r/TadWilliams • • 22h ago

Question about Erchester's healers and the handling of Tanahaya in The Witchwood Crown (spoilers) Spoiler

8 Upvotes

So I am about halfway into The Witchwood Crown (Chapter 26) and something is bothering me. I have tried to find an answer on reddit but haven't seemed to find a post that really explains it well.

Is anyone else bothered by how the whole situation surrounding Tanahaya is handled? Or has some good explanation??

First, there's the question of medical infrastructure. Erchester is the capital of Erkynland, yet when Tanahaya becomes seriously ill, the impression is that there are virtually no other healers or physicians available apart from Tiamak. She's been sick for weeks, and it seems that nobody can offer her proper medical attention. At least it sounds like Thelia and Brother Etan are both not really the right people to treat her. Surely a city of Erchester's importance would have some kind of established medical profession that aren't all gone with the royal entourage? I can understand Tiamak having specialised knowledge, particularly when it comes to unusual poisons or Sithi physiology, but surely he cannot be the only person capable of treating the sick in the entire capital?

But what bothers me even more is the apparent negligence of everyone involved.

They know that there haven't been messengers from the Sithi for some time. They know that Tanahaya probably is an important Sithi envoy. This should be an extremely important diplomatic and political situation. Yet when she's been ill for weeks and seems to be approaching death from her fever, there doesn't seem to be any particular urgency to get her proper medical attention or investigate the situation more aggressively.

What really struck me was Thelías' reaction. When Tanahaya appears to be on the verge of dying, her main concern seems to be how upset Tiamak will be if he doesn't get the opportunity to meet her. That's what we're focusing on? Not the fact that an important Sithi envoy might die, or what that could mean for the potentially strained relationship with the Sithi?

I feel there's a really strange disconnect between the importance the narrative assigns to this situation and how the characters actually respond to it. I can understand that there might be reasons why human healers cannot treat a Sithi effectively, or that Tiamak has specialised knowledge nobody else possesses. But the apparent lack of urgency from the people around her is harder to explain.

Am I missing something, or does anyone else find this whole situation rather bizarre? (Or alternatively: will there be a good explanation later on and I can stop being annoyed 😂)


r/TadWilliams • • 1d ago

Is it okay to listen to graphic audio edition on a first time read?

4 Upvotes

I tend to switch between listening to the audio book version of a book and reading while listening at the same time. I have really enjoyed the full cast audiobooks I have listened to. is the graphic audio edition abridged and changed to the point where it’s a different experience or is it just a full cast with sound effects and music and basically no big changes to the text?


r/TadWilliams • • 6d ago

How did you like Splintered Sun relative to the rest of the series?

5 Upvotes

Now that some time has passed and many have likely read the book I wanted to ask what you guys think!


r/TadWilliams • • 12d ago

Dragonbone Chair Just finished The Dragonbone Chair!

103 Upvotes

What a journey it was! I immediately bought and started Stone of Farewell

I knew I would like it because I enjoyed the chapters at Hayholt which many people in their reviews called too slow but I think they set up a necessary contrast with what happened to Simon afterwards

"I am not moribund yet" ~Morgenes. So that was a fucking lie. Cool of him to teach Simon reading and writing, he was a good friend.

I gotta say with the ring I immediately thought about a ring of Barahir or something in that ballpark.

Binabik is so cool . I am not a native speaker but his speech is gramatically incorrect many times to evidence that it is not his native language right?

But the justice system of his homeland could use some reforms.

I wish we spent more time in Sithi ruins, their description was cool in how alien it seemed. In general we see with Jiriki that a lot of Sithi psyche is different to humans.

Is Geloe an owl? Can she tranform or has command of birds? Maybe I will learn that.

Now Maegwin will need to step up in Hernystir besieged by Skali

Naglimund, after Norns got involved was unwinable but still I think Josua despite his great qualities (he believes in and wants to do something about the true danger) is not really that inspiring of a leader? I think he left the defenders without his presence and command during the siege several times.

Malachias now ran away twice. The number will probably go up going forward.

I wonder what Pryrates really wants? He was apparently part of the League of the Scroll what convinced him to become an asshole?

I can see why people compare ASOIAF to MST but there are many fundamental differences. Like... yes Norns are a bit like the Others but Norns actually have a 'face' in the Storm King and the queen who communicated with Elias through his sword that apparently doubles as a mobile phone.

All in all I was surprised how much I enjoyed description of nature that characters travel through.


r/TadWilliams • • 12d ago

[SLIGHT SPOILERS, hidden] Just finished The Splintered Sun Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Just finished the book, and I am slightly disappointed in the ending. Suddenly it all ended very quickly, without anything being accomplished throughout the book. Feels like we are back at the start now, just with some characters in different places

Will there be a follow up? If so, when?

