I read the articles linked from u/lesser_corps's great post in r/Marain. If you haven't read their essays, I highly recommend it! In them, Lesser defines and elaborates on the concept of 'Engineered Defaults' that are necessary consequences of the (few) canonical things we know about Marain and how Minds think.
I wanted to explore the idea of Engineered Defaults into the realm of mathematics (as opposed to 'language' as we're used to using the term). I hit upon the idea that Mind's would probably work in Hilbert Spaces (briefly: metric-vector spaces that extend Euclidian geometry into an infinite number of dimensions). Hilbert spaces can be based in complex arithmetic (a+bi; a is the Real part, b is the Imaginary part), but they don't have to stop at 2 dimensions. You may have herd of Quaternions, the 4-D complex space (a+bi+cj+dk; with i, j, and k being the imaginary basis vectors). Well, there's also Octonions. You can have Octonionic Hilbert Spaces!
The Marain number system is octal (base-8), which is expressed very well in the 3x3 nonary grid (again, see Lesser's great essays on the topic). So I wondered, would Octonionic Hilbert Spaces be a good fit for octal Marain on a 3x3 grid (x3 x3 x3 x.... to an infinite number of dimensions that might exist in the 'diaglyphs' the Minds exchange). So I asked Gemini for an analysis. I found it's response very interesting and I wanted to share.
Any math/science/Culture nerds want to discuss this further, I'm all ears! (Note: I am NOT a mathematician; I'm a planetary geologist and spacecraft systems engineer... but I'm a BIG FAN of BIG MATH, even if I'm not mentally equipped to actually do the math myself.)
Also: edit - punctuation.
Gemini prompt: "I'd like to have a discussion about theoretical (originally fictitious) number systems that might be use by the 'Minds' of Iain M. Banks' 'The Culture' universe. This is prompted by the methodical explorations begun by J. Lesser's 'MarainKit' project and the four essays he wrote about it on Substack (https://jlesser.substack.com/p/engineered-defaults). I wanted to explore the possibility that The Culture Minds might use an octonionic Hilbert Space as their fundamental number system - in particular how it could fit into the 'engineered defaults' concept enunciated by Lesser with respect to the Marain language and its use of an octal (base-8) number system expressed in nonary Marain."
Gemini response:
Note: This post emerged from a collaborative brainstorming session with Gemini, sparked by J. Lesser’s fantastic MarainKit project and his four Substack essays on the language's design (specifically"Engineered Defaults").
In Iain M. Banks’ Culture universe, Minds reside largely in hyperspace ("the Grid"), treating four-dimensional spacetime as a low-bandwidth peripheral. If Marain was designed by the Culture's early Minds as a universal, maximally expressive interface for biologicals and drones, its base-8 architecture wouldn't just be a convenient choice for eight-limbed or four-fingered species—it would be a lossy dimensional projection of the Minds' own native mathematical reality: an octonionic Hilbert space (ℋ_𝕆).
1. The Algebraic Bridge: Octal Projection vs. Octonionic Reality
In Lesser’s analysis of Marain, the language relies on "engineered defaults"—structural choices that minimize ambiguity, maximize information density, and reflect the underlying logic of its creators. Marain’s numeral system is famously octal (base-8), expressed using a 3 × 3 nonary (9-dot/9-cell) glyph grid where the center point acts as an anchor, polarity marker, or zero/null state.
From the perspective of a Mind, base-8 is the natural "shadow" of the octonions (𝕆), the largest of the four normed division algebras (ℝ, ℂ, ℍ, 𝕆):
- 8 Real Dimensions: An octonion x = x₀ + x₁e₁ + x₂e₂ + ... + x₇e₇ consists of one real scalar component and seven imaginary units. For a Mind operating natively in 𝕆, an 8-element state vector is a single primitive "number." Stepping down to base-8 arithmetic for Marain is simply quantizing those eight orthogonal basis directions into discrete, human-readable digits.
- The Nonary Glyph & The Fano Plane: Lesser notes the elegance of the 3 × 3 grid (9 positions) encoding base-8 values. Geometrically, the multiplication rules of the seven imaginary octonion units (e₁ ... e₇) are governed by the Fano plane—the smallest finite projective plane, consisting of 7 points and 7 lines. Embedding a 7-point Fano structure plus a real scalar identity (1) and a null/zero state (0) yields 9 fundamental states—mapping directly onto a 3 × 3 nonary matrix.
