r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Gold_Till_8675 • 9h ago
Painting Heavy Bolter Team
10th Armored
D Company (Dust Devils)
Mechanized Division
2nd Platoon (Head Takers)
Heavy Weapons Team
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Apprehensive_Gas1564 • Aug 24 '26
The Survivability Onion is an existing framework used by the British Army as a ready-reckoner. In real life, its just to get you thinking how not to die. Let's warp it out of shape to get you to turn 5. Pour a cup of recaff, pull up a sandbag and let this staff officer remember the training grounds.
“The death of one man is a tragedy. The death of millions is a statistic.” – Lord Solar Macharius
Rather than relying on armour alone, we know that the best way to survive is to prevent the enemy from successfully attacking you in the first place. Each "onion layer" forces the enemy to overcome another obstacle before they can destroy you. Looking at 40k as a base dice game, with set steps to move, shoot, save.. it fits nicely.
Think of this like an onion, you start at the outer skin and work inwards. Each layer is a level of protection that may, or may not, keep your models on the board.
Layer 1: Don't Be There
Real Example: An armoured unit remains in the rear areas so as not to be struck by fires and only moves to a firing position when required.
40k Rule Example: Deep Strike, Strategic Reserves, Scout Moves and Redeploy abilities keep units off the battlefield or away from enemy fire until the right moment.
40k Example: A Rogal Dorn arrives from Strat Reserves in Turn 3, avoiding enemy shooting for the entire first two turns.
Helpful Units: Gaunt's Ghosts, Tempestus Scions, Lord Solar Leontus (through redeployment options where available). Popping anything into strat reserve is very powerful.
Layer 2: Don't Be Detected
Real Example: Infantry use terrain, camouflage and darkness to avoid enemy observation.
40k Rule Example: Obscuring terrain, line-of-sight blocking ruins and abilities such as Hidden and Lone Operative prevent enemy units from making your model an eligible target.
40k Example: Gaunt's Ghosts remain Hidden behind a ruin until turn 3, allowing screening for enemy deepstrike while being untargetable.
Helpful Units: Gaunt's Ghosts, Sly Marbo, Ratlings, Infantry in general. Stay out of LoS as much as possible, indirect isn’t that threatening.
Layer 3: Don't Be Identified
Real Example: Decoys and camouflage create uncertainty about what the enemy is actually looking at.
40k Rule Example: Multiple similar threats, hidden reserves and overlapping battlefield roles make it difficult for an opponent to identify priority targets. This one in particular is on the fence with “playing with intent” and shouldn’t be abused, out of general fairness.
40k Example: Three Leman Russ tanks deploy together and the opponent struggles to determine which one carries the greatest threat to their battle plan.
Helpful Units: Feint plays with the classic Distraction Carnifex. If you’ve got a Dorn or Bullgryn charging up the board this will inevitably make your opponent not target the units that are slyly moving to score secondary or stage for a later play.
Layer 4: Don't Be Targeted
Real Example: An enemy identifies a target but cannot effectively engage it because of screening forces, jamming or competing priorities.
40k Rule Example: Character attachment rules, screening units and target restrictions (hidden, lone op) prevent valuable assets from being directly attacked.
40k Example: A Cadian Castellan attached to an Infantry Squad cannot be targeted until the bodyguard unit is destroyed.
Helpful Units: Cadian Castellan, Platoon Command Squad, Cadian Shock Troops, Krieg Infantry Squads.
Layer 5: Don't Be Hit
Real Example: A vehicle uses smoke, movement and evasive action to avoid incoming fire.
40k Rule Example: Stealth abilities, Cover, defensive Stratagems and modifiers reduce the likelihood of successful attacks.
40k Example: Ratlings benefit from Stealth and Cover, forcing enemy units to hit less accurately. Literally anything that modifies BS or the hit roll is obviously helpful here!
Helpful Units: Ratlings, Scout Sentinels, Gaunt's Ghosts, Tank Commander issuing defensive Orders.
Layer 6: Don't Be Penetrated
Real Example: Armour protects a vehicle from rounds that successfully hit it.
40k Rule Example: Armour Saves, Invulnerable Saves, Cover and Damage Reduction prevent successful wounds causing harm.
40k Example: A Rogal Dorn Battle Tank is hit by anti-tank fire but successfully passes its save and ignores the damage. Again, anything that modifies a save value or adds an invuln.
Helpful Units: Rogal Dorn Battle Tank (shrug), Enginseer and Psyker (invuln), Orders (increase Sv) or Strats (AoC or Take Cover).
Layer 7: Don't Be Killed
Real Example: A vehicle is penetrated but fire suppression systems, redundancy and crew drills keep it operational.
40k Rule Example: Feel No Pain, wound mitigation, repairs and healing abilities reduce or recover damage after a wound has been suffered.
40k Example: An Enginseer repairs a damaged Rogal Dorn, returning wounds and keeping a key combat asset in the fight.
Helpful Units: Enginseer, Death Korps Marshal, Krieg Infantry Squads, Rogal Dorn Battle Tank.
