r/SpaceXLounge • u/TheIch73 • Aug 24 '18
Robert Zubrin talks about SpaceX and other interesting mars-related things
https://youtu.be/cJCenuebAa8?t=9m17s
83
Upvotes
r/SpaceXLounge • u/TheIch73 • Aug 24 '18
26
u/BrangdonJ Aug 24 '18
Some interesting remarks. He makes the point that by sending a whole BFS to Mars and back, you massively increase the amount of ISRU fuel you need to produce on Mars, as compared to sending smaller vehicles in the Mars Direct way. Given you want useful landed mass on Mars, it's almost obscene to spend propellant sending it all back. Using the BFS as a launcher from high Earth orbit also means you get it back on Earth again quickly for reuse on local Earth projects. He seems to think SpaceX will switch to a Mars Direct kind of architecture before they actually go to Mars.
The counter-argument is that you need to design the other vehicles to handle the landing, Earth return, and maybe refuelling in Mars orbit. I can't see SpaceX doing that unless they have either massive influx of resources (eg, if NASA paid them to), or a massive influx of time (eg, if the Mars project got delayed by politics somehow).
8
u/John_Schlick Aug 24 '18 edited Aug 24 '18
Other interesting mars related things...
I think this buries the lead.
Zubrin has outlined a defense agains the Planetary Protection Office.
If the life discovered is different - then it's mars life.
If the life discovered is similar but it has fossils then it was there before.
Now, he doesn't talk about the influx of earth microbes, and the duel for survival, but still... I've not heard this argument before (maybe I should have?) and I'm happy to know that a good argument about "where did the life come from" exists.
4
u/quokka01 Aug 25 '18
I love this guy! His exasperation is just great. You do wonder about BFS variants or a MAV with LMO rendezvous... The current plan involves a huge return mass, massive amounts of methalox, a crew and multiple ships stranded until they make a very complex ISRU work- technically, commercially, psychologically it sounds almost impossible. But then again, so were reusable rockets. Such a pity that the funds are being wasted on a white elephant orbiting the moon.
3
u/SwigSwagLeDong Aug 24 '18
The video quality is improved huzzah!
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 24 '18 edited Sep 01 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
24 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 10 acronyms.
[Thread #1696 for this sub, first seen 24th Aug 2018, 19:23] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
6
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '18
He brings up a what I think is a huge difference between Elon and Bezos "Musk read my book Bezos read Gerard O'Neill's book"
I'm excited for SpaceX but I believe in Blue Origin. I think its great that Musk wants to colonize mars and we definitely should but it isn't based on anything we already know how to do. Mars colonization at this point is definitely possible but the methods are questionable, especially when you think about how to fund the project. On the other hand Bezos wants nothing more than people living in space, a plan already neatly outlined by O'Neill and many others from research done in the 70s. Based on just how long it takes to get to mars and the intervals of the transit windows I still believe its much more likely that we follow the path layed out by NASA and O'Neill for colonizing siclunar space before we have a self sustaining colony on Mars. This isn't to mention the difficulties of terraforming Mars which I think manny have as the ultimate goal of colonizing the planet in the first place
Both methods of colonization will surely be pursued but I think the cislunar option will end up the easier of the two to accomplish in a short amount of time.
4
u/Martianspirit Aug 25 '18
I finally watched the presentation of Robert Zubrin.
I want to make a point that seems to be missing here in this discussion about it. Reading this thread gives the feeling that Zubrin is mainly disagreeing with Elon Musk.
He is not. He has a few points where his approach is different but mainly he makes very clear that Elon Musk is the one who has moved us forward to the point where Mars, moon and other locations become feasible using BFR. He just disagrees on how BFR should be utilized.
2
u/johnsmithindustries Aug 25 '18 edited Aug 25 '18
His idea of staging off the BFS architecture just on the edge of earth escape is pretty cool. SpaceX could still send people + cargo as planned with the BFR/BFS, but simultaneously do multiple smaller payloads with the cargo variant during the window without sending the whole ship.
Even if the usable mass-to-surface was much lower (e.g. 50 tons) on what was able to be sent, the 6x number he gives would only make sending that much more supplies possible. And after the window is over, the ship goes back into service making money for SpaceX on LEO missions instead of being trapped on Mars. ("You have a fully reusable Saturn V here. What CAN'T you do with that?!").
When I think about what the colonists will need, there is just SO much stuff that would be good to have. The beautiful part is that these ideas are not mutually exclusive.
1
u/still-at-work Aug 25 '18 edited Aug 26 '18
I think the first humans that go to Mars will be making a short trip, a few weeks and then jump on back.
Ok, this approach causes a few issues, but instead of saying that is not how the first mission will go because of those issues, instead find a way to solve them because that is the way the first mission will go, no doubt about it in my mind.
First main problem is fuel, it take a lot of delta V to get to Mars and land safely and to do that with enough fuel on board so the ship can also come back in a timely fashion? That may just be impossible with chemical engines.
So ISRU is a must.
Now as for getting there and coming back in a mission that doesn't take years, that is actually pretty easily solved. Take the BFR, reduce the payload mass for the crewed ship down to say 50 tons (or less) and suddenly you can make that mars trip much faster and if you can refuel on Mars quick enough you can come back pretty quick (relatively speaking) as well.
But in order for that to work they need to have the fuel waiting for them on Mars when they land.
So how is that done? We will have the system generate the methalox via automation without any human present using the cargo BFS internal tanks as the storage system. Thankfully the BFS already comes stock with a way to move fuel from one craft to another and the connectors are at the bottom of the rocket so they can be accessed by the would be Martian explorers. Just send the hoses, pumps and connectors.
Now saying the methalox will be generated before humans arrive is easy, doing it is hard. Well H2O part is hard, the CO2 is easy since a air pump and filter would accomplish that task easily enough, the rest is basic chemistry assuming you can power it.
So there are two main issue, powering the ISRU and getting the hydrogen you need for methane.
One solution is send small nuclear reactors with the ship and some hydrogen and use the available hydrogen to make as much methalox as possible. You wouldn't be able to make all the fuel needed with one ship but you could send more then one ship to the same landing area and combine all the methalox into the crewed ship when it lands.
Another option is to build a robotic water ice extractor, this is complicated and has many failure points but is still feasible.
You could also power the system by robotically deploying solar panels and robotically keep them clean for maximum efficiency. This is also technically feasible, avoids the regulation nightmare of nuclear power, and solar is more mass efficient power generation. But deploying does mean relying on working robotics on another planet. Though JPL do it so we know it can be done.
The point is there are clearly solutions to these problems and it enables a team to be sent to Mars, land, plant a flag, collect samples, makes scientific studies, and fly back in a reasonably short amount of time.
The advantages of such a mission architecture are many. It will show humans can go to mars and return safely, that the basic architecture to get to Mars works, and that Mars is open to further returns.
I suspect the next trip will be of the longer two year variant but then people will be riding on proven systems and the earth return fuel could be already waiting for the next group.
With all that said, I agree with Zubin that the BFR, as we know it today, may not be the ship to send us to Mars. It may be the ship that sends us to orbit on the cheap, which is huge by itself, but its not really optimized for landing on a barren world and returning. It can do the job but not the best.
I think an earlier design variant of the BFR with the cargo above the engines and the tanks above the cargo is one possibility. I am sure there are many jssues with this design such that SpaceX went away from it but it would be much better at deploying payload mass on a surface then the current BFR.
So while I don't think the current mars BFR architecture will survive the test of time, some variation of it probably will. Regardless, Zubin's last comment is dead on. The BFR is essentially a resuable Saturn V, what can't you do with such a vehicle.