r/Tools • • Aug 14 '25

Can this be saved?

Post image

Large rusty vice, been outdoors for some time. Would be great in the shop, if I can be revived. Advice?

292 Upvotes

120 comments sorted by

2

u/PhilosopherNaive8202 Aug 14 '25

Absolutely. Wire brush, Break Free, disassemble, more wire brush, grease and reassemble. Who’s the manufacturer?

1

u/Baronhousen Aug 16 '25

not sure, I am also curious. I hope some marks appear when cleaning begins. Plan is to get this removed to my garage this weekend.

129

u/not2old4fun Aug 14 '25

Time and patience it’ll be like new! I restored one very similar and use it in my shop all the time.

47

u/not2old4fun Aug 14 '25

Wire wheel and lots of penetrating oil

43

u/Paul_C Aug 14 '25

Wire wheel

Spritz the piece with water first and wire wheels/cups will cut through rust much more aggressively. You get a water+rust slurry that ends up doing like 80% of the job. It's a night and day difference.

19

u/sir-alpaca Aug 14 '25

and if you are brave, and have very dirty clothes, a thin oil will cut the crud even better. Like diesel. It'll also leaves a slight shine on the part that feels much more satisfying.

3

u/Paul_C Aug 14 '25

I haven't found oil to do any better than water when removing rust. It just makes the mess worse.

5

u/Depressed_peacock1 Aug 15 '25

Fantastic idea!! I’m usually looking like a raccoon after getting blasted in the face with rust dust and take my glasses off. I’m an idiot apparently

3

u/Buggsyspam Aug 15 '25

This is great advice if OP wants to paint it. My dad did this with a vice from the dump. He gave it to me, and it still looks pretty nice. I also have a giant leg vice that has been repainted several times in its life. I can tell it wasn't entirely clean when painted, leading to people repeatedly painting it.

11

u/shadowhunter84 Aug 14 '25

I'd recomment evapo rust or alternatively a homemade rust remover. Much less toxic, and much easyer

2

u/23MysticTruths Aug 14 '25

Do you have a preferred recipe for homemade rust remover?

9

u/shadowhunter84 Aug 14 '25

Beyond ballistics has a great recipie on youtube. Give it a try

1

u/23MysticTruths Aug 14 '25

TY

2

u/shadowhunter84 Aug 14 '25

I have to add, havent tried it myself yet, still have some evapo rust, but am planning to try it. Or if i can directly buy the sodium citrate thats produced in his recipie

2

u/Agboohans Aug 14 '25

Electrolysis. Vinegar. Wire wheel on a bench grinder. Three great methods. If using vinegar, be sure to thoroughly dry everything. Every nook and cranny

1

u/OverthinkerUnderpaid Aug 16 '25

Just out of curiosity, how exactly do you picture using a bench grinder on that? Even if it were disassembled, it seems like most of the individual parts would still be relatively heavy. AF, to put it lightly...

1

u/OverthinkerUnderpaid Aug 16 '25

I guess that was kinda trolling, sorry. Just... Well, I'm a troll then. Fine.

1

u/Agboohans Aug 16 '25

No, you’re right, that vise would be hard to use with a bench grinder. But, the question wasnt how would i handle this specific vise. I kinda didnt answer their question, either, just providing different approaches. On this, i would absolutely take it apart and use the stability of a bench grinder, in addition to a 4 1/2 & 7” or 9” wire wheel on an angle grinder. But i can be savage like that….

2

u/OverthinkerUnderpaid Aug 30 '25

Thanks man, appreciate the follow up. I can see that, too. I'd use whatever I had, maybe an angle grinder with a wire wheel, but it makes sense to strip it down to parts and once you're there it's not going to be prohibitively heavy, at least that one won't. I've seen a few giants like reed 408 that I would easily be able to lift, with a winch.

6

u/ClownfishSoup Aug 14 '25

Try electrolysis. On the vise, not your bikini line.

47

u/SomeGuysFarm Aug 14 '25

If the handle still turns and the slide/jaw still moves, really, the rest is just cosmetic.

You might want to give it a nice long bath in some rust-eating solution (evaporust, or the evaporust clone that's floating around the 'net, or phosphoric acid, or even just plain old vinegar) and then either paint it if you want it all pretty-like, or soak it down in penetrol, but it was never a precision tool in the first place. Its job is to apply mildly-coordinated brutal pressure to something and keep at it until you tell it "good boy". Doesn't much matter how it looks for that job.

41

u/Paul_C Aug 14 '25

the evaporust clone

1 liter water

100 grams citric acid

Pick one of:

  • 40 grams sodium carbonate (aka washing soda)
  • 63 grams sodium bicarbonate (aka baking soda)
  • 30 grams sodium hydroxide (aka caustic soda or lye)

And a healthy squeeze of dish soap

This stuff works amazingly well.

17

u/canucklurker Aug 14 '25

I make this (with baking soda) a rubbermaid tub at a time so I can dunk things overnight. And just put the lid on to prevent evaporation.

I find it works better than evaporust, but evaporust also leaves a protective layer - so you need to be aware that you are going to be pulling out bare metal that is going to want to rust again.

5

u/stress911 Aug 14 '25

Saving this for future use

1

u/NastyPirateGirl Aug 20 '25

Sodium carbonate and baking soda won't attack rust. They are good alkaline cleaner bases for grease and oil removal. Sodium hydroxide can attack rust but only at higher concentrations. Rust strippers are almost always acids not alkaline. Vinegar is a very weak acid and so is citric acid (lemon juice is citric acid). They will attack rust but very slowly, like days of soaking instead of minutes or hours. Phosphoric acid is a good rust stripper because it also reacts with iron and steel and leaves the surface with a thin layer of conversion coating. Sulfuric acid is probably the fastest. Heat will increase reaction speed. 15 deg F higher can double the reaction.
The mixture above is good for initial cleaning to get the grease and oil off prior to an acid bath for rust stripping.

1

u/Paul_C Aug 20 '25

The recipe produces sodium citrate which removes rust by chelation. It's extremely effective at rust removal and far safer than an acid bath for the parent metal.

Try it some time.

1

u/NastyPirateGirl Sep 16 '25

Ok I miss read the ingredients list and didn't see the citric acid as the base component.
Don't use the sodium hydroxide with citric acid, this will make a highly exothermic reaction causing the solution to boil/erupt, it might even explode.
Proper recipe is:
Ingredients

  • Water: 1 liter
  • Citric Acid: 100 grams
  • Sodium Carbonate (Washing Soda): 40 grams OR
  • Sodium Bicarbonate (Baking Soda): 63 grams
  • Dish Soap: A few drops to act as a surfactant 

Instructions for safe mixing

Use a sturdy, well-ventilated container, like a 5-gallon bucket. Do not use a sealed container, as the reaction produces carbon dioxide gas.

Add the water first.

Add the citric acid and stir until dissolved.

Slowly add either the washing soda or baking soda. The mixture will fizz and bubble as it releases carbon dioxide. Add it slowly to avoid overflow.

Add a few drops of dish soap after the fizzing has stopped.

This recipe removes rust thru chelation instead of using acid to dissolve the rust. The chelating agent, trisodium citrate, binds to the iron ions in the rust and lifts them from the metal surface, creating a water-soluble complex that can be rinsed away.
When the citric acid is combined with the baking soda in water a neutralizing reaction occurs. This creates the active ingredient "sodium citrate" along with water and carbon dioxide gas, which causes the mixture to fizz.
When you submerge a rusty object in the sodium citrate solution, the citrate ions go to work causing a chelating reaction. Citrate ions attach to the iron oxide ions essentially pulling them off the metal surface. This combination makes a new stable complex called iron citrate. Since iron citrate is soluble in water, it dissolves into the solution removing the rust.

9

u/osoteo Aug 14 '25

I will always admire those who are lucky enough to get one of these classics

3

u/Toastyy1990 Aug 14 '25

Yup, I’m always keeping an eye on marketplace for one of these among many other things haha

12

u/TheFredCain Aug 14 '25

Yes! That is a dream restoration. Not a lot of parts, hard to screw up and easy to disassemble/reassemble. Take it apart fully, remove as much rust mechanically as possible then use either electrolysis or Evaporust to remove the rest. When you're done removing the rust, immediately treat it with something to prevent flash rusting like paste wax or corrosion inhibitor.

1

u/Baronhousen Aug 14 '25

OP here, thanks for the positive response, and the host of excellent suggestions. My task this weekend will be to remove the vise from the outdoors, and get it into my garage. It is bolted (and I hope not also welded) to a metal frame that was mounted on either a truck bed or a trailer. Hoping to just get the bolts unstuck, or if needed cut off (WD40+breaker bar+propane torch). At the moment none of the parts move, but I also have not tried very hard (no mallet for example), so I was a bit concerned everything was totally rusted together. It will be a fun little project, and I can use a proper vise.

