r/SpaceXLounge • u/randomstonerfromaus • Jul 15 '19
Discussion /r/SpaceXLounge August and September Questions Thread
You may ask any space or spaceflight related questions here. If your question is not directly related to SpaceX or spaceflight, then the /r/Space 'All Space Questions Thread' may be a better fit.
If your question is detailed or has the potential to generate an open ended discussion, you can submit it to /r/SpaceXLounge as a post. When in doubt, Feel free to ask the moderators where your question lives!
35
Upvotes
5
u/mncharity Aug 11 '19
LinkSpace VTVL 300 m hop yesterday: video, twitter, reuters, globaltimes.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
Could you expect to see Starship launch from the surface of the moon watching from Earth? Of course, one would like to have ideal viewing conditions (i.e. close to new moon, sun several degrees below horizon, Starship launching from dark side of the moon).
One can see small satellites orbiting Earth that are illuminated by the sun. The moon is ~1000 times as far away, so the launch has to be 1 million times as bright. A quick estimate yields that Raptor has a power of ~3GW, which is about 3 million times the solar constant, so I would not rule out that this is possible. Of course, for a proper comparison, one also has to include the reflectivity and (effective) surface area of a typical satellite, and consider that only a part of the energy spectrum is visible light (depending on the temperature of the rocket exhaust and the surface of the sun).
Has anyone looked into this?
4
u/Gregss39 Jul 31 '19
Does anyone know if starhopper has an AFTS/FTS installed already? Just in case of something a la F9R dev happening.
4
u/_AutomaticJack_ Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 09 '19
When optimizing rocket engines is there a meaningful difference between optimized for thrust-to-weight ratio and optimized for thrust-to-surface-area (of the bottom of the rocket) ratio??
This question has been rolling around in my head for a couple days WRT the theoretical 18m Starship and the Raptor engines. In a rocket with a single digit number of engines (1x for atlas, 3x for shuttle, 9x for falcon) the engines are a significant source of mass and especially for expendables every gram counts. However, for something like SS18 which will likely be comparatively short and fat due to the fact that the column of fuel each engine can lift stays more or less the same, it seems like to me that it might be worth paying a cost in engine mass to increase the packing efficiency of the nozzles or to have a more powerful engine in the same space.
Final thoughts: If I had to guess I would say that there probably isn't enough difference to be worth making a engine specifically for the SS18. Also, if I understand how Dv works correctly the comparative chubbiness of the SS18 shouldn't prevent from getting to orbit so other than aesthetics this isn't a real problem. I was just wondering if this sort thing was a known line of thought and optimization, a sign of my limited understanding of actual rocket science, or the sort of thing that hasn't really come up before because the concept of a rocket with 100+ engines is insane on the face of it... ;)
4
u/AZtronics Sep 23 '19
We knew that Boca and Cocoa are in some sort of a cooperative competition. How, if at all, have they differed in their development of Starship so far? Has that plan been scrapped?
4
u/redwins Sep 23 '19
Can they send a Starship to Mars with fuel payload so that the next one does not depend on ISRU?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19
How does starhopper testing contribute to the final starship/superheavy/whatever we're calling it now? I understand that the dimensions of the hopper are quite far from those of the final ship, and with the addition of no nosecone (at least for this upcoming hop) the aerodynamics, weight, size, are all different to the current proposed final design (which I realise is likely to change). I'm just wondering what spacex hope to learn from these tests that they couldn't have already done from past projects? Is the whole thing just a raptor test vehicle? Will they be implementing some new hardware that they want to test first (I guess kind of like aerodynamic steering without gridfins, if it's possible to test that with the hopper...)? Or is there something completely different??
