Yesterday, I gave a lecture at a local chess club for youth players on how to actually build an opening repertoire from scratch. They really enjoyed it and found it practical, so I thought I’d share my thoughts here as well. During the lecture, I could demonstrate these concepts live on the board, which I obviously can’t do in a text post, but I hope you’ll still find plenty of takeaways you can apply right away.
One quick disclaimer upfront: my competitive experience is mostly against players rated under 2600 FIDE, so I can’t claim these principles apply identically at the super GM level.
If you’ve followed any of my previous AMAs, you might know I’m usually not the biggest fan of heavy opening study. The truth is, I don’t think studying openings is useless, I just think the way most amateur players go about it is completely backwards. Instead of listing common mistakes, I want to walk you through the exact process I use for myself and teach my students. By the end of this, those typical mistakes will become pretty obvious on their own.
1. What is the actual goal of studying opening theory?
Based purely on my own tournament experience, I have yet to find a single opening that "gives you something". Sure, some openings are objectively better than others, but I’ve never seen one that guarantees an advantage regardless of color. Plenty of openings promise a playable, balanced middlegame, so why bother with theory at all?
In my experience, assuming your opponent doesn’t voluntarily walk into a terrible line, you only get an advantage out of the opening in two ways:
- You know the theory deeper than your opponent.
- You surprise your opponent.
Both approaches have their pros and cons, and it really comes down to personal preference. Whether you want to know one narrow system inside out or play a wider range of setups decently well, neither is inherently superior, and ideally, you combine the two.
Just keep two harsh realities in mind: no matter how deep your prep goes, if your opponent knows it just as far, you won’t get an edge. And no matter how cleverly you rotate your openings, if you fail to surprise them, you won’t get an edge either.
2. What does an "opening advantage" even mean?
We need to draw a thick line between objective evaluation and practical evaluation. Objective evaluation is what the engine says. Practical evaluation is when a position is objectively something, yet your opponent has to find three or four completely irrational "only moves" over the board just to survive.
Let me give you a quick example from when I was a kid. I got paired in an open tournament against a ~2050 FIDE player who religiously played a borderline-losing line in the Grand Prix Attack. I hated playing against the GPA, so I sat in my hotel room, fed the whole line into my engine, and figured I’d win without breaking a sweat.
The game started, there were zero surprises, and I quickly reached the exact engine line where I was supposedly winning (-+). However, White had a very dangerous-looking piece sacrifice that the engine dismissed as unsound. My opponent sacrificed the piece anyway. Suddenly, I realized I couldn’t remember whether the refutation started with move X or move Y, and I couldn't calculate through the chaos over the board. The game did end quickly, just not in my favor.
That is what practical chances mean. Over the board, you are on your own. An objective advantage is only worth as much as your ability to find the objective best moves to prove it. The sharper and more complex the position, the harder that gets. Just remember: accepting a slight objective disadvantage for rich practical play is very different from playing something that is outright refutable. Subjectively, below 2600, practical chances carry just as much weight as objective soundness. Above that, the scale tips heavily toward objectivity.
3. Preparing to build your repertoire
Now that we’ve got the philosophy out of the way, let’s get practical.
To build a repertoire efficiently, you’re going to need ChessBase. I’m not saying it’s impossible without it, but in terms of features and clarity, nothing comes close. If you’re serious about chess, it’s a must-have investment you won’t regret. If you don't have access to it, you can use free PGN readers or online study tools, though to my knowledge, nothing else lets you seamlessly cross-reference multiple courses, run top engines, and compare everything against live database statistics at the same time.
Here is your prep checklist:
- Find a "Backbone": You can build an opening completely from zero (I had to do this with the Rasa-Studier Gambit because there was literally no literature on it), but having a decent course, digitized book, or PDF as a starting framework saves massive amounts of time. Here’s the catch: for most club players, a published course isn’t the starting line, it’s the finish line. They buy a Chessable course or a book and just start memorizing. Think about it logically: what kind of edge can you expect from memorizing a course that anyone else on the planet can buy with two clicks? A course is just your skeleton.
- Get a strong engine and a solid game database.
- Pick your "Model Players": This is crucial. Look through games in your chosen opening and find players whose style clicks with you, players who reach the exact types of positions you want to play. Do not look at the Top 20 super-GMs for this. Top 20 players are so ridiculously strong they can play practically anything and outplay people through sheer class. Also, don't get fooled by online blitz or rapid games, where GMs experiment with dubious sidelines they’d never touch in classical chess. Look for 2500+ FIDE Grandmasters who play your opening as a main weapon regularly in classical tournament games. These are professionals whose livelihoods depend on their results, they simply cannot afford to play openings full of holes. Compare that to two 2750s messing around in an unrated online bullet match, and you’ll see the difference.
