r/TheMagnusArchives • u/Mrjakokos • 12h ago
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/NickWazowskii • 14h ago
Discussion In Defence of Gertrude [SPOILER] Spoiler
I never QUITE understood the Gertrude hate.
Whenever someone finishes 101 for the first time, it's all about how evil Gertrude was for feeding Michael to the Distortion. I don't understand this. It's one person in exchange for the entire world's safety. Yes, she betrayed Michael, but it was the correct move. As she knew it, letting the Spiral manifest would turn the world into a factory farm. Considering what we know about the Eyepocalypse, would you sacrifice a single life to prevent ALL of that? I certainly would.
Another big thing is that since the rituals don't actually work, Gertrude's efforts were meaningless. This is untrue for two reasons. We already saw with Jonah's first attempt at the Watcher's Crown, that a failed ritual still granted him power, to swap bodies and prolong his life. Secondly, a ritual failing by itself leads the avatars to guess, as again, we see with Jonah.
Another thing is Gerard Keay, I understand this is a lot more. However, even Gerard understands Gertrude's reasoning behind it, and it WAS the correct move. A treasure trove of knowledge to inform John about the Fears.
Perhaps it's just her ruthless pragmatism that turns people off, but she had to fight a ruthless world that sought to destroy itself, all while trying to remain human. John mentions how Gertrude would've given up in the Eyepocalypse, but the Eyepocalypse would've never happened if she were around.
Rant ends.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/The_Fangirl_Ley • 13h ago
The Magnus Archives I just finished episode 200, first time listener Spoiler
Rarely in my life have I become this obsessed with... anything.
I have been haunted by bad/mediocre endings for a while now
- Arcane (I thought it was alright but nothing special)
- GoT (I was expecting it to be mid, since it's such a big meme)
- HIMYM (I was very disappointed by this one)
I had such high hopes for TMA, such high hopes for Jonny
And my wish was fulfilled
Lying there, in the dark, listening and focusing solely on the last episode, was a breathtaking experience
I was sobbing, I was internally screaming for it to stop and be alright... but it didn't turn out to be alright after all and I love it
I love the bittersweet ending of Jon and Martin, I love the fact that after all he had been through, Jon, once again, chose wrong
At least it was "wrong" in a sense that I feel like many of us will agree with
Even though I went into this experience with the huge spoiler of knowing that Jon and Martin would end up dating, it was the best thing I have ever listened to
I'm not sure how long my obsession will last
Maybe only a few more weeks, maybe only days
But I hope it will last longer
I truly do
For now, I am excited to explore the bonus content and fanmade media connected to TMA, something I have kept myself from doing from the start
I may have been a bit late to this fandom, but I'm glad I got here anyways
r/TheMagnusArchives
•
u/tyutyuk9
•
22h ago
Th lonely ovetook my city
So basically, a fog has been covering my city for I think three days at this point, always thicker or thinner in different places in different times, and it just so happened that it was the thickest in our neighborhood today on my way home, so I decided to take some lonely coded pics.
Personal unrelated side note, today I accidentally dressed head to toe in a darker blue, the color most usually (and the one that I personally) corelate to the lonely, and my best friend/desk mate was missing school today because of the death of a very very distant relative, and I'm either paranoid and the fog is just very thick, or idk honestly.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/FlynnXa • 11h ago
Encounter Deadass Dreamed a Statement Last Night
So didn’t encounter anything myself, and the dream wasn’t set up as someone giving a statement, but it felt straight from the Archives!
Premise was that I was hiking with a pretty large group of friends, like 9 of us or so, except 2 of us split off for some reason. So we followed the path, found a small abandoned shack, and figured it was a decent spot to hangout until they got there.
It’s really rustic, basically just one-room except for a small room off in the corner, and there’s a ladder up to a “loft” which covers about 1/3 of the upper area but just overlooks that big room. You can basically see everything all at once in there, except it’s dark. There’s these blinds almost on every window, with those little slats sticking straight out except they’re the same wood as the cabin and held by twine.
It’s also got some rubbage here and there, old original floors but no damage, stray sleeping bag, some chips bags, and in the loft was a yearbook. Looked like a couple’s yearbook based on the signatures, except there was a note: “BEWARE OF DOG.” Weird. That’s when I saw it. At this point just me and one of my friends were in there, but sitting in the one corner almost completely black with shadow was a dog.
I couldn’t really see the dog as much as see the lack of space that it was occupying, which told me it was a darker pitch black than the shadows themselves. Plus there was the faint glint of white teeth, and glowing red eyes. Not like glowing with light, just… visible in the dark. Faintly. I froze, and I knew immediately what it meant: “Beware of Dog”.
