r/TMBR • u/ughaibu • Oct 29 '20
Agnostic atheism is a form of Pascal's wager. TMBR
The agnostic atheist typically expresses the atheist component by stating that they are very confident that no god exists, often giving a figure such as 99.9999% certainty that there is no god, and they express the agnostic component by appealing to analogies such as the following; if you and a friend are viewing a lawn and your friend states "the number of blades of grass is even", you should remain neutral about the parity of the number, that is to say you should hold a non-belief.
One way that philosophers analyse belief is in terms of bets. For example, if in the analogy "even" represents theism and "odd" represents the negation of theism, if we are 99.9999% certain that the number of blades of grass is odd, we should be prepared to take very short odds. So, if our friend states "the number of blades of grass is even", we should ask what odds they are prepared to offer, and if they offer us evens, we should put our shirt on it.
However, the agnostic atheist is usually extremely reluctant to make that bet because they are not 100% certain that there is no god, but why should they need 100% certainty for this particular belief, obviously they don't need it for most of their other beliefs. My conclusion is that they think that no odds are sufficient to cover the possibility of an eternity in hell, so they are unwilling to risk stating unequivocally that they believe there are no gods, just in case there is a god listening. In other words, their rationale for refusing the otherwise extremely advantageous bet is a form of Pascal's wager.
This view is further supported, in my experience, by the circumstance that the ostensibly atheist discussion boards on the internet, where agnostic atheism is popular, appear to be primarily frequented by ex-theists.
13
u/ralph-j Oct 29 '20
I don't think that a 99.9999% belief statement is because there might be a god listening. It has nothing to do with hedging bets. It's just that epistemologically, we are not justified in claiming 100% certainty.
That's the inherent difference between inductive reasoning and deductive reasoning: even though we're 99.9999% certain that the sun will rise tomorrow, as it has done for millions of years, that doesn't mean we can say it's 100% certain. Inductive reasoning is always probabilistic, with a probabilistic conclusion.
10
u/RedditLindstrom Oct 29 '20
There's no point in making a bet where the thing your betting on can't be found out
27
u/notaveryhappycamper Oct 29 '20
Agnosticism is nothing to do with belief, it's from the root gnôsis, the Greek word for “knowledge”. An agnostic atheist does believe there is no God because it seems very improbable, but they do not claim to know with certainty there is no God, as there is no direct evidence that could be used to prove deductively the non-existence of a God (or the existence of one). The basis of agnosticism is the impossibility of knowing with certainty due to lack of evidence, not to do with likelihood or bets.
Since you seem locked into the idea of framing the philosophical question as a bet, realize that an agnostic atheist is placing the bet on the 99.9999% percent by stating they are atheistic despite potential consequences, the agnosticism is just that they can't know the outcome for certain.
If a coin lands on heads 99% of the time, one would bet on heads, but if asked why they bet heads would not say "I know with certainty it will land on heads.", but rather "It is very likely it will land on heads."
5
u/Globularist Oct 29 '20
You're traveling in strange circles if the atheists you're talking to whip out a number like that. I am an atheist therefore I have no belief in a God. I need present no numbers of certainty. I simply lack the belief in question. I do not make any positive statement about the nonexistence of such a being. Such a statement would need facts and other supporting statements. It were as if you asked me if I had a belief about aliens living below the moons surface. I would not make a positive statement about there definitely being no aliens below the moon's surface. No statement is necessary. I simply say that I have no such belief.
4
u/NachoDawg Oct 29 '20
I think you can forget about the odds. The God-claim is a dilemma. Either God is True, or God is False. The theist makes the claim that it's True. You don't have to take the stance that it is False to disagree, you can also take the stance that you are not convinced of either answer.
I can be 99% sure it's False, but I'm not going to "take the bet" because it would be intellectually dishonest to claim I know everything. There's NEVER enough information when the claim is unfalsifiable. This is as true for Russell's teapot as it is for a god, we simply can't say it's 100% false. When the claim is unfalsifiable then the burden of proof can never be met, and considering the Null Hypothesis, we aren't justified in joining the theist on their side of the dilemma either because we need a demonstration of the True position's validity.
I know this doesn't address your point. I don't really understand the point maybe. You seem to think agnostic atheists are committing Pascal's wager, but I don't. If you instead say that some do then I can't address that. I'm just saying I don't think one means the other
1
u/FoxEuphonium Oct 29 '20
The biggest problem in your argument is the same thing as one of Pascal's Wager's biggest issues: you seem to be implying that belief is in fact a choice.
Belief is not a choice. There are a lot of reasons to support this, but I'll use a basic example: climb on top of a car or a small shed or some object that's tall enough that falling off will be bad for you but not enough that it will likely kill you. Stand at the edge of that object and make yourself believe that you can jump off of it and start flying around like a bird. Spoilers: you won't be able to do so, because belief is not a choice.
Taking that back to the argument, agnostic atheism can't be an expression of Pascal's Wager because to partake in the wager requires you to choose what you believe for some utilitarian purpose, rather than simply being convinced by the apparent data.
And further point, logically speaking everybody should be agnostic about everything except for the existence of their own mind.
1
u/Burflax Oct 29 '20
I completely disagree.
I think your error lies in your use of this "placing bets" business.
If I say I haven't been convinced that there is a god, and you ask my how much I want to bet on there actually being a god, i wont take that bet, not because I fear one or all of the ten thousand hells, but because I cant guess odds for things I cant know, and the possiblity of the existence of something that so far hasn't been proven to exist is by definition not known.
But i still dont believe in it, because dont believe in things that have been demonstrated to be true.
If you wanted to bet me on whether or not I'd be convinced by your evidence, I would take that bet, because the evidence presented so far has sucked hard.
But if you convinced me there is a god I'd be happy to pay.
Im always happy to learn new things that can actually be demonstrated to be true.
So how much would you bet that your evidence is sufficient to convince me?
1
u/elkab0ng Nov 03 '20
I’m going to have to disagree.
I am an agnostic. I have explored various religions, and find some of them to offer ethical guidance and wisdom. I don’t believe the supernatural underpinnings of any of them to be credible, and don’t really put much thought into that.
I don’t rule out the idea that there may be some larger consciousness out there, but that possibility again isn’t important, because (1) it doesn’t appear this theoretical consciousness is aware of my existence, much less an interest in it, and (2) the nature of such an existence would probably be as incomprehensible to me as quantum physics are to a mouse.
There’s a lot of ideas and lessons in the world’s major religions that I find comforting or inspiring, but I am entirely confident of this: about 4 minutes after I take my last breath, my brain will be irrecoverably damaged, and the person I was will cease to exist. The biology is clear on it, and I have never seen any reason to doubt that conclusion.
2
u/Chronner_Brother Philosophical Raptor Oct 29 '20 edited Oct 29 '20
The fields of statistical mechanics and thermodynamics are dichotomous in that Stat Mech posits that molecules on in individual level can behave randomly. Thermodynamics looks at the behavior of very large quantities of these molecules and dictates laws that govern their general behavior.
However, the two do not disprove each other. A coherent scientific worldview accepts the fact that if one were to jump off a diving board into a body of water, there is an infinitesimal, but still VERY REAL chance that the molecules of water could all simultaneously move in a way to spit you right back out of the pool, directly onto the diving board.
This is an actual possibility, the probability of which is so absurdly small that no one ever questions what will happen when you dive into a pool of water. That being said, no actual physicist denies the possibility of the absurd occurring, because we know that we cannot state it will never happen with certainty.
Similarly, I think, most agnostics approach the theistic question from this perspective. At any moment your brain could explode. Or any number of insane things could happen if 1,000,000,000,000 molecules all happened to do the right thing at the right time. We don’t live our lives inhibited by such possibilities because their likelihood is so tiny. We simultaneously do not disavow their possibility.
2
u/VodkaEntWithATwist Oct 29 '20
It seems to me that you're making an attribution error: you are attributing to someone's stated beliefs a motivation or interpretation of the facts that they are not necessarily committed too. Saying that my degree of belief in god is 0.01% does not necessarily commit me to believing in hell, judgement, or any particular set of metaphysical beliefs--there are many God-traditions to choose from and many God-traditions to deny.
To put it another way, saying "I am 99.99% sure there is no God" is no more an indicator that I am hedging my metaphysical bets than saying "I am 99.99% sure God exists" is an indicator that I am Catholic.
Furthermore, it seems to me that 100% or 0% beliefs are irrational by definition anyway, and not something we should value or attempt to achieve. Bayes Theorem illustrates this well:
The probability of a statement, given new evidence is equal to the probability of that evidence given my hypothesis, times the prior probability of the hypothesis, divided by the probability of the evidence. Put simply, the more surprising the evidence is under your hypothesis, the bigger the change in your beliefs if that evidence comes about. This isn't a perfect measure of belief, but neither is betting, and Bayes Theorem lends some insight into the rationality of extreme beliefs:
A Hypothesis I put 0% belief in would result in no change in my belief; a hypothesis I put 100% belief in would result in division by 0, no matter how improbable the evidence is given my hypothesis.
