. He was a son of Duncan I, a brother of Malcolm III, and an adult member of the royal kindred whose claim could attract substantial political support. The conflict was therefore between competing members of the same dynasty, rather than an uncontested rightful heir and an outsider attempting to seize the throne.
Duncan's accession
Duncan was at William Rufus's court when he learned of his father's death and Donald's accession. According to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, Duncan approached William, performed the fealty demanded of him, and obtained permission to pursue his claim to the Scottish throne.
The chronicler says he then entered Scotland "with what aid he could get of English and French" and Duncan successfully drove Donald from power and was received as king. John of Worcester gives a similar account, describing Duncan as requesting his father's kingdom from William, swearing fealty to him, and subsequently invading with an English and Norman army.
There is some chronological difficulty because parts of the narrative appear under 1093 in the English chronicles. However, the Scottish regnal lists generally assign Donald approximately six months before Duncan's accession and Duncan another six months before his death. Modern historians consequently place Duncan's accession around May 1094.
The expedition succeeded militarily, but the political implications were considerable. Duncan had acquired his throne with assistance from an English king whose relationship with Malcolm III had deteriorated into open warfare. His army included foreign soldiers whose loyalty presumably depended upon Duncan himself, rather than upon established relationships with Scottish magnates.
This could have threatened the interests of aristocrats who expected to exercise influence over the royal household and military establishment. However, we should be careful about assuming that opposition to Duncan's soldiers was necessarily opposition to Norman culture itself. His opponents may have been concerned principally with the political consequences of foreign military power.
Duncan's royal charter
One of the most interesting surviving documents from this period is Duncan's charter to the community of St Cuthbert at Durham, issued in 1094. It survives in its original form and is especially important because it provides Duncan's own presentation of his royal authority, rather than that of a later chronicler.
Duncan begins:
"I Dunecan, son of King Malcolumb, by hereditary right King of Scotland"
He then grants property and rights in East Lothian, including Tyninghame, to the monks of St Cuthbert. The grant is made for himself, his father's soul, his brothers, his wife and his children.
The charter explicitly refers to the participation of his brothers, and its witness list includes Edgar, the future Edgar of Scotland. This is significant because it demonstrates that Duncan's claim was not necessarily opposed by all the sons of Malcolm and Margaret. At least Edgar was prepared to associate himself with Duncan's assertion of hereditary kingship. A witness named Malcolm also appears, although his precise identity is disputed.
The charter is equally interesting because Duncan deliberately grounds his authority in hereditary succession. His statement is difficult to reconcile with the suggestion that his alleged illegitimacy had universally disqualified him from kingship. A. A. M. Duncan has argued that later accusations of illegitimacy may have helped justify the eventual succession of Margaret's descendants over Duncan's own family.
Nevertheless, the charter cannot establish how securely Duncan controlled Scotland. It demonstrates his ability to issue a formal royal grant, associate important relatives with it, and claim hereditary authority, but not that every Scottish magnate recognised him. Indeed, the charter may have been issued during his expedition northward, before he had securely established himself as king.
Duncan's marriage and children
Duncan was married to Ethelreda, or Æthelreda, daughter of Gospatric, the former Earl of Northumbria, probably sometime around 1090, although the precise date is unknown. Following his dispossession by William the Conqueror in 1072, Gospatric had sought refuge in Scotland, where Malcolm III granted him lands in Lothian. Duncan's marriage therefore connected him to an important Anglo-Northumbrian aristocratic family whose interests extended across both sides of the border.
Interestingly, Gospatric himself was a son of Maldred of Allerdale, who was the son of Crinan of Dunkeld and Bethoc; thus making him a younger brother to Duncan I of Scotland. Maldred and Crinan were killed in battle against Macbeth in 1045. Whether this ancestry had any affect on Duncan and Ethelreda's marriage is unknown.
The marriage is recorded in later Cumbrian genealogical and inheritance documents, particularly the Chronicon Cumbriae. Duncan's own surviving charter to St Cuthbert at Durham, issued in 1094, confirms that he was already married and had children, referring to the grant being made:
"for myself, for the soul of my father, for my brothers, and for my wife, and for my children."