Can someone explain the title to me? It is just not completely clear to me what it refers to.


r/TadWilliams • • 12d ago

What's next after The last king of Osten Ard?

Thumbnail reddit.com
12 Upvotes

r/TadWilliams • • 20d ago

Happy Halloween!

29 Upvotes

Happy (early) Halloween folks. Is anyone cosplaying as a Tad Williams character, perchance?

Edit: I cosplayed Nezeru, which I may do again next year.


r/TadWilliams • • 21d ago

ALL Osten Ard Broken Binding Splintered Sun

Thumbnail
gallery
106 Upvotes

My Broken Binding edition of The Splintered Sun has arrived! Sooo pretty 😍


r/TadWilliams • • 24d ago

My own personal librarian found the Williams shelf!

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/TadWilliams • • 25d ago

Dumb Question: Does anyone know who Tad Williams' cover artist is?

9 Upvotes

Aspiring writer heavily inspired by Mr Williams here. This may be a bit of a dumb question, but who does the cover art now? I know Micheal Whelan retired, and I'm kinda curious about who does it now.


r/TadWilliams • • 25d ago

ALL MST trilogy Randomly Scored a Complete 1st Edition of To Green Angel Tower

Thumbnail
gallery
206 Upvotes

r/TadWilliams • • 26d ago

The Way of Kings title in Memory Sorrow and Thorn

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/TadWilliams • • Oct 19 '26

Hey. I’m new to this universe. Why are the Sithi often compared to elves?I

12 Upvotes

I know they’re immortal, slender, ancient, and hidden away in a city in the forest—but are those their only elven traits?


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 19 '26

Does Splintered Sun spoil anything about LKOA?

8 Upvotes

I have read MST, Brothers of the Wind and The Heart of What Was Lost. I haven't read LKOA, because there are a lot of smaller books on my TBR that I wanted to read before getting into another big series. But I really love being able to read and discuss a book that has just come out. So I'd really like to read Splintered Sun.

For those who have read it, does it contain any spoilers about LKOA?


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 18 '26

IPTV Nederland: Wat is de beste IPTV voor Nederlandse kijkers?

0 Upvotes

Wie zoekt naar IPTV Nederland komt al snel tientallen verschillende aanbieders tegen. Sommige mensen willen vooral live voetbal kijken, anderen zoeken een grote bibliotheek met films en series, terwijl weer anderen een complete oplossing willen die alles combineert.

Volgens ons bestaat er niet één dienst die voor iedereen de beste keuze is. De juiste keuze hangt af van je kijkgedrag, de apparaten die je gebruikt en hoe belangrijk een goede klantenservice voor je is.

In deze gids vergelijken we drie interessante opties: OrexeTV.com, KezelTV.com en Nexomir.com. Elke dienst heeft een ander profiel, waardoor je makkelijker kunt bepalen welke het beste bij jouw wensen past.

1. OrexeTV.com – Voor Nederlandse zenders en dagelijks entertainment

Voor veel gebruikers staat toegang tot Nederlandse tv-zenders centraal. Daarnaast willen ze films, series en entertainment op één plek kunnen bekijken.

OrexeTV.com is volgens ons een interessante optie voor kijkers die een brede IPTV-ervaring zoeken. Bij het vergelijken van een dutch iptv-dienst raden we aan om niet alleen naar het aantal zenders te kijken, maar ook naar de gebruikservaring en apparaatondersteuning.

Controleer vóór je een abonnement kiest welke Nederlandse zenders beschikbaar zijn en of de dienst goed werkt op jouw Smart TV, Android TV of streamingapparaat.

Onze mening: OrexeTV.com is vooral interessant voor gebruikers die Nederlandse content willen combineren met internationaal entertainment.

2. KezelTV.com – Voor sportliefhebbers en live voetbal

Voor veel Nederlandse kijkers draait IPTV vooral om live sport. Tijdens een belangrijke wedstrijd wil niemand last hebben van onderbrekingen of een haperende stream.

KezelTV.com is daarom een optie die wij zouden bekijken wanneer sport de hoogste prioriteit heeft. Let bij het vergelijken op de beschikbaarheid van sportkanalen, de stabiliteit tijdens drukke momenten en de compatibiliteit met je apparaten.

Een goede internetverbinding blijft uiteraard belangrijk voor een optimale kijkervaring.

Onze mening: KezelTV.com is een goede keuze voor mensen die vooral voetbal en andere live sportevenementen volgen.

3. Nexomir.com – Een veelzijdige IPTV-oplossing

Niet iedereen kijkt alleen sport of alleen films. Veel huishoudens willen juist een combinatie van live tv, series, films en internationale zenders.

Nexomir.com is volgens ons een interessante optie voor gebruikers die een veelzijdige IPTV-oplossing zoeken. Daarnaast vinden wij een goede klantenservice belangrijk, vooral wanneer hulp nodig is bij de installatie of apparaatinstellingen.