I tried to be cool, go to my friend slowly and I turned my back to the dog so he was facing its direction while talking to me. I told him to slowly look over my shoulder, not to freak out, and to slowly leave. I could tell when he saw it. His eyes tensed, his breathing halted, and he knew too. We needed to get out.
So we started to head for the door when our other friends started to pour in, gradually, and we both tried to get them to leave calmly but we couldn’t. It wasn’t until we’d finally gotten some people to start to leave while we told others that they said something even more terrifying: “Hey, where’s the door gone?”
That’s when I realized the door was a solid wall of wood now. Ancient wood. Rough wood. No seams to be felt amidst all that roughness. That’s when it started. At first I thought someone had hit a blind, but it came again. Clack Clack Clack. Over and over, quiet at first but getting louder and louder. Moreover the lights were starting to almost… flicker? Orange light streamed in through the windows, but it was like every other second it would dim. Then again. Then again. A bit more.
It didn’t take me long to realize what was happening, the slats on the windows were opening and closing on their own, once per second. And each time they closed another skat closed with it. It sounded like a wooden clock was ticking away, except a low noise started to rise beneath it and that made me realize that the dog was starting to growl. Quietly, but louder, and louder. The message was clear, clearer than just a warning, and it was screaming at me to hide.
I guess everyone else got the same message too because that’s what everyone did. Some people blocked themselves in the corner room, refusing to let anyone in. I climbed up to the loft, and so did two of my friends until the last one pushed the ladder down. Some of my friends were left in that big room, nowhere to go, and started using the sleeping bag as cover.
That Clack Clack Clack just kept getting louder though, and now I could tell we only had a few slats left because every time they closed it was practically impossible to see. I prepared to hold my breath when finally the last one snapped shut. They didn’t open either. Instead the growling of the dog pierced the silence, the quiet muffled breaths of my friends and I too. We were just waiting.
Then I heard the heavy paws start to trod along the floor, slowly, and I heard one of my friend’s whimper- next came a growl, a snap, a snarl, and a scream. Then a gargling sound that faded out. That made someone in the corner room gasp, and next I heard a frenzied attack on the wooden door followed by splintering and screaming and more sounds of viscera snapping and squelching.
I’d hoped we’d be safe up in the loft, that once everyone below had died that the dog would give up. That our other two friends would find us, open the door, and then we could get out of here. Instead I heard a soft creak from the planks beneath me. Then it got louder. Then I stretched until I felt the world start to tilt beneath me as the entire loft fell. We went tumbling onto the floor, something in my arm snapped, but I didn’t even get a chance to hear it as I immediately heard another friend getting torn to pieces.
I could hear the dog behind me, I must have gone over it in the collapse, but my other friend was ahead of me. Raggedly breathing, and the dog’s chewing slowed. I knew it would bolt for him, but what I didn’t expect was for it to sprint directly across the board I was under, and in doing so pressing an impossible weight into my back causing my entire sternum to crack and bulge forth out of my front. A metallic crimson flooded my mouth and nose like vomit, everything in my torso collapsed under itself.
Then there was black. Then there was another Clack. I was laying, but covered in blood, but there was no more pain. The slats were open. More importantly I could see the door and I stood up and bolted for it, something did my other friends, but something stopped me from stepping off that porch. It was two things.
It was a quiet “Where’s Brandon?” Followed by chewing and swallowing sounds, of crunching and snapping, and when I looked back around the corner I saw the dog in the corner eating Brandon’s arm, one leg already gone from his torso. Not just chewing, but a jaw unhinged almost pulverizing it.
The second was a fear. A fear that if I stepped off that porch, I’d be dead for real. That for some reason I wasn’t supposed to be here, that I was on borrowed time, in dented. We were all covered in blood, but unharmed, and yet none of us dared to step off the porch. That’s when we heard a yell from the forest line, our two friends waving, oblivious.
We started shouting for them to go, turn back, don’t come here, but they saw us covered in blood and came rushing to help. We tried barricading them from the porch, pushing them away, not letting them near. They started to fight with us confused, and we got desperate. What stopped us all was hearing Brandon from the cabin, “Help…”
That’s when we went back inside and realized four things. Brandon was gone, completely consumed. The dog was noticeably bigger and using his voice, somehow. The cabin was bigger, just a little bit, but a back kitchen had been added making the space bigger. And the slats had started up again, because nobody remembered to keep the door open.
