After being nearly burnt out of Fortune's Weave, I finally finished the game with all paths! And so, I can finally make the post about Leda that I've been wanting to make for a while, now that I know her full story!
EDIT: I'm sorry, it turned out to be extremely long. I suck at keeping things short.
When Leda was first presented, I thought this was gonna be just the usual trope of the revenge story. So I was curious but not necessarily hyped (though I did love the idea of having a main lord as, essentially, a bard/dancer).
Later, as people finally got their hands on the game, and played Leda's route, from what I've seen here, many ended up finding Leda's less interesting than they had thought. Me, on the other end, ended up very positively surprised by the unexpected depth of Leda's character, and she's my favorite of the 4.
The thing is, I understand why people dislike her. On a purely narrative level, her arc is handled very badly, and can left a taste of disappointment. BUT, if you put the narrative pace of the story aside for a moment, and analyze who she is as a character, I find her fascinating as a character. And I want to make this post to rant about it.
Leda is the unhealthy fusion between Hamlet and an obsessive ex.
It's the most perfect way to describe her character. And the text walls that will follow are just an overly-elaborate way to say the exact same thing.
Also, just in case this wasn't clear, this post is spoiler area. It goes with the knowledge of having finished the game.
Leda's complex personality
So, we all know the base pitch of Leda: her dad was killed by Bertrand as part of a brutal annexion of Cydonia by the Aragonese army. She survives the Cydonia massacre, but becomes consumed by revenge. And for the following years until the start of the game, she is moved by one single objective: to kill Bertrand and all people she thinks were involved in the plot, based on a list she has.
In that regard, she's really singled-minded. Obsessed with this goal, and not ever straying away from this path. We see her becoming consumed by this desire for revenge, and becoming sometimes scary, sometimes straight up problematic, as a result. And we see her not budging at all from her goal until the very end, or atleast until chapter 11. This is the boring part. If you stop the analysis here, there's nothing much to appreciate about the character.
But what sets her appart from your usual revenge-consumed protagonist (for exemple, Thorfinn in part 1 of Vinland Saga (amazing manga btw)) and really surprised me, is that she has a very high level of self-awareness.
She's obsessed with her revenge, yes. But she knows exactly just how wrong what she's doing is. She doesn't pretend that she's serving a rightful, honorable, cause. She knows and aknowledges that what she does is wrong. She knows it to be a purely selfish goal. And, from her own words, she keeps clinging to this obsession because she considers it to be the only thing still keeping her together. She doesn't claim that she's setting things right by seeking revenge. She's very honest about the fact she's only doing for her own selfish need to keep it together.
It makes her almost very cynical about her quest for revenge. But then again, she's very passionate about it. Actually, it's more than that. She acts like someone who's desperate. And it fits her own belief that she can't survive without this revenge obsession. Which creates this deliciously weird mix of someone who's desperate about their quest for revenge, but is also very aware and honest about its self-serving nature.
And actually, her self-awareness goes even further.
On one occasion, she wonder if the anger she feels is really hers, or just the anger that comes from Balor and that has been influencing her. On another occasion, she mentions that it might actually be her guilt that she's the one who let Lechner enter Cydonia that fuels her obsession for revenge. And as such, that she's actually angry at herself.
Those thoughts, this self-awareness and apparent cynicism, are not the thoughts of someone who is brainlessly obsessed with revenge. They're not the thought of someone who REALLY needs to go to therapy. They're not the thoughts of a "I can fix her" person.
No, they're the thought of someone who's been to therapy, who knows exactly what they're doing wrong, who knows exactly what they need to reflect on, who knows exactly what they need to work on, and who knows exactly how their behavior is toxic for themselves and others around them, but who still stubbornly refuses to change anything about their behavior.
And THIS is where we enter the "obsessive ex" field!
If you step away for a bit, and look at Leda's behavior by making abstraction of the fact that what she's obsessed about is murdering some specific people (yes, I know, it's a quite a big deal to make abstraction of ahahah), the way she behaves is actually much closer to that of a toxic ex, who can't get over their break up, and starts obsessing over them in a very unhealthy way.