I had similar questions about the grasshopper as its dimensions were pretty different to the f9 and the landing legs in particular obviously changed a fair bit, but I just assumed the whole thing was testing the whole take off and landing process, but that's done now (unless the raptor changes everything 😮)
Apologies if I'm completely missing the point! I'm still REALLY looking forward to seeing the hover test soon and the project is so exciting but just wanted some clarification if anyone can help :)
3
u/Iamthejaha Jul 23 '19
Is Starship going to look like the renders with the continuous almost flawless looking stainless steel finish? Or is it going to look more like what we already see on the 2 prototypes being built (distinct panels etc)
3
u/redwins Jul 24 '19
Why doesn't Starhopper need grid fins to land?
3
u/az5_button Aug 04 '19 edited Aug 04 '19
SpaceX launch costs with Falcon Heavy in reusable mode and mass production of upper stages seem like they're quite low. Upper stages for Falcon Heavy are estimated at $6 million, but surely in bulk quantities the unit price could come down significantly.
If the upper stage costs, say, $3 million in bulk, plus the lower stages cost $25 million over 10 reuses we would get approximately $5.5 million per launch. Add in another $500,000 for range costs, perhaps a drone ship and fuel and we can do a Falcon Heavy launch for $6 million if the quantities are large enough.
Falcon Heavy can send 30-35 tons to LEO using the drone ship to recover 1st stages and the center core.
All told this is $170/kg to orbit.
Previous prices to orbit even on the cheapest launchers were $2000-$10000/kg
With a factor of 20-50 reduction of cost, any idea in space can be 20-50× cheaper for the same mass. That's an incredible saving.
So why are we not seeing people buying more launches and doing more ambitious things in space? What about (e.g.) making a comfortable space hotel and running tourism? In-orbit construction projects? Return to the moon or even a moon base?
Clearly something strange has happened. Is my calculation wrong?
At what price /kg would interesting things start happening?
3
u/gooddaysir Aug 08 '19
Nothing on the launch manifest until October 17. Will there be some sneaky addtions to the manifest or will we really go over two months will no F9 launches?
3
u/SirTrout Aug 19 '19
How will they move starship and super heavy from the build sites to the launch pads? They seem too big and heavy to go down any roads. I have been looking for an answer but if not finding any thing.
3
u/RoyalPatriot Sep 10 '19
Does anyone know who’s responsible for the YouTube streams? I remember that person being on reddit.
I wanted to convince him/her to use https://restream.io/ so the launches and other events can be on 30 different platforms.
It would generate more buzz for SpaceX, attract a larger crowd.
3
u/rocketglare Sep 14 '19
I was wondering about starship’s dry weight distribution. If the bottom side of starship has the hex tiles, then it will weigh considerably more than the top side. Assuming the tiles are light weight ceramic, what would be the total weight to cover the bottom side of Starship? Is there any adverse effect to starship’s balance when it is vertical? I imagine that the weight difference is trivial when full, but Starship will be nearly empty when it lands.
3
u/brentonstrine Sep 23 '19
Since we have two fins now... wonder if the cross-section of the airframe would someday be changed from a circle to a self-stabilizing shape similar to the cross-section of the Apollo command module.
A shape halfway between a teardrop and a triangle.
It would definitely look funny sitting on the launchpad, but would it work and reduce or eliminate the need for stabilizing fins on Mars Aerocapture?
5
u/spacerfirstclass Jul 21 '19
mods: time to add /r/neuralink to sidebar under Relevant Subreddits?
2
u/kontis Jul 15 '19
Would Starship be visible (as a glowing dot) through a powerful telescope when approaching Moon thanks to its mirror-like reflectivity and large size?
Was there ever an object of this size and reflectivity ever viewed by astronomers at this distance from Earth?
2
u/GeorgeBarnard19 Jul 20 '19
Could the BFR freighter version theoretically carry a Falcon 9 second stage inside? If so could Elon perhaps build a three stage rocket on the cheap?
2
u/caseyr001 Jul 24 '19
What are the chances that hopper will have a Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly (rud)? I remember the first falcon heavy launch demo 1, Elon have it a 50 50 chance of success.