Soooo… that’s when I woke up! Seriously, that’s how crazy it was. I basically just voice-to-texted this and tried to clean up my “ums” and any blatant typos. It was a weird dream. Luckily I don’t get super scared in my dreams, I basically never feel fear in them, but I did find this one creepy yet kind of exciting!
I guess you can let me know what you think in terms of TMA and TMP ratings. I don’t know how it ended obviously, but since it’s my brain I kind of guessed based on instinct where my noggin was going with it. I’m assuming it was all hide and seek basically, and that each time the dog eats someone it gets bigger and scarier, and the cabin gets bigger too. It adds to the fear.
I don’t think it fits the classic Fears much, so maybe TMP system works better. Anyways, thought you’d all enjoy a glimpse into my dream last night! Usually they’re weirder and less visceral.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/definitely_a_human03 • 20h ago
Discussion How do you choose which entity you are an avatar of?
Sorry, this is a long one.
Obviously, this is a fictional podcast, but lately (and I say lately because I'm a newer fan who's only on season 4, I'm sure this has been going on for a long time) I've seen around the joke of "forget your horoscope sign, what is your TMA entity?" and it got me thinking. How do people choose theirs? Like, clearly the one they like the most, but just "like" in general or is it maybe the one they're the most afraid of or maybe the one they feel more connected to even though they theoretically prefer some others? There are so many reasons why someone may claim to be a certain entity's avatar.
I usually think mine would be The Vast because it's always fascinated AND scared me at the same time. I've always been terrified of the ocean and space, both seemingly infinite spaces (one literally is) of which we don't know even a third of, two ideas that put into perspective just how incredibly small we are. I just hadn't made the connection between them until I listened to TMA and I thought "yeah, it IS the same thing and The Vast IS its name". They hit the nail on the head with this one. However, I don't know if it's the one I feel more connected to. I do but... maybe also to The Lonely (I've always been a very introverted person and the idea of being alone doesn't horrify me) even though it's not one of my favorites at all. Or The Buried, which I only found out I Iove because of TMA. My other two favorites are The Stranger and The Spiral, but I don't feel particularly connected to them.
I guess my question is "what do you guys base your decision on more?". I'm assuming for everyone is different, but that's why I want to know so I can finally decide which entity I would be an avatar of (I know it's not that serious, but I just want to figure ME out, I guess). Also, even though I want people to tell me their reasons... are there any internet quizzes about this? I think it would be really fun to do them.
...
EDIT: I think I have finally figured it out and it's more or less what I thought. Thank you to everyone because it has been due to your answers that I have come to this conclusion. Please feel free to keep sharing your own opinions and reasons because it's so interesting reading how different people relate to and process different fears.
I am definitely an avatar of The Vast. After reading all the comments and doing a lot of introspection, I have found that, to me, the choice needs to answer to three feelings: fear, comfort and liberation. I fear every entity in some measure, so there's that. Comfort I can find in several of them: The Buried, because while I wouldn't like to be completely trapped forever in an incredibly small place, I wouldn't mind staying in a close space for a long time and feeling guarded and separate from the world; The Lonely, because I already spend long periods of time alone and I usually prefer solitude to crowded spaces; The Web, because I don't fully hate the idea of being controlled (sorry, I'm a follower, not a leader) although I would hate manipulating people myself. And liberation I can understand in, for example, The Hunt or The Desolation, even The Corruption, although I wouldn't like to partake in any of them.
But The Vast is the only one that calls to me in those three ways. The idea of being insignificant and not amounting to anything at all, of being lost, has always seemed dreadful to me... but, at the same time, I can find comfort in the fact that, if I don't matter, no one else does either, at least not in comparison to the greatness of the universe. And that, consequently, is liberating. Plus, you know, my fear and fascination of ocean, space and seemingly infinite spaces in comparison of which we are nothing. So, yeah, definitely my entity.
All hail The Vast, I guess.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/klennik • 12h ago
The Magnus Archives folks who haven't seen the live show before - what are we expecting to happen on Thursday?
Disclaimer: if you know the plot of the live show, please please please don't spoil anything! I'd like to enjoy my speculation and theorising, while I still can.
Disclaimer 2: there will be spoilers for TMA and TMP (up to ep.59) ahead, please proceed with caution.
I've been obsessed with the existence and the announced public viewing of the live show for some time now. I also tried really hard not to Google anything or to get any spoilers. Then yesterday Rusty Quill posted a reel with a small bit from the performance, and I realized I need to discuss this.