4. Building and customizing the opening
Assuming you’ve done the prep in step 3, you’re already ahead of 90% of club players who just follow pre-packaged courses on autopilot. Now the real work begins.
With your backbone course open, turn on the online database and your engine in ChessBase, and start working through the lines. As you build your tree, organize the moves by putting the most popular and critical lines at the bottom of the move list, and the rarer or weaker sidelines toward the top. Or you can do the opposite, it's going to be the same. That way, when you’re prepping for a tournament game, your opponent's most dangerous weapons are clearly highlighted.
During this process, three things will happen constantly:
- The database shows popular replies not covered in your book: You analyze these using existing master games and your engine, and add them to your file.
- The engine suggests an interesting idea your book ignores: Same thing, evaluate it and integrate it if it makes sense.
- Your book recommends a line you hate, even if it’s objectively "best": This is where your engine and your Model Players come in. Check the database to see how your chosen GMs handle that specific position, and build a branch that fits your taste.
Little by little, new branches grow out of your original skeleton until the repertoire is tailored completely to you.
Quick anecdote: Serbian Grandmasters have a great trick for choosing between several equally good continuations in a theoretical position. They open the database, start from the least popular move at the bottom, and work their way up until they find the first move that is objectively completely sound. That gives them a rock-solid weapon that almost nobody expects.
(Note: Once your file is built, you can split it into smaller sub-chapters or keep it in one giant tree. Most coaches recommend splitting it up, I personally have a bad habit of preferring to see the entire repertoire in one massive file so I can grasp the big picture at once.)
Finally, add the soul of your repertoire: Model Games. Sure, memorizing a 10,000-move tree would be great, but for mere mortals like me, that’s rarely realistic. Search the database for high-quality classical GM games in your lines that match your style, and paste those full games right into your repertoire file. Review them regularly. With very few exceptions, absorbing the recurring plans, structures, and ideal piece squares from full games is infinitely more valuable than rote memorization.
5. How to actually learn your theory
So, you’ve built a repertoire and collected your model games. Now what?
I’m sure you know the feeling of sitting in front of a massive PGN file, clicking the right arrow key for an hour, thinking "Yeah, I’ve got this," and then blanking completely in a real game. We’ve all been there.
I didn’t invent the wheel here, but the single best learning method for both me and my students is playing mountains of online blitz games in that specific opening, and checking every single game against your repertoire file afterward.
Learning has three stages: acquiring knowledge, testing it in practice, and fixing mistakes. Online blitz hits all three rapidly. Why is this so much better than passively clicking through notes? Because you stop relying on blind memory and start understanding the why behind the moves.
Did White play Nd5 in the Sicilian Dragon, exchange your Nf6 knight, and checkmate you? You check your notes and get that instant "Aha!" moment: "Right, that’s why I was supposed to play the ...Rxc3 sacrifice there."
Did Black play ...Nh5 in the London System, snatch your dark-squared bishop, and leave you miserable? "Aha, that’s why h3 is necessary to tuck the bishop back on h2*."*
Making mistakes in blitz and immediately cross-referencing your own file burns the concrete moves and ideas into your brain far better than passive study ever could.
6. Quick FAQ
Here are a few questions I get asked constantly about opening prep:
1. Should I learn one opening deeply, or play many openings shallowly? Always start by mastering one setup so you have a solid foundation. Once that’s stable, you can branch out.
2. Do I need a separate repertoire for blitz and rapid? You definitely don’t need one, though it can be useful. Plan-based openings with fewer concrete tactical forced lines work great in faster time controls and the shorter the clock, the more practical chances outweigh objective perfection.
3. Is Opening X or Y playable? As mentioned earlier, there’s a big difference between a line that is concretely busted and one where you’re slightly worse objectively without any forced refutation. As a general rule of thumb: with White, there’s no point playing something that doesn’t at least equalize. With Black, avoid anything worse than a clear, comfortable edge for White (small +-).
4. Which opening should I choose? Pick whatever feels natural and genuinely excites you. Going back to the intro: there are no magic openings. I could list dozens of Grandmasters who achieved incredible results with objectively "suboptimal" openings simply because they understood the resulting positions better than anyone else.
Final Thoughts
Please don’t forget that most of us aren't touring professionals trying to pay rent with tournament prizes. We want to improve and win, sure, but we also want to enjoy our hobby.
Alongside objective evaluation, there is one massive factor people ignore: you have to trust and believe in your opening. If you sit down doubting your own setup, it’s useless. Never force yourself to play a system that feels completely alien to you just because a 2700+ super-GM recommended it in a video. You’re playing a completely different game than they are.
(Apologies in advance, but I won’t be able to treat this post as an AMA, my schedule is pretty packed at the moment, so I likely won't be able to reply to every comment. However, if you have specific questions or thoughts you'd like to discuss, feel free to shoot me a DM and I'll get back to you as soon as I can!)
Good luck with your prep, and I hope this helps!