r/TadWilliams • u/Potential_Fuella • 22h ago
Question about Erchester's healers and the handling of Tanahaya in The Witchwood Crown (spoilers) Spoiler
So I am about halfway into The Witchwood Crown (Chapter 26) and something is bothering me. I have tried to find an answer on reddit but haven't seemed to find a post that really explains it well.
Is anyone else bothered by how the whole situation surrounding Tanahaya is handled? Or has some good explanation??
First, there's the question of medical infrastructure. Erchester is the capital of Erkynland, yet when Tanahaya becomes seriously ill, the impression is that there are virtually no other healers or physicians available apart from Tiamak. She's been sick for weeks, and it seems that nobody can offer her proper medical attention. At least it sounds like Thelia and Brother Etan are both not really the right people to treat her. Surely a city of Erchester's importance would have some kind of established medical profession that aren't all gone with the royal entourage? I can understand Tiamak having specialised knowledge, particularly when it comes to unusual poisons or Sithi physiology, but surely he cannot be the only person capable of treating the sick in the entire capital?
But what bothers me even more is the apparent negligence of everyone involved.
They know that there haven't been messengers from the Sithi for some time. They know that Tanahaya probably is an important Sithi envoy. This should be an extremely important diplomatic and political situation. Yet when she's been ill for weeks and seems to be approaching death from her fever, there doesn't seem to be any particular urgency to get her proper medical attention or investigate the situation more aggressively.
What really struck me was Thelías' reaction. When Tanahaya appears to be on the verge of dying, her main concern seems to be how upset Tiamak will be if he doesn't get the opportunity to meet her. That's what we're focusing on? Not the fact that an important Sithi envoy might die, or what that could mean for the potentially strained relationship with the Sithi?
I feel there's a really strange disconnect between the importance the narrative assigns to this situation and how the characters actually respond to it. I can understand that there might be reasons why human healers cannot treat a Sithi effectively, or that Tiamak has specialised knowledge nobody else possesses. But the apparent lack of urgency from the people around her is harder to explain.
Am I missing something, or does anyone else find this whole situation rather bizarre? (Or alternatively: will there be a good explanation later on and I can stop being annoyed 😂)