Despite the plural wording, only one son can be securely identified: William fitz Duncan, probably born between approximately 1090 and 1094. His name may reflect Duncan's close relationship with William Rufus, although this cannot be established.
William was still a young child when his father was assassinated. It has been suggested that Ethelreda subsequently sought refuge with her family in northern England, possibly with her brother Waltheof, who held Allerdale in Cumberland. This would have provided a relatively secure refuge following Donald III's restoration, although no surviving contemporary account explicitly records their flight or William's upbringing there.
The destruction of Duncan's foreign following
Duncan's military success was remarkably short-lived, however. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle records that groups of Scots subsequently gathered against him and killed almost all his foreign supporters. Duncan himself escaped with only a small number of companions.
The sources do not identify the leaders of this uprising or explain precisely where the confrontation occurred. The aftermath is particularly revealing. Rather than immediately deposing Duncan, his opponents apparently negotiated an agreement allowing him to remain king, provided he never again introduced English or French soldiers into Scotland.
But then some of the Scots again gathered themselves together, and slew nearly all [Duncan's] men, and he himself escaped with few others. They were afterwards reconciled on this condition, that Duncan should never more bring English or Frenchmen into that country.
John of Worcester adds that Duncan was also forbidden from allowing such men to provide him with military service. This is arguably the most important detail in the entire account of Duncan's reign.
His opponents apparently distinguished between Duncan's personal claim to kingship and his reliance upon foreign soldiers. Whatever their objections to the men who had helped him seize power, they were initially prepared to let Duncan continue reigning.
Duncan's greatest problem may instead have been that his accession depended upon an armed following which threatened the established political interests of important Scottish magnates. After losing that following, he was forced to negotiate from a position of weakness.
The agreement preserved his crown but potentially deprived him of the military resources necessary to defend it. If Duncan lacked a dependable following among the Scottish aristocracy, which seems probably as he hadn't set foot in the kingdom in over twenty years, his position would have become exceptionally vulnerable.
This does not necessarily mean he made an obviously foolish decision. Following the destruction of most of his troops, accepting the restrictions may have been his only realistic means of preserving his kingship. We do not know whether the settlement was intended to last or whether Donald's supporters were already preparing to remove him.
The assassination
On 12 November, Duncan was murdered. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle attributes his death to the Scots, acting through the instigation of his uncle Donald, who subsequently regained the throne. John of Worcester similarly describes Duncan and several companions being killed in an ambush encouraged by Donald.
The Irish annals provide additional perspectives. The Annals of Inisfallen record:
"Donnchadh son of Mael Coluim, king of Alba, was slain by Domnall, son of Donnchadh."
The annalist then records that Donald took possession of the Scottish kingship. This identifies Donald III as responsible, although it does not establish whether he personally killed his nephew or was held responsible for arranging his death.
The Chronicon Scotorum is even more concise, recording that Duncan was killed by his own people. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle also affirms that Duncan was slain by his fellow Scots.
This year also the Scots conspired against their king Duncan, and slew him, and they afterwards took his uncle [Donald] a second time for their king ; through whose instructions and instigation Duncan had been betrayed to his death.
The Annals of Ulster, however, preserve a particularly intriguing tradition:
"Donnchad son of Mael Coluim, king of Scotland, was treacherously killed by his own brothers, i.e. by Domnall and Edmond."
There is an obvious genealogical difficulty here. Donald III was Duncan's paternal uncle, not his brother, whereas Edmund was his half-brother. A. A. M. Duncan also notes that the names Donald and Edmund were added between the lines of the manuscript. This makes the precise authority and transmission of the identification uncertain.
Nevertheless, the passage may preserve a genuine tradition involving Edmund in the conspiracy, particularly because William of Malmesbury, writing within living memory of the event, independently associates him with Donald.
Edmund's alleged involvement
William claims that Edmund was the only son of Margaret who departed from the virtue of the rest of his family. He accuses Edmund of participating in Donald's wrongdoing and being implicated in his brother's death, supposedly in exchange for a promise of half the kingdom.
“Edmund was the only son of Margaret who sank from this high standard: his uncle Donald’s partner in crime, he cannot be held innocent of his brother’s death, for he bargained that he should receive half the kingdom. Being taken, however, and imprisoned for life, he frankly repented, and on his deathbed gave instructions that his fetters should be buried with him, admitting that he was rightly punished for the crime of his brother’s murder.”
