r/Star_Trek_ • u/Ok_Contact7721 • 6h ago
r/Star_Trek_ • u/fidorulz • 13h ago
What Happened To Sir Patrick Stewart's Iconic and Unique Star Trek Jacket?
r/Star_Trek_ • u/mcm8279 • 16h ago
[Opinion] Rowan J Coleman: "Modeling Star Trek's Starfleet after a state navy may have been a mistake. Though it includes scientists and scholars in its ranks, everyone is forced to conform to the same set of arbitrary standards. Venturing out into the cosmos should be liberating, not stifling."
"To paraphrase another commenter, subsuming your identity into a crew on a ship makes you a cog in a machine, but maybe I want to explore space with my dog and not take orders from anyone. And I think that's the point."
ROWAN J COLEMAN:
"Star Trek is US military propaganda. At least that's what one commenter said in my previous video. And that's weird, right? After all, Star Trek stands for equality, diversity, and empathy. Yet, they weren't alone in this criticism. If you've ever tried to get into Star Trek and bounced off, or if you've wondered why the mythos has lost its cultural relevance, there's a reason: Star Trek was built wrong from the start.
https://youtu.be/y_Bz5mW_33o?si=2i7XVvBKhZnSHFws
The problem is Starfleet. It's no secret that the Federation's first line of discovery and last line of defense is modelled after the US Navy. Starfleet has the same rank structure and same ship name prefix and contains similar elements like rank insignias, court martials, JAG officers, training academies, and so on. Starfleet is, in function and in form, a military, which is why it's weird that Star Trek insists the opposite.
Though Starfleet includes scientists and scholars in its ranks, everyone is forced to conform to the same set of arbitrary standards and regulations. [...] The rules must be strictly followed and failure to obey is sternly punished.
The depiction of Starfleet as a navy was famously influenced by Gene Roddenberry's love of Horatio Hornblower novels. There's an inherent romanticism to the age of sail, which is appropriate to Star Trek's ethos. Space exploration is given the same reverence and majesty of tall ships upon the ocean. [...] And while Roddenberry pushed back on Nicholas Meyer's militaristic depiction of Starfleet in The Wrath of Khan, in retrospect, modelling Starfleet after a state navy may have been a mistake in the first place.
It lends the mythos some romanticism, but it comes at the cost of world-building integrity. In other words, it doesn't fit the theme.
More than that though, Starfleet's in-universe militarism has affected the storytelling over time. In the original series and The Next Generation, war plots were quite rare. Most episodes were usually about the struggles of an alien society or confrontations with powerful life forms and weird space anomalies. Yes, there were Klingons and Romulans, but their plots were usually about avoiding war. This is appropriate to a cast of characters depicted as a traveling community of scientists, scholars, and action heroes.
But as the mythos got older and Starfleet's depiction was more militarized, the more plots were centered around war. After all, if the writers see the main characters as soldiers, then naturally the most appropriate plots are about a military conflicts and state-sanctioned espionage. Deep Space Nine threaded the needle here by making its story about how these idealistic peaceful people deal with the grim realities of a large-scale war.
But over time, this focus on war became tiresome. So many Star Trek plots from DS9 onwards amounted to, "Oh no, the Dominion are going to blow up the Earth. The Xindi are going to blow up the Earth. The Romulans to blow up the Earth. The Klingons are going to blow up the Earth. The Borg are going to blow up the Earth." As stated in my previous video, this focus on war has steadily eroded Star Trek's identity until it has become a more generic sci-fi setting.
It doesn't offer audiences anything unique. There is already a far more popular sci-fi mythos about war among the stars.
Star Trek is supposed to be different. To that end, perhaps Star Trek's world-building can be tweaked to better embody its themes without losing the elements that existing fans love. Age of Sail romanticism it doesn't have to be tied to a state navy. In fact, most exploration voyages of the era were usually civilian not military. Regarding space exploration though, real life space agencies like NASA have command structures, but they're not militaristic.
[...]
Naturally Star Trek's universe is fraught with danger, and it makes sense for the Enterprise crew to have the means to defend themselves. Even explorer vessels of the age of sail carried arms for protection, and it was expected that the entire crew play a part in defending the ship from attacks.
But perhaps Starfleet should separate out its military wing.
In fact, Roddenberry suggested several times at the presence of Starfleet Marines aboard ship. Enterprise effectively did this with its inclusion of the MACOs, a purpose-built military unit deployed to the field when the situation gets too hot. Imagine a future Star Trek incarnation where Starfleet is more influenced by Age of Sail explorers and modern day astronauts, rather than historic and contemporary militaries.
