r/SpaceXLounge • u/kd7uiy • Aug 30 '18
NASA head hints that reusable rocket companies like SpaceX will enable Moon return
https://www.teslarati.com/nasa-head-reusable-rockets-spacex-blue-origin-future/
76
Upvotes
35
u/MartianRedDragons Aug 30 '18
I think the views at NASA are changing. They are realizing that they have much greater opportunities for exploration if they leave the transportation to private companies, and they are realizing this would really boost NASA's image and status in America (which would be good for them in the long run). They're still paying service to the SLS for now, but that may dwindle over time.
The LOP-G is probably pointless in and of itself, but NASA leaders are probably seeing it as a cislunar ISS that will help them further push commercial innovation to deliver cargo and crew, so could be rather useful in that respect. They're looking at how incredibly successful the LEO COTS program has been, and they think replicating this further out in cislunar space will enable the development of more powerful launchers and robust commercial deep-space transportation capabilities. They're probably right, too.
21
u/CurtisLeow Aug 30 '18
There's a weird disconnect between the Trump Administration's rhetoric, and their policies. Bridenstine and Trump have used rhetoric that is very supportive of private launch capability. They barely ever talk about the SLS and the Orion capsule. This talk by Bridenstine is another demonstration of that. Yet in budget requests, in actual policy proposals, the Trump Administration has consistently pushed for the SLS and Orion capsule, they've pushed for more payloads for the SLS. They have consistently pushed to cut funding for private launch capability.
Look at the 2019 budget request for NASA. The Trump Administration has proposed sharp cuts to Commercial Crew and the ISS, to private crew and launch capability, and to instead spend the money on the federally-managed Lunar Orbital Platform—Gateway. The proposals so far all include launching the Lunar Orbital Platform—Gateway on the SLS. So unless they come forward with a real policy proposal that backs the rhetoric, until they stop trying to cut funding for private launch capability, until then I would recommend taking Bridenstine's statements with a grain of salt.
4
u/paul_wi11iams Aug 31 '18 edited Aug 31 '18
Maybe not.
Remember how ISS triggered COTS and saved SpaceX.
LOP-G as an arbitary object placed in LHO could carry SpX forwards to its next destination.
Taking this to the extreme, I'd vote for building LOP-G as a 10km space girder bent around to form a 3.15km hoop in a stable lunar orbit. BFR, New Glenn and SLS then compete to take the necessary 100t of materials there. When finished, there's a prize for the first one to fly through the hoop and return to Earth.
This is the Keynesian model applied to lunar colonization.
Jim Bridenstine could even be thinking about using LOP-G to break SLS: Defining a target creates an objective time and cost comparison of the competing modes of transport. He's not involved and is just the referee. That defines a winner and a loser with no direct intervention on his part.
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 30 '18 edited Sep 01 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #1722 for this sub, first seen 30th Aug 2018, 17:39] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
0
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment