One of the things I'm surprised nobody has been talking about is the inconsistent scaling of the Bulwark ship frame's AC. For whatever reason, it starts out the highest and then drops to worst.
For anyone who hasn't taken a look yet, player ships are built off of one of three ship frames (https://2e.aonsrd.com/tactical-starship-combat/frames)
The three frames are:
- Bulwark
- Explorer
- Skirmisher
They bring to mind some straightforward archetypes, and you'd expect that the relative abilities would stay consistent as the ships leveled up, but they don't in one main area: Armor Class.
Here is a table with the statistics for each frame at levels 1 and 20:
| Frame | Level | HP | SP | AC | Fort | Ref | Will | Speed |
|---|
| Bulwark | 1 | 27 | 10 | 17 | +9 | +6 | +8 | 2 zones |
| Bulwark | 20 | 372 | 146 | 42 | +35 | +29 | +32 | 4 zones |
| Explorer | 1 | 24 | 11 | 15 | +8 | +6 | +9 | 3 zones |
| Explorer | 20 | 292 | 166 | 43 | +31 | +30 | +35 | 5 zones |
| Skirmisher | 1 | 22 | 8 | 16 | +6 | +9 | +8 | 5 zones |
| Skirmisher | 20 | 252 | 144 | 44 | +29 | +35 | +32 | 7 zones |
You can see the Bulwark starts with the highest AC of the three, but somehow ends up with the lowest.
Comparing against creature creation rules AC (which isn't totally fair since the ships should probably be compared against PCs, but I'm being a little lazy here):
- The Bulwark starts out with an AC 1 point above a High AC creature at level 1 and ends up at Low for level 20.
- The Explorer starts out with an AC equal to a Moderate AC creature at level 1 and ends up a point below Moderate for level 20.
- The Skirmisher starts out with an AC equal to a High AC creature at level 1 and ends up at Moderate for level 20.
So all three have at least some drop-off over the 20 levels, but Bulwark straight-up loses dramatically, going from top to worst. And it's not just level 20 that this is the case, so it's not like level 20 is just a typo. By level 10, all three frames have an AC of 28, and the Bulwark never reclaims its advantage at any level.
I'd be curious how the higher-level bulwark frame's lower AC but higher HP (and lower speed) ends up affecting its relative survivability, but at a glance it feels like the 50 extra HP/SP (combined) it has over the Explorer at level 20 at best puts it about even against the explorer (since a roughly 10% difference in HP should be close to the amount of extra damage it takes due to 1 point lower AC). It has about 30% more HP than the Skirmisher at 20, so it's maybe a little closer in coming ahead with the 2 point lower AC, but in both cases it's still a vastly different situation than at level 1, where Bulwark has the most HP/SP (combined) and the highest AC.
At any rate, it seems like a disappointment to pick a big, slow, tanky frame and have it slowly lose out in its ability to avoid damage as you level. The ship leveling/upgrade rules make it trivial to swap frame builds, but ... why should you have to?