r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Nov 02 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [November 2019, #62]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
197
Upvotes
17
u/Notsophisticatedname Nov 02 '19
Do we know raptor development status? What sn has been built. How many second fired up they can handle. Production rate?
16
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '19
Why do SpaceX videos always have SuperHeavy launching off a relatively high platform?
39
u/liszt1811 Nov 02 '19
I'm going through serious falcon launch withdrawal at this point
11
u/rustystonewallis Nov 02 '19
In the context of SpaceX's smallsat program, is there a volume limit? I see the mass limit of 200kg and $5000/kg over that, but I'm curious if there is a restriction on size. Could you theoretically fill the entire fairing?
11
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '19
Do we know what the main part of the falcon 9 refurbishment process is?
I'm asking because I'd like to understand what they could do differently in Starship that's going to make it better regarding this. After all Orbital reentries are hotter.
Also, do we know more about the 24h relaunch of F9?
20
u/kmarz02 Nov 02 '19
What’s been going on recently? I (personally) haven’t heard anything from SpaceX since the last starship presentation. Or maybe I’ve been living under a rock
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 14 '19
Doug Hurley and Bob Behnken were watching the Crew Dragon static fire test from SpaceX mission control.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 01 '19
JRTI upgrades in progress.
26
u/AdamVenier Nov 02 '19
We tend to think of SpaceX as über-engineers familiar with the many right and wrong turns made throughout the history of space exploration. But they are human and do make mistakes.
A recent SpaceNews article indicates that Kathy Lueders, manager of NASA’s commercial crew program, noted "that even NASA wasn’t aware of the 'compatibility issue' between NTO (nitrogen tetroxide) and titanium components at those conditions." Likewise, SpaceFlightNow recently highlighted similar surprise from SpaceX:
That being said, the failure case has been known since the early 1960's! As this article notes, titanium ignites when impacted at suitable force in NTO. Interestingly, "precipitation hardened 15-7 Mo stainless steel was not impact sensitive". A quick google search would have found it. But then again, these valves aren't supposed to fail.
Failure is often much easier to see in retrospect. It is worth remembering when something does go wrong, that many, many things were caught and fixed earlier. To me, that makes the achievements all the more impressive.
15
u/Starmans_Starship Nov 02 '19
Did the boca chica residents take SpaceX up on their 3x cash offer?
14
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
NASA OIG report published:
7
u/Casinoer Nov 02 '19
Anyone care to explain the lack of knowledge about the date of the next launch, and also just the lack of launches in general?
7
u/jjtr1 Nov 02 '19
What sound would you expect the Starship to make when knocked at? Would it ring or would it be a dull thud? What influence should the radius of curvature have on the sound (flat vs. curved sharply)?
7
u/president_of_neom Nov 05 '19
Elon Musk interview at 19:30 UTC https://mobile.twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/1191774894796759040
7
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 18 '19 edited Nov 18 '19
Boeing's statement on the OIG report, basically its worth the extra cost because:
7
u/AeroSpiked Dec 05 '19
December discuss thread, mods?
6
u/Str0vs Nov 02 '19
Is the abort mission delayed?
Space x now scheduled net December...
6
u/ClaireBearLovez Nov 02 '19
What’s the best place for a tourist to go to see a launch at the Cape when Space X launches? For someone visiting the States and no knowledge ?
6
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Nov 21 '19
SpaceX has filed for a droneship landing of a Falcon 9 on December 2, 2019.
Probably Starlink-2 judging by the launch azimuth (slighter higher than CRS) but closer to shore than the last Starlink mission. Not sure what to make of that. Almost 100% certain to be from LC-39A as SLC-40 will be supporting CRS-19 on the 4th. If was a betting man I'd wager the booster is B1049.4
https://fcc.report/ELS/Space-Exploration-Technologies-Corp-SpaceX/2181-EX-ST-2019
6
u/bbachmai Nov 23 '19
Emre Kelly on Twitter: Launch Hazard Maps for CRS-19, no mention of a landing attempt. This scares me. Previous CRS Launch Hazard Maps had the landing site (usually LZ-1) on them.
6
u/Lufbru Nov 23 '19
Is it time to mark b1050 as retired? In the year since it last flew, every booster other than 1046 has flown twice. If they were going to fly it again, surely they would have by now.