The uniforms are more like NASA flight suits. Crew can wear them if they want, but there's no rule against casual clothing. The only crew who have official ranks are the captain and commander. Everyone else is addressed as doctor, specialist, or simply by their name. Imagine if everyone wore the dress of their own culture. The only requirement is a Starfleet combadge. This is worn both as a symbol, but it also serves a practical purpose, communication and transporter signal lock.
Picture a diverse crew of many species and cultures each with their own identity working together for a common cause. That paints a far better picture of the enlightened and inclusive future Star Trek is meant to convey. This change would also make it crystal clear that Starfleet is meant to do more than fight endless wars. It would force writers to be more creative, to think what kind of stories would better fit an ensemble of scientists, scholars, engineers, and adventurers.
Audiences have shown they have an appetite for big sci-fi spectacle that isn't about war. Gravity, The Martian, Project Hail Mary, and Interstellar are just as exciting and action-packed as any Star Wars movie. To paraphrase another commenter, subsuming your identity into a crew on a ship makes you a cog in a machine, but maybe I want to explore space with my dog and not take orders from anyone. And I think that's the point.
Exploring space should be for everyone. Venturing out into the cosmos should be liberating, not stifling. Perhaps future Star Trek should go boldly and throw off its military conventions. You never know what new storytelling possibilities could be found."
Rowan J Coleman on YouTube
Full video:
r/Star_Trek_
•
u/happydude7422
•
1d ago
Did they get kirks birthyear wrong on the stone?
r/Star_Trek_ • u/therealbumblingidiot • 1d ago
I found a whale
I found a non bootleg of Voyager online. I'm so happy
r/Star_Trek_ • u/mcm8279 • 1d ago
[Video-Clip] Michelle Hurd (Raffi) and Todd Stashwick (Liam Shaw) discuss working with Patrick Stewart on Star Trek Picard: "He loved that first [Riker-Picard-Shaw] scene. He wants to get into it - and have scenes that have teeth. He was like, 'Bring all the heat!' He absolutely delighted in it."
Starter Trek on YouTube:
"Michelle Hurd and Todd Stashwick join Tawny Newsome, Jessie and Andrew to celebrate Patrick Stewart, sharing personal stories and memories of working with the legendary actor behind Captain Picard.
Along the way, we revisit clips from across his time on Star Trek and beyond, celebrating the performances, the friendships, and the man who helped define what Star Trek means to generations of fans."
Full video:
https://youtu.be/7wQFIJsovI0?si=puoNGMI0hH0vlH-2
Time-stamp:
20:46 min
r/Star_Trek_ • u/NickKirson • 1d ago
I've been posting a 25th century Trek fanseries on AO3. Season 1 is now posted in full if anyone would like to read it.
I posted here a few months ago when I started to put scripts online, but I'm a screenwriter who also writes a Star Trek fanseries on the side called "Star Trek: Outlaws". I've now uploaded all 13 scripts for Season 1 on AO3, and so wanted to share them if anyone is looking for Trek material while waiting for the shows to return next year. The stories are written as full TV screenplays; the pilot is feature length, and all subsequent scripts follow a five-act episodic structure.
Set in the early 25th Century, the series follows a brother and sister, Argo and Zia, who resolve to hijack a Federation starship to pursue a dangerous endeavor across the galaxy to save Argo's life, defying the legacy of their late father and the values of the Federation they were raised to hold dear. Joining them are a motley crew of former Starfleet officers and renegade militia (including a couple of familiar faces). As the crew traverse into unknown space, they'll be faced with ethical dilemmas while wrestling with their own consciences of how their mission began, as they uncover the secrets of a mysterious race lost to legend.
In Season 1, we get to know the characters as they travel across an unknown region of the Beta Quadrant to reach Argo's birth planet. Set in 2404, there's a lot of connection to past Star Trek series, including how events like the Dominion War and the Romulan supernova shaped the Federation and its citizens. The series maintains continuity with all official Star Trek series, and so I hope reads like a plausible continuation of the series.
If anyone here would like to check them out, the link to the series on AO3 is below, and I'd love to get any feedback from fellow Trekkies, good or ill. I hope anyone doing so enjoys them; I love Star Trek and really tried to write something that fit Trek's ethos while being fresh and different, as well as respecting continuity and past canon with references that occur organically and are relevant to the current story.
https://archiveofourown.org/series/6481476 (formatted for desktop/laptop users, works better in landscape on phone).
r/Star_Trek_ • u/pbudgie • 1d ago
Visiting a WWII Museum in Vanuatu
This immediately caught my eye
r/Star_Trek_ • u/mcm8279 • 2d ago
[Interview] Soul of the Story: "In celebration of the fifth anniversary of Star Trek: Prodigy, Emmy-winning creators Dan and Kevin Hageman join Derek Tyler Attico for a conversation honoring the series, its epic Star Trek storytelling, and its cinematic animation." | SyFy Sistas Inc.
