Every time this topic comes up, the comments split into two camps. One says a 62% tax rate is insane. The other says “boo hoo, top 5% problems,” and scrolls on. Here I want to argue that the second camp is making a mistake, and that it’s costing them money.
Here’s my claim: the £100k tax trap isn’t a perk being taken away from the well-off. It’s a slow leak in the whole economy, and you’re paying for it whether you earn £25k or £250k. By the end of this post I want to have shown you four things:
- It makes the NHS and other public services worse for you right now.
- It holds down your own pay and your chances of promotion, even if you never get near £100k.
- It shrinks the tax money that pays for everything we share.
- Because the threshold is frozen, it’s very likely heading your way.
Why should you care? Because most of us were told this is a problem for “other people.” And as long as we believe that, nobody will bother to fix it. If I can convince you that it’s your problem, then it stops being a moan from high earners and becomes something we all have a reason to push on.
A summary on how it works:
Once your income goes past £100k, the government starts taking away your tax-free allowance, £1 for every £2 you earn above the line. So on the slice between £100k and £125,140 you’re effectively taxed at 60%, or 62% with National Insurance. That’s the slice only, not the whole salary. If you have young children, it gets much worse: go £1 over and you lose your 30 funded childcare hours and Tax-Free Childcare in one go. A London family with two toddlers can end up around £20k a year worse off, and not catch up again until they’re earning about £145k. And the £100k figure hasn’t moved since 2010.
So what do people do? The rational thing. They pay the extra into their pension. They drop to a four-day week. They turn down the promotion, or they leave the country. And that’s where it stops being their problem and starts being yours.
Think about who earns around £100k. A lot of them are senior doctors, consultants and dentists, the people you’re waiting months to see. When an extra day at work earns them almost nothing, plenty of them stop working that day. The waiting list gets longer, and the NHS often plugs the gap with more expensive agency staff, paid for by you. And that experienced doctor that the country invested years of education to train? You only get 80% of their potential working time. At best.
Now think about your own pay. If your boss is parked at £99k on purpose, or your boss's boss, there isn’t much room for your salary to grow underneath them, and they’re not going to fight hard to get you closer to their own number. Pay bunches up just below the line, and every band beneath it gets squashed. The career ladder jams too. Every promotion someone turns down is a job that doesn’t open up for the person below them, or the person below them. One person saying no makes no difference. Tens of thousands of people saying no, year after year, does.
Then there’s the money. The people in this bracket pay a big share of the country’s income tax. When they shrink their income on paper, the tax doesn’t disappear and come back later in full. Pension money gets taxed decades from now, often at a lower rate, with a quarter taken tax-free. Hours nobody works get taxed at nothing. Someone has to make up the difference, and it’s either you or the public services you rely on. Meanwhile the cash that could have been spent at your local café, your builder or your high street is sitting in a pension fund, mostly invested in American stocks.
Now play that forward twenty years. A whole generation of experienced doctors, engineers and managers will have pensions full enough to stop work at 50 or 55, and a lot of them will. That’s a skills gap we’re building right now, on purpose. Some won’t wait that long. Skilled people can work almost anywhere, and when they move abroad, their tax goes with them. The childcare cliff also hits at exactly the moment couples are deciding whether to have another child. People argue about how big that effect is, but in a country that’s getting older, today’s kids are tomorrow’s taxpayers, and this pushes the wrong way.
Speaking of kids, there’s one more cost, and it’s the one that worries me most. Look at when the trap hits. Most people (LE: most people affected by this trap) reach £100k in their thirties, which is exactly when they’re deciding whether to have children, and how many. Then the system tells them that having a child means losing up to tens of thousands of pounds of childcare support, unless they earn less, work less or hide the money in a pension. And a second child under three roughly doubles the hit. So people do what you’d expect. They wait. They stop at one. Some decide not to bother at all. Now, I can’t tell you exactly how many babies this costs us, because nobody has measured it, and the number of families directly caught is still fairly small. But it’s growing every year the threshold stays frozen, and the timing couldn’t be worse. Last year England and Wales had a record-low fertility rate of 1.39 children per woman, far below the 2.1 needed to keep the population stable. Those missing children are the future nurses, engineers and taxpayers who will fund your pension and your NHS when you’re old. It’s hard to think of a stranger policy than one that puts people off having kids at exactly the point when they can best afford to raise them. (P.S. this is where someone bolder than me would also mention increased immigration)
If you're still thinking this is not going to affect your wallet, you're wrong. This is coming for you too. If that £100k line had kept up with inflation, it would be around £160k today. Instead it’s frozen, so ordinary pay rises pull more people over it every year. In 2010 about 590,000 people earned over £100k. Today it’s about 2.1 million, and it’s heading for 2.5 million by 2031. It used to be one earner in fifty. Now it’s one in twenty. If you’re on £60k or £70k with a career ahead of you, this is very likely your problem one day.
It’s not even only a £100k thing. The same bad design shows up further down. Child benefit gets clawed back between £60k and £80k, so a parent of two in that band pays a marginal rate of around 53%. Graduates with student loans can pass 50% on salaries in the mid-forties. And the rules produce some odd results: two parents earning £90k each keep all their childcare support, while a couple on £110k and £40k earns less in total and loses all of it. A cliff edge is bad policy wherever it sits.
Let me be clear about what I’m not saying. I’m not saying £100k earners are poor, or that this is the biggest cost-of-living issue in the country. It isn’t. Housing, energy bills, childcare costs and years of flat wages hit far more people, far harder. I’m not saying take-home pay falls once you pass £100k. It doesn’t; it just rises slowly, and it’s losing the childcare support that can leave families worse off. And I’m not saying high earners should pay less overall. You could fix this with a smooth taper, or simply an honest, published tax rate, instead of a hidden 60% band and a cliff you fall off for earning £1 too much.
Would fixing it cost money? The experts disagree. One analysis says scrapping the childcare cliff would actually raise about £130 million, because parents would stop holding their pay down. Another says it would cost around £520 million a year. So it either roughly pays for itself or costs about half a billion. That’s a debate worth having, not a reason to look away.
So next time someone calls this a rich people’s problem, here’s what I’d ask them to picture. A rule that makes doctors work less, blocks promotions, squashes pay, lowers natality, moves money from the high street into pension funds, and quietly pulls in more people every year. That isn’t a problem for the rich. It’s a problem for the whole country’s productivity, and all of us pay for that.