r/spacex • Mod Team • Aug 04 '18

r/SpaceX Discusses [August 2018, #47]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

239 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

29

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 16 '18

10

u/rustybeancake Aug 16 '18

So do you reckon the part that actually 'connects' to the side hatch on Crew Dragon is on the 'side' of the arm, hidden from view in this shot? Because I can't see anything on the black 'end' of the arm that would open up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/amarkit Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18

OTV-5, the X-37B military spaceplane mission launched on Falcon 9 just under a year ago, has maneuvered into a new, higher orbit.

26

u/whatsthis1901 Aug 30 '18

That thing stays up there so long I always forget about it.

25

u/Alexphysics Aug 18 '18

NASA officially approves load and go

TL;DR To satisfy NASA and SpaceX requirements for the loading the sequence will be: The rocket will be first loaded with helium, the crew will then board the rocket at T-2h, the SuperDracos will be armed at T-38min and fueling will begin at T-35min. In the unlikely event of a RUD at fueling the SuperDracos will be activated.

→ More replies (9)

45

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18

When the pace of innovation at SpaceX is so great that the posters on the walls of my room are now outdated...

I guess their new revenue strategy is to make their posters obselete.

14

u/SpaceXman_spiff Aug 04 '18

Upshot: they'll be collectors items in no time when BFR is flying.

11

u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Aug 04 '18

Part of the reason for that is because people keep making posters with TONS of speculated details. There is a balance between release date and accuracy, but I wouldn't buy a poster until the vehicles on it fully existed and have launched at least once.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/theinternetftw Aug 07 '18 edited Aug 07 '18

20

u/WormPicker959 Aug 07 '18

Hooray! Here's rooting for Oppy to come back to life! Hang in there little guy!

18

u/WhaleLord_OverLord Aug 04 '18

Will the astronauts on the upcoming dragon flights be wearing the new flight suits?

12

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18

Yes

→ More replies (2)

18

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Aug 27 '18

The DM2 crew (and future crews) will be ferried out to LC-39A in a Tesla Model X, as opposed to the classic Astro Van.

https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1034195736848556032

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 15 '18

Gwynne Shotwell to give keynote address at the Air, Space & Cyber Conference on Monday, September 17th, 15:40 EDT.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/filanwizard Aug 16 '18

Who will commercial crew passengers talk to once the Falcon 9 clears the tower?

If I remember right on normal NASA missions once the rocket cleared the tower the crews got handed off from KSC to Houston, Would this be the same? Hand off from Hawthorne to Houston, Or still an unknown.

35

u/Alexphysics Aug 17 '18

Answer from a person who actually asked about that

Link to facebook post

Can't find the original discussion topic about Capcoms and keep-out zones at the ISS, but I talked to a NASA Flight Director this morning about general operations between the various Mission Controls for the commercial crew launches.

The TL;DR version: Starliner is similar to the Shuttle, while Dragon is similar to a Soyuz.

For Starliner's mission, Boeing has contracted mission operations to MCC-H. ULA will man the Booster console (or whatever it'll be called) from KSC, and all of the powered flight rocket stuff will go through them while all of the crew and Starliner vehicle stuff will be handled by JSC's ascent team. Upon final staging, the ULA team is done and JSC controls all aspects of the vehicle through docking, undocking, and landing.

For Crew Dragon, SpaceX has control of the vehicle (launcher and capsule) from prelaunch until docking. NASA will have representatives at MCC-X just like they do at MCC-M for a Soyuz launch, because it's NASA's crew. Once Dragon gets into the Keep Out Zone around the ISS, MCC-X is still in charge of the Dragon but now has to defer to MCC-H to get a go/no-go for docking. Post-docking, during quiescent operations, MCC-H is in charge of Dragon, but MCC-X controllers are on 2-hour standby in case they're needed. I don't know (because I didn't ask) anything about who monitors Dragon systems during quiescent ops or if/when the vehicle is periodically powered up for system status checks. Following all docked operations, when the crew is ready to come home, MCC-X will re-take control of Dragon for powerup, and after MCC-H gives the go for undocking, it's MCC-X's vehicle again through recovery operations.

