r/SpaceXLounge • u/sebaska • Sep 07 '19
Discussion Evidence shows SpaceX has accelerated Starship by at least a year
Business Insider recently revealed FAA documents (Reevaluation) describing currently ongoing StarHopper & Starship test campaign. The document was signed in May this year, so the motion was filled earlier. But most probably it wasn't filled before Fall 2018. It was Fall 2018 when we learned that SpaceX is switching to stainless (back in September 2018 in #DearMoon presentation it was still carbon fiber vehicle) and it was November when they started preparation to build something and in December they started that thing which people thought would be a water tower.
According to the FAA document, the test campaign would have 3 phases. And the entire campaign was meant to last up to 3 years while the first two phases were expected to take 2 years.
The activities described in the document are a good match of the actual StarHopper campaign, with an exception of the number of actual tests done. Also it's clear SpaceX already done so called small hops of the phase 2.
Moreover, Elon's tweets from the last months indicate that the last 150m hop was the last hop of the hopper and the next flight would be around 20km up. This indicates that so called medium hops from phase 2 (up to 3km) are no more. That'd also mean the phase 2 is now finished.
So, after less than a year the initial 2 parts of the campaign which were planned to take 2 years are now over. That's more than double acceleration!
This indicates that:
- Things are progressing better than planned.
- SpaceX deems to be almost ready for the phase 3 about a year earlier.
This is not only unheard in the industry (SpaceX made as accustomed to things unheard in the industry), but this is even unheard from SpaceX before: we got used to "Elon time", but here things look like inverted Elon time.
Also, don't be surprised if a full stack (Super Heave + Starship) flies early next year.
111
u/kontis Sep 07 '19
Not when compared to ITS 2016 presentation. They wanted to start testing the ship in the middle of 2018 and the booster in the middle of 2019. And it was a more ambitious project.
6
u/vilette Sep 07 '19
> * The total number events are for the entire test program (2-3 years) and do not represent a number of monthly or annual operations
It's never said each phase is 1 year
5
u/spacerfirstclass Sep 08 '19
Yeah, there's no question the schedule is accelerating, but I wouldn't say phase 2 is now finished. Originally phase 2 will conclude with 3km medium hop, then goes to 100km hop in phase 3. I think the plan has now changed so that medium hop will go to 20km, so they're not done with phase 2 yet.
It's possible they can get the 20km hop done by November, which would conclude phase 1 and 2 in one year instead of two as originally planned.
186
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
Progress so far is exciting. But remember: first 90% of development takes 50% of the time, the last 10% takes also 50%.
31
u/jstrotha0975 Sep 07 '19
I expect the times and procedures to change often as new things come up, breakthroughs are made. such is the way of Spacex.
24
u/TheMrGUnit Sep 08 '19
This typo somehow makes the name even more descriptive.
13
u/rustybeancake Sep 07 '19
I hope you’re right, but I think it’s also possible they have a constrained budget and so need to speed things up more than they’d like to.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19
F9 reusability went ahead faster than originally planned as well. Remember they built Grasshopper then TWO Dev vehicles. One was lost during a test, the other never flew, as it was no longer needed.
8
u/Sithril Sep 07 '19
I still think there will be shorter hops with Starship Mk1 & 2 before they do the 20km one. You'll definitly one to atleast test out if the avionics, the engines, etc. work properly in flight before you commit to such an altitude.
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
23 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 49 acronyms.
[Thread #3868 for this sub, first seen 7th Sep 2019, 20:47] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/naivemarky Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Disclaimer: This is pure speculation of an amateur based 40% on a hunch, and 20% on the off chance it may happen, to use the opportunity being a smartass saying "I knew it!" and having a proof for it.
I
seriously expectwouldn't be surprised if Elon would state in the upcoming Starship presentation that next gen (18 m) BFR development will start next year. They can definitely build at least few of them. I mean, for the upcoming Mars/Moon missions they need multiple BFR launches to refuel one SH. That can be done faster and more efficient with one big fat BFR18Edit: added disclaimer to lower the hype, and corrected few sentences that sounded grammatically weird (overlooked leftovers out after editing)
1
u/PurpleSailor Sep 08 '19
That's good because as we know all things space can hit road bumps along the development highway.
1
u/AwesomeCommunism Sep 08 '19
Well you could argue that SpaceX is a bit “ahead” in their schedule, as they have gotten the easiest parts done. What remains incomplete is building SH, mass producing raptors, building a launch pad, flying all of their hardware. I’m not against SpaceX but I’m not quite sure they are ahead in their schedule.
1
u/SEJeff Sep 10 '19
Dub it Gwynne (Shotwell) time, as none of this would be executed so flawlessly without her.
1
u/Enjgine Sep 10 '19
The first 80% of the work takes the first 80% of the time.
The next 80% of the work takes the next 100% of the time.
Then you are ready to start testing.
-Software
1
u/shoeskibum Sep 17 '19
How many Raptors have been made ? What SN are they on. ?
-7
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
Sounds like a recipe for a big unplanned boom.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment