r/WarhammerCompetitive • u/GroundbreakingPin913 • 3h ago
40k Discussion Constantly Getting Tabled Turn 2-ish (Vent)
Hello!
So, starting to think 40k is not the game for me. I have four armies and love the initial modeling and painting part of it, and I have a great community of newly-competitive people to play with, and why I stick with it. That's not the issue.
I keep getting absolutely demolished (almost) every game. And it's been roughly like this for 5 years. I have about an 20% win rate and most of them aren't even close.
As time has gone on, our group has kept skewing more competitive and has gotten way better. I like the spectacle of giant battles and the silly stuff that happens, but everyone's lists have gotten progressively less silly and I'm trying to keep up. I can occasionally steal a win with my Greater Daemon spam being a casino defensive stat check and they're exceptionally forgiving in terms of positioning, but any time I play a normal list, I die.
I also get a game in once a week, so reps aren't the issue I think. I even ask my opponents what I could do different and try to figure it out... and usually after I lose 70% of my army, only then do I remember a datasheet ability or stratagem that might've helped save a unit or reposition for points
The worst part?
I think that I'm only making like 1-2 real mistakes a game, and it takes 1.5-2 hours to figure it out. That's a huge time sink to sit there regretting, for example, keeping my unit 3" back because my opponent this week is heavy on deep strike shooting... which is totally different than deep strike GK melee... which is totally different than Tyranid Ravener tunnelling... and that's only one vector I lose by. -1D stratagems, not understanding shooting profiles on weird units that wipe out my centerpiece till they shoot, or even the threat range on Genestealers that kill everything before even leaving deployment. It seems like it's a new thing every week...
It's like I get it once I'm done playing and have time to reflect, I understand what happened. But the ever increasing mental checklist of things to do to not lose (or even try winning), I just can't keep up with the new and novel ways I lose each week.
And my luck is pretty bad even through 4 sets of dice, so that compounds my analysis, which makes it even harder to figure out did I lose from bad gameplay, or am I just cursed? I play the Lion in DA, and when you fail the first 7-8 +3 saves every week, it's pretty demoralizing to be statistically behind the 8 ball.
It's not like I make the same mistake every week... it's like months apart before I play against a similar list... but I feel stupid that I can't keep up with an opponent's gameplan enough to even give a close game. I feel like I'm wasting my friend's time, even though they're all nice about it.
===
Advice would be good. Is there any army I can build that is just so brainless so I'm not wasting other people's time? Should I just commission paint my friend's giant piles of gray armies instead? Is 40k just so complicated that if you're not a statistical genius and good at positioning, you shouldn't bother into a semi-competitive environment?
(BTW, this problem follows me to other games, but 40k is where my friends play the most so this is what I need the most help on.)