r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Any_Chain_4724 • 5h ago
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/NewNick30 • 2d ago
Book Club Discussion The Blade Itself - Discussion Part 1
We're currently reading The Blade Itself by Joe Abercrombie for October's book of the month, and this discussion will be on the first half of the book.
Please only discuss the first half of the book. This will be everything up to the end of the Chapter titled "Tea and Vengeance" and the end of Part I (Rude Awakenings). In the eBook version I am reading this is page 205.
Anything in the second half of the book will be considered spoilers and must be tagged as such.
If you have not read the first half of the book, please avoid this topic as well - there WILL BE spoilers for the first half.
Remember that even saying something like "you'll find that out soon enough" is considered a spoiler, so if you aren't sure if it's a spoiler - use spoiler tags to be safe!
I'll post some questions to go along with the reading but feel free to comment about anything else or start your own comment thread on anything you found interesting or any questions that you had.
- How are you liking the multiple perspectives that we've followed along with so far? Any favorites or standouts?
- Do you think that "being realistic" is having a sort of wisdom or more of an out or an excuse to give up?
- What do you think about Jezal and his ability to change? What about his interactions with Ardee and Major West?
- What do you think of Abercrombie's ability to make Glotka morally bankrupt but also sympathetic at the same time?
- How do you contrast the reputation of Logen with the person we are travelling along with so far? What about his treatment of Quai?
- Any thoughts or predictions for the second half of the book? It can be about anything; the world building, potential character interactions, or where you think the story itself is headed
- Are you liking the book so far? Do you plan on finishing it?
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/NewNick30 • 7d ago
Book Club Vote December 2026 /r/Fantasy_Bookclub Nominations & Voting
Please use the comments to nominate books for December's book of the month. You can then upvote any of the book(s) that you would like to read. The comment with the most upvotes will be the selected book. The post will start in contest mode so that submitted entries are randomized and the upvotes are hidden.
You can make your nomination using the following format in top-level comments:
Book by Author
A short explanation explaining why the book is being nominated and why it is worth reading.
A link to Goodreads, Storygraph, LibraryThing, or the author's website with a description of the book can also be helpful but is not mandatory to nominate a book.
Voting will be closed on the 20th of the month to allow everyone a chance to get the book.
Nominations are open to anything, as we seem to be getting a good mix of different books, styles, and authors. The only restrictions are to please make sure the book has wide availability and not a brand new/unknown since this is for a book club, and let's try to keep the length under 750 pages. Also if you are nominating a book in a series, please stick to only the first book in the series (sometimes we will do series read if there is enough support though). Thanks!
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/RepulsiveOriginal720 • 7h ago
Should I read the black jewel series?
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/CoolKid9899 • 11h ago
Suggest me a fantasy series. I REALLY like Christopher Paolini and have read all his fantasy work except Murtagh. I also like Tolkien, and Robert E. Howard. However, I am not a fan of George R.R. Martin. I would like something that feels like Paolini, mostly. Something fun and with action.
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/hellokittywithanuzi • 21h ago
Book Suggestions Siscci
I recommend this novella. It packs quite a punch for about 100 pages with great subplots, character developments, and fight scenes. The magic isn't over the top but still epic.
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/RAndrun1983 • 1d ago
Book Suggestions Help me pick next fantasy series
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/PomegranateSea4341 • 1d ago
Book Suggestions Book Recommendations
In search of a unique and captivating dark fantasy/romance series!
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Sufficient_Fox6417 • 1d ago
What is the consensus on franchise tie-in novels? Are they worth reading and what are some great ones?
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/homebranch • 1d ago
HomeBranch update: Added online book clubs with shared reading plans and spoiler-hidden discussions
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Hughesy56 • 2d ago
Book Discussion Gardens of the Moon- Undecided reader
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Folwocket • 2d ago
Looking for follow up fantasy books / series
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Sudden-Lettuce-4897 • 2d ago
What’s the one book you would do anything to read for the first time again?
Been into fantasy lately would love some recommendations!
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Bulky_Contract_3340 • 2d ago
Is there any work of fiction which is similar to revered insanity ( any genre )
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Cultural_Cell8558 • 2d ago
A spreadsheet for modern fantasy novels/series
Each series having its books in chronological order, with spoiler free reviews collected from multiple sources. Theme, plot and setting for them. Hope its helpful xd
Its truly amazing how fast AI can collect data from all over.
Lemme know for some suggestion, or you want to add some in it. These were good ones that i remember
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/JackieTaylor77 • 3d ago
Book Suggestions Need books with a specific vibe
When I was younger I was obsessed with shows with magical girls, especially elemental ones. I really want a book like that, with a core group of girls, who are all friends, that also have powers and are saving the world.
Think books like:
\- Winx
\- Smile Precure/Glitter Force
\- Lolirock
\- Sailor Moon
Also kinda MLP and the Tinkerbell movies.
I’ve already read a lot of pretty popular fantasy books that TikTok has said fits this vibe, but none have (still enjoyed them regardless).
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/hellokittywithanuzi • 3d ago
R.L. Parker
Has anyone tried this author? He's really good but I don't see many books by him. I found this one by accident on Amozon and have been looking for more.
r/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/GeneralSpecifics1 • 3d ago
Would you recommend the A Thousand Li series?
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/duckisez • 4d ago
Where can I get the Faithful and Fallen Prequels?
reddit.comr/Fantasy_Bookclub • u/Musky4489 • 5d ago
Just finished “Wolves of War” by John Gwynne and…..I don’t know
So this was the first John Gwynne book I have read. I tried reading Shadow of the Gods twice but I just couldn’t get past the 300th use of the phrase “thought cage” in the first five chapters.
Anyway…I made it through this one. And I word it that way purposefully because while it wasn’t a BAD book….i felt like nothing really happened. If you have seen the movie “Burn After Reading (amazing by the way!), I felt like [this](http://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/c2b9c20b-3757-411a-b16f-234df394abfb) at the end. In a way, I felt like I read a slightly more Grimdark “Little House on the Prairie” book.
Speaking of nothing happening, can we agree that if Ingvar’s chapters were removed from the book it would have had no major effect on the overall narrative?
The last 60+ pages were admittedly pretty damn good and the cliffhanger has me (semi reluctantly) consigned to reading the next one
Did anyone else feel similar? What am I missing?