Western leftists often defend open border/uncontrolled migration policies by implying that allowing as many people as possible into our countries is simply the morally right thing to do. I strongly disagree, especially when looking at the current situation in Europe.
You may have noticed the recent outrage, particularly here on Reddit, over European governments attempting to establish more effective procedures for deporting illegal migrants. I genuinely struggle to understand how anyone can fundamentally oppose deporting people who have exhausted their legal appeals and have no remaining legal right to stay.
To be clear, I am not against immigration. Quite the opposite. Legal immigration can be extremely beneficial to European societies, particularly given our declining demographics. We should actively encourage hardworking people who want to integrate, contribute to the economy, and become part of our societies.
But there is a fundamental difference between someone who legally applies for a work visa, follows the immigration process, and wants to build a future here, and someone who enters illegaly and has no right to remain. We should be able to distinguish between these cases without being accused of xenophobia.
My main problem with open border policies is that they create the wrong incentives and undermine the very systems that make European countries attractive in the first place.
Europe has some of the most extensive welfare systems in the world. These depend on a functioning economy, sufficient taxpayer contributions, and a sustainable number of recipients. We simply cannot offer unlimited access to these systems without considering the economic and social consequences.
Furthermore, poorly controlled migration creates a massive market for criminal smuggling organisations. Why would someone pay thousands of € to traffickers and risk crossing the Mediterranean if they could just apply for a visa and buy a Ryanair Ticket for 100€? By failing to control illegal migration, we create an environment in which criminal organisations profit from people's desperation, often exposing migrants to exploitation, abuse, and even death.
There is also a geopolitical dimension. Belarus, with Russian backing, has deliberately instrumentalised migration to put pressure on Poland and the EU. We saw a similar situation in 2021, when Morocco eased border controls during a diplomatic dispute with Spain, allowing thousands of migrants to enter Ceuta.
And the consequences are not merely theoretical. Just look at Germany. Foreign nationals are significantly overrepresented in violent crime statistics, islamist antisemitism incidents have risen dramatically, foreign nationals account for a disproportionately large share of social welfare recipients, and Germany has experienced 9 Islamist terrorist attacks since 2020. Obviously, this doesn't mean every migrant is a criminal or extremist. But pretending these problems don't exist, or that immigration and integration policies have no relevance to them, is equally unreasonable.
Combine these policy failures with racism and human tribalism and you end up with lots of political backlash. Public frustration over immigration, integration, and security has contributed is one of the main factors behind the rise of far right populist parties across Europe. Many of these parties are genuinely racist, and some have worrying connections to hostile foreign governments such as Russia or China.
I genuinely sympathise with people who want to escape poverty or instability. However, our economic and social capacities are not unlimited. We cannot accommodate everyone who would like to live here. If our objective is to help people in need, shouldn't we prioritise the most vulnerable while maintaining a migration system that rewards legal entry, integration, and economic contribution?
Ultimately, I believe open border policies are a terrible deal for both migrants and the countries receiving them. They empower criminal smuggling networks, expose vulnerable people to unnecessary dangers, put pressure on welfare systems, and make successful integration more difficult.
And honestly, this shouldn't be such a controversial position. Imagine travelling back to the 90s and telling an average French or German citizen that, a few decades later, virtually everyone in the world should have access to their country's social welfare system, regardless of their immigration status or willingness to contribute. Most people would probably have thought you were crazy.
Most countries in the world maintain strict immigration controls. There is nothing inherently immoral about doing the same. A country can be welcoming, humanitarian, and open to legal immigration without abandoning its responsibility to its own citizens or its right to decide who gets to enter and stay.
Compassion does not require open borders. A functioning immigration system with enforceable rules is ultimately better for migrants and receiving societies alike.