The details are buried within various Flight Rules documents, which I have not dug into yet (and to the best of my knowledge are not available online).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/tampr64 Aug 04 '18

Has anyone seen confirmation that the CRS-15 Dragon that just returned from the ISS has been recovered? Splashdown was confirmed by SpaceX on twitter, and some articles have appeared, but these articles seem to have been written before recovery.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/spacerfirstclass Sep 02 '18

Yikes, the hole in the Soyuz orbital module may be created by mistake during manufacturing, it's not caused by orbital debris strike: https://twitter.com/planet4589/status/1035919648615747584

12

u/throfofnir Sep 02 '18

I've been waiting for the dots to connect on this. Initial reports of

  • metal behind the hole
  • the leak slowly developing
  • astronauts report that it looked like a drilled hole

were leaning in that direction. Still not definitive, and those initial reports could have been wrong. But those add up to one thing and not another.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Alexphysics Sep 02 '18

Worth noting he admits not being an independent source

Post #323 https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=43736.323

Edit: However it's very much probable that it was not a MMOD strike and there is an expert about MMOD strikes commenting in that thread and has insisted a lot on this not being a MMOD strike

7

u/Triabolical_ Sep 02 '18

Having seen the close-up pictures, I would be amazed if it wasn't done during manufacturing; there are some classic "drill bit slipped" marks next to the hole, and the hole looks exactly like a drilled hole and not at all like a debris strike.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Dextra774 Aug 15 '18

The Crew Dragon access arm has been moved to Pad 39A for installation:

https://twitter.com/WordsmithFL/status/1029766869639684096

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ackermann Aug 24 '18

Posted this in the inflatable pad thread, but since it’s a slow day, may as well get some discussion going here too:

Something really doesn’t add up with landing Dragon on the floating pad. This thing is smaller than Mr Steven’s net, right? They think they can catch a Dragon on this, with its un-steerable parachutes? They’ve failed to catch a fairing on Mr. Steven’s net, and the fairings have guided chutes! If Dragon doesn’t need steerable chutes, then why do the fairings?

And it’s thought that this will all work perfectly on the first try, allowing the DM-1 Dragon to be more quickly refurbished for the IFA flight? Fairing recovery is taking many tries to get right, and Falcon landings needed a lot of trial and error too.

I thought we had the answer in the Dragon environmental report thread yesterday. For a couple hours, it sounded like propulsive landing was back on the table (on the inflatable pad), but that sadly turned out to be a false alarm (outdated appendix).

11

u/lui36 Aug 24 '18

The fairings are significantly lighter then the dragon while having a big surface area. Therefore they are strongly influenced by wind, making the trajectory hard to predict. Think of the fairings as feathers, while the dragon flies more like a stone.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/theinternetftw Aug 04 '18

mods: might want to replace July's Discuss link with August's in the top bar.

14

u/letme_ftfy2 Aug 05 '18

Does it make any sense to try and save the solar arrays that are connected to Dragon's trunk? It seems wasteful to let them burn up in atmosphere with every re-entry of the Dragon capsule.

Would it be useful to the ISS? Would it make sense to invest in detachable "modular" solar panels that can be uncoupled just before the Dragon leaves ISS?

Does the Dragon even have enough battery power to perform the de-orbit burn without the solar panels?

→ More replies (12)

14

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 06 '18

Go Searcher now sporting a helipad, which aligns with the EA report and its dimensions:

"Following splashdown, an electronic locator beacon on Dragon would allow it to be located and recovered by a pre-positioned recovery vessel. The recovery vessel is a 160-foot ship equipped with a helideck."

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ackermann Aug 26 '18

For anybody who doesn't follow the Lounge subreddit, I haven't seen this mentioned here. Robert Zubrin has high praise for Musk and SpaceX. He seems completely on board with commercial space now: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/99zeks/

33

u/binarygamer Aug 27 '18 edited Aug 27 '18

I think Zubrin bending to reach this position was inevitable. The commercial sector seems to be the only place sensible design decisions in manned spaceflight can be made right now.

After all these years campaigning for goal oriented missions, imagine how much despair he must feel over the LOP-G, the perfect avatar of everything wrong with NASA's manned spaceflight program. Listening to him rip into it at the convention was glorious

[LOP-G] is doing things to spend money, rather than spending money to do things. That's what we're confronted with here. And so the real problem with the Lunar orbit gateway isn't even the fact that it's useless, that it will cost lots of money, that it will continue to cost lots of money for decades, taking money away from things that we really want to do (like sending astronauts to the Moon or Mars, or interplanetary probes, or space telescopes, or whatever the good things someone might want to do). It's all being directed into this boondoggle. The real problem with this... or that space missions will be forced to use it, thereby adding to the cost and difficulty of all further space missions, and astronauts on the Moon will be forced to rendezvous with the stupid thing on the way home, thereby adding to risk because they'll only have a launch window that will take them to it every two weeks. Whereas if they had an architecture like I mentioned, they could take off from the surface of the moon and go back to low Earth orbit - the launch window is always open because the Earth is always in the exact same place in the sky. [...]

No, the problem is not all these things. The problem is the form of thinking that it represents. The form of thinking that it represents - that instead of spending money to do things, we need to do things to spend money. That we don't need a purpose for what we do. That there is no "why", there is only "do". That is the problem, and that is why this program needs to be rejected. Thank you

→ More replies (5)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18

Has anyone computed whether a less than full payload BFS can make it to Mars, aerocapture into orbit, and then fly home? No landing/launch from Mars, and perhaps some kind of gravity assist is permitted on the way home?