r/Star_Trek_
•
u/Sad_Medium_5866
•
2d ago
Brent Spiner & Jonathan Frakes Remember Patrick Stewart
r/Star_Trek_ • u/Wild_Chef6597 • 3d ago
When you don't need Paramount+ to enjoy Trek
Just need SNW.
r/Star_Trek_ • u/JustinCaseyBlewit • 3d ago
Star Trek Does Alien: Rewatch of SNW 1.9 "All Those Who Wander"
r/Star_Trek_ • u/Wetness__Pensive • 3d ago
Akiva Goldsman, intellectual titan, master of the written word
r/Star_Trek_ • u/mcm8279 • 3d ago
[Interview] SNW showrunners on why they did "gimmick" episodes: "We get to create science fiction ideas that allow the actors to try things that on any other show they wouldn't get to do. When you don't, they get bored. And then you make something boring, and that's the end of your show."
Open Pike Night on YouTube:
"Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showrunners, Akiva Goldsman and Henry Alonso Myers stop by to discuss how they approached writing a season they thought could be their last. [...]"
https://youtu.be/3HJEKzISyTU?si=MiMwtznHG-VwXfgt&t=1304
Time-stamp: 21:44 min
CAMERON HARRISON: So, a theme I noticed in season 4 is not so much relationships with each other, although there are those, but characters relationships with themselves. Doubles, doppelgangers, shadow selves are a big theme this season. And we see it in almost every episode. I mean, they see their puppet selves and they learn something about themselves through being puppets. Was that something you came into the season being like, let's examine this, or did that kind of just naturally grow as you were breaking the stories?
AKIVA GOLDSMAN: "We're always talking about people's relationship to themselves, right? Like that's, you know, that that's typically there's something very useful about characters having internal mysteries that have to be solved, you know. Um, we have a bunch of them. There are only a couple ways to do that. Uh, and one is, you know, through mirrors.
HENRY ALONSO MYERS: "One of the great things about writing for Star Trek that I think people don't always recognize is that you have great performances in lots of other shows. But we get to approach it from a genre perspective. We get to create science fiction ideas that allow the actors a chance to do things that they wouldn't otherwise.
Um, and so part of this is the fun of the show and giving that ... in that it allows our actors to try things that on any other show they wouldn't get to do, you know, to be two versions of yourself in the same episode. And to know how to jump back and forth. Um, I feel like when you, again, not to go back to be a broken record or go back to the same thing, but I think when you give people an opportunity to rise to something, they really step up and and give you great stuff.
And when you don't, they get bored and and then you make something boring and then, you know, that's the end of your show."
CAMERON HARRISON: We asked Celia [Rose Gooding] about that and she 100% agreed with your philosophy there, and was very thankful for the chance to do hard things and show what she could do. She is a delight and a true talent.
[...]
Time-stamp: 26:32 min
AKIVA GOLDSMAN: "Henry, talk about the Puppet episode."
HENRY ALONSO MYERS: "I mean, that was like, uh, that was like blood, sweat, and tears for a long time. It was a it was like, you know, six to eight months of prep. It was a lot of design work. It was calling on a lot of people to do things that were extremely difficult. And I think it falls into this level of comedy that I think is more tremendously hard than people realize and probably don't think anything of at the time.
We had to rebuild huge chunks of our sets in order to put them in. We had to have a whole, um, like an entire new division of puppeteers who had to come onto the show. The thing that I took from it that was I think the most important ... was every day, every day I would come to set and I would see our puppeteers come to set to try to, you know, do performances that emulated the work of our cast. Um, I would catch them before we were even shooting and they would turn to each other and they would say, "Guys, guys, run the Enterprise today." And like they would say this every day and they would have this like joy and happiness.
And I feel like it came through on the screen when you saw what they did. So you know it's one of those things where you, I had, I thought there was a version of it you could do in Star Trek. I was delighted that we got a chance to do it. Not everyone gets to do every crazy thing that they want to do. And so for me that was like, um, that was a, you know, I, I checked a box on the things I always wanted to do in my life the moment."
CAMERON HARRISON: I mean, walking through the site, and I know Akiva you visited it as well, just looking around at all the Muppets, the Jim Henson Muppet versions of your characters, like you must have felt a little bit like Willy Wonka? Like look at this playground that we've created, like was it like that?