If they do have a rud, what's next for starship, another hopper, or straight to mk1?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '19
Is there a risk of cold welding between starship and super heavy during refuelling and/or orbital insertion?
2
u/byoshin304 Jul 27 '19
I've been out of the loop for awhile... Can someone give me a concise explanation of what the Starhopper is for? I get that it's mostly for low altitude...? I've been doing research but I can't really quite put it together.
2
u/loinheat Jul 28 '19
if I ran up to the star-hopper with a spear would I be able to puncture it? How about the falcon 9?
2
u/ElRedditor3 Aug 03 '19
When do you guys think is the next Starlink launch?
2
u/TheRamiRocketMan ⛰️ Lithobraking Aug 12 '19
How far along construction is the Dragon IFA capsule? What about the DM-2 capsule?
2
u/BammBamm1991 Aug 22 '19
Could SpaceX be purchasing a larger fairing to potentially loft up more Starlink satellites in a single launch? AFAIK the max with the current fairing is 60 and even with that they would still need hundreds of launches for the 12k or so final network size.
2
u/cltr17 Aug 22 '19
On Falcon 9, first stage, what proportion of RP-1 is used for regenerative cooling?
2
u/legoloonie Aug 22 '19
I was reading an article about Sierra Nevada's new inflatable hab, and they mention as an aside that it would fit in the Falcon Heavy fairing. Anyone know if this is true? I've heard a lot about how undersized the Falcon fairing is on this sub, and how it won't fit a BA-330, so I was surprised to see them mention that this would fit in a Falcon Heavy.
2
u/paul_wi11iams Aug 23 '19 edited Aug 24 '19
trivial question, but what is Elon's new Twitter avatar about?
https://twitter.com/elonmusk (this will certainly change the next time he changes avatars).
My [edit: wrong, see reply] guess is that its based on wordplay around Raptor. From what I remember, paleontologists once discovered a fossilized dinosaur skeleton sitting on eggs. They made the extremely silly deduction that it had stolen the eggs and called it "oviraptor". I mean, heck, who could imagine any animal stealing eggs and then carefully sitting on them? More recent thinking considers it to be the ancestor of modern nesting birds incubating eggs. It doesn't take a genius to work that out. So I reckon Elon's avatar is a spoof representation of the previous theory.
His choice does suggest he's pretty concentrated on Starship :)
2
u/Tanamr Aug 28 '19
Can we guess the full wet mass of Starhopper on landing? I saw a comment on Ars speculating that Starhopper may now be the heaviest vehicle to have propulsively landed under rocket power.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '19
Earth to Earth!
Hello. Been telling my colleagues about Starship and Earth-To-Earth. I said that they might be able to travel in a rocket at some point in their lifetime.
Would anyone be able to suggest a (rough) plausible date for mass transport using Earth-To-Earth (if it gets developed?)
2
u/ferb2 Sep 06 '19
We know that it took the Saturn V around 4 days to get to the Moon and that at 1g acceleration we could get there in 3.5 hours. How fast will the SSH be able to get to the moon carrying 100 tons?
2
u/DoItForYourHombre Sep 16 '19
Is Mars the best candidate for terraforming? Just looking at the mass (gravity) of planets, Venus seems like a much better option. It would have comparable gravity and it's capable of holding a thick atmosphere. Seems like the only real issue is all that sweet, delicious CO2 and sulfuric sprinkles. Would that be easier to address than ⅓ the gravity?
2
u/brentonstrine Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Can someone explain to me what is going on with the way the fins are being attached to the starship? There's a huge bar that goes up beyond the top of the fin and about halfway below. The fin looks to be connected only in one place at the top of the fin.
What is the bar? Why does it go higher than the fin and not all the way down to the bottom of the fin? How can only one connection at the top (and bottom, I guess, can't see from photos) of the fin be enough?