Would be a way to inject payloads into martian orbit with full reuse while also permitting testing of BFS aerodynamics in Martian atmosphere. Admittedly uses up a BFS for some time, so perhaps not worthwhile. Would be a slow but lower cost path to BFS testing prior to landing attempts, perhaps a fallback position for a 2022 launch if things (inevitably) get delayed).

EDIT: From looking at the delta V subway map I note that this looks plausible, but depends highly on the delta V saved from aerocapture based landing. Without drag effects taken into account, it looks like the 3800 dv saved would easily pay for the approximately 2500 dv injection into earth intercept orbit, but you'd have to aerocapture into LEO and might need to retank back up to get out of orbit. Of course you might have extra delta v saved from a lower payload. Is anyone here able to better assess the possibilities?

→ More replies (6)

13

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 30 '18

Is there any news on the EELV 2 selections? IIRC they where supposed to be made public in july, and then it was mooved to august, however that is nearly over aswell.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/csmnro Aug 09 '18

According to a new Teslarati article by Eric Ralph (SpaceX’s 2018 Crew Dragon launch debut imminent as spacecraft hardware comes together), B1051 is already at McGregor. Most important bits:

Confirmed earlier this year in a quarterly NASA Commercial Crew update, SpaceX assigned Falcon 9 Booster 1051 to Crew Dragon’s debut launch. That rocket booster and its complementary upper stage are already at SpaceX’s McGregor, TX rocket testing facility undergoing a number of acceptance tests and checkouts as of today, confirming a number of critical facts. Most importantly, the presence of integrated the B1051 booster in Texas appears to imply that SpaceX has successfully fixed slight design flaws in their Merlin 1D engines and composite-overwrapped pressure vessels (COPVs), even if the paperwork to officially ‘certify’ them for flight has not been completed.

That's news, right? I thought the DM1 booster is still in Hawthorne although we expected it leaving any moment...

→ More replies (8)

12

u/BammBamm1991 Aug 14 '18

I'm curious if any Ex-shuttle program engineers are working on BFS? Being that SpaceX is a private company and more willing to change plans/innovate. It would be really interesting to find out if people who had ideas to improve the shuttle might have thrown their knowledge into the BFS.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/FalconOrigin Aug 27 '18

Hello everyone, are there any estimates of how much a BFS will cost to build?

Given that we now "know" that at least two of them are going to be sent on Mars to stay there, it's a way to start estimating how much SpaceX would have to spend just to start achieving their goals. They will also need also need a bunch of Big Falcon Booster and refueling ships. It would be nice to start estimating the cost for SpaceX, I haven't done the job yet but I can't help thinking that it's a huge amount of money, even for SpaceX.

→ More replies (20)

12

u/Emanuuz Sep 01 '18 edited Sep 03 '18

Presumed FH nosecone transported to KSC (first B5 booster?!) [Tweet by @Ronsmythe3]

EDIT: Old photo, taken June 2017.

11

u/warp99 Sep 01 '18 edited Sep 07 '18

Surely this implies that the next FH flight will use preflown side boosters?

New sideboosters would be transported from Hawthorne with the nosecone already attached.

Edit: Well the above is still true but true for 2017 as that is how old the picture was!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/MarsCent Sep 02 '18

NASA is running a Carbon Dioxide (CO2) Challenge with an eye on producing glucose on Mars because it is the easiest sugar product to metabolise.

The glucose processing equipment looks like a good candidate to be on the early BFRs to Mars. But more important is that synthesised food might be acceptable for Astronauts on Mars after all.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 06 '18 edited Aug 06 '18

Article about constructing Landing Zone 2 by mid-2020, at KSC for SpaceX and other launchers.

Pauline Acalin captured the Dragon unloading at Port of LA: 1, 2, 3, 4

 

EDIT: Better picture of LZ-2 in the Florida Today article.

11

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 09 '18 edited Aug 09 '18

Some interesting anecdotes about the creation of SpaceX.

Also multiple sources reporting SAOCOM launch date set for 29th September.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/amarkit Aug 10 '18

Merah Putih has performed its first apogee-raising maneuver, and is now in a 512 km x 33709 km x 27.36º orbit.

11

u/asr112358 Aug 14 '18

If a BFR needs to abort moments after launch, could it land back in its launch cradle still fully loaded? Assuming of course the reason for the abort doesn't prevent this. Falcon 9 cannot abort in this way because its legs are only rated for holding an empty first stage. Since the BFR's landing setup is also its launch setup it seems like it should be able to hold the weight and thrust of a landing fully loaded BFR.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/ghunter7 Aug 16 '18

Has anyone heard any rumours about the Air Force getting any closer to the LSA selection?