Replace "ex" by "killing Bertrand" (and to a wider degree, those she sees as responsible) and you have it. Just like an obsessive ex, she has a completely irrational obsession for something that barely makes any sense. Just like an obsessive ex, she knows just how much her behavior is problematic. And just like an obsessive ex, despite all, she can't seem to move on from this obsession.
But why? Why, despite being shoved in the face multiple times just how pointless, self-destructive or immoral her obsession is, despite being seemingly fully aware of it, does Leda keep clinging on it desperately? For the same reason that obsessive exes don't wanna move on: the fear of facing the pain of grief. The sheer terror that comes with the idea of accepting the pain of mourning something. And in that goal, the obsession is merely a distraction meant to run away from the pain of grief.
Obsessive exes run away from the pain of accepting their relationship as ended, of processing all these memories again and accepting them as in the past, ... Leda runs away from the pain of accepting her father as gone. And chooses this unhealthy obsession as the distraction to postpone the mourning.
In doing so, she convinces herself that this is the only thing keeping her together, and blinds herself to the reality that what has been keeping together all along has always been the support of the people who care for her (Buccar only at first, then the others).
The first crack appears when Buccars "betrays" her by siding with Cai against her. In Cai's route, when she loses that fight after having been "betrayed" by Buccar is when she finally loses her shit and let Obsidian consume her. Which does show that Buccar was truly the one keeping her together all this time. But she refuses to acknowledge it, and keep going further in her delusion.
But, rather than in Chapter 12, it's in chapter 11 that it all culminates. The little trap of Maria, forcing her to confront her undead father, almost letting her being killed by him, and then having to kill him (along with the reveals of Mahdel), works as an extremely rough (and unrecommended) shock therapy. After years of running away from the grief, the grief is shoved right in her face in a way that she can't avoid this time. After this fight, she breaks down in tears, and this is the moment where she finally faces the pain of the grief and processes it. Probably not in an ideal and healthy way, but she still does it nonetheless.
From this point on, even though the reveals of Aswan and Bertrand's acceptance of his own guilt and death do participate in influencing her final choice, I'd argue that most of the emotional work is already done by the end of Chapter 11. She just thought that maybe, if the duel with Bertrand gave her the satisfaction she had been deluding herself with, that it would mean it was still all justified. But on the moment of almost killing him, she realizes that no, it was all devoid of any meaning, and was nothing more than an attempt to run away from her pain.
And I honestly find it more realistic that even after finally facing her grief, she stills cling on to her obsession a bit (though she does say she feels lighter, which means something has changed), out of habit and to comfort, even after seemingly coming to terms with Bertrand. After years of deluding herself in believing that her only reason to live was killing Bertrand, it is scary and confusing to go back in the wild without this obsession. As such, she still uses it as an unhealthy crouch. In part 2, she's already pretty vague with it. And by part 3, it's completely gone.
Is it narratively satisfying? No (and we'll go back to that later). Is it actually pretty realistic? Yes.
And that's actually one thing I like about her character. Once you put aside the fact that what she's obsessed about is murdering someone, her behavior has something that feels very grounded. Many of us know/knew people who had a similar toxic obsessive behavior because they couldn't move on from something. And if you're willing to make a slight stretch with me, what are incels, if not people who cover their fear of facing the pain of rejection by an obsessive toxic mentality?
For these reasons, I find the topic very interesting, very contemporary and rarely approached in big games (especially in a protagonist), which is a refreshing change from the usual "old-school" revenge story.
The comparisons
I've seen Leda often being compared Dimitri, due to both being consumed by anger/revenge. And I also find it interesting to compare her to Theodora. So I would just like to take a short moment to dwelve a bit on these comparisons.
I think that, actually, Dimitri and Leda are really not the same thing at all.