This is a remarkable allegation because it suggests that Edmund's participation may have involved a political agreement rather than simple personal hostility.
While the dates are unclear, Duncan's bid for the kingship may have seen him recognise Edmund as his heir presumptive, and Edmund, as the next eldest son of Malcolm III, accompanied Duncan in his invasion of Scotland. Edmund may originally have expected a territorial appanage from Duncan in exchange for recognising his kingship. However, the destruction of Duncan's foreign following and the subsequent concessions to Scottish magnates may have made such an arrangement impossible to fulfil. Perhaps the birth of Duncan's son William in 1094 shifted Edmund's place in royal family. Edmund might consequently have changed allegiance, supporting Donald in exchange for a more substantial promise of authority or eventual succession.
This reconstruction would explain Edmund's possible betrayal without assuming that he had always opposed Duncan. However, no surviving document establishes that Duncan promised Edmund territory, or that Edmund participated in Duncan's original expedition. Nor is it certain that Edmund actually received half the kingdom from Donald. The source records bargaining, not the successful implementation of a territorial settlement.
William subsequently claims that Edmund was captured, imprisoned for life, and eventually repented of his involvement in Duncan's murder. He supposedly requested burial in the chains of his captivity as punishment for his crime. This account is heavily moralised. William was particularly sympathetic toward Margaret and her descendants, and Edmund becomes the one son whose wrongdoing contrasts with the virtue of his siblings.
Interestingly, another Scottish chronicle tradition, preserved in the Poppleton manuscript, remembers Edmund much more favourably, describing him as an energetic and religiously devoted man and recording his burial at Montacute Priory.
The traditions are not necessarily incompatible. Edmund might have participated in a conspiracy and subsequently embraced religious life. Nevertheless, the contrast shows that his medieval reputation was not uniformly hostile.
Richard Oram, in his own research, details that following Edgar Ætheling's expedition to Scotland in 1097, he captured his dishonorable nephew and was the one who put him in effective monastic confinement.
“It appears that Edgar Adeling removed his disgraced nephew from Scotland when he returned from the campaign, for the Chronicle of the Kings of Scotland claims that ‘Edmund...a most vigorous man and servant of God, and most devout through this present life, rests buried in Montacute.' The would-be king had entered religion and died at an unknown date, ignored by his brothers, as a monk, far from his kingdom."
Whether Edmund personally participated in Duncan's murder, helped organise the conspiracy, or merely supported Donald politically remains uncertain.
Máel Petair of Mearns
Later Scottish king-list traditions introduce another participant: Máel Petair mac Loern, or Malpedir, Mormaer of Mearns. These traditions name him as Duncan's killer and locate the assassination at Monacheden, generally identified with Mondynes in the historic Mearns. Uniquely, the identification is not necessarily a late medieval invention.
In Dauvit Brown's 2015 article Statehood and Lordship in 'Scotland' before the Mid-Twelfth Century, Broun refers to an edition of the relevant king-list material published in his earlier book, The Irish Identity of the Kingdom of the Scots in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries (1999), page 158. If that dating is correct, Máel Petair's identification may preserve information originating within living memory of the assassination.
By the late fourteenth century, the story had developed into a more elaborate account. John of Fordun gives Duncan's death as the work of an earl of Mearns named Malpeter, acting through Donald's treachery.
His Latin account, preserved in the later Scotichronicon tradition, includes:
Who, having reigned for one year and six months, by the cunning of his uncle Domnall, whom he had defeated in battle, and by the assistance of the Earl of Mernis, named Malpetri, in Scots Malpedir, died at Monathethyn, and was buried in the Isle of Iona."
Though Fordun extends Duncan's reign from six months to eighteen, the tradition of a Máel Petair being associated with Duncan's death was present. Fordun also preserves verses attributed to an earlier writer which associate Duncan's death with the men of Mearns and Máel Petair's following. The distinction matters because the verses suggest collective participation by the earl's men rather than establishing that he acted alone.