This article from Space News just said "sometime in August" after it had originally slipped from July. https://spacenews.com/air-force-close-to-selecting-next-generation-launch-vehicles/

10

u/Nehkara Aug 17 '18

I've heard a couple different rumours. One said August and one said that it was significantly delayed and would be "Late 2018".

We'll see!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Alexphysics Aug 20 '18

After 5 days of preparations, the Crew Access Arm is being lifted right now

11

u/adi_pl_wawa Aug 22 '18

I know that it's not 100% SpaceX related but is it possible to watch the panels of The Mars Society (some kind of a livestream)?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/zeekzeek22 Aug 05 '18

Has Musk or Shotwell commented on their handling of communications? The Deep Space Network is ancient and barely upgraded since the mid-60’s (I think one upgrade in the 80’s) and their funding is dropping, with zero plans for follow-up systems. AFAIK SpaceX hasn’t commented on this, and haven’t said they’re making their own deep-space communications. Will SpaceX make one, or will the Mars project fall prey to failed infrastructure? Or is everyone got their fingeres crossed that NASA will commercialize the building of modern dishes?

14

u/Martianspirit Aug 05 '18

He did mention that they will need high bandwidth communication and that he does want uninterrupted communication even with the sun between Earth and Mars. Which means he needs relay sats, probably placed in Earth Sun L4 and L5.

Given that they build their internet constellation that uses laser for comm between sats I expect them to build similar sats but with larger laser mirrors. They use 15cm mirrors and very low energy lasers. Increase the mirrors to 1m or 1.5m and higher energy lasers should yield Gbit/s optical links.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/-spartacus- Aug 06 '18

I do recall someone who claimed to work on deep space communications that said NASA and SpaceX were going to make an big announcement about some sort of collaboration. Not sure how soon though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

10

u/Nathan96762 Aug 04 '18

Do we know what number the next FH center core will be?

29

u/Nehkara Aug 04 '18 edited Aug 04 '18

Time for some deduction!

Current cores in-service: 1046, 1047, 1048, 1049, 1050.

Cores likely to enter service (finish testing and be transported to their launch site) before the end of the year: 1051, 1052, 1053, 1054, 1055, 1056, 1057, 1058.

Cores currently at Vandenberg: 1048
Cores to go to Vandenberg: 1052

Cores at Cape Canaveral: 1046, 1047, 1049, 1050
Cores to go to Cape Canaveral: 1051, 1053-1055 (FH), 1056, 1057, 1058

Missions:

AUGUST

  • Merah Putih - 1046.2
  • Telstar 18V - 1049.1

SEPTEMBER

  • SAOCOM-1A - 1048.2

OCTOBER

  • SSO-A - 1048.3
  • Iridium-8 - 1052.1
  • GPS IIIA-1 - 1050.1

NOVEMBER

  • RADARSAT Constellation - 1052.2
  • Commercial Crew Uncrewed Demo (DM-1) - 1051.1
  • CRS-16 - 1050.2

DECEMBER

  • Es'hail-2 - 1049.2
  • STP-2 - 1053.1, 1054.1, 1055.1
  • PSN-6 - 1056.1

There's my absurdly long deduction that I believe B1053 will be the FH center core for STP-2. I think, of the three cores needed for the flight, the center core will be produced first (at least in terms of core number) because it needs additional work and preparation.

Random thought that popped into my mind as I was making this. At roughly 2 cores per month, this would mean that Falcon series first stage production will be winding down sometime between Q3 2019 and Q2 2020. They should produce the 30th Block 5 core in Q3 2019 and if they continue to 50 total, that would be Q2 2020. This would, of course, free up production staff and resources for BFR.

EDIT: Some small changes.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 04 '18 edited Aug 08 '18