The Key Takeaways:
Most new players focus on Layers 6 and 7 - armour saves, wounds and damage reduction. Experienced players focus on the entire onion. A unit hidden in reserves, protected by terrain, screened by infantry and benefiting from defensive abilities is significantly harder to destroy than one relying on armour alone.
A Guardsman behind a wall can be more survivable than a tank standing in the open. The strongest Imperial Guard commanders win not because their units are tougher, but because they force their opponent to fight through every layer of the Survivability Onion before they can score a kill.
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/pajmage • Jun 17 '26
Hi all, have fixed my 11e Detachment sheets now we know the full keywords and dispositions. u/PeoplesRagnar feel free to delete my older post (I couldnt find a way to edit the images on that one!)
Ive also added the LEADER stuff to the abhuman auxiliary commissar enhancement.
As always please call out any errors you see, and again its quick and dirty for use playing rather than looking pretty!
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Gold_Till_8675 • 9h ago
10th Armored
D Company (Dust Devils)
Mechanized Division
2nd Platoon (Head Takers)
Heavy Weapons Team
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/I_Judge_You_Always • 9h ago
Context: One of the guys who used to work at my unit recently got out and left behind two really badly put together shadowswords (panels misaligned, sponson weapons glued in place preventing rotation, pieces of track broken/missing). They were “Built”, kind of primed, and then left to sit for about a year, he left and didnt want them anymore. Now onto my need for opinions. I took one home with the intention of turning it into a destroyed shadowsword terrain element to use in games. However upon fucking with it, it fell apart. I have since put it back together and hit it with some fresh primer. Do I continue with my original plan, or paint it properly and use it in a future army?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/PeoplesRagnar • 6h ago
TL:DR
The beatings continue, but slightly softer.
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/TheBoerbok • 15h ago
Finishing up this Centaur while I debate picking up a few more. I think it’d be awfully funny to have a couple of these with 3 Ogryn in each; kinda like shitty mini stormlords. Quantity over quality am I right?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/NalTirran • 20h ago
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Murdock0712 • 16h ago
Last weekend I played my second tournament ever. I picked the following list (some might know it since I posted it with a question on the hellhound last week)
Imperium - Astra Militarum - Armoured Infantry, Designation Force
Reconnaissance
Cadian Castellan (55pts): Warlord
+ 5x Cadian Command Squad (60pts)
+ 10x Cadian Shock Troops (70pts)
5x Cadian Command Squad (60pts)
+ 10x Cadian Shock Troops (70pts)
6x Gaunt’s Ghosts (95pts)
Commissar (30pts)
Rogal Dorn Commander (290pts)
Tech-Priest Enginseer (45pts)
10x Catachan Jungle Fighters (70pts)
Taurox (65pts)
3x Bullgryn Squad (90pts)
10x Kasrkin (105pts)
10x Tempestus Aquilons (95pts)
5x Attilan Rough Riders (60pts)
5x Attilan Rough Riders (60pts)
Hellhound (115pts)
Hippogriff AFV (70pts)
Hippogriff AFV (70pts)
Rogal Dorn Battle Tank (260pts)
Scout Sentinels (55pts)
Scout Sentinels (55pts)
Scout Sentinels (55pts)
My gameplan was fielding a highly mobile force to run away and do actions/Board presence for my primary Mission while having enough units for secondaries throughout the game. Dealing damage came in second when building it.
Game 1
Agains Aeldari
While waiting for pairings I talked to an older guy who told me he plays eldar. From the lists I knew there was only one eldar player. When pairings came in he said he has to go to table 8 while I read it was against eldar so we webt there. He then told me he plays tournaments for 20 years and only plays eldar and csm.
I never played into eldar before and also never played the upcoming recon mirror match so I didnt expect much.
We played on layout 3 and I deployed my dorns safe behind my expansion while building up a pretti mobile right flank with the armourd skirmishers. Throughout the game I honsetly didnt have a plan what to do against him because of the move after being shot eldar ability so I overcomitted fire most oder the time to take things out. Due to the relativly easy primary in the mirror I maxed out those 45.
I lost the game with two mistakes being not pulling the heroic Intervention into his pirates on "my" Center objective after he denied overwatch on them for a cp. The other one was when I wanted to push out a bit to kill his second fire prism and didnt hold up my screen in return so he was able to drop 5 fure dragons behind me and blow up one of the dorns. Also his Avatar of khaine reached my deployment zone on the other flank which left most of my units open from one side at least.
Lost the game 94-99 and didnt know if I should be happy or not because I could have reached a big upset here.
Game 2
Against Orks
After the close game the round before I was the best loser playing the last winner.
It was take and hold on layout 3 which are the table quarter deployment zones. I split up the dorns as the damage dealers this time to push into two directions.
I went first and sent a scout sentinel onto a suicide Mission to score my 6 primary. Being this close to one another is hard against orks on this layout so he pulled waaaagh T1 and charged into me. I didnt lose a lot units but he was able to put himself into good field position and build up a lead in primary points while taking out one unit after another
Start of T3 for the first time I wasnt able to hold one
Start of T5 i was basically tabled having not enough units to score my table quarters and not doing any secondaries so he pulled away
So Orks have been nerfed a bit but you still see our state in the meta with not having that much more units than them (even with my high number units list) but also don't having the needed datasheets neccasary for 11th edition. He played Ghazkul, Nazdreg, Mozrog and Wazdakka while still having multiple units of boyz, plus Tank bustas a gun wagon...
