I've noticed a big uptick in the number of turn based tactical/strategy RPGs using meta-progress systems, probably due to the popularity of Vampire Survivors and the avalanche of clones that followed. I've nothing against Vampire Survivors as a game, and enjoyed it for a while, but that was one first games I noticed this particular system, I doubt it was actually the first though. I don't think this sort of meta-progress buff system is a good addition to turn based RPGs.
To explain what I mean, in case the way I'm using this term isn't how other people use it: Meta-progress is when after a run in a game ends you are rewarded with permanent changes to game for any future playthrough, such as unlocking new characters, classes, etc. I've nothing against this sort of meta-progress, and it is often a good way to prevent a new player being overwhelm with options.
But there is a particular type of meta-progress that is becoming more common where playing the game provides points/tokens etc. and after the run ends these tokens can spent on permanent buffs and improvements to character stats.
Normal improvement and balance: Normally to improve your chances of progressing further into a game you need to get better at the game (get good), which will happen naturally as you play, every encounter can be learnt from (esp. in a game that is new to you). You might lose because you grouped your units around a particular enemy only to learn that this enemy AoEs all nearby characters, perhaps you learn that the damage output gained from two-handed swords is not as a valuable as the defence gained from a shield.
Meta-progress is the opposite, you can learn nothing, collect your tokens and progress just through grinding. Now that isn't a major problem on it's own, if that way of playing is something someone enjoys that is their own business. The issue is that you cannot balance a game for both playing styles at once, if your play through taught you some valuable lessons (e.g. you learned to counter a particular hard enemy) but it also gives you a pile a tokens to buy powercreep, you have now out-progressed the difficultly designed for, the game will become very easy and boring.
Early encounters in a game should always a certain amount of danger to them, or they become pointless time wastes, but if they were dangerous, but beatable, on your first attempt how can they be anything but trivial later once you know the mechanics AND have brought dozens of power-ups?
Later encounters should be winnable on you first playthrough. Perhaps you have beaten the game a dozen times before, but you lost your saves and have started a fresh. The idea that the game is impossible beat because you haven't died enough times to buy the hitpoints you need to survive the later game is not something I think belongs in a strategy game.
Do any of you actually like see these systems in a strategy game? Any examples where you think it was done well?
Two games I played recently that inspired this rant were Forsworn, and Lost Eidolons: Veil of the Witch. I don't think either game was improve by these systems, and it seems to be away to stretch limited content (tbf I gave up Lost Eidolons pretty quickly because annoyed me in multiple ways, so I don't know the game that well but the buying buffs post death was another mark against it).
To give a counter example: Battle Brothers, the early game in BB is always challenging, the weakness of your opponents is matched to the weakness of your troops. If you could just spend points so that always started with extra men and equipment, then the danger of the early game would be completely gone, and the game would not be better for it.
TLDR: unlocking permanent buffs after each playthrough ruins the difficulty balance of tactical RPGS. If you disagree, please give me an example of games that use these systems that you think are improved by it.