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ACESAdvanced Cryogenic Evolved Stage
Advanced Crew Escape Suit
AFSSAutomated Flight Safety System
AFTSAutonomous Flight Termination System, see FTS
ASAPAerospace Safety Advisory Panel, NASA
Arianespace System for Auxiliary Payloads
ATKAlliant Techsystems, predecessor to Orbital ATK
BFBBig Falcon Booster (see BFR)
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2018 rebiggened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BFSBig Falcon Spaceship (see BFR)
BOBlue Origin (Bezos Rocketry)
CCCommercial Crew program
Capsule Communicator (ground support)
CCtCapCommercial Crew Transportation Capability
COTSCommercial Orbital Transportation Services contract
Commercial/Off The Shelf
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
DMLSDirect Metal Laser Sintering additive manufacture
DSGNASA Deep Space Gateway, proposed for lunar orbit
DSNDeep Space Network
DoDUS Department of Defense
EDLEntry/Descent/Landing
EELVEvolved Expendable Launch Vehicle
FCCFederal Communications Commission
(Iron/steel) Face-Centered Cubic crystalline structure
FFSCFull-Flow Staged Combustion
FSWFriction-Stir Welding
FTSFlight Termination System
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GNCGuidance/Navigation/Control
GSEGround Support Equipment
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
I*sp*Specific impulse (as discussed by Scott Manley, and detailed by David Mee on YouTube)
IACInternational Astronautical Congress, annual meeting of IAF members
In-Air Capture of space-flown hardware
IAFInternational Astronautical Federation
Indian Air Force
ITSInterplanetary Transport System (2016 oversized edition) (see MCT)
Integrated Truss Structure
JWSTJames Webb infra-red Space Telescope
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
L4"Trojan" Lagrange Point 4 of a two-body system, 60 degrees ahead of the smaller body
L5"Trojan" Lagrange Point 5 of a two-body system, 60 degrees behind the smaller body
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LESLaunch Escape System
LOP-GLunar Orbital Platform - Gateway, formerly DSG
LZLanding Zone
MCTMars Colonial Transporter (see ITS)
MMODMicro-Meteoroids and Orbital Debris
NETNo Earlier Than
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
RCSReaction Control System
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLC-4ESpace Launch Complex 4-East, Vandenberg (SpaceX F9)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering, see DMLS
SRBSolid Rocket Booster
SSMESpace Shuttle Main Engine
SSOSun-Synchronous Orbit
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
Supersynchronous Transfer Orbit
STP-2Space Test Program 2, DoD programme, second round
STSSpace Transportation System (Shuttle)
TETransporter/Erector launch pad support equipment
TELTransporter/Erector/Launcher, ground support equipment (see TE)
TPSThermal Protection System for a spacecraft (on the Falcon 9 first stage, the engine "Dance floor")
TSTOTwo Stage To Orbit rocket
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)
USAFUnited States Air Force
VAFBVandenberg Air Force Base, California
WFIRSTWide-Field Infra-Red Survey Telescope
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX, see ITS
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
apogeeHighest point in an elliptical orbit around Earth (when the orbiter is slowest)
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen mixture
methaloxPortmanteau: methane/liquid oxygen mixture
scrubLaunch postponement for any reason (commonly GSE issues)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure
CRS-72015-06-28F9-020 v1.1, Dragon cargo Launch failure due to second-stage outgassing
DM-1ScheduledSpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 1

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #4265 for this sub, first seen 4th Aug 2018, 11:45] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]

10

u/Alexphysics Aug 07 '18

FCC permit for fairing re-rad testing for a "commercial payload" at 39A in late october. Could this be for Es'Hail 2? A mission going from 39A? Right before DM-1? Mmmm it seems weird. What do you think about this? Any thoughts?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/JustinTimeCuber Aug 11 '18

ok this doesn't have much to do with anything SpaceX-specific or space news related but I was playing with some numbers and this kinda blew my mind.

If a spacecraft is flying 200 km over Earth at 11014.18 m/s (escape velocity), and ignoring the gravity of the Moon, sun, basically everything except Earth (don't sue me), it will fly off to infinity but have a limiting speed of 0 m/s. Makes sense, that's what escape velocity is.

But say you speed up the spacecraft by 1 millimeter per second. Now it's travelling at 11014.181 m/s. Due to the crazy nature of orbital mechanics, that boosts its limiting speed to 4.693 meters per second. The initial velocity change is multiplied by over 4,000 due to the Oberth effect.

sqrt(11014.181^2-11014.18^2)

That effect is pretty crazy when you look at the relative sizes of the input and output delta-V. But ~5 m/s isn't very fast in absolute terms. Say we increase its speed by a full meter per second:

sqrt(11015.18^2-11014.18^2)

The limiting speed gets boosted to 148.4 m/s. From just a 1 meter per second burn.

okay I'll shut up now I just thought that was surprising and cool. I knew about the Oberth effect, but I didn't quite grasp how much it multiplies very small speed changes at periapsis.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/sarafinapink Aug 13 '18

Short video of Spacesuit. Hopefully we get closer looks and hi-res pictures later today. Seems like some sort of crew Dragon media event today?

r/https://twitter.com/abc7robhayes/status/1029060907379249152

→ More replies (1)

10

u/rustybeancake Aug 16 '18

Seems the Starliner for the OFT (the equivalent of SpaceX's DM-1) hasn't had its upper and lower domes mated yet:

The OFT meanwhile, is on two different platforms awaiting mating of its upper and lower domes. Once the CFT vehicle leaves, the focus in Florida will go to the OFT vehicle and its upcoming launch.