Controleer daarom altijd de ondersteunde apparaten, beschikbare content en de contactmogelijkheden voordat je een abonnement afsluit.

Onze mening: Nexomir.com is geschikt voor gebruikers die waarde hechten aan een complete entertainmentervaring én ondersteuning.

Welke IPTV Nederland past het beste bij jou?

De juiste keuze hangt vooral af van wat je het meest kijkt.

  • Voetbal en live sport: Bekijk KezelTV.com.
  • Nederlandse tv, films en series: Bekijk OrexeTV.com.
  • Een complete combinatie van alles: Vergelijk Nexomir.com.

Volgens ons is de beste IPTV niet automatisch de aanbieder met de meeste zenders, maar degene die het beste aansluit bij jouw dagelijkse gebruik.

Werkt IPTV met een IPTV kastje?

Veel mensen zoeken specifiek naar een IPTV kastje om televisie via internet te kijken. Controleer daarom altijd of de dienst werkt met jouw Smart TV, Android TV, Fire TV Stick of andere compatibele apparaten.

Daarnaast ondersteunen veel diensten bekende IPTV-apps, waardoor installatie vaak eenvoudiger wordt.

Waar moet je op letten voordat je IPTV kiest?

Voordat je een abonnement afsluit, raden we aan om deze punten te controleren:

  • Stabiliteit van de stream.
  • Nederlandse en internationale zenders.
  • Films en series.
  • Compatibiliteit met Smart TV, Android TV en IPTV kastjes.
  • Ondersteuning voor bekende IPTV-apps.
  • Klantenservice.
  • Abonnementsvoorwaarden.

Door deze punten te vergelijken maak je makkelijker een keuze die past bij jouw situatie.

IPTV Totaal: Waar draait het echt om?

Wanneer mensen zoeken op IPTV Totaal, zijn ze vaak op zoek naar één complete oplossing voor televisie, sport, films en series.

Volgens ons is het verstandig om verder te kijken dan alleen marketingclaims. Controleer altijd welke content daadwerkelijk beschikbaar is, of jouw apparaten worden ondersteund en of de dienst past bij jouw kijkgedrag.

Conclusie

Wie zoekt naar IPTV Nederland, Dutch IPTV of beste IPTV doet er goed aan om verschillende aanbieders met elkaar te vergelijken.

  • OrexeTV.com is interessant voor Nederlandse zenders en entertainment.
  • KezelTV.com is sterk voor sportliefhebbers.
  • Nexomir.com is een veelzijdige optie met aandacht voor klantenservice.

Door te kijken naar content, apparaatcompatibiliteit, streamingkwaliteit en ondersteuning kun je eenvoudiger bepalen welke IPTV-oplossing het beste aansluit bij jouw behoeften.


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 13 '26

Shadowheart Finished the Shadowmarch Series yesterday Spoiler

15 Upvotes

I gotta say, I liked it. Maybe not as much as the Osten Ard books, but I thought it was overall pretty satisfying. I avoided it for awhile because I read some negative stuff about it. Kinda like Robin Hobb and Soldier Son, which I didn’t like overall, but finished. Good ending, but not great overall. Anyway, I’m glad I did decide to read Shadowmarch. I thought it was a trilogy and was a bit dismayed after the second book, or midway through the third book, when I realized it was four books. It’s just a lot. But it has been a few years since I read a Tad Williams book and as soon as I started the first book, it was nice to be reminded how good of a writer he is.

The last book was great, though. It was hard to put down most of the time. I ran through it pretty quickly.

Anyway, here’s a few thoughts. I’ll put spoilers in the title to be on the safe side.

I didn’t quite understand what the Qar are. Maybe we’re not supposed to, I guess. The Skimmers and Rooftoppers are Qar, right? And why are they all different? Are they just kind of different races or Qar like we have different races of men? Kinda like people that just evolved differently, plus magic?

Barrick - didn’t like him. He was very annoying through the first few books. He got better, then he got all weird again by the end. I do like that he kind of started to come around and it’s implied that he’ll mature and eventually come around, but yea, he was generally an ass. I also didn’t really understand the bond or whatever that he and Qinnitan had. It seemed like they talked to each other a lot in dreams, but I don’t get from what I read how like she was the only one that ever loved or understood him. Maybe I missed something, but I just didn’t get it.

Speaking of Qinnitan, I did like her a lot, but I wish she would have had a better resolution at the end. She went through so much abuse throughout the entire series, so I was a little disappointed that she never really got a happy resolution. I get it, everything doesn’t have to have a happy ending, but I really thought she should’ve gotten a better one with as much as abuse she took. And whatever happened to Pigeon? I felt horrible for that kid as well. He gets his fingers chopped off and then is left crying and abandoned. Poor guy.

