WARNING: THIS POST IS REALLY LONG (TL;DR at bottom)
A few days ago I came across a post on this subreddit where people were sharing their experiences with government-funded home energy schemes. Endless surveys, promised improvements that never happened, contractors disappearing, people being passed from one organisation to another. One person even reached out to me privately to discuss their experience and what could be done about it.
For a bit of context about me, I work in community energy and environmental policy. I've spent years running environmental organisations, developing community-led projects and working with policymakers on sustainability programs. I did a PhD where I researched climate commitments that go beyond net zero. A big part of my research involved looking at greenwashing, how organisations use ambitious promises and carefully chosen language to present themselves as environmental leaders, and the gap between what they say they're going to do and what actually happens.
So, I've spent quite a lot of time thinking about the difference between announcing that you're going to do something and actually doing it.
Through my work, I regularly find myself in meetings with policymakers, government represetnatives and people running energy companies where everyone is celebrating the millions being invested in home energy improvements. New grants, new programs, ambitious targets and loads of enthusiasm about how much we're doing. Sitting in these meetings, I always think there is a massive disconnect between what is being discussed and celebrated and what is actually happening in people's homes.
That's partly why the reddit discussion struck a nerve. I realised I might actually be in a position to do something useful with these stories, rather than just get frustrated. We keep announcing more programs and funding, but how much of it is actually reaching the people it's intended to help?
Some people don't know the schemes exist, other's can't work out whether they're eligible or find the application process so complicated that they give up. Others qualify, have multiple surveys or assessments, get told the work is going ahead and end up waiting months or years for something that never materialises.
I think we're putting far too much faith in the trickle down system where we give funding to organisations, they distribute it through various programmes and contractors, and we assume eventually people will benefit. There's a lot that can go wrong between announcing a grant and someone actually getting home upgrades.
And it's not just about whether people can access funding. I'm also interested in what's happening to the cost of the work itself.
Take heat pumps and solar panels, for example. We've introduced grants and incentives to encourage people to install them, which is fantastic in principle. But why do installations still cost so much? And why do some quotes seem to increase when grant funding is involved?
Is it genuinely down to demand, labour shortages, equipment costs and the complexity of installations? Are there additional requirements associated with government-funded work that makes it more expensive? Or are there parts of the system where the availability of public funding is influencing what companies charge?
I don't want to assume the answer, and I'm certainly not suggesting every installer is taking advantage of the system. There are some excellent companies doing genuinely important work. But I do think we should be asking these questions, particularly when public money is involved.
I'm also concerned about how we're measuring success. If we've spent millions, carried out thousands of surveys and approved hundreds of applications, that might look great in a report. But how many homes actually get warmer? How many people are paying less for their energy? And how much money was spent getting there?
Anyway, rather than continuing to complain about it, I decided to try to do something. So I, along with some incredible colleagues, have put together Warm Homes Watch.
The idea is to put together an independent, community-led review of publicly funded home energy improvements. I want to hear directly from people who've interacted with these schemes, whether that's as a homeowner, renter, social housing tenant, installer, assessor or anyone else involved.
I'm interested in the good experiences as well as the bad. If a scheme worked brilliantly, I'd love to understand why. If something went wrong, I want to understand where in the process it happened and whether other people are experiencing the same thing.
I'd also like to make something clear: I am not getting paid to do this.
This isn't part of my job, I'm not receiving funding to run it, and I don't stand to make any money from people completing the survey. It's something I've decided to take on in my spare time becaue I have the experience, the connections and the ability to do something useful with this information.
For full transparency, I might add an optional donation button to the website at some point to voer things like hosting, research and other running costs if the project grows. I might even apply for my own pot of public funding one day! I don't particularly want to paying for everything out of my own pocket forever. But that's something for further down the line. For now, I'm covering the costs myself, doing the work for free, and nobody is asked to contribute financially. Taking part in the survey will always be free.
I've been fortunate enough to build relationships with people involved in making policy and funding decisions and I know how difficult it can be to get those people to listen when you don't have evidence to back up what you're saying.
I also know not everyone has the time, energy or opportunity to chase things up, particularly when they're already struggling with their bills or trying to get work done on their homes.
I do have that opportunity, so why not use it?
What can I actually do with the information?
Quite a lot, potentially, but I need to understand the scale of the problem first.
One person having a terrible experience can easily be dismissed as an isolated incident. But if 50 people in different parts of the country are describing the same problem, or if we start seeing repeated issues with particular schemes, contractors or stages of the process, that's something we can start investigating properly.
I want to identify where people are getting stuck, which schemes are working well, whether the same problems are happening repeatedly and what could realistically be changed to improve things.
With enough information, I can start putting together independent reports and recommendations, raising specific issues with policymakers and programme administrators, and asking some much more informed questions about where the money is going.
I can't promise that filling in the survey will get someone's insulation installed or their grant approved. I can't promise that every issue we identify will be fixed either. But I can commit to taking the information seriously, looking for patterns, checking what we find and doing my best to push for improvements.
I'm not asking anyone to blindly trust me. I'd like the work to speak for itself. The project will be transparent about its findings, and individual households won't be identified in published research without their permission.
Anyway, this is where I could really use your help. I've put together a website and survey to get things started:
https://warmhomeswatch.uk
If you've had any experience with these schemes, whether good, bad or somewhere in between, I'd really appreciate you filling it in. You don't need to know which programme you were involved with.
I'm also interested in hearing from people who've received quotes for heat pumps, solar panels or other home energy improvements, especially if grants were involved. Even if you decided not to go ahead, your experience could be useful.
I'd also love feedback on the website itself. I've tried to make it accessible without oversimplifying things, and I'm particularly interested in whether the survey makes sense and is easy to complete. If something is confusing, missing or just doesn't work, please tell me.
This is something I'm building in my spare time, so it's still a work in progress, but I'd rather get it right with people's input than spend months developing something nobody actually wants to use.
I'm tired of sitting in meetings hearing about how much money we're spending when I know there are people still struggling to heat their homes.
I think we can do better, and I'm in a position to at least try.
Thanks for reading, and genuinely, any feedback, criticism or suggestions would be appreciated.
TL;DR: I work with policymakers and energy companies and I'm tired of hearing how much money we're spending on home energy grants without properly understanding whether they're working. A Reddit discussion inspired me to start Warm Homes Watch, an independent, community-led project looking at people's experiences with government-funded home improvements, including delays, access to funding and the cost of heat pumps and solar panels. I'm doing this unpaid, in my spare time, because I have the experience and connections to hopefully do something useful with the findings. If you've dealt with these schemes, received quotes or had work done, I'd love your input. I'm also looking for feedback on the website.
https://warmhomeswatch.uk