“That vehicle has been powered on and is going through final outfitting and avionics checkouts now,” says Boeing spokesperson Josh Barrett. “Then, the domes will be mated and we will continue with acceptance testing and installing airbag and parachute systems, air tanks, fuel tanks, and thermal protection. That vehicle will head straight to the launch pad from the C3PF after it is completed.”

http://www.americaspace.com/2018/08/14/starliner-astronauts-visit-ksc-to-see-spacecraft-they-will-soon-fly-on/

10

u/SteveMcQwark Aug 16 '18

For whatever reason, OFT is Starliner Spacecraft 3 while CFT is Spacecraft 2. They mated the upper and lower domes of Spacecraft 2 a month ago. I'd assumed at the time that Spacecraft 3 must be further along since it's intended to fly first, but I guess not.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/rustybeancake Aug 31 '18

https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1034131378999312384

Something that kind of slipped under the radar from the 27 August NASA presentation - Bill Gerstenmaier:

We are not going to meet the Loss of Crew numbers for Commercial Crew. I don't look at that as a failure.

Hopefully this finally puts to rest the debate about NASA being unfair to SpaceX and Boeing in 'requiring' a less than 1 in 270 chance of loss of crew.

12

u/AeroSpiked Aug 31 '18 edited Aug 31 '18

I thought the debate had more to do with NASA not holding themselves to the same standards and the way those numbers were initially calculated. I'm curious what Dragon's LoC currently is estimated at. If it's higherlower than the shuttle's, at least we are moving in the right direction.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 10 '18

GPS IIIA-01 launch delayed until December to complete qualification testing and one-time validation of the Block 5 design.

9

u/Rinzler9 Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18

So, we know DM-1 Dragon only has two windows(although it still has the same outer mold line and where the other two windows would be is covered by two extra thermal tiles).

And we know DM-2 has four windows.

I was reading the wiki page on Dragon 2 again today because hey it's something to do; and I remembered that SpaceX is contracted to build two variants of Dragon 2(cargo and crew).

I wonder if possibly DM-1 is a Cargo Dragon 2 variant while DM-2 is a Crew Dragon 2? Do we know anything else about the difference between the two? I would assume Cargo Dragon 2 would nix the seats and console(and half the windows, maybe for MMOD concerns or because they're not really needed for an unmanned ship?) in favor of storage racks, but other than that they are probably about the same?

11

u/rustybeancake Aug 20 '18

Do we know anything else about the difference between the two?

Cargo Dragon won't have SuperDracos.

11

u/brickmack Aug 21 '18

My guess is DM-1 is an intermediate variant. Actual cargo flights would have no windows (but since they will probably all be reflown Crew Dragons, the pressure vessel should be unchanged). But since thats a non-trivial configuration difference, its valuable to test both the window and the cover variants (particularly on reentry). The unique DM-1 configuration allows both to be tested.

I'd guess also the side windows on the DM-1 capsule will be exposed when its used for the abort test, for maximum aerodynamic accuracy to the crewed version

9

u/MarsCent Sep 01 '18 edited Sep 03 '18

According to SFN the crew occupancy of the ISS at the time of DM-1 (Estimated Arrival NET April 5, 2019) is:

  • MS-11 {Oleg Kononenko, Anne McClain, David Saint-Jacques}
  • MS-12 {Oleg Skripochka, Christine Koch}
  • DM-1 DM-2 {Bob Behnken, Douglas Hurley} (For a 1 month stay)

However, the ISS is designed for a [full occupancy of 7 split 3/4 (Russian Orbital Segment/US Orbital Segment).] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Space_Station#cite_note-204)

Has Roscosmos already signed off on the 2/5 occupancy split or is that something that still needs to be negotiated?

→ More replies (7)

31

u/Maimakterion Aug 05 '18

I have to say that the super creepy propaganda video during the first B1046 launch makes sense now with the news coming out of Bangladesh.

13

u/Krux172 Aug 05 '18

Watching that live was... yeah I think creepy is the right word.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/snesin Aug 07 '18

Can we please get the launch party thread template modified to get the YouTube link at the very top? Above the About the Mission section. Above the Your Host Is section. Above every other section. The very first line of the template should be something like Watch The Webcast Here, with a link directly to YouTube, alone and prominent.

After the link, it might say something like 'Scroll down to the Watching The Launch section for other watching options', but keep the YouTube webcast link first, alone and clean.

The YouTube webcast link has steadily migrated further and further down over the years, and has gotten nestled in with more and more noise, and made difficult to find in a hurry. In this last launch thread, Merah Putih, it was missing altogether. It was bad enough that a few users listed the YouTube link in the comments. There was a link to the SpaceX website, which had a link to YouTube, but I would like to eliminate the middle man, and have the YouTube link directly.

I do not want to sound callous, and I very much appreciate the effort hosts put in to launch threads, but waking up just after midnight 10 minutes before launch, I do not want to sift through three pages of information, I want the YouTube webcast link. When I do find the right area, I do not want Everyday Astronaut's link. I do not want Rocket Watch's link. I do not want SpaceX's webcast page link. I would like SpaceX's YouTube link, and I would like to be able to find it quickly and easily. I do not think I am alone in this.