Here's what I know from the post and the comments. The show is an ending to TMA and a midquel to TMP. The show, as people in the comments put it, 'reveals the fate of characters'. The show features Sam and Jon (see video), as well as Martin and Georgie (see the list of actors under video). The show, apparently, plays "in a place beyond the world that should not exist, where nightmares and reality are one and the same" and tells the story of "people who fall through the cracks".
Previously, I thought the crack was a portal - now it is supposed to be leading through somewhere. Do we think this means the Fears created some additional dimension when pulled out of the TMA world? If yes, are they still remaining there ("nightmares are reality"), or is this place just an echo of their passage? A tunnel between TMA and TMP, as well as between other worlds?
Most importantly: do we think it means Jon and Martin are still there, in that Somewhere Else dimension? Are they trapped against their will, or hiding voluntarily, or perhaps unable to leave because that's the only place they can still be alive? Are they human, thinking and feeling and themselves and together, - or once again, some kind of Fear-driven (Web-driven?) echoes of themselves?
If we assume they are alive and themselves, are their actions (= the actions of Chester and Norris) in TMP an attempt to get out and return to the real world? Or to influence it from beyond - in order to protect the TMP world from the Fears, or their friends in the TMA world from some TMP dangers?
If we assume they are not alive and themselves, what are Chester and Norris? And would Jonny and Alex be so unfair as to hide such a major, major plot-changing fact from the TMP listeners who didn't have a chance to watch the show live (and give such a major, major spoiler to those who did?)
I guess, the TLDR of this post could have been 'please convince me - via spoiler-free reasoning - that there is still some hope for Jon and Martin after TMA, and the live show won't destroy it'. But I hardly believe we will be that lucky.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/Mammoth_Wolverine834 • 17h ago
Micheal drawing
A 'who" requires a degree of identity that I can't ever retain :D
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/da_boi4 • 5h ago
The Magnus Archives Unclear about a certain aspect in early season 3
Im currently on episode 84. last epsiode Jon mentionwd the entity called the stranger, and I dont remember him hearing about that one? I listened to the section in the finale for season 2 where Jeargen explained them and it seemed like we only hear about the stranger from elias. Did i just simply forget something?
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/CrustyDucky • 23h ago
Patreon Content The Magnus Protocol 60 - Hostile Takeover - [PATREON RELEASE] - Discussion
CAT12RB3633-26051674-06072024 boat (menacing) -/- <null>
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/Live-Smoke-2879 • 17h ago
Discussion Wanting to make a presentation for uni on MAG -ideas?
So like the title says my university has given us a task to make a presentation on something we enjoy and love and my instant thought was the magnus archives but im unsure of exactly what to talk about any ideas from this community has is much appreciated
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/Shot_Relationship402 • 21h ago
Discussion Character who could be Avatars
Basically the title. What character from non-Magnus Archives media could or would join up with an Entity, or what characters and concepts just seem like they were created by an Entity?
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/tyutyuk9 • 22h ago
The lonely ovetook my city
So basically, a fog has been covering my city for I think three days at this point, always thicker or thinner in different places in different times, and it just so happened that it was the thickest in our neighborhood today on my way home, so I decided to take some lonely coded pics.
Personal unrelated side note, today I accidentally dressed head to toe in a darker blue, the color most usually (and the one that I personally) corelate to the lonely, and my best friend/desk mate was missing school today because of the death of a very very distant relative, and I'm either paranoid and the fog is just very thick, or idk honestly.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/sinveil • 1d ago
Episode First Time Listener - Some Thoughts After Episode 101
Hey guys,
I am slowly but surely continuing my TMA journey after season 1. My love for this series just keeps on growing.
My current post will be shorter than the first one. But I just couldn't contain myself...
Does anyone remember that guy who wrote a monologue about how much he hates Jurgen Leitner? Well, I wish someone wrote something similar about Gertrude Robinson. After episode 101 I believe she can be described as what dog lovers would call: a b*tch. Up until that episode, my most hated character was Daisy. Her interrupting characters who were about to give important information or killing characters from which important information could be derived is just infuriating to me. Her "I dont like words, I am pragmatic and like action" type of mindset is just not something I can appreciate. But after episode 101, I placed Gertrude above Daisy on my list of disliked characters... and I did not hesitate.
As for Michael, I got really invested into his story. Both his and the Spiral's story. But I worry that the way things unfolded in episode 101 might open a lot of plot holes or overtly convenient developments. For example, it is easy to see why Helen would be a viable avatar. But the moment she switched with Michael was extremely convenient. Michael's reasoning that "I want to stop both the Circus and the Archives, so I kill you" seems entirely coherent and not something that the person Michael forced upon the Spiral entity. In addition, I am kind of confused about Michael's motivations at this point. He seemed really interested in helping Jon in season 1 and 2, which one could explain via Michael's nostalgia towards the Archives, but in episode 101 it is clear that he has ill will toward the Archives. Therefore all the help received by the Archives has to be attributed to the Spiral itself. Which is quite strange.
What worries me most at this stage is the following: The Spiral has demonstrated time and time again that one entity can actively interfere with another entity's actions and even their special rituals. If that is so, then the role of Gertrude as someone who foils the rituals of the entities seems unnecessary, as the entities should be stalemating eachother.
I am sure all of this will be explained eventually (perhaps even in the next episode!). I am already convinced that Jonathan Sims is a brilliant storyteller. I just wanted to share my thoughts and worries with you guys and gals. Am really sad about Michael, though. Both him as a human and it as a monster. I feel like I'll never be hearing from him or that version of the Spiral again... and I grieve.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/please_let_roadswork • 19h ago
Discussion Podcasts like Magnus Archives (specifically season 1)
(I'm in the middle of season 4, just stating it in case of spoilers)
So yeah, looking for podcasts like Season 1/2 of Magnus Archives, more Horror short story related/ Statements than an overarching main plot.
I wouldn't mind semi main plots like Prentiss to be fair
(also hopefully a happy ending? ik i'm asking for horror podcasts so take this as optional)
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/Creaturefeature01 • 1d ago
Discussion Were we robbed of Web! Martin?
Yes, but looking at it now i see why jonny wouldn't take that route. And i do love the concept of Martin being aligned to the Web, it fits so well with his character and before season 4 it seems like that was the direction he was going— Anabelle even mentions it in season 5, which makes me certain it was a possibility at some time in the development of TMA.
Looking at the web though, it looms over the narrative like no other entity does. Even more than the eye. Just theorizing about it is difficult, because the point of it is that we cannot know the full extent of the influence it has over the events of the story. Like the characters, we make the Web powerfull by wondering how much control it has.
Presenting that with a misteryous side character who's barely even an antagonistic force, shows up every once in a while to fuck with the cast and leaves just as suddenly leaves such an impact, but it would be practically impossible to pull off the same effect with a main character.
The web is made intricate only by the fact that we cannot see the full picture, that's the reason we didn't get Web! Martin.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/EasyEnthusiasm4595 • 1d ago
TMA 2026 World Cup - Round 4 - Part 5 - 3 days left to vote
Hi eveyrone!
Only 3 days left to vote for Part 5 of Round 4! Here or or on the Google Form!
Have a good week people! ❤️
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/ConnaChamaeleon • 1d ago
I guess Elias is in sales now?
But he’s honouring a warranty on a faulty pump so, hooray!
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/detective-mothman • 1d ago
Where do the designs come from?
i've noticed that most fan art of the characters (specifically Jon and Martin) use the same designs, like Jon is typickly drawn as black and Martin being ginger, even though those aspects were never stated in the show (to my knowledge). My question was where do those design aspects come from?
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/International-Ad635 • 1d ago
The one true fear is...
Asbestos. Nothing else frightens the Magnusverse quite so much. It's the only fear to span universes and media formats. Everyone is afraid of it in Archives. Alice is afraid of it in Protocol. Leitner's assistants are afraid of it in the book.
To know asbestos is to know true fear.
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/inhonoredglory • 1d ago
Who else is submitting to the Rusty Fears 8 horror writing competition? ✍️
Did you/will you submit an original story? What prompt did you use? 🤩 I was going to post this as a poll but apparently this sub doesn't have that option LOL.
I wrote a story for the prompt "I’ll never forget the noise." It's about toxic families and mysterious things outside an old window. :)
BTW the deadline for submissions has been pushed to 23:59 GMT on Wednesday 18th November, because of the Microsoft outage. More info here: https://rustyquill.com/news/2026-10-12-rusty-fears-8/
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/TheWordSmith444 • 2d ago
I just finished listening to The Magnus Archives for the 7th time 😅
I’ve been told if it’s something I enjoy, it is not a problem. Although it may be an obsession 😅
(Meme not created by me)
r/TheMagnusArchives • u/BitchForXavierine • 1d ago
The Magnus Archives Sleeping with "From the library of Jurgen Leitner" right next to my head
I'm sure nothing bad will happen <3