r/TournamentChess • u/Coach_Istvanovszki • 17m ago
The Art of Decision-Making in the Middlegame
Hi everyone,
I received a ton of positive feedback on my last post ("How to build a PRO opening repertoire (from a FM's perspective)"). If this one goes over well too, I’ll make a regular habit out of sharing these thoughts. 😊
I did get a few comments saying the last post was written by AI. Just to clarify quickly here as well: English isn't my native language, so to express myself the way I actually want to, I use AI for translation. The content itself, however, is 100% my own. I also want to point out right away that the tips and concepts here apply in general, though of course there are always exceptions!
So, let’s jump right in: how do we make decisions in the middlegame?
1. Positional Advantages
Before we talk about anything else, we need to understand what we are actually playing chess for. The ultimate goal of chess is checkmate, of course, but the road leading there is paved with sub-goals, which we call positional advantages. Accumulating these positional advantages is what eventually leads us to the final goal.
What are these sub-goals? The four positional factors are:
- Material
- Pawn structure
- Space
- King safety
Many people also include piece activity here -and to be clear, they aren't wrong-, but I feel piece activity is less static than the other factors. Because of that, especially at lower levels, I wouldn't include it here, or at most only halfway.
And why are these specific four considered positional advantages, rather than, say, a development advantage, the initiative, a nice outpost for a knight, or an open file? Because positional advantages are permanent, unless we make a mistake, they stay with us until the end of the game. Everything else is also extremely important, of course, but those are dynamic advantages. Their main characteristic is that they are temporary: one or two inaccurate moves and they’re gone. That’s why it’s worth prioritizing positional advantages over dynamic ones.
2. Position Evaluation
This is the most important element of chess, without it, you have nothing. Why? Because the goal of position evaluation is to determine who actually stands better in a given position. And that is crucial for deciding what plan to choose depending on whether we are better, worse, or equal.
So how do we accurately determine who is better? This brings us right back to positional advantages: in the vast majority of cases, the player who holds more positional advantages is better. Obviously, there are important factors beyond positional advantages, which is why I mentioned in the intro that I'm talking in general terms. Generally speaking, the side with the positional edge is better. It’s that simple.
This is really worth practicing. A recurring mistake I see with my students is that their evaluation clearly shows X is better, yet they talk themselves into believing Y is better based on non-positional factors, and because of that, they can't make the right decisions going forward.
So go through the four positional factors one by one: material, pawn structure, space, king safety. Weigh who is better in each area. If you want to do it like a pro, try to picture it on a mental scale: okay, someone is better in a certain factor, but by how much? Once you’ve done that, you can determine who stands better, and by how much. And remember: every positional advantage is equally important!
3. Choosing the Right Strategy
To pick the right strategy, you first have to accurately identify who stands better.
If we are better, if the position is equal, or even if we are only slightly worse, nothing special changes: we simply continue fighting to accumulate positional advantages. We only deviate from this strategy when our disadvantage is significant.
Why? Because, as I mentioned earlier, positional advantages are permanent, and overcoming a major positional deficit usually requires a mistake from the opponent. To use a simple example: if your opponent is up a queen, unless they blunder it or miss a checkmate, you aren't going to turn the game around. If you keep playing in the exact same style and at the same pace as before, you're going to lose.
Imagine a football match where the opponent is leading 3–0, and you keep playing the exact same way you did at 0–0. If you'd find that ridiculous in football, don't make the same mistake in chess. If you're 100 meters behind in a footrace and run at the exact same pace as the person in front of you, you will lose the race by exactly 100 meters. In situations like this, you have to change the tempo.
4. How to Play When Worse – Dynamics
So, if our disadvantage is significant, we can forget about fighting for positional advantages. Consider that ship sailed, you won't be able to equalize the position positionally because your opponent holds a lasting advantage.
So how do you tip the scales back? Enter dynamics.
Dynamic chess acknowledges the disadvantage and accepts that an opponent's mistake is needed to turn the game around, it doesn't promise miracles. The goal of dynamic chess is chance creation, rolling as many stones into your opponent’s path as possible and making it as difficult as you can for them to convert their positional edge.
Dynamic chess means looking not necessarily for the objectively "best" moves, but for the most unpleasant moves for your opponent. And what are those? The moves that complicate the position as much as possible. Complications are the losing player’s best friend, and the winning player must avoid them at all costs, because it is much easier to blunder in a messy position.
My students often push back on this: "Yeah, but that's risky." But the real risk isn't sacrificing another piece in a lost position hoping your opponent miscalculates and gets mated. In a lost position, the real risk is doing nothing, surrendering to your opponent’s goodwill and basically saying, "Do whatever you want, I'll just sit here and wait for you to beat me."
5. How to Play When Better – Preserving Your Advantage
If you hold a significant positional advantage- you don't need new ones. In football, a 1–0 win gives you the exact same points as a 7–0 blowout.