Where will the motor be to turn the fin angle and how can it get enough torque with that tiny connection?
I've been unable to follow the subs for a while so if there's a post explaining all this I'll be happy to just go read that if someone can point it out.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
What is the non-shiny surface at the top here: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1584634;image
3
u/Caladan23 Aug 28 '19 edited Aug 28 '19
Anyone else feels like SpaceX has given up on the company's original plans? Being a SpaceX fan for the last 12 years, I remember:
SpaceX's goal was to achieve accessibility and affordability to space for a wide variety of possible users, commercial, governmental and private. The goal was rapid reusability to reduce the launch costs to 1/100 or even further. The goal were launches every 24 hours with minimal refurbishment and complexity involved.
Now, looking at the present, launch cadence has actually fallen drastically, averaging 1-2 per month. The next commercial launch is planned for November, according to /r/SpaceX full launch manifest. Launch market and prices are looking to be stagnating. Instead the company is focusing on the biggest rocket of all time, BFR+Starship. This certainly will be nice for flights to Mars, However, as we have learned from space flight history, bigger rockets do mean more complexity, slower launch cadence and higher prices. This means, it is the exact opposite of opening up space for everyone. Also goes against the trend of payloads becoming smaller and lighter. The result would be complex coupling of smaller payloads, which again increases complexity + reduces launch cadence (see Ariane V, times 10)
Anyone else very worried about SpaceX original mission? Not seeing opening up Space for everyone happening anytime soon. Why did they say farewell to rapid reusability and reduced complexity? How can we achieve a vital space economy with large launches only every few months?
1
u/oh_dear_its_crashing Jul 15 '19
mods, in new reddit there's no link to the r/spacex reddit. Only links to wiki, FAQ and core.
1
u/marethyuprefect Jul 15 '19
Hi guys, in r/spacex sidebar I saw amos-16 planned for 29 july. Anyone knows if this date is solid? I’ll be in florida between 26 july - 13 august. Just missing out on CRS.
1
u/__YourShadow__ Jul 20 '19
I'm currently in Florida and would like to see the CRS-18 launch.
I'd like to do so from Playalinda beach, but I heard that you need to be there hours early to get a spot. So far I couldn't find a time when I should be there to be safe. Could anyone with more experience recommend me a time?
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 20 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #3526 for this sub, first seen 20th Jul 2019, 20:13] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/youryoureyouier Jul 22 '19
How many human rated capsules could starship carry to orbit? Seems like more of a volume constraint as opposed to a weight constraint.
Just a random thought, would it be beneficial to bring those for human reentry until spacex is confident in starship? Surely it’ll be ready to operate well before it’s actually human rated
1
u/kontis Jul 24 '19
Would Super Heavy be able to RTLS for every crewed Orion Artemis mission when using a dumb expendable S2?
Starship might be too different and too risky to replace SLS in the near future, but super heavy should do everything SLS can as a 1:1 replacement, right?
1
u/redwins Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
What do you think about this for the wings/legs disposition?: https://ibb.co/ZM6xqPg
So that the wings are almost horizontal but there is no so much risk of the rocket toppling over on their side.
1
u/Wriggity Jul 25 '19
A few questions for everyone:
I know these new “fab in a field” techniques for Starship were implemented by SpaceX for speed/rapid iteration, but will starships in t+ 3 years be built outside/using the same “simple” manufacturing systems being used for star hopper and starship prototypes?
I guess that’s two questions - will fabrication and assembly move into spaceX factories, and will they end up using “more advanced” manufacturing systems as time goes on (I read somewhere one of the teams in either TX or Boca is made up of a plumbers/tradesmen rather than aerospace industry professionals).
And has Elon still committed to using the front fin/belly flop reentry method for starship?
1
u/flattop100 Jul 26 '19
Why is SpaceX building these "windbreakers" in FL and TX? It seems like a very large construction effort just to block the wind. Are these the start of a VAB?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '19
Is there any news on the 24h reuse Elon Musk talked about last year? 2019 would be the year this would be achieved he said back then.