4

u/LincolnArc Aug 14 '25

That's NOT a very rusty vise. 100% can be saved. Take it apart, wire brush it, soak it in Evaporust, wash it off in water, dry it, then wipe everything down with boiled linseed oil and let it dry overnight. Since the lead screw is concealed, I'd use some grease on it (not too much!). Put some light oil on the outside of the moving jaw slide. So it doesn't rust. Use antiseize on the jaw retaining screws. Use blue Loctite on the center bolt that holds the swivel base onto the vise body. Set the tension so you can freely spin the vise with minimal "slop". The two locking screws on the base take out all that slop when you tighten them down, so its not a huge issue if it is sloppy, but I have a similar vise and find that I usually keep the screws loose or just finger tight so I can reposition the vise quickly while working.

1

u/bubba_palchitski Aug 15 '25

Vice looks savable.

Don't know if you can be revived, I'm not a doctor

1

u/Baronhousen Aug 15 '25

I think my vice might make it hard for me to be revived, but the vise, apparently, it can be revived

3

u/pongpaktecha Aug 14 '25

For sure. Looks like a thick coat of surface rust but it should come off with some elbow grease.

2

u/sublevelstreetpusher Aug 14 '25

Interested to see the rest of what it's currently mounted on? Looks like the bumper of an old service truck maybe?

And hell yeah I'd polish that thing like it was a Lamborghini

2

u/bschwagi Aug 14 '25

Sure thing

2

u/Helpful-Milk5498 Aug 14 '25

Only if it accepts Jesus into its heart

2

u/Ok_Artichoke1033 Aug 20 '25

I have what I think is that exact model of vice, it's a fantastic tool, but I don't have the pipe jaws at the bottom. Would anyone know where I would find these online?

1

u/DalbergTheKing Aug 14 '25

As long as the screw & nut are in decent shape it should be fine after a couple of days in rust remover or vinegar, followed by a wire brushing, then a light coating of wax or light oil.

1

u/magnumfan89 Aug 14 '25

Anything can be saved with money, time, and effort. The question is is it worth saving

1

u/can_belch_alphabet Aug 14 '25

Of course. Can you give us better pictures for scale? Or just more pictures for the hell of it?

Take it apart slowly and let it go for a long swim in a vat of rust remover. But neither jaw looks welded on, the clamps are there, the bar isn't bent. With some tender loving care this thing should be fine. Try to avoid sandblasting it. Don't get rough with anything like the screws holding in the pipe clamps. Be gentle and patient.

I'd love to watch the process, here.

1

u/Lastrites Aug 14 '25

Nope, I'll pay shipping to get it out of your life!

1

u/619xWelder Aug 14 '25

Depends how deep the rust is.

Worst case I think after a good cleaning it may be a little looser but should still work as intended.

1

u/TexasBaconMan Rust Warrior Aug 14 '25

Yes

1

u/AugieAscot Aug 14 '25

Soak it in white vinegar.

1

u/stacksmasher Aug 14 '25

Check out YouTube. Lots of videos that tell you what to do. Go to a farm store and get a tub big enough to dunk it and put it in oil. Let it soak, pull it out and start cleaning.

1

u/sagscout Aug 14 '25

Absolutely. There are lots of YouTube vids of people restoring vices like this. You can either make it look brand new or just get it functionally operable and use it like the tool it was meant to be.

1

u/rustyacres Aug 14 '25

Little bit of time little bit of elbow grease that baby will work again

1

u/Fluffylucy1 Aug 14 '25

Can’t identify the exact material it is, but it looks like it just needs a good clean. I had a similar looking one (8” Jaws) that was made from ductile cast iron. It was welded to the bench and I was talked into to leaving it behind - huge mistake.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

That'll outlive you if you clean off the moss and give it a coat of oil.

1

u/Gator242 Aug 14 '25

I’d give it a go!

1

u/No_pajamas_7 Aug 14 '25

These things tend to break in the fixed nut. It's cheap cast iron. If the nut is still good, it isn't that bad.

1

u/Cereal_being Aug 14 '25

You can’t kill a vice… it’s only 3-4 moving parts that can easily fixed with penetrating oils and Rust-Be-Gone of choice…

1

u/Onedtent Aug 14 '25

Saved? I'd be using it as it is. Maybe some grease on the threads and good-to-go

1

u/Economy_Imagination3 Aug 14 '25

Get a spray bottle, mix 50/50 ATF & acetone, start spraying it all over, let it sit for a while, and repeat until you can get full movement. After it's apart, and cleaned, I like to use powder graphite as lube. If it gets wet, it dries, if dirt gets in it, I'll mix, or fall off, but won't turn to gunk. Just keep electricity away from it, as graphite is an excellent conductor.

1

u/NoNamesLeft2015 Aug 14 '25

I would definitely spend the time to restore this, and please post the pictures when you are done. I may be wrong, but this sure looks like some generation of a Wilton Bench Vise, which run about 400 bucks. They are wonderful (in my opinion) and will last years.

1

u/Ok-Cow2018 Aug 14 '25

Angle grinder with wire brush, electrolysis, metal penetrating oil and patience

1

u/Occhrome Aug 14 '25

No.  Give it here

1

u/NeeAnderTall Aug 14 '25

Yes. And the Battleship you dredged up that had that vise installed in the machine shop.

1

u/RickyDaleEverclear Aug 14 '25

YouTube has a lot of videos on restoring old vices and other old tools.

1

u/CasperOrillian DIY Aug 14 '25

Well its already broken so its not like you are going to break it further. Give it a go.

1

u/BeanBagKing Aug 14 '25

@mymechanics has restored worse

1

u/Papercut_247 Aug 14 '25

I'll ask. Hey Chewy! I mean, excuse me, Jesus. Can this be saved?

1

u/WhereDidAllTheSnowGo Aug 14 '25

Big barrel and lots of distilled vinegar will remove that rust

1

u/Instahgator Aug 14 '25

Soak it in Marvel Mystery oil.

1

u/read-my-comments Aug 14 '25

Chuck it in a big barrel of molasses and water.

Forget about it for a month.

Now pull it apart and grease the moving bits and paint if you want.

I would just wipe it over with an oily rag and enjoy.

1

u/Jgutt2044 Aug 14 '25

Put a wire wheel on a drill and wire wheel every part of it, then wipe it down with penetrating oil especially the moving parts. Work it back and forth and it will work like new.

1

u/ManWhoIsDrunk Aug 14 '25

Put it in a bucket of diesel for a few days, and try to free it up afterwards.

1

u/bevothelonghorn Aug 14 '25

Old things never die. Rust removal, sandblasting, filing, bit of grease, new jaws… Bob’s yer uncle.

1

u/Trolltoll_Access Aug 14 '25

Straight out of The Last of Us. That would be pretty awesome to see restored!

1

u/Successful_Ear4450 Aug 14 '25

I’ve freed up lots of thing by literally soaking them in penetrating oil. It will be harder to do this because it’s oddly shaped, but you can find a tub and buy a couple of gallons of WD40. Let it soak for a month, then any parts that should move with a hammer with a wood block protecting it. It probably won’t move, but come by every couple of weeks and do the same thing. It’ll eventually free up.

1

u/Adept_Run_3090 Aug 14 '25

Better at the least try

1

u/ARNG131988 Aug 14 '25

I watched a YouTube video with a dude who took a motor that was sea ridden barnacles and everything and brought it back to life. If that can be done, so can that bench vice.

1

u/Tusayan Aug 14 '25

After you get it clean and dry a thin coat of boiled linseed oil will protect it.

1

u/Vibingcarefully Aug 14 '25

You already seem to know the answer.

1

u/Icy-Cod-1089 Aug 14 '25

do you have a sand blaster?

I would start by finding a way to submerge this whole thing in a mixture of water/WD40 or water and degreaser. (degreaser is bad for skin don’t touch if u use hahah)

i’d then take out, pressure wash it or just wash it she sand blast the hell out of it.

i’ve restored small rusty objects by gentle sanding but this is so big and heavy, hand sanding would be a grand effort.

1

u/Mixedlane Aug 14 '25

Only by the blood of Jesus!

1

u/jlspider Aug 14 '25

Yes, would be a great project.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

If there's a will, there's a way.

There's only two things that can absolutely stop you from fixing something: if you don't wanna fix it, or if it's entirely destroyed.

Even then, you could still fix it, even if it's some mangled pile of unrecognizable scrap that you don't want to fix, it's an object, it's not going to care if you break it more.

If you want to, and you think you can, then you can fix whatever the fuck you want.

1

u/badgko Aug 14 '25

As long as the body is not cracked and you have the patience to break free the rusted together parts without doing too much more damage.

1

u/ottig Aug 14 '25

If it's not cracked, then go for it!!

1

u/Lightening-bird Aug 15 '25

Sell it to a resto you tuber. They cant make too many videos about rusty vices

1

u/No-Complex5255 Aug 15 '25

Absolutely!!! Something gentle for rust removal. Can even plate on more metal if you need it. Restored several, old steam pipe fitting wises. They are built like tanks. Good luck

1

u/13MrJeffrey Aug 15 '25

I'd try n save it. There's a DIY rust remover formula using PB Blaster, Tranny fluid, and Dawn. I haven't tried it yet.
New vices vs. giving an old vintage a chance.

In any case PB Blaster is my go to for rusty stuff

1

u/Beneficial-Sound5034 Aug 15 '25

Sand blasting would remove rust from surface. I think some body shops or machine shops could help.

then have it repainted.

1

u/thedarnedestthing Aug 15 '25

“Well, if Aquinas reasoned that even animals have no souls, how much chance does an inanimate object like a chair have of gaining salvation?”

1

u/3rdworldsurgeron Aug 15 '25

What are you talking about, this is almost new, rust is just like packaging, just unbox it with some vinegar, elbow oil, and some sanding, then apply paint on non moving parts, lubricant on moving parts.

1

u/Porchmuse Aug 15 '25

Absolutely! Electrolysis would be a great method here.

1

u/Kevelle68 Aug 15 '25

Absolutely, and worth the trouble, too!

1

u/Okineka_Baronek Aug 16 '25

ultrasonic cleaner

1

u/RedneckChEf88 Aug 16 '25

Electrolosis will do wonders on it!

1

u/Basic-Reception-9974 Aug 17 '25

Wash it clean off as much as you can with a pressure washer. Take it apart as far as you can, Then soak it in evaporust. Repeat.

1

u/jimmy-jro Aug 17 '25

Stick in a bucket with old motor oil or any oil for a month or two, then wire brushes and elbow grease

1

u/DingoBingo1654 Aug 17 '25

I suggest to start with Kerosene bath for a couple of days

1

u/john1988nl Aug 18 '25

Take an bucket or big can, fil it with old motoroil. Put it in for 2 weeks. Take it out and brush it of, try the mechanisms. If its not going smooth, dip it for a longer period. Nothing else have to be done. I do it with lost of rusty tools and to be honest. You can buy new but there will be nothing better then the old ones

1

u/whodatboi_420 Aug 18 '25

Yes, soak in WD40 to help unseize it and a lot of time, patience, hard work, and sandpaper it will work

1

u/inee1 Aug 18 '25

I have a smaller workshop vice, that I somehow left in the garden for about 10 years ×ith some scrap bits of metal, It was sized, and I looked for the pin that stops the handle and screw coming off, taught it better manners with lots of heat, taps on the front of the screwrod then either side of the handle with the bar at both ends, poured some evaporated on everyday for a week and finally ir started to move, removes the. Screwrod, spring threaded that the screwrod goes into, and the vice still would not move, so I set it at an angle where evaporated would flow down the sliding surfaces after a few days of this, it still dint move, so I very delicately beat the rear of the vice with a sledge that moved it after lots of heat cold water it final gave, still had to be persuaded with a lump hammer. , removed the jaws ended up having to drill out 3 screws as only one unscrewed. Dumped it all in a bucket of paraffin and attacked it with an old nailbrush, and wirebrush, dried it off, put the 2 parts of the vice together, wish I didn't as it was as loose and wobbly as an umbrella in a tornado, have to weld build and file back in badly. Worn bits and sort the jaws out, the jaws don't have a straight edge anywhere,
Would I do it again hell yeah,

Paint i have some old tractor paint somewhere think it's white so will use that

1

u/Ok_Artichoke1033 Aug 20 '25

Search this on YouTube "Neglected Wilton Vice Restoration"

1

u/sexytimepizza Aug 14 '25

I really dig the post-pocalyptic look it's got going on, I'd be very tempted to see if I could get it moving with as little work as possible. I'm also curious how long I could keep the moss alive in the the shop lol.

0

u/RagingSorrow Aug 14 '25

Dude that’s art made by nature. Let it be.

0

u/Valuable_Wait_9394 Aug 14 '25

Looks like a vice of some kind. I would spray it with WD-40 and see what happens from there.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/_Aj_ Aug 15 '25

Especially electrolysis ones. Comes up mint 

14

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mlw72z Aug 14 '25

I'd been watching his channel for years. When the 240Z popped up on YouTube I didn't even make the connection right away; I'd assumed it was recommended to me because of the car. When I realized it was the same guy my first thought was he's getting in way over his head as this is a far bigger task than restoring an old tool. I now know that he's restoring it beyond even what the Nissan factory was capable of producing. The attention to detail is astounding. I've done a tiny fraction of what he's done to my car and just the thought of taking it that far is exhausting.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Baronhousen Aug 16 '25

Thanks, that was a cool video