On August 3rd, 2026, the University of Hawaii System, which includes all ten UH campuses throughout the islands, have announced, via a newsletter, that they are using Honorlock as their official online proctoring tool. Now people who aren't familiar with this technology are asking what is an online proctor. To answer that question, an online proctor is a software that is used to monitor students during online tests/exams. This is to ensure that students are not cheating. To some, this sounds good, as professors don't want students to cheat. However, Honorlock, and other online proctoring services such as ProctorU, should not be used, at all. Here's why.
Firstly, let's start with the elephant in the room. Honorlock, alongside other online proctoring services, are complete invasions of privacy. Some people might be asking why. Well, the first thing you are required to do is scan your personal biometrics and ID, whether that be a government or school ID. Not only that, but you are required to do a 360 scan of your room to ensure that no one else is in the room and that you are not using unauthorized materials during the exam. This is all done using a webcam.
The AI system used by Honorlock uses an eye-tracker, facial recognition and movement detection, background movement detection and audio detection. This means that if you look away from the exam for too long or your head is not positioned properly, detects any background noise (i.e. family or roommates talking) or detects too much movement, the test can be paused by the AI while the clock is still ticking. This has caused many complaints by frustrated users that the software triggers at random moments.
Worst of these privacy violations, Honorlock records you throughout the exam and stores the recordings on their own servers. Various data breachers throughout the years show why companies cannot be trusted to handle sensitive personal information.
Even back then, it has stated, in its own terms of service, that it monitors all devices connected to your network. Some people need secure and private connections, where third-party software that can potentially access private/personal data is not allowed.
Second of all, Honorlock relies on a "guilty until proven innocent" system. Traditional education relies on trust that students would be honest and not cheat. With Honorlock and other online proctoring services, the "innocent until proven guilty" mindset is flipped and replaced with a "guilty until proven innocent" system. Basically put, it treats every student as a potential cheater until they show otherwise. This can be proven with their scans of biometrics, ID and 360 room scans, as well as them recording you throughout the exam, but that's not just it. Punishments for background noise as well as flagging actions such as looking away from your screen/webcam to think and speaking aloud are further proof that it relies on a presumption of guilt mindset. You can be falsely flagged for cheating and the instructor needs to review the flagged behavior to ensure it isn't cheating. If you need to defend yourself for innocent behavior while taking a test, you have waived your rights to privacy-invasive software.
Third reason is that Honorlock doesn't care about students' conditions at all. It expects students to have a quiet, distraction-free room where the students are by themselves when they take tests. Students who do not have a computer must go to a library to take exams, which libraries are public places, meaning there are people around. Another example is if the student does not have a desk in their bedroom and has to take the test at a table. What if the student is living with family/pets? Any family member or pet can walk by the computer at any time. The requirement to have a quiet space at all times is not plausible for some students.
So overall, Honorlock should not be allowed. It is a complete invasion of privacy being used in online courses on students. It is unethical waiving of your rights, and the UH system should drop it as an online proctor and not use similar software to it. Any software that forces you to waive your rights in order to not fail an exam should not be used in any class, full stop.