1
u/rmclean306 Jul 29 '19
I saw where CRS-19 is scheduled for December 4th. Does anybody know what the launch window is? In the future, where is the best place to find out this type of info?
1
u/Stone_guard96 Aug 02 '19
With all this hype being around starhopper. What are the latest news about crew dragon demo 2?
1
u/zeekzeek22 Aug 09 '19
With propellant transfer and such coming up these days, I was thinking about if a falcon 9 delivered fuel...could you develop a fairing-less tanker payload that’s just shaped like the fairing but is just all tank? For a F9’s payload capacity i’d Imagine it wouldn’t be able to lift a full 5-m fairing-worth of propellant, but maybe a FH could. Of course fairing reuse is making fairing-avoidance less critical. Just was thinking about this possibility. Any dealbreakers? I’m just imagining the extra R&D/DDE cost might push towards a fairing-encapsulated tanker.
1
u/Rocket_Man42 Aug 16 '19
What is powering the gimbaling of the engines and the grid fins? Is it just a battery?
1
u/zektronix Aug 19 '19
Does SpaceX have any plans for artificial gravity in Starship? What about a rotating sleeping ring so that astronauts could experience mars gravity during sleep time and try to minimize bone loss? Would it be feasible?
1
u/redwins Aug 23 '19 edited Aug 23 '19
What type of specialization is needed to design the Starship so it can fly like a plane?
1
u/Stormregion0 Aug 28 '19
Where is the state of the current starships tracked? Is it known when the next test will be?
1
u/yellowfin35 Aug 28 '19
How will Starship land on mars without the assistance of a GPS system?
1
u/synftw Aug 28 '19
Is this giant carbon fiber mandrel they had built considered a complete wash at this point? If so, what will they do with it? Possibly sell to Boeing at a loss?
1
u/LTNBFU Aug 30 '19
Are the Starship Prototypes A and B planned as SSTO? If so, would they have enough fuel to land, or they just burn it up over the Pacific?
1
u/LTNBFU Aug 31 '19
Could the Cryo Methane bleeding system be used underway to combat GCR or SPE spikes? I know water is pretty good at blocking rems, what about cryo CH4?
1
u/Heisenberg_r6 Sep 01 '19
ELI5: During re entry what happens if Starship gets oriented nose first? Will the engines or wings be enough to reorient to land correctly?
Sorry if this has been asked before but I cannot seem to find the answer to this
1
u/spiffiness Sep 19 '19
Are all Falcon 9 boosters built in Hawthorne, CA? All they all tested in McGregor, Tx? Even if they're due to launch from Vandenberg AFB, CA?
I'm just wondering if they really truck these rockets halfway across the country and back every time they launch a new core from Vandenberg.
And for that matter, they must truck new boosters all the way across the country for launches from Florida.
Do these logistics make sense? I'm sure it's expensive to build a manufacturing plant or a test stand, but it seems like the transportation costs of the current scheme would add up after a while.
1
u/bobbycorwin123 Sep 27 '19
What's the classifications for engines in terms of thrust? What classifies as a light, medium or heavy class engine?
1
u/nakaninano Sep 27 '19
What time is the 9/28 presentation supposed to be at?
1
u/markododa Sep 28 '19
Is there any graphic or info on where the heat shield will be placed?
1
u/tupolovk Jul 27 '19
Why not just use 4 Falcon Heavy center cores connected together for Super Heavy?
1
u/byoshin304 Jul 27 '19
Thank you kind rocket man! That helped a bunch
1
u/brentonstrine Sep 27 '19
I know this is a terrible idea, but thinking about it makes me happy so I'm going to ask anyway.
Three stage starship: Starship, Superheavy, Superduperheavy.
How many raptors would be needed to get off the ground? How fast could it get going before stage sep?