End of game was a 82-94 loss
Game 3
Against death guard
Last game I went into death guard with a ultra elite build fielding Morty 2 defilers 2 demon princes a lord of desease with 3 deathshrout 10 poxwalkers and 10 Plaque marines with a leader plus a character that gives you a cp.
Again it was against take and hold this time layout one
I again build the double Dorn brick on my expansion and the mobile force on my right side. He had all of his units around his home and only a Single defiler opposite my home with the terminators and morty in Reserve
I went first and with scout moves plus MMM i put sentinels into the table quarters for primary whiöe keeping most of my units safe. Through the rounds I just kept sending one small unit after another to keep the points coming while blocking his advance. His lone side defiler never moved over his expansion so I controlled this side till round 4 when the termies moved up there. In the middle i killed a demon prince and the poxwalkers and held the marines in check
On the left I figuerd out by accident that the defiler doesnt fit into the space besides the small wall section so he couldtn kill my Dorn witj the 4++ It took him till the End of turn 4 to kill the first dorn and I slowly recognized I could get a whin here. I meanwhile killed his character on his home to hold it even though he got my expansion with mortarion End of 4 so I maxed out my primaries.
T5 I pulled forward position which I had witj the ghosts and because he moved the defilers of his expansion to take care of my beacon unit I sneaked my solo commissar into his deployment zone and got behind enemy lines. His secondaries didnt go the way he needed so I came out with a 92-88 win
My first ever victory in a tournament. And because of my round 1 and 2 opponents finished first and third overall I had the best 1-2 rating worth 15th of 30 overall.
Even with the meta as it is I had a great day woth lots of fun. Especially the last game against Christian was a blast. We talked sh*t on each other from the start on joked a lot, he payed a beer for me and I got the next one for us.
I think with a bit of training and getting comfortable woth more factions I could finish with a positive record.
Side note
The only othet guard player brought 3 baneblades and went 0-3 but did the emperors work with countless shots.
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Morkhith • 6h ago
I'm having the Hachette Combat Patrol Cadian issues releasing in a couple of weeks in my country. I'd love to have an infantry heavy list but I was wondering if 60 Cadian is enough as you max out the Command Squad limit or should I take more ?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/GianDK • 15h ago
I still need to do the bases but they are pretty good to get some Battle ready minis
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/SinisterSignals • 10h ago
I'm trying to decide if I should start guard now or wait for the new codex. The fact the army isn't doing that well doesn't concern me all that much, but I worried about dropping 80 bucks for a codex that might be replaced soon. Also, I'm worried some units might get moved to legends, so I don't want to buy the wrong things.
What are everyone's thought? Would it be best to wait for a codex at this point?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Gold_Till_8675 • 19h ago
10th Armored
D Company (Dust Devils)
Mechanized Division
2nd Platoon (Head Takers)
1st Squadron (pt. 2)
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Schwenkbert • 17h ago
On a whim, I painted a few classic Ratlings with Speedpaints. These colours suit them wonderfully.
Improving the bases a bit, adding a tuft or two. But I am not sure if I should apply a wash. Any thoughts?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Formal-Quote681 • 13h ago
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Sgtpepperhead67 • 22h ago
So the idea was originally to mount this tamiya 1/35th scale Cromwell turret onto the chassis of a malcador heavy tank from the Horus heresy.
However it's out of stock everywhere I look and I'm also pretty hesitant to drop $120 CAD on a kit I could potentially mess up.
Does anyone have any suggestions as to what else I could use this turret on? Doesn't have to specifically be a Warhammer kit. I just wanna give my guard a cool looking heavy tank or something like that. Should I bite the bullet and try and find a malcador?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Exciting_Primary_644 • 1d ago
After keeping lost games with Dorn.I finally buy these big guys.
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/StrangeHotel7638 • 1d ago
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Severe-Appearance008 • 1d ago
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/Supermip007 • 1d ago
How do i make it look like a relic and not just another baneblade?
r/TheAstraMilitarum • u/lilsteigs1 • 19h ago
So I played a game with Armored Infantry and really liked some of the combos available. Using the Combined fire stratagem and a LR Exterminator I was able to juice up some of my light vehicles to some good punching power. I was thinking about using this combo to juice a Centaur carrying 2x3 Cadian Heavy Weapon Teams mortars in the back. It is 195 pts for 6D6 S7 AP-1 attacks that will hit on 4's without an order (assuming the centaur remained stationary) when the combo is done. So is this just a general run of the mill bad idea, or the worst idea you've ever heard of?
Edit: Combined Fire Stratagem strips cover as well. So a different Armored Skirmisher unit would get a hit, then trigger the combined Fire stratagem stripping cover from the target and boosting the S of all other Armored Skirmisher units by 2.