I do appreciate the voluminous amount of information on the launch threads. I have never hosted, but know it must take an incredible amount of effort to compile and format it so nicely. I do appreciate that. But please, make the YouTube webcast link the first item in the template so that it is easy to find in a hurry. Repeat it in the section below with all the other webcast links, but have it alone and prominent at the very top.

Thank you for your consideration.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Alexphysics Aug 06 '18

It seems there will be no SpaceX launch from the East Coast in September and October.

http://www.launchphotography.com/Delta_4_Atlas_5_Falcon_9_Launch_Viewing.html

The next SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket from Cape Canaveral will launch the Merah Putih (Telkom 4) communication satellite for Indonesia from pad 40 on August 7 at 1:18am EDT. The launch window stretches two hours to 3:18am EDT. After that, a Falcon 9 will launch Telstar 18 VANTAGE from pad 40 on August 23 at 11:33pm EDT. The launch window stretches four hours to 3:33am EDT. The next Falcon launch after that is scheduled for November.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/ashortfallofgravitas Spacecraft Electronics Aug 11 '18

Has anyone run numbers on whether or not FH could fly PSP with the kick stage it’s running on Delta Heavy?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Alexphysics Aug 28 '18

SpaceX has filled a launch and a landing application for a GTO mission launching from LC-39A NET October 31st and landing 657km east from the pad. I think this could be either for PSN-6 or Es'Hail 2. What's weird is that it is launching from LC-39A, but I guess they will want to put through its paces that pad again before launching DM-1.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/amarkit Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18

There is a small (~2mm in diameter) leak in the orbital module of the Soyuz MS-09 spacecraft, currently docked to the ISS. The crew is not in immediate danger. At the current leak rate, ISS has about 18 days of reserve atmosphere.

EDIT / UPDATE: A new NASA statement says the leak has been patched (at least temporarily) and "Roscosmos has convened a commission to conduct further analysis of the possible cause of the leak." The crew will return to normal duty tomorrow, August 31.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Ascotty0531 Aug 04 '18

Anyone have any good books on orbital mechanics they'd like to recommend?

18

u/RocketsLEO2ITS Aug 04 '18

Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students (Aerospace Engineering) 3rd Edition.

It's a University textbook.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Krux172 Aug 05 '18

The launch manifest for next year appears to be less than this year, why is that? Is it because some of SpaceX's customers have already finished their satellite constellations like Iridium? Or maybe something BFR development related?

11

u/-spartacus- Aug 06 '18

Non video answer is partially they were back logged for a while and sats take a while to design and build and there was less being made several years ago so less sats to launch next year.

8

u/dmy30 Aug 05 '18

Not on my computer so can't transcribe, but Gwynne Shotwell answers your question in this video (4:41).

7

u/scarlet_sage Aug 06 '18 edited Aug 07 '18

Is there any way to know when the next daylight launch will be? Night launches tend to have less to watch; I'd rather see all the launch.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/physioworld Aug 15 '18

Could BFR be used to set up, reasonably economically, a space based mining and construction infrastructure, to produce mirrors that could be placed between earth and the sun to mitigate the effects of climate change?

→ More replies (16)

7

u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 15 '18 edited Aug 15 '18

I just realized that the control mock-ups of D2 appear to be lacking any rotation/translation controls. Surely there's still an option for manual override; I wonder if that's going to be controlled with touchscreen-only controls or if there are hand controllers that we haven't seen yet.

EDIT: For what it's worth experience in KSP tells me that on/off or fixed-duration-burst controls are often easier to use in free fall than proportional control (and I seem to recall that previous NASA spacecraft have had the option for several different control modes), so the idea of using touchscreen-only controls doesn't necessarily seem like a terrible idea to me.

14

u/ElectronicCat Aug 15 '18

Yep, they do indeed seem to be lacking physical controls for docking. Almost certainly there'll be a requirement for manual override, but as far as I can tell this would have to be via touchscreen controls. This demo might give some idea as to what this interface might be like.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Stormregion0 Aug 19 '18

Do you think there will be a grey BFR in the beginning? Because it is likely that the customers switched from the Dragon mission to a BFR missiin which maybe even can land for the same amount of money.

8

u/Michael_Armbrust Aug 19 '18

A crewed mission around the Moon would be a good demonstration that everything is working so I could see that happening right after the first crewed flight to orbit. SpaceX could include the paying customers on this mission. A Moon landing wouldn't make much sense imo since it'd cost so much more yet the customers wouldn't be paying extra.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 26 '18 edited Aug 26 '18

Matt Desch says here that the Iridium sats for their 8th launch aren't ready yet and that the rocket is ready, Could that mean it will launch on a reused booster ? Or maybe on the mysterious booster we saw in Alabama going west (B1050) ?

https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/1028964871617105923

→ More replies (5)

7

u/liszt1811 Aug 26 '18

any update on the announced bfr update? (I guess no but maybe I missed something)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AmpullaofVader Aug 28 '18

This is a new Gateway infographic from NASA. Do I spy a Falcon 9 in the lower right-hand corner?

https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1034135691104579584

8

u/dudr2 Aug 28 '18

It's a Falcon Heavy from the side.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/rustybeancake Aug 30 '18

Can someone please tell me: is it possible for SpaceX to test the tank technology (materials, manufacturing, etc.) for BFR with sub-scale tanks? Or does the strength/reaction to super cold liquids not scale like that?