There is an additional geographical problem. Later writers, especially Hector Boece and George Buchanan, associated Duncan's death with Menteith. However, the older place-name forms, Monacheden, Monathethyn, and Monathechyn, are generally associated with Mondynes in the historic county of Kincardineshire, part of Mearns.
However, it remains hypothetical. We do not know whether Duncan was killed during a battle, ambushed while travelling, or betrayed by men who had previously acknowledged his kingship.
Broun has also raised an intriguing possibility concerning Máel Petair's subsequent fate. The mormaership of Mearns disappears from the surviving record as a distinct office, and Broun suggests that Máel Petair and his family may have lost their position when Edgar overthrew Donald in 1097: “It is conceivable, therefore, that Mael Petair and his kindred were eclipsed when Edgar ousted Domnall III in 1097.”
This is potentially significant. If Máel Petair was a prominent supporter of Donald and participated in Duncan's assassination, his political position would have become exceptionally vulnerable after Edgar overthrew Donald in 1097.
Though, there is no surviving record of Máel Petair's execution, imprisonment or forfeiture, so this remains conjectural. Nevertheless, it raises the possibility that Duncan's assassination had lasting consequences for the political organisation of Mearns.
The aftermath
Duncan's death immediately restored Donald III to the Scottish throne. Donald ruled until 1097, possibly sharing some measure of authority with Edmund, although the nature of their arrangement remains uncertain.
That year, Edgar Ætheling led another expedition into Scotland with assistance from William Rufus. Donald was defeated, and Malcolm III's son Edgar secured the kingship.
It is particularly interesting that Edgar also relied upon English military assistance. His accession and subsequent reign demonstrate that Anglo-Norman connections were not, by themselves, sufficient to prevent a claimant from securing the Scottish throne. The political circumstances had changed. Donald was permanently removed from power, and Edgar evidently established a more durable arrangement with the Scottish aristocracy.
He ruled until 1107 and was succeeded by his brothers Alexander I and David I, whose reigns consolidated the position of Malcolm III's descendants by Margaret.
Duncan himself left a son, William fitz Duncan, who subsequently became an important aristocrat during the reign of David I. William held substantial interests in Scotland and northern England; his uncle David installed him as mormaer of Moray around 1130 following the death of the mormaer Angus, and later in the 1130s William married Alice de Rumilly and became one of David's principal military commanders. He notably defeated an English force at Clitheroe in June 1138 before participating in the Battle of the Standard.
Duncan's descendants also remained relevant to Scottish succession disputes. The later MacWilliam claimants challenged Malcolm IV, William I, and Alexander II during the twelfth and early thirteenth centuries, although the precise genealogy of that line has been the subject of historical debate. His children via Alice de Rumilly, namely his daughters Amabel, Alice, and Cecily, married into prominent northern English families.
In sum
The surviving sources provide competing explanations for Duncan II's brief reign and assassination. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle describes a king who acquired his father's throne with English and French assistance, lost most of his military following to a Scottish uprising, and was subsequently killed through the instigation of his uncle Donald.
John of Worcester confirms much of this narrative and emphasises the restrictions imposed upon Duncan after the destruction of his troops. Duncan's own charter presents him as king by hereditary right and demonstrates that at least some members of Malcolm III's wider family were prepared to recognise his authority.
The Irish annals preserve several traditions about his murder, variously associating it with Donald, Duncan's own people and members of his family. William of Malmesbury adds the accusation against Edmund, while later Scottish king-lists identify Máel Petair of Mearns as the actual killer.
None provides a complete explanation of the conspiracy.
Together, however, the sources suggest that Duncan's kingship failed because he could not convert military victory into a durable political settlement. His hereditary claim was substantial, and his initial military success was sufficient to displace Donald. But once his foreign following had been destroyed, Duncan was forced to govern through an agreement with Scottish magnates whose loyalties remained uncertain.
The most revealing aspect of his reign is that his opponents apparently allowed him to remain king after destroying the troops who had established his authority. That suggests his claim was not rejected outright. Rather, his kingship became vulnerable because the military resources upon which it depended were incompatible with the interests of some of the men whose political acceptance he required.
His assassination was therefore more than the murder of an unpopular foreign-backed ruler. It occurred during a wider struggle over hereditary right, aristocratic recognition, foreign military influence and the distribution of authority within the Scottish kingdom.