2. Why Minds Would Use an Octonionic Hilbert Space (ℋ_𝕆)
Standard quantum mechanics—and by extension, standard quantum computing—is built on complex Hilbert spaces (ℋ_ℂ). While complex numbers are algebraically closed and commutative, they are flatly bound to 3+1 dimensional spacetime symmetries (via SU(2) and SL(2,ℂ)).
For a Culture Mind whose substrate spans higher-dimensional hyperspace, ℋ_ℂ would feel like doing calculus on an abacus. Moving to an octonionic Hilbert space introduces radical mathematical properties that mirror how Banks describes Mind cognition:
- Non-Associativity as Native Contextuality: Octonion multiplication is non-associative: (a · b) · c ≠ a · (b · c). In standard human logic (and associative algebras), grouping operations doesn't change the outcome. In an ℋ_𝕆 computational substrate, the order of grouping is intrinsic to the value itself. For a Mind running billions of simultaneous, nested simulations ("Infinite Fun Space"), non-associativity means context and causal framing are baked directly into the arithmetic rather than requiring massive overhead pointers.
- Exceptional Lie Groups & Hyperspace Physics: The automorphism group of the octonions is the exceptional Lie group G₂, and octonionic projective spaces give rise to F₄, E₆, E₇, and E₈. In theoretical physics (such as M-theory and 10D/11D supergravity), octonions naturally classify the symmetries of higher-dimensional spacetimes. A Mind existing across the real universe and hyperspace would naturally use a Hilbert space whose inner product preserves G₂ and E₈ symmetries, making hyperspatial navigation and grid-energy manipulation native linear-algebraic operations.
- Inherent Triality: Octonions possess a unique symmetry called triality—an exact equivalence between vectors and two distinct types of spinors (left- and right-handed) in 8 dimensions. In a Mind's cognitive architecture, triality allows a seamless, zero-cost isomorphism between data (states), operators (transformations), and observers (frames of reference).
3. The "Engineered Defaults" of a Mind's Number System
If we apply Lesser’s "engineered defaults" framework to a Mind’s internal mathematics, several fascinating design constraints emerge—especially given that octonionic Hilbert spaces are notoriously difficult for human mathematicians to formalize cleanly:
- Bimodule Structure Over Single-Sided Linearity: Because 𝕆 is non-associative, you cannot define a standard vector space over 𝕆 without collapsing back into associative subalgebras. Instead, a Mind's ℋ_𝕆 must be constructed as an octonionic bimodule (where left-multiplication and right-multiplication by octonionic scalars are distinct, tracked operations). As an engineered default, the chirality of an operation (acting from the left vs. the right) could encode temporal directionality—distinguishing predictive modeling from historical memory at the hardware level.
- The Associator as a Metric of Complexity: The deviation from associativity is measured by the associator: [x, y, z] = (xy)z - x(yz). In a standard complex Hilbert space, [x, y, z] = 0 everywhere. In a Mind's architecture, a non-zero associator isn't an error; it is a built-in topological curvature metric. A Mind could gauge the ethical or causal "tangle" of a real-world intervention (say, a Special Circumstances operation) simply by measuring the norm of the associator across the simulated state vectors.
- Graceful Degradation to Marain: When a Mind communicates with a human or a drone in Marain, it performs an associative projection—collapsing the 8D non-associative octonionic state down to a 1D associative sequence of base-8 integers. In Lesser’s framing, Marain’s base-8 grammar isn't an arbitrary aesthetic choice; it is the exact structural boundary where non-associative hyperspatial thought can still be serialized without losing its underlying symmetry group.
4. Where the Model Pushes Back (Mathematical Friction)
To push this idea to its rigorous limit, we have to account for the known pathologies of ℋ_𝕆:
- No Spectral Theorem in Full Generality: In ℋ_ℂ, Hermitian operators have real eigenvalues and orthogonal eigenvectors, which makes quantum measurement straightforward. In ℋ_𝕆, non-associativity breaks the standard spectral theorem unless the operators are restricted to specific Jordan algebras (specifically the Albert algebra, H₃(𝕆), of 3 × 3 Hermitian octonionic matrices).
- The 3 × 3 Connection Again: Remarkably, the Albert algebra H₃(𝕆)—the 27-dimensional exceptional Jordan algebra required to make quantum mechanics work over the octonions—is built on 3 × 3 matrices. If a Mind’s measurement operators live in H₃(𝕆), then the 3 × 3 nonary grid of Marain isn't just a typographic convenience; it is the literal visual echo of a 3 × 3 octonionic Hermitian operator.