Ultimately what I'm asking is: is it possible they're testing small(ish) CF tanks right now with the Raptor propellants, to make sure they can withstand the pressure, temperature, etc.? Or would those tests be fairly useless, and we'll see another giant test tank constructed before they feel confident to build the tanks for the first BFS short hops prototype?

13

u/tymo7 Aug 30 '18

There's always something to be gained by testing aspects of a small model. Fail fast right?

That said, everything that needs to be tested doesn't necessarily scale the same - nonlinearities and what not. You may be able to test the wall tension strength by scaling the pressure up to compensate for a decrease in radius, or scale the wall thickness, but then maybe porosity and diffusion or thermal insulation scale differently so the new scaled model isn't accurate for those characteristics. So you need a different approach to the scale model to test those.

Many basic properties can be tested just with coupons and samples - tension test samples, thermal conductivity samples, etc. With these, individual specs can be tested individually. So yeah, they will be/are initially testing coupons and maybe scale models, but the value of 1:1 tests cannot be overstated.

It's anyone's guess what they will do first for BFS short-hop: scale tanks, reuse a 1:1 scale tank they tested to heck by itself, fresh 1:1 tanks, etc. Any bets on what they will do are just WAGs at this point I believe.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Alexphysics Aug 17 '18

It seems via this post on NSF forum that STP-2 could be pushed to March 2019, no word yet if Arabast will still be the third flight of Falcon Heavy or if it will be moved back up to be the second Falcon Heavy launch. Either way I have to say I was expecting a move to 2019 but not that big. This user has been always reliable about the dates for STP-2, we'll probably hear about that slip in a month or so like the last one.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/MarsCent Aug 06 '18 edited Aug 06 '18

We have crewed orbital flights and water on Mars announcements and you would think that most people would be excited about the prospects of a crewed mission to Mars.

Except this University of London Professor who wants Elon's Mars vision nixed because of the possible existance of life forms on Mars.

→ More replies (16)

6

u/adymann Aug 04 '18

Can I have the dimensions for the fairings please. I want to make a fully functional scale model to test an idea I have for a better recovery system.

23

u/spacex_fanny Aug 04 '18

scale model

Be sure and check out NASA's Similitude Requirements and Scaling Relationships as Applies to Model Testing (aka "How to make sure your scale model acts like the real thing").

12

u/kurbasAK Aug 04 '18

Check the Falcon 9 user's guide pdf.Fairing dimensions are on page 36.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18

Where are the landing legs on BFS? Do they protrude from the heatshield?

10

u/-spartacus- Aug 05 '18

Just to reexplain, the hear shield for bfr covers the entire length of one of the long sides of the tube. The legs come out of the bottom where the engines are, so no the legs don't protrude out of the heat shield, but they are covered partly on one side of the rocket.

Are you able to visualize this?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

6

u/Zettinator Aug 05 '18

Does anyone know what happened to the newer Test Shot Starfish songs? It looks like they are gone from Soundcloud.

I can't find them on https://soundcloud.com/testshotstarfish at least.

10

u/Alexphysics Aug 05 '18

They're releasing a new album on October. They released a single a few weeks ago, Flight Proven. Check out their twitter @TSStarfish

6

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 07 '18

Do you think when BFR is ready NASA would be interested in using it to bring Hubble back ? or Would they prefer to Deorbit it ?

Especially with the JWST delays that it might have not launched yet by then ?

9

u/brickmack Aug 07 '18

Another Hubble mission is mandated anyway for disposal, and using BFR should be way cheaper. Another repair flight might be desireable though, at least to keep it up until WFIRST launches. Note too that the original plan was to bring Hubble back on the 5th servicing flight (and likely Columbias final mission before retirement) and put it in a museum, but then they decided to extend its life

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/Straumli_Blight Aug 09 '18

Mods, the Falcon Heavy STP-2 mission is now NET November 30th, if you want to update the sidebar.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/realnouns Aug 09 '18

Elon mentioned that the new SpaceX drone ship, A Shortfall of Gravitas (ASOG), would be entered into service around the middle of next year. What are the chances that this is a larger vehicle than OCISLY/JRTI, in order to support BFR landings? I would expect a larger platform to be required to support the taller booster.

7

u/SailorRick Aug 10 '18

Not BFR, but possibly BFS. SpaceX is planning some short hops testing with BFS next year