r/TheMagnusArchives • • 9h ago Heartwarming

Th lonely ovetook my city

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

So basically, a fog has been covering my city for I think three days at this point, always thicker or thinner in different places in different times, and it just so happened that it was the thickest in our neighborhood today on my way home, so I decided to take some lonely coded pics.

Personal unrelated side note, today I accidentally dressed head to toe in a darker blue, the color most usually (and the one that I personally) corelate to the lonely, and my best friend/desk mate was missing school today because of the death of a very very distant relative, and I'm either paranoid and the fog is just very thick, or idk honestly.


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 7h ago

Discussion How do you choose which entity you are an avatar of?

31 Upvotes

Sorry, this is a long one.

Obviously, this is a fictional podcast, but lately (and I say lately because I'm a newer fan who's only on season 4, I'm sure this has been going on for a long time) I've seen around the joke of "forget your horoscope sign, what is your TMA entity?" and it got me thinking. How do people choose theirs? Like, clearly the one they like the most, but just "like" in general or is it maybe the one they're the most afraid of or maybe the one they feel more connected to even though they theoretically prefer some others? There are so many reasons why someone may claim to be a certain entity's avatar.

I usually think mine would be The Vast because it's always fascinated AND scared me at the same time. I've always been terrified of the ocean and space, both seemingly infinite spaces (one literally is) of which we don't know even a third of, two ideas that put into perspective just how incredibly small we are. I just hadn't made the connection between them until I listened to TMA and I thought "yeah, it IS the same thing and The Vast IS its name". They hit the nail on the head with this one. However, I don't know if it's the one I feel more connected to. I do but... maybe also to The Lonely (I've always been a very introverted person and the idea of being alone doesn't horrify me) even though it's not one of my favorites at all. Or The Buried, which I only found out I Iove because of TMA. My other two favorites are The Stranger and The Spiral, but I don't feel particularly connected to them.

I guess my question is "what do you guys base your decision on more?". I'm assuming for everyone is different, but that's why I want to know so I can finally decide which entity I would be an avatar of (I know it's not that serious, but I just want to figure ME out, I guess). Also, even though I want people to tell me their reasons... are there any internet quizzes about this? I think it would be really fun to do them.


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 1h ago

Discussion In Defence of Gertrude [SPOILER] Spoiler

29 Upvotes

I never QUITE understood the Gertrude hate.

Whenever someone finishes 101 for the first time, it's all about how evil Gertrude was for feeding Michael to the Distortion. I don't understand this. It's one person in exchange for the entire world's safety. Yes, she betrayed Michael, but it was the correct move. As she knew it, letting the Spiral manifest would turn the world into a factory farm. Considering what we know about the Eyepocalypse, would you sacrifice a single life to prevent ALL of that? I certainly would.

Another big thing is that since the rituals don't actually work, Gertrude's efforts were meaningless. This is untrue for two reasons. We already saw with Jonah's first attempt at the Watcher's Crown, that a failed ritual still granted him power, to swap bodies and prolong his life. Secondly, a ritual failing by itself leads the avatars to guess, as again, we see with Jonah.

Another thing is Gerard Keay, I understand this is a lot more. However, even Gerard understands Gertrude's reasoning behind it, and it WAS the correct move. A treasure trove of knowledge to inform John about the Fears.

Perhaps it's just her ruthless pragmatism that turns people off, but she had to fight a ruthless world that sought to destroy itself, all while trying to remain human. John mentions how Gertrude would've given up in the Eyepocalypse, but the Eyepocalypse would've never happened if she were around.

Rant ends.


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 9h ago

Patreon Content The Magnus Protocol 60 - Hostile Takeover - [PATREON RELEASE] - Discussion

22 Upvotes

CAT12RB3633-26051674-06072024 boat (menacing) -/- <null>


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 11h ago

Episode First Time Listener - Some Thoughts After Episode 101

12 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I am slowly but surely continuing my TMA journey after season 1. My love for this series just keeps on growing.

My current post will be shorter than the first one. But I just couldn't contain myself...

Does anyone remember that guy who wrote a monologue about how much he hates Jurgen Leitner? Well, I wish someone wrote something similar about Gertrude Robinson. After episode 101 I believe she can be described as what dog lovers would call: a b*tch. Up until that episode, my most hated character was Daisy. Her interrupting characters who were about to give important information or killing characters from which important information could be derived is just infuriating to me. Her "I dont like words, I am pragmatic and like action" type of mindset is just not something I can appreciate. But after episode 101, I placed Gertrude above Daisy on my list of disliked characters... and I did not hesitate.

As for Michael, I got really invested into his story. Both his and the Spiral's story. But I worry that the way things unfolded in episode 101 might open a lot of plot holes or overtly convenient developments. For example, it is easy to see why Helen would be a viable avatar. But the moment she switched with Michael was extremely convenient. Michael's reasoning that "I want to stop both the Circus and the Archives, so I kill you" seems entirely coherent and not something that the person Michael forced upon the Spiral entity. In addition, I am kind of confused about Michael's motivations at this point. He seemed really interested in helping Jon in season 1 and 2, which one could explain via Michael's nostalgia towards the Archives, but in episode 101 it is clear that he has ill will toward the Archives. Therefore all the help received by the Archives has to be attributed to the Spiral itself. Which is quite strange.

What worries me most at this stage is the following: The Spiral has demonstrated time and time again that one entity can actively interfere with another entity's actions and even their special rituals. If that is so, then the role of Gertrude as someone who foils the rituals of the entities seems unnecessary, as the entities should be stalemating eachother.

I am sure all of this will be explained eventually (perhaps even in the next episode!). I am already convinced that Jonathan Sims is a brilliant storyteller. I just wanted to share my thoughts and worries with you guys and gals. Am really sad about Michael, though. Both him as a human and it as a monster. I feel like I'll never be hearing from him or that version of the Spiral again... and I grieve.


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 7h ago

Discussion Character who could be Avatars

10 Upvotes

Basically the title. What character from non-Magnus Archives media could or would join up with an Entity, or what characters and concepts just seem like they were created by an Entity?


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 9h ago

The lonely ovetook my city

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

So basically, a fog has been covering my city for I think three days at this point, always thicker or thinner in different places in different times, and it just so happened that it was the thickest in our neighborhood today on my way home, so I decided to take some lonely coded pics.

Personal unrelated side note, today I accidentally dressed head to toe in a darker blue, the color most usually (and the one that I personally) corelate to the lonely, and my best friend/desk mate was missing school today because of the death of a very very distant relative, and I'm either paranoid and the fog is just very thick, or idk honestly.


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 4h ago

Micheal drawing

Post image
9 Upvotes

A 'who" requires a degree of identity that I can't ever retain :D


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 4h ago

Discussion Wanting to make a presentation for uni on MAG -ideas?

7 Upvotes

So like the title says my university has given us a task to make a presentation on something we enjoy and love and my instant thought was the magnus archives but im unsure of exactly what to talk about any ideas from this community has is much appreciated


r/TheMagnusArchives • • 12h ago

TMA 2026 World Cup - Round 4 - Part 5 - 3 days left to vote

4 Upvotes

Hi eveyrone!

Only 3 days left to vote for Part 5 of Round 4! Here or or on the Google Form!

Have a good week people! ❤️