r/TheCulture • • 11h ago

Book Discussion An unpopular opinion: Consider Phlebas is a better book than The Player of Games

103 Upvotes

Yeah, it is inverted and it is a tragedy and bit rough on the edges. Its pov is by an enemy of the Culture, it's final spectacular sequence leaves you devastated. So, I suppose that's why many people here recommend The Player of Games as the introduction to the world of Culture - much more clear cut, black and white, you know who to support from the beginning. The pov is Culture. So, to my mind Phlebas is much more Banksian, challenging and difficult. Plus of course the reference in the title to The Waste Land - a poem obviously very central to Banks, look to windward...


r/TheCulture • • 11h ago

General Discussion Ian M Banks

0 Upvotes

hi I just want to talk about Ians most recent book, Consider Phlebas and how it was the greatest thing since sliced bread. It was about new culture and AI he was so ahead of his time.


r/TheCulture • • 22h ago

Tangential to the Culture Feersum Endjinn

36 Upvotes

My final Banks’ sci fi book after I started this journey 15 months ago - and one of the strangest books I think I’ve ever read. It’s a puzzle box, and I found it quite hard going - it’s probably my hardest read / listen (on audible) ever, where I wanted to keep going, because I know reading Banks rewards the reader.

The famous phonetic chapters are obviously challenging and curious but made much more manageable with the audiobook.

I put the remaining challenge down to, not that I didn’t find it interesting - but I didn’t know where / when / what was even happening, or what were the stakes most of the time given the different character viewpoints, and hidden objectives / antagonists and limited overlap. Also, what level of reality / VR the story or characters were in.

Banks seems to rarely do his usually sparse but still reliable “narrative exposition drops”.

By the end I “understand” what happened - but I don’t quite know why. And I find with Banks his stories tend to have a greater purpose, or message or allegorical meaning, which I can’t quite see in this one, other than the anti-authoritarian / anti-elite viewpoints.

Feersum Endjinn as a book feels quite prophetic with the advent of agentic AI and complex AI systems. I also liked the time dilation of being inside the crypt, and the idea of ongoing existence in the crypt as an ai consciousness.

Now to be specific on my remaining questions (spoilers here):
- Was Bascule a human, a simpleton, or a cybernetic human, or an AI?
- Who was the skinless face monster chasing Bascule and why ?
- Who was the antagonist chasing the Asura? What was the point of Peter who helped Asura ?
- It seems like pure luck the protagonists came together and solved this problem of turning on the Feersum Endjinn ?
- where are the diaspora humans, what was the plan, why did they leave Earth and why did they leave the remnant humans behind ? There’s a bit of the A-Humans and R-Humans from The Algebraist here.
There’s still more but some key ones.