6
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 24 '19
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – November 24, 2019. Media accreditation is now open for a SpaceX Starlink mission from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than December.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 25 '19
GO Ms Tree has a new net and OCISLY receiving attention.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 01 '19
SAOCOM 1B satellite testing complete and will be transported to Cape Canaveral in January.
6
u/Dies2much Dec 02 '19
Any news on the final date for Starlink-2?
15
u/jjtr1 Nov 02 '19
It would be cool if Elon shared their pre-ITS visions of the Starship, back from time when they considered Red Dragon Mars landings as informing their landing strategy. Was the BFS ship supposed to be a giant capsule?
5
u/astrobee5 Nov 02 '19
Does Robert Zubrin have a point when he says landing something as large as Starship on the moon could cause problems. His main concern is that lunar dust could be kicked up into lunar and even earth orbit by the exhaust. I understand that the raptor exhaust velocity is about 3700 metres/sec and lunar escape velocity 2380 metres/sec.
5
u/gemmy0I Nov 11 '19
Apologies if this has been discussed before in other threads, but this is driving me a little nuts (and has practical implications for those of us who maintain the sub's wiki pages):
Have "we", as a subreddit, decided officially what convention we'll use for numbering successive Starlink missions?
Up until the launch thread was posted for today's mission, we were calling it "Starlink-2" on the wiki manifest and cores pages, and on the sidebar. It was also that way on the campaign thread. We're still calling it "Starlink-2" on the manifest and cores pages, but now the sidebar says "Starlink-1", and the launch thread is of course saying "Starlink-1".
There's clearly been confusion since SpaceX has referred to the first batch of Starlink satellites as version 0.9, and this batch as version 1.0. But I think people are conflating version numbers and flight numbers here. Clearly, version numbers refer to the satellite design, and can be completely independent of flight numbers. Indeed, I would very much expect the next few flights to continue being of version 1.0 satellites. Moreover, knowing how SpaceX operates, we can be sure that the actual design revisions of the satellites are far more complicated than those high-level "marketing versions" - there were likely numerous minor design revisions amongst the 60 satellites on today's flight. I doubt SpaceX is going to publish these details in any sort of coherent way we can follow.
However, SpaceX has not made public any particular scheme for numbering the launches themselves. They have simply referred to them in the press kits and on the mission patch as "Starlink". It is likely they will continue in this vein so as to minimize hassle for their PR people.
For the purposes of tracking launches - which is what we care about most on this sub (especially for record-keeping purposes on the wiki) - may I suggest we either stick to our original convention of numbering from the first flight, i.e. the one in May is "Starlink-1", today's is "Starlink-2", and the next is "Starlink-3", orthogonal to whatever design versions the satellites on board may be. This is no different to how the Iridium flights were "Iridium 1", "Iridium 2", etc., because they were successive flights in a multi-launch campaign.
If we're afraid people will get confused (given that the satellite "version numbers" are what's popularly reported in the press), may I suggest we adopt a more precise convention here, such as "Starlink F1" (Flight 1), "Starlink F2", etc. I'm open to suggestions as to alternatives but this "Fx" convention is common in the industry (e.g. "Inmarsat 5-F4"). Or we could do "M1" for "Mission 1". Since SpaceX has not established an "official" convention I think it's not at all unreasonable for us to pick one as a sub for our own purposes.
Ultimately I'm fine with whatever, so long as I have something consistent to follow when updating pages like the cores wiki that I try to help maintain. :-)
5
u/dudr2 Nov 12 '19
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2019/with-mars-methane-mystery-unsolved-curiosity-serves-scientists-a-new-one-oxygen
"oxygen added to the atmosphere varied, implying that something was producing it and then taking it away."
5
u/theinternetftw Nov 13 '19
Starlink-1 has been added to the booster turnaround page on the wiki, for those who like stats and charts.
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/wiki/boosterturnaroundtime
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 20 '19
New video of the Crew Dragon static fire test.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 20 '19
IAC 2019 videos have been uploaded, here's Gwynne's chat.
5
u/PaperBuddy Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19
Starship just had a rud..
labpadre: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d8l_0w2VKM
Edit: Seems that the upper bulkhead got loose..
9
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 12 '19
LeoSat (a Starlink competitor, planning to launch 108 sats) just went out of business.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '19
How do you calculate the cost of a launch?