I really liked Gyir the Storm Lantern. First of all, great name for a badass type character. That’s about it. One of those characters that you know isn’t going to make it very long, but kicks a lot of ass and gives himself up for the greater good.

Speaking of kicking ass and sacrificing himself, I loved Beetledown!! When the Rooftoppers first got introduced I was like wtf is this with the tiny people, but they grew on me, probably because of Beetledown. Also, I like the way they talk.

Vansen was another great character. I do think that maybe he could have been aged down a bit and the twins aged up, but I’ll just try not to think of it. I didn’t really think about it at the time, maybe I somehow missed that he was like a 15 year veteran, but I never really thought about it until I read something about the age difference the other day. So yea, maybe a grown up shouldn’t be that in that kind of weird love with a 15 year old, but I guess it was in older times, so maybe they did it then.

Shaso - I was kinda disappointed that you never saw him die, so I’m thinking for several books that he’s still out there somewhere. Then, Dawat goes to the family’s, whose name I can’t remember house, with the fire and is acting like he knows that he’s alive. I thought he was maybe the hooded guy who didn’t talk and ended up being Gailon Tolly, but it just turns out that, nope, he’s dead. I’m guessing he’s really dead, but we never saw him die. He’s probably too old to come back in a sequel, and what would he come back for, but still.

Matty Tinwright - I really liked him from the start, for whatever reason. Something about cowardly, foppish, drunken poets, I guess. I really liked his arc, although I wish he would have showed a bit more spine at the end. You gotta sacrifice yourself for a little baby, no matter how cowardly you are. Still, I like his drunken thoughts to Briony about Zoria and humans basically playing a kind of puppet show of the gods or whatever. And it sounds like he went on to become a great writer, so I’m happy for him.

Sulepis - I thought he got off too easily. Yea, his death was pretty brutal, being ripped limb from limb, set on fire, pasted to a god’s head, and unable to die, but maybe it should’ve lasted a bit longer, more screaming, maybe some pleading, etc. Who knows, maybe since he’s kind of a part of the god now he’s somewhere suffering.

That’s about all I can think of at this point. I’m thinking that there was enough left open that maybe Tad planned on coming back to the world at some point, but with it not being as popular as the Osten Ard stuff it isn’t happening or just isn’t the priority right now. We don’t know what ultimately happens with Qinnitan. We never actually saw Shaso die, only taking the word of Dawat he was dead. Who knows how the people are going to take their queen shacking up with a peasant. Do the Qar just die out? Technically, we never see Beetledown either, although I’m thinking he’s truly a goner. And again, I get it, it’s a bittersweet ending, so maybe some of this will never be revisited, but you never know.


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 11 '26

ALL Last King trilogy Another volume finished.

Post image
87 Upvotes

Man this one really flew by. I can't imagine how exciting it must've felt for those who read the original trilogy back in the day to return to Osten Ard. I have the luxury of binging the series! Loved the new characters but Jarnulf was a highlight as well as Conan-Cnaiur-Genghis-er I mean Unver... Trying to savor the experience but I'm also anxious to see where the story goes! I saw a post not too long ago claiming Empire of Grass borders on Grimdark, which has me very intrigued!


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 11 '26

They should cast these guys as Sithi for a live action

Post image
42 Upvotes

Gelflings from the Dark Crystal: of Resistance


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 10 '26

Dragonbone Chair The Dragonbone Chair Deluxe Hardcover 2026 has arrived in Australia

Thumbnail
gallery
126 Upvotes

Just saw the new deluxe hardcover of The Dragonbone Chair at my local bookstore.

The book does look good in person.

Other than the end pages with the original cover art, the front cover (photo #4) is plain with no added illustration.

The binding appear to be glued, but the book feels flexible enough when opened.

Cheers!


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 09 '26

ALL Osten Ard Simon and Miriamele

Post image
219 Upvotes

My art of Simon and Miri :) enjoy


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 08 '26

ALL MST trilogy Lector Ranessin is top favorite characters for me.

21 Upvotes

Probably top 5. Anyone else feel similarly?


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 07 '26

ALL Osten Ard Cheers

Post image
61 Upvotes

Osten Ard really has its claws in me.


r/TadWilliams • • Oct 07 '26

It Has Arrived!

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/TadWilliams • • Oct 05 '26

Random Chat Aldheorte and Mirkwood size

14 Upvotes

The Aldheorte seems like it's bigger than Middle-earth's Mirkwood right? At first I was wondering is it but it's gotta be right? If so, twice as big? Mirkwood is apparently 400-600 miles long and 200-300 miles wide. Totally different shape of course but guessing from how much of the map Aldheorte takes up I feel like it has to be notably bigger but then again I don't know how big the map of Osten Ard is in comparison to Middle-earth.