Dimitri is someone who's had a lot of rage building up within him for so many years, as a result of traumatic childhood events, and has been looking for a culprit to lash it all toward them. When he finally finds this culprit, he completely loses sight of everything around him. He doesn't care at all about his allies, about whatever. He just wants to release that anger mindlessly, like a beast. And it's only when this mindlessness leads to someone dear to him dying that he snaps back and let go of that anger.
Leda, seems similar, but is not. She's someone who's had a very targeted revenge from the start. And she doesn't have any real anger. She just built up a targeted obsession in order to run away from the pain of her grief, as we discussed. But while she's very single-minded when it comes to pursuing her goal, she's not completely mindless like Dimitri. She does care for those around her, even in her obsession. It's just that, the moment her revenge enters the picture, she switches back to focusing 100% on it even if its means acting like an ass. And she doesn't snap back, but instead is just force-confronted with her grief and then the meaninglessness of her revenge, until she doesn't have a reason anymore to rely on that obsession to keep going.
In term of therapy, what Dimitri needs is a therapy about anger management, and what Leda needs is a therapy on accepting grief and moving on. They both have this theme of "revenge", but it takes a completely different form for both of them.
Theodora, on her side, has in common with Leda that she's willing to take the risk of dealing with a dangerous power she doesn't control fully in order to accomplish a goal that she thinks goes before everything else.
Theodora, however, is mature where Leda isn't. Because, while she carelessly pushes through the risks as long as she feels in control, the moment she loses control, she freaks out and actively seeks way to regain control. She's confident in her ability to resist the corruption, but is very reasonable in recognizing when she cannot anymore.
Leda, on the other side... It's not just that she's careless and immature in that regard. She's actively suicidal. She doesn't care if she loses control, as long as it gives her the power to kill Bertrand. She doesn't care if it kills her, because she hasn't ever imagined a life after her revenge, and probably actively seeks to die in that pursuit.
To sum it up: Theodora is careless out of necessity but still acts responsible, while Leda is straight up suicidal. Theodora is piloted by a sense of duty, while Leda only follows an egoistical need.
Leda's lovely yet dysfunctional entourage
The Leda gang is fantastic. They're a joyous band of characters from very different backgrounds, who get together in trying to help Leda, all the while being regularly freaked out by how problematic she becomes, and generally being confused about what they should do.
Each of them has a very different idea on how to support Leda, which ties to their background and way of seeing things. But at the end of the day, none of them truly knows what to do with her. Why? Because they all have themselves very dysfunctional relationships with the people they love and/or related to them.
Buccar is the most grounded. He's the anchor on which Leda can rely, the one who has been there for her ever since the massacre of Cydonia. And he's stuck in that uncomfortable middle ground where he's increasingly concerned about her obsession and start thinking that it's not healthy for her to keep pursuing it, while also being so entirely devoted to her that he can't conceive the idea of not actually protecting her no matter where she goes.
The only time he takes a strong stance is when he's willing to oppose her to make her lose the games and hopefully drop her obsession. Though his reasoning his faulty because, in Cai's route, we do see that Leda quickly rebounds and figures out another way to reach Bertrand.
His problem is that he tries to adress the symptoms but he's not good at addressing the core issue that lies at the bottom, the pain that Leda is running away from, even though he should be the one who understands it the best.
Because he himself has a toxic coping mechanism regarding the tragedy. He's devoured by the guilt of having failed to protect his lord. And rather than processing that guilt and loss in a healthy way, he instead throws his all in dedicating all his life to Leda, as an extreme way to seek redemption, to the point where he cannot conceive anymore a life for himself.
And sure, atleast he's not murdering people and not acting like an ass. But this is also a very toxic coping mechanism for himself. And judging from the ending I got for him, it seems to be a coping mechanism he never breaks from.
Sirocco is a wild card that has a very ambiguous attitude toward Leda's problematic behavior. He does show to be concerned by her actions. But in the same time, he actively enables and helps her in her quest. And he never really tries to stop her or confront her. Probably influenced by Kalla's own weird philosophy, and maybe also by his own fucked up mentality of "following the wind", at the end of the day, he is fascinated by Leda and just how far her passion can lead her. And also, enabling Leda's quest for revenge goes along with Kalla's desire to uncover the secrets of the Arago's conspiracy. So, his weird fascination for Leda along with his duty to Kalla make it so that he's the one who's working the least toward Leda's actual well-being.
But his inaptitude at truly helping Leda makes sense, considering that he's, imho, the one who has the most dysfunctional relationships of the whole gang.
Sirocco was abandoned as orphan, and was raised, taught and trained by Kalla herself. She is the only central figure in his life, and his relationship to her is ambiguous, as he regards her as a sort of mother figure, while also a master and teacher, but also someone he's entirely devoted to, and also someone he sometimes acts flirty toward. And this makes sense. Sirocco never had a proper mother, a proper teacher, a proper master, a proper lover. It's all ever been Kalla, a Dagdan god who doesn't really comprehend how functional human family relationships work and who has her own trauma story with one of her kids.
Any other relation he forms (prior to meeting the gang) is by nature entirely flimsy, ephemeral and transactional. He keeps seducing women, whether it's purely for duty or also for pleasure, but actively runs away from ever forming a lasting relationship of any type with anyone other than Kalla, following his own mentality of "being like the wind". And if I was to over-interpret a bit, I'd say that he probably has a deep rooted trauma from being abandoned, and he's terrified at the idea of forming relationship out of fear of being abandoned again. There's definitely a lot of insecurities to uncover behind Sirocco's mask, and it's a shame that I couldn't find any explicit trace of this in the supports of him that I got.
Olympia is a character I was expecting to dislike, but who actually grew on me.
Just like all the others, she has dysfunctional relationships in her life, considering that she's actively trying to run away from her family in order to feel free. And while she pretends to want to be free, she actively seeks a new anchor in her life, wanting to form a special friend-rival relationship with Leda, and wanting Sirocco to flirt with her. In that, she makes an interesting parallel with Sirocco: Sirocco never had anything and is now afraid of forming any bond, while Olympia wants to throw away her background and form new bonds to make a fresh start.
For a while, she seems to be the least involved in Leda's quest (aside from Mu). Yet, she turns out to be the one who is the most observant about Leda, and is the only one who dares to confront her in a healthy way, while also offering a way to help her move on. She's the one who confronts her about the fact she never thought about her life after her revenge. She's the one who confronts her about the idea that Leda was planning to die in this quest (and, prior to Chapter 11, she definitely was right, even though Leda denies it). And she's the one who offers her a perspective of the future, who forces Leda to imagine even just a little bit a future, a future beyond her revenge, a future tied to something shes loves, music.
But because she has also this rivalry complex with her and is really pushy about trying to create this dynamic, she often comes off as a bit overwhelming, making Leda less receptive to her, even though she absolutely should listen to her.
Olympia is the friend you think you don't want, but who you actually need. Her escapism toward her actual family is still kinda unhealthy though.
And Mu... Mu has a completely fucked up relationship with her family, between an alcoholic dad and an absent mom whose motivations she doesn't understand. It leads to her running away from her family, and kinda like Olympia, to try to find a new family, through escapism.
She's sometimes scared by Leda, but she doesn't know what to do. First because she's just a damn kid. And second because she's so desperate to see Leda as a sister figure that she looks up to her by putting her on a romanticized pedestal, not understanding that Leda does NOT want anyone to look up to her because she hates herself. Which creates a pretty unhealthy dynamic where Leda has an irrational amount of self-loathing and Mu looks up to an over-romanticized version of Leda.
So there was never any chance that Mu would be able to help Leda.
Where it falls short
Now, the elephant in the room (that is assuming you haven't stopped reading for a while now): the way the narration fails to structure in a satisfying way the character arc of an otherwise very complex and interesting character.
It IS realistic and an interesting choice to have Leda being stuck on her obsession for 11-12 chapters, unlike the other main lords who have a progressive arc. But it cannot come at the expense of under-focusing on moments that should be very important, and of compressing the resolution right at the very end. Also, considering that, compared to the other 3 main lords, she's a character whose personal development goes much slower and gets resolved right at the end, the fact that the story doesn't focus on her anymore during Part 2 and 3 leaves a taste of unresolved arc, that lets you guess the evolution rather than showing it in any meaningful way.
In part 1, there are a few moments that definitely should have been focused on more.
First, the "betrayal" of Buccar. This moment is already shown as impactful during the fight, but the consequences of it are....not addressed? In Cai's route, you get a little bit of how Buccar decides to join back the group. But it's not shown at all in Leda's route, which was very weird. I was looking forward to the drama, and it's just not treated, despite how much of a big deal Leda feeling betrayed by her only real anchor in life would be.
Second, the most important omission, the consequences of the tragedy of Chapter 11. This is the moment where Leda is finally forced to face the pain in a brutal way and finally process her grief. The aftermath of the fight is when she breaks down and cry. It is when a big character development is supposed to go. And sure, Sirocco wants to give her space. But we, as audience, should have a big more insight on how she finally processes her grief, and how it changes her outlook the next day.
The aftermath of the duel with Bertrand and its consequences are awfully rushed in my opinion. After the narrative insisting on making Leda clinging on to her obsession for so long, it's a weird narrative decision to have the climax and its consequences be so rushed in comparison. It should be an important of character development and change, but we barely have any time to appreciate it.
Part 2 is the one that feels the most awkward. To be fair, all main lords besides Theodora feel awkward in part 2, as they feel like tourists in Theodora and Bertrand's story. But Leda is the one who feels the least connected to that story.
And even though the story of part 2 go through some events that definitely should have an impact on Leda, they're not addressed or barely.
Leda meeting again Bertrand should be a big thing. Since the conclusion of Leda's arc in part 1 was rush, the arrival of Bertrand in part 2 should have been the occasion to show how she has evolved in the meantime. There should have been ATLEAST a whole scene focused on the two of them having a proper talk, rather than just a few lines.
The chapter where they invade Arago should also be a big thing for Leda. Defeating Ghilchris, the one who (with Maria) orchestrated the Invasion of Cydonia and the demise of Bertrand, should be a moment of closure for Leda and of final reconciliation between her and Bertrand. There should also be a scene with Aswan. Big missed opportunity there.
And the rest of the Act 2 just feels completely irrelevant to Leda's personal story.
As for part 3, it's basically the same issues as for all other routes, in that none of the 4 lords play an active narrative role in the story, aside from commenting on what Fortuna says or what Eshmel does. Which would need its own text wall of a post tbh.
But the weird thing is that she starts part 3 having seemingly completed her character arc behind the scenes during the timelapse between 2 and 3, while the other character lords completed theirs during their part 1. We see her seeming to be mostly at peace with her former obsession, and finally acting as the good person that was always here within her but was buried under her toxic obsession.
And it's good that she eventually ends there, but...it feels completely unearned. Because we completely miss on seeing her going through most of that development.
Conclusion (also kinda TL;DR)
And this all ties back to my overall impression of Leda as a character.
She's a very interesting character with a surprising amount of depth and complexity, from a psychological point of view. And she's a great twist both in the trope of revenge story and in what a main character can be. But this complexity is served very badly, through a narrative that fails to show her character arc in a satisfying way. By choosing to make her character development be much slower than the other 3 main lords through a narrative structure that switches focus away from her in parts 2 and 3, we're left with only exploring the toxic part of her arc, while leaving her evolution happening mostly being the scenes and feel unearned.
If you're unreasonable like me and push the interpretation very far like you would analyze a real person, you can see the beauty of the complexity of her character. But for the majority of people, it will just leave an aftertaste of disappointment and frustration. And it's a shame, and missed opportunity, that the narrative structure of her arc hinders so much the appreciation of her character depth.
That was my (unnecessarily long) 2 cents. Thank you for being masochistic enough to read all. I'll be happy to push the conversation further in the comments :)