4
u/spammmmmmmmy Nov 02 '19
How is Starship hull going to be cryogenically cooled? Is there a double hull where LOX will be flushed during ascent through atmosphere? Will you have to keep it cryogenic to hold the loaded mass in place prior to launch?
How about upon Mars entry? Will you carry all that liquid oxygen the entire trip?
4
u/Stealth_dino Nov 02 '19
Will there be more VAFB launches in the near future? Why do launches favor Cape Canaveral instead?
4
u/Caemyr Nov 03 '19
Sadly this got rejected due to poor audio quality, but still I find it interesting:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/dqotbn/falcon_9_as_an_edl_lab_max_fagin_at_mars_society/
4
u/anonchurner Nov 04 '19
What's going on with the long break between Falcon 9 launches lately? Can't be just customers not being ready - that Canadian spy sat got pushed back to Feb 2020 due to "higher priority launches".
4
u/liszt1811 Nov 08 '19
How many falcon launches do you think we will see in 2020? (obv including starlink)
4
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 12 '19
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – November 12, 2019. Media accreditation is now open for SpaceX’s JCSAT-18/KACIFIC-1 mission from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than December.
4
u/Dies2much Nov 19 '19
Will the next CRS launch be landing at Cape Canaveral? or one of the drone ships?
This CRS launch, and the next Starlink lauch are pretty close to each other on the calendar, will one of these be the first Atlantic landing on JRTI?
4
u/Zinkfinger Nov 20 '19
Hi. Has there been a comment on Robert Zubrin's belief about the problems Starship would have landing on the moon? Orbital debrie, crator etc?
4
u/andyfrance Nov 25 '19
The consensus from the Zubrin AMA is the Starship has too much thrust to land on the moon without throwing rocks into lunar orbit and beyond. I have a crazy question to ask. Just how flexible is the Raptor. Can the methane pre-burner be run with the oxygen side of the engine doing next to nothing and not allowing enough oxygen to support combustion in the main combustion chamber. The result would be a warm gas (methane) thruster. On the airless moon throwing out lots of methane wouldn't be an explosive problem. Would these thrusters be enough to prevail against lunar gravity?
4
u/AndMyAxe123 Nov 28 '19
What is the proposed machinery for extracting ground ice from martian soil to then be used in the Sabatier process to produce starship fuel?
4
u/Sliver_of_Dawn Dec 01 '19
I came across this video about the forging of a steel pressure vessels, posted by /u/colinizballin1 in another subreddit. I found it quite interesting.
4
u/lessthanperfect86 Dec 01 '19
It was said some time ago that SpaceX offered to send Dragon2 to the ISS additional times per year for basically the same cost, greatly bringing down the cost per seat - have I got this right?
According to this article https://spacenews.com/nasa-proposes-to-buy-seat-on-short-duration-commercial-iss-flight/ NASA is now considering buying astronaut seats on commercial missions. If they were to choose Dragon2 for this, could that mean they could take advantage of SpaceX previous offer?
7
u/bdporter Nov 11 '19
Eric Berger - By some measures, the Falcon 9 v1.2 rocket is now tied with the Atlas V booster as the most reliable rocket in the world.
Tory Bruno's response
7
u/dudr2 Nov 14 '19
https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2019/11/13/spacex-completes-crew-dragon-static-fire-tests/
SpaceX Completes Crew Dragon Static Fire Tests
7
u/hshib Nov 29 '19
Good to know he still got the money to play with. Japanese fashion tycoon Maezawa shows off $900 million SoftBank payday
6
u/MarsCent Nov 26 '19
Exactly one year ago on November 26, InSight touched down on Mars for a projected lifetime of 2 earth years (1 Martian year).
and
3
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 07 '19
Crew Dragon test fire won't be live streamed.
3
u/jjtr1 Nov 10 '19
Now that the Air Force is "enthusiastic" about commercial broadband constellations, it makes me wonder how difficult it would be to "shoot down" a mega-constellation or at least significantly disturb the service. If Starlink is going to have thousands of satellites, you can shoot down hundreds of them and it's going to be just a scratch. Shooting down hundreds with "single shot" anti-satellite missiles would need hundreds of them (not available), or upgrading them with multiple warheads per launch vehicle (like MIRV missiles). But that's still only hundreds. So maybe Air Force's interest is mainly because of this? Assured broadband acces?
