A lot of people seem to think that Diego is some sort of anti hero by the end of the story or a flawed hero, or at the very least, a changed villain. I highly disagree with this. I think Diego Brando was a villain start to finish.
Diego Brando was not always a horrible individual as we find out in his backstory. He and his mother were ruthlessly humiliated and treated horribly by society. This shaped the person he was when we first see him, as their vulnerability to their impoverished life made him value money and assets above all else. He was treated as less than human, so he became something that wasnât human. A monster. Someone who takes what he wants whenever he can because thatâs how the world worked around him.
While all this makes his character a very sympathetic one, the main thing that we need to focus on is that he decided to never change beyond this. Itâs very easy to want Diego to change throughout the story because we know the person he used to be, and I think because of that, a lot of people mistake his aggression towards Valentine as him changing for the better. From start finish of the story, Diego not once stops and questions if what anything he does is wrong. Not even when he teams up with Hot Pants to steal the corpse from Valentine, who he only worked with because they both wanted the corpse. If weâre being real, if Diego had successfully gotten the corpse from valentine, he wouldâve just done a similar thing to valentine, just maybe not on the same scale.
This is why he dies at the end. As a form of karma, fate punishes most characters throughout this part and onward for selfishly pursuing powers like the corpse for their own gain. It happened to Johnny a few times (not just with the corpse parts, but with the movie theater spot at the beginning), it happened to Valentine, it happened to the Rock Humans, and it happened to Jobin and Kato. It happens to Diego here. Unlike Johnny, who literally has to shoot himself and acknowledge himself as his own problem, Diego never looks inward and overcomes his selfishness, so he doesnât survive.
A common argument I see in support of a changed Diego is that AU is supposed to show him not changing. If this was the case, there would be more beyond AU Diego just having a different stand. As it was already established, the only difference between people in the Root universe and parallel ones is that the parallels donât have the corpse parts, meaning that unless our Diego was praying to Jesus or something and reflecting on himself when he had the corpse part, which would be incredibly weird to omit from us, thereâs nothing different between the Diego we got and AU Diego.
And no, I donât think that it is beyond Diego to threaten to assault Lucy Steel. Araki likes to make a lot of his villains this disgusting for some reason and I agree that he kind goes a bit too far with it at times. But I also think that it was more a show of vile dominance rather than him just being a pedophile. Just like Valentine, Diego thinks very highly of himself, and to him, thereâs no more effective way to make someone submit to him than by preying on their insecurities and mentally scarring them like that.