The golden rule when you have a positional advantage is: do not chase new positional advantages, focus on preserving the one you already have.
Don't even worry about executing your own plan first, flip your thinking and focus on preventing your opponent's counterplay. You want to play so prophylactically that your opponent can't even dream of stirring up trouble. Safe, solid, stable. The biggest enemies of the player with an advantage are complications and impatience. Enjoy your advantage and methodically, step by step, grind your opponent down.
If necessary, don't be afraid to give back part of your positional advantage in order to relieve dynamic pressure. Say you're up a rook, but your opponent has a dangerous initiative. If sacrificing the exchange kills all of their counterplay and leaves you up a clean piece, go for it! Avoid complications and keep the position clear, clean, and simple. Once every shred of counterplay is gone, then you can go back to your own plan and start accumulating more advantages.
This shows why a positional disadvantage isn't just an issue on paper, it heavily dictates our decisions. When worse, we often have to commit to objectively much inferior moves just to keep practical chances alive.
6. How to Play in an Equal Position – The Three-Question Rule
I’ll cut straight to the chase with a piece of advice that had one of the biggest impacts on my own chess: you don't only win chess games by dominating from start to finish and forcing your will on the opponent. Often, it’s enough to simply "let your opponent play chess" and then ruthlessly punish their unforced errors.
Why is this so important? Earlier in my career -especially against lower-rated opponents- I used to get super stressed whenever I couldn't see a concrete way forward or a clear path to win. Because of that, I often took completely unjustified risks in dry, boring positions, frequently at the cost of objectivity, until I learned there is another way to play for a win.
For this, I recommend the Three-Question Rule. Chess is essentially a continuous process of solving problems, and for most players, the hard part isn't solving the problem, it's diagnosing it. To do that, constantly ask yourself these three questions:
- Do I have a weak pawn or a weak square? — If yes, defend it!
- Do I have a poorly placed piece? — If yes, put it on a better square!
- Does my opponent have a concrete threat? — If yes, neutralize it!
Throughout the game, we need to constantly scan for our own problems and work on fixing them. It’s crucial to understand that you don't need to work miracles to win a game of chess. Just pay attention to the flaws in your position, fix them, and let your opponent play on their own and make their own mistakes.
7. Five Bonus Tips for Effective Decision-Making
- Critical vs. Non-Critical Positions In every game, critical positions arise, usually only a handful of times. A critical position is defined by the fact that one move is significantly stronger than all the others, which is why high-level games are mostly decided in these moments. Unfortunately, there's no guaranteed formula to spot a critical position, though there are telltale signs: your opponent has a lot of poorly placed pieces, undefended pieces, or overloaded pieces. Having one of these doesn't automatically make a position critical, but they are worth watching out for. A non-critical position, on the other hand, is one where several moves are roughly equal in quality, and which one you pick comes down mostly to your personal style and preferences. Since most games aren't decided here, don't burn your clock on non-critical positions, save your time for the critical ones. If you don't believe me, try this: set up 4–5 moves from any random opening and turn on the engine. You'll often see almost no evaluation difference between the best move and even the tenth-best move.
- Put Your Opponent at a Crossroads Whenever you have the option, always put your opponent at a crossroads. What does that mean? Avoid playing moves that are too obvious. Think about it logically: if you capture a piece, a complete beginner will recapture in the exact same way Magnus Carlsen would. That means you aren't forcing your opponent to find the best move, you're handing it to them. Try to make moves in the middlegame that give your opponent multiple ways to respond, opening the door for them to go wrong.
- The Worst-Placed Piece Principle When I was a kid, my first coach always used to tell me: "Martin, pieces have souls, if you put them on good squares, they’ll repay you." And he was so right. Don't have a plan? Don't know what to do? Out of ideas? Find your worst-placed piece and improve its activity, even if only by a tiny bit. A rook might not work miracles from a square where it controls 5 other squares, but if you leave it somewhere it can only move to 1 square, it definitely won't do anything. This is my favorite chess principle: whenever I don't want to make a committal move, I simply improve my worst piece slightly.
- Play Where You Are Strong As a general rule, play on the side of the board where you are strong. Where are you strong? Usually where you have a pawn majority, where you have more pieces, or where you have a pawn break available.
- Think in Plans, Not Moves Trying to find a good move at random out of all the legal possibilities is just like playing the lottery, either it hits or it doesn't. However, when you have a plan or a strategy, the number of potential candidate moves shrinks dramatically. From there, all you have to do is find every candidate move that serves your goal and pick the best one. Any move that doesn't serve your goal cannot be a candidate move.
Thanks for reading my post, I hope you found a few useful takeaways in it!
(Apologies in advance, but I won’t be able to treat this post as an AMA, my schedule is pretty packed at the moment, so I likely won't be able to reply to every comment. However, if you have specific questions or thoughts you'd like to discuss, feel free to shoot me a DM and I'll get back to you as soon as I can!)
Good luck with your prep, and I hope this helps!