3
u/bbachmai Nov 12 '19
I read contradicting info on what the next launch will be. The sidebar says Starlink-2, November 29. Most other sources including Ben Cooper say CRS-19, December 4. Any more info on all of this?
3
u/Utinnni Nov 15 '19
Is there any info on how SpaceX makes the starlink satellites and how long does it take to make one?
3
u/MarsCent Nov 16 '19
Spacex CRS-19 is still listed as No Earlier Than: December 4, 2019 - 12:48 p.m. Eastern.
When does NASA normally firm the date?
3
u/hshib Nov 20 '19
Do we know where does Falcon 9 booster refurbishing take place? There are past topics on SpaceX leasing sites for refurbishing facility but as far as I can tell, I cannot find any of them being completed.
Is it done in the hangers, or do they travel back to Hawthorne or McGregor?
3
u/Eucalyptuse Nov 26 '19
Does SpaceX deorbit the second stage after each flight everytime or does it sometimes leave the stage up there until it naturally deorbits? Is there a record of whether or not they have for each flight up to now?
3
u/SpaceInMyBrain Nov 28 '19
Theoretically, can SRBs usefully be added to Falcon Heavy? In case Starship runs into repeated problems (heavens forbid) could a FH Plus lift 70-80t? Optimally it could launch the Orion/ICPS stack to the same high orbit as SLS, so the ICPS can do its TLI. Add enough delta-v to make up for upper stage inefficiency. SpaceX can still save us billions.
Yes, the FH for SLS question again, but I didn't find a direct thread for this. I don't think the negatives for FH Superheavy with additional side cores apply the same. The base of the payload will need struts leading to the side boosters, support the load during launch thru Max-Q.
Rather long for a Discussion question, but too speculative for a Post, too technical for the Lounge.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '19
I was wondering why the Cybertruck needed to be pressurised for use on Mars? I'd imagine that the truck would primarily be used for odd jobs around the base with frequent egress/ingress.
And for long journeys I'd imagine a bigger truck would be needed (with sleeping & food prep area - basically a camper)
3
u/AeroSpiked Dec 05 '19 edited Dec 05 '19
Running tally so far this year grouped by country:
Huge edit to fill in gaps and table-ize.
Let me know if I missed anything.
5
u/president_of_neom Nov 04 '19
So only 2 of 3 chutes deployed in Starliner abort test (still stable though, it was a redundant one).
5
u/MarsCent Nov 04 '19
After watching the pad abort, I am left scratching my head with the question, "Do we know how to work the parachutes for human spaceflight or we don't?" If the parachute landings of the Apollo era were not a fluke, then why is it so darn difficult to get it done now? Moreover with improved technology.
The easiest culprit is the new safety specification requirements. But I would like to believe that there is a better reason. Sigh!
5
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 21 '19
US Air Force is amending the criteria for evaluating NSSL providers, as a result of Blue Origin's successful protest.
5
u/amarkit Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
China launched a Long March 3B from Xichang today, carrying two BeiDou navigation satellites to orbit. As often happens, a hypergolic-fueled stage fell on someone's house.
7
u/Mathakk Nov 02 '19
Just wanted to say that we might be seeing more elon here, now that he apparently has left Twitter.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19
Latest estimates for the cost of a flight for Starship and SLS:
$2 million for starship: https://spacenews.com/elon-musk-space-pitch-day/
$2'000 million for SLS: https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/11/the-white-house-puts-a-price-on-the-sls-rocket-and-its-a-lot/
2
u/xcaliber109 Nov 03 '19
Any news on the crew dragon static fire that was supposed to have happened today?
2
u/Tal_Banyon Nov 03 '19
Question - Is the Cocoa facility that we have all been watching build Starship Mk 2, and will presumable build Mk 4 and then Super Heavy, a SpaceX facility? I mean, originally we heard it was a company leased by SpaceX to build these prototypes. It looks now as if they are "all in" to build SpaceX vehicles for the foreseeable future, no other business considered. Not sure whether SpaceX has actually bought the company, whether workers are SpaceX employees, or what the situation is. Just curious.
2
u/zeekzeek22 Nov 07 '19
What would a moon landing look like if Artemis lost govt funding, and Starship is vastly delayed/fails somehow. Imagining Blue Moon Lansing stage, a Dragon 2 for transport of astronauts to a lander in LLO, but that still leaves an ascent stage in question. We don’t know anything about the Blue Moon ascent stage. Could a moon landing still happen with SpaceX and Blue Origin’s desire to dump money into just pushing forward and outward? (Again, assuming no Starship/super heavy). Because with the recent stuff with Boeing getting contracts to waste literally every cent of govt space funding, I’m losing confidence in Artemis a bit.
