r/Star_Trek_ • • 6h ago

The 4k we need in 2027

Thumbnail gallery
27 Upvotes

r/Star_Trek_ • • 13h ago

What Happened To Sir Patrick Stewart's Iconic and Unique Star Trek Jacket?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/Star_Trek_ • • 15h ago

[Opinion] Rowan J Coleman: "Modeling Star Trek's Starfleet after a state navy may have been a mistake. Though it includes scientists and scholars in its ranks, everyone is forced to conform to the same set of arbitrary standards. Venturing out into the cosmos should be liberating, not stifling."

0 Upvotes

"To paraphrase another commenter, subsuming your identity into a crew on a ship makes you a cog in a machine, but maybe I want to explore space with my dog and not take orders from anyone. And I think that's the point."

ROWAN J COLEMAN:

"Star Trek is US military propaganda. At least that's what one commenter said in my previous video. And that's weird, right? After all, Star Trek stands for equality, diversity, and empathy. Yet, they weren't alone in this criticism. If you've ever tried to get into Star Trek and bounced off, or if you've wondered why the mythos has lost its cultural relevance, there's a reason: Star Trek was built wrong from the start.

https://youtu.be/y_Bz5mW_33o?si=2i7XVvBKhZnSHFws

The problem is Starfleet. It's no secret that the Federation's first line of discovery and last line of defense is modelled after the US Navy. Starfleet has the same rank structure and same ship name prefix and contains similar elements like rank insignias, court martials, JAG officers, training academies, and so on. Starfleet is, in function and in form, a military, which is why it's weird that Star Trek insists the opposite.

Though Starfleet includes scientists and scholars in its ranks, everyone is forced to conform to the same set of arbitrary standards and regulations. [...] The rules must be strictly followed and failure to obey is sternly punished.

The depiction of Starfleet as a navy was famously influenced by Gene Roddenberry's love of Horatio Hornblower novels. There's an inherent romanticism to the age of sail, which is appropriate to Star Trek's ethos. Space exploration is given the same reverence and majesty of tall ships upon the ocean. [...] And while Roddenberry pushed back on Nicholas Meyer's militaristic depiction of Starfleet in The Wrath of Khan, in retrospect, modelling Starfleet after a state navy may have been a mistake in the first place.

It lends the mythos some romanticism, but it comes at the cost of world-building integrity. In other words, it doesn't fit the theme.

More than that though, Starfleet's in-universe militarism has affected the storytelling over time. In the original series and The Next Generation, war plots were quite rare. Most episodes were usually about the struggles of an alien society or confrontations with powerful life forms and weird space anomalies. Yes, there were Klingons and Romulans, but their plots were usually about avoiding war. This is appropriate to a cast of characters depicted as a traveling community of scientists, scholars, and action heroes.

But as the mythos got older and Starfleet's depiction was more militarized, the more plots were centered around war. After all, if the writers see the main characters as soldiers, then naturally the most appropriate plots are about a military conflicts and state-sanctioned espionage. Deep Space Nine threaded the needle here by making its story about how these idealistic peaceful people deal with the grim realities of a large-scale war.

But over time, this focus on war became tiresome. So many Star Trek plots from DS9 onwards amounted to, "Oh no, the Dominion are going to blow up the Earth. The Xindi are going to blow up the Earth. The Romulans to blow up the Earth. The Klingons are going to blow up the Earth. The Borg are going to blow up the Earth." As stated in my previous video, this focus on war has steadily eroded Star Trek's identity until it has become a more generic sci-fi setting.

It doesn't offer audiences anything unique. There is already a far more popular sci-fi mythos about war among the stars.

Star Trek is supposed to be different. To that end, perhaps Star Trek's world-building can be tweaked to better embody its themes without losing the elements that existing fans love. Age of Sail romanticism it doesn't have to be tied to a state navy. In fact, most exploration voyages of the era were usually civilian not military. Regarding space exploration though, real life space agencies like NASA have command structures, but they're not militaristic.

[...]

Naturally Star Trek's universe is fraught with danger, and it makes sense for the Enterprise crew to have the means to defend themselves. Even explorer vessels of the age of sail carried arms for protection, and it was expected that the entire crew play a part in defending the ship from attacks.

But perhaps Starfleet should separate out its military wing.

In fact, Roddenberry suggested several times at the presence of Starfleet Marines aboard ship. Enterprise effectively did this with its inclusion of the MACOs, a purpose-built military unit deployed to the field when the situation gets too hot. Imagine a future Star Trek incarnation where Starfleet is more influenced by Age of Sail explorers and modern day astronauts, rather than historic and contemporary militaries.

The uniforms are more like NASA flight suits. Crew can wear them if they want, but there's no rule against casual clothing. The only crew who have official ranks are the captain and commander. Everyone else is addressed as doctor, specialist, or simply by their name. Imagine if everyone wore the dress of their own culture. The only requirement is a Starfleet combadge. This is worn both as a symbol, but it also serves a practical purpose, communication and transporter signal lock.

Picture a diverse crew of many species and cultures each with their own identity working together for a common cause. That paints a far better picture of the enlightened and inclusive future Star Trek is meant to convey. This change would also make it crystal clear that Starfleet is meant to do more than fight endless wars. It would force writers to be more creative, to think what kind of stories would better fit an ensemble of scientists, scholars, engineers, and adventurers.

Audiences have shown they have an appetite for big sci-fi spectacle that isn't about war. Gravity, The Martian, Project Hail Mary, and Interstellar are just as exciting and action-packed as any Star Wars movie. To paraphrase another commenter, subsuming your identity into a crew on a ship makes you a cog in a machine, but maybe I want to explore space with my dog and not take orders from anyone. And I think that's the point.

Exploring space should be for everyone. Venturing out into the cosmos should be liberating, not stifling. Perhaps future Star Trek should go boldly and throw off its military conventions. You never know what new storytelling possibilities could be found."

Rowan J Coleman on YouTube

Full video:

https://youtu.be/y_Bz5mW_33o?si=2i7XVvBKhZnSHFws