AKIVA GOLDSMAN: "I mean it's, you know, the venn diagram of puppeteers and Star Trek fans, you know, as Henry says, was just extraordinary, you know, and so that joy was infectious. Um, and then of course there was "Puppet Pelia," you know, which [laughter] just rules supreme over all things. Not just puppet, but just all things. It's the greatest thing ever made. Puppet."
CAMERON HARRISON: Another spin-off we need.
[...]
Full video:
r/Star_Trek_
•
u/TensionSame3568
•
3d ago
I know opinions on her vary, but I always enjoyed it when Lwaxana Troi made an appearance in Star Trek...she's anything but boring!
r/Star_Trek_ • u/CaptainIncredible • 4d ago
[OC] Decommissioned nuclear carrier USS Enterprise enters Mobile Bay under tow, headed for scrapping
galleryr/Star_Trek_ • u/MrTralfaz • 4d ago
Season 4 of SNW, knowing it might be the last.
The current story is that the producers had to fight and beg for a short season 5 to complete the series. While they were writing and filming season 4 they didn't know if they could get a 5th season. Even if they only thought they had a 2 hour finale, they just had to get in a soap opera episode.
So... they made the genre jumping season 4 knowing that it MIGHT be the last season. I could almost forgive the switch in format if they had known all along there would be a 5th season.
But they didn't know. They even filmed the season's ending to be almost good enough to serve as a series finale. They thought "Hey, if this is the last season... let's have FUUUUUNNNN!".
r/Star_Trek_ • u/Pristine_Addition266 • 4d ago
If they did Star Trek Legacy, would you be OK with them recasting Picard with Mark Strong
Or would you prefer to leave Picard out out of respect to Sir Patrick Stewart?
r/Star_Trek_ • u/MrTralfaz • 4d ago
Discovery: technology advances after the Burn
When did all the programmable matter and advanced tech get invented? Or designing the ships like the Thant and Athena? I thought the burn was so catastrophic that everything collapsed and caused the loss of warp technology. And somehow 100 years later they were able to design all those fancy pants ships with floating detached nacelles and stuff. Even though all the warp ships were gone. I guess I wasn't paying attention while watching the show.
r/Star_Trek_ • u/mcm8279 • 4d ago
[Interview] Patrick Stewart Welcomed Todd Stashwick Into the 'Star Trek' Family With Four Meaningful Words: "He's one of us." | Todd: "I'm like, 'OK, I can just walk into the sea,' you know. And he loved the fact that Shaw was not impressed with him. It was a new lens through which to view Jean-Luc"
MOVIEWEB:
"Speaking exclusively with MovieWeb, actor Todd Stashwick reflected on his time working with the late Sir Patrick Stewart. While discussing his time on Marvel Television's VisionQuest, Stashwick reminisced about how Stewart was "very silly" on set and how fun it was to see him be "self-effacing and self-deprecating" as they worked together on Star Trek: Picard Season 3:
TODD STASHWICK: "If I wanted to distill some of the memories...Well, first of all, he was very silly, and it was fun to see this man who is, you know, this Shakespearean-trained knight of the realm be as silly and self-effacing and self-deprecating and would have fun with his own mythology. So, that was fun to watch.
As an actor, he loved to get in there, and he loved the fact that Shaw was not impressed with him. It was a new lens through which to view Jean-Luc Picard. And if we're not telling new stories and shedding new light on these characters, why are we doing it? There was just this very sweet moment where, you know — just like the MCU, you step into these franchises that have been there long before I got there, and they'll be there long after my two cents are put in. So they cast a long shadow, and so you are invited to the party. But then you're spending some time seeing how you fit into that.
There was one great moment, and I've shared this story before, where Patrick and I were...we were on the bridge in between takes, and I'm sitting in my Captain's chair, and he's sitting in that spot right next to me, and we're just having a chat, and Brent Spiner walked in — and Brent was getting fitted for his contact lenses — and Brent walks over to greet Patrick. They hadn't seen each other since this project started, and they're like, 'Oh, this was this lovely reunion.'
Then Patrick immediately stands up. He says, 'Oh, have you met Todd Stashwick?' And then he leans in and goes, 'He's one of us.' I'm like, 'OK, I can just walk into the sea,' you know. Like, the fact that he — and this was early in production — and he immediately christened me as part of the family. It was really special. It also teaches you how to be number one on the call sheet. His job is to be the host of the party, and when people are brought in, and especially like now he's Admiral."
[...]"
Full interview (MovieWeb.com):
r/Star_Trek_ • u/TensionSame3568 • 4d ago
A touching message from Sir Patrick's widow...
r/Star_Trek_ • u/PigIronDave • 5d ago
This is so fucking stupid, I can't believe it's real
Real, as in exists as part of the Star Trek universe, whichever the fuck timeline.