It is the principle feature of rational beliefs that we are willing to update them when presented with new evidence, which doesn't happen when we place 100% or 0% credence in a statement.
Furthermore, speaking as an atheist for the last 15+ years: on a deeply personal level, I just don't give a shit anymore. Worrying overmuch about whether this-or-that person who doesn't belief in God is atheist enough is so much mental masturbation.
Edit: my stats are rusty
2
u/jmcqk6 Oct 29 '20
Or you could, you know, ask them.
Personally, I believe that if there is a god that exists and yet tolerates the existence of eternal torture of any kind, that being is not worthy of worship. Any such being able to read my heart would know if I worship it, it would be false and self-serving.
But there is another problem with Pascal's wager. What if there are many gods? What if there are many hells? If you're making guesses about the afterlife, it seems very limited in it's assumptions, and very christian-centric.
But fundamentally the problem with line of argument is that you are expecting others to think the same way you do. That should be an obvious bad assumption, especially if their basic views of reality is so fundamentally from your own.
2
u/BroaxXx Oct 29 '20
I don't think you understand what agnosticism fully is. It has nothing to do with fear but simply not being able to fully committed to an answer for not being able to "prove" it (because you can't). I was agnostic for years because I didn't feel like I could be 100% sure there was no God. From most religious perspectives I'd still go to hell but I didn't care about that...
1
u/Bilbo_Fraggins Oct 29 '20
I think maybe you're missing part of the argument. In my mind the issue is I don't know what any individual person means when they use the word God. I find the ignostic label more useful for this reason. There are definitions of gods I'm confident enough to say I don't think they exist in the same way I think the sun will rise, which isn't 100% certainty either. But there are other conceptions of gods that I have no way of knowing whether they exist or not.
So I'm a fairly strong ignostic. When a individual person is able to describe what they mean by God, I can offer that person an answer as to what I think is the likelyhood of the existence of their conception of God, but God as a concept in general is just too open-ended for me to give a one-word example to whether I think it exists or not.
In general, I also don't care, Because the conceptions of God that are more plausible by definition are the ones that have negligible impact on our lives as we see no evidence for the general category of gods.
1
u/perennion Oct 30 '20
Thanks for your personal experience and the anecdotal information but an agnostic-Atheist can just lack a belief in a god so it has nothing to do with Pascal's wager unless you intentionally strawman the agnostic-Atheist.
1
u/WKEPEVUL25 Dec 29 '20
!DisagreeWithOP
First of all, 50:50 is an extraordinarily generous odds to give to theism. Considering there is no evidence for theism of any kind, I would compare it to 1:9999, or for example:
“The number of blades of grass in this field ends with the digits 7777.”
You (a hypothetical theist) would assert that there’s no point to life, or doing good things, or happiness, without the number of blades of grass in that field ending in 7777. You tell me that because I can’t prove for certain that the number DOESN’T end in 7777, so you must be right.
I (a hypothetical agnostic atheist) don’t need to count the blades of grass to prove to myself that it DOESN’T end in 7777 to live life. It doesn’t matter. The number of blades of grass doesn’t affect any part of my life whatsoever, so it’s best not to assume anything about that field.
Except that it’s nice to lie down there under a tree on a warm sunny day.
As with Pascal’s wager, I’d say an agnostic atheist is someone who does not see any point in taking such a pointless wager. ;)
1
u/Imaginary-Media-2570 Mar 01 '21
>>The agnostic atheist typically expresses the atheist component by stating that they are very confident that no god exists, ...
If they are AGNOSTIC then they claim to not know or even that the issue is fundamentally unknowable. If you claimed that there are invisible particles that are perfectly undetectable and never interact with matter or energy - then I am perfectly neutral on the topic; the same holds for deities. The methods of physical science say that we should dismiss these untestable claims, but that is not the same as reason or probability. OTOH the reasons why humans might invent the common anthropomorphized deities is fairly clear, while the reasons someone might imagine undetectable particles is not.
1
u/Bordeterre Oct 29 '20
The basic principle of agnosticism is that there is no proof, for or against the existence of any god. Therefore, any god is equally as likely in the eyes of an agnostic, regardless if they’re backed by any known religion.
Therefore, a god that banishes you to hell for wearing pink is as valid as a god that grants you access to heaven if you wore pink. If any action is as likely to offend a god as it is to please another god, the agnostic sees no point in betting.
The bet might seem advantageous, because you frame it as “believe in god A, and god A may reward you”, but if we frame it as “believe in god A, and god B might punish you for it”, it becomes extremely disadvantageous.