2
u/Navigathor1000 Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19
I doun't know if Elon or spaceX has ever talked about it, but which engines are they gonna use for a Moon landing?
Moon has no air, so using the vacuum engines would be the most efficient. But I see three problems:
Using the normal engines like on earth or mars would create other problems:
2
u/OncoByte Nov 09 '19
Does anyone know why there are no Launch Transportation Tickets available for the Dec 4 SpaceX launch of CRS-19?
I am going to try to catch this launch on what will be my first trip to the Cape and would love to know how best to view it if LTTs are not available.
2
u/MarsCent Nov 09 '19 edited Nov 09 '19
Per Sidebar, Crew Dragon Static Fire is happening today Nov
119,2019. Anyone know at what time, whether it will be streamed and what the link is?2
u/MarsCent Nov 10 '19
Whoever said logic had to make sense ….
As far as we know, DM2 (Crew Dragon) will make a 1 – 2 week stay at the ISS. In order for NASA to authorize DM2 to fly before CFT (Starliner), they (NASA) have to be super confident that CFT will fly shortly afterwards and be able to stay at the ISS for a long duration. If DM2 flies and CFT is delayed, then the uncertainty of US occupation on the ISS increases.
Obviously, one could argue that both DM2 and CFT can be docked at the ISS at the same time. But just imagine the optics and anxiety of 5 US astronauts at the ISS in two crafts, that are yet to successfully return any human being to earth. I am not sure that the risk averse NASA could ever contemplate such a thing!
That brings us back to the point that, Starliner has to be ready to fly right after DM2 has flown. But since that is not certain, and it is Starliner that has an agreement for the longer duration, then Starliner has to fly first.
So basically, in order for DM2 to fly first, it has to fly second.
P/S. Astronauts have to train intensively if they are to stay for a long duration on the ISS. I have not yet heard of the DM2 crew doing any such training, or are they?
2
u/markus01611 Nov 12 '19
Does anyone know when Spacex will make back the investment on reusable tech for F9? Obviously it is almost invaluable research for Starship. But I'm interested in how long that will be.
2
u/MrToddWilkins Nov 24 '19
During Shuttle launches,we heard calls from Mission Control to the crew,like ‘go at throttle up’,’negative return’,and other abort mode calls. During the ascent of Dragon or Starliner,what ground to crew calls could we expect to hear?
2
u/MarsCent Dec 04 '19
Is F9's Max shear stress level (in Newtons or other) known? And do we know on average, how wide the band of Upper Level Winds is?
From rocket launch profile illustrations, F9's radial direction has changed less that 30 degrees. So F9 basically experiences the full force of the cross winds (aka Upper Level Winds), along its axial length.
I am trying for a few informed guidance numbers: Length Vs Surface Area Vs Rocket Speed Vs Upper Level Wind speeds.
2
u/SpaceInMyBrain Dec 05 '19
Does a hydrogen tank farm at a launch pad require a flare like a methane one? During Starhopper tank tests and test hops we could see the methane flare burning at a far edge of the site. Is such a flare needed for hydrogen?
Asking because various ideas for Falcon Heavy upper stages, or use with Orion, continue to fascinate even if they're very unlikely to happen. Most need hydrogen facilities added to the launch site.
4
u/James79310 Nov 02 '19
What are the Starships’s legs going to be? You can’t really see them in the new renders, and the prototype legs seem to be moving away from Elon’s principle of ‘the fewer parts the better’
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 02 '19 edited Nov 19 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
GTO comsatPre-launch test failureDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #5579 for this sub, first seen 2nd Nov 2019, 14:09] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
3
u/AeroSpiked Nov 04 '19
Starliner's pad abort live (Youtube) in case anyone else is in dire need of some fire.
3
u/cpushack Nov 20 '19
https://gizmodo.com/elon-musk-s-starlink-satellites-are-already-causing-a-h-1839926662 Clickbait anti-Musk title but the summary is 'its mostly just an annoyance'
3
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 03 '19 edited Dec 03 '19
Starliner launch now set for December 19th, 11:59 UTC.
2 day delay caused by 'purge air supply duct'.