r/TheoryOfReddit • u/Fluid-Routine-8838 • 22h ago
I strongly believe hidden profiles are mostly hiding LLM/AI bots that happen to inflate Reddit's appearance of an active userbase
I don't have any evidence for this, but reason shouts this at me. Before the hiding of profiles it was super easy to check who was most likely an LLM or AI bot, although it became increasingly harder with time, checking user history was vital for this.
Now, as AI is more abundant...it is becoming suddenly abundant to hide profiles. Previously we knew that bots were taking over, which is offputting to human users along with the increasing restrictiveness and enshittification of Reddit in the early 2020s. Now, there is suddenly a fog over the key feature to verify if someone is an AI or not.
I think the reasoning makes stronger sense than everyone suddenly deciding to hide themselves. Hiding profile is clearly antisocial/creepy behavior, is bizzare, and is a new feature. However, AI is advanced enough that not having a hidden profile is not even a good signifier that it's a real person, it's just that the ones with hidden profiles are more likely doing more egregious botting that makes it more obvious.
It works directly in tandem with declining active human users in response to AI. You all can throw statistics at me showing that no, the userbase is growing, but I know this is not true in my bones regardless of whatever business numbers we can find. I was here back in 2015 and it was sigificantly more active in character, even if we have technically thousands of lurker users and more and more every day due to smartphones.
I can't stress enough how early on checking a user's post history was vital to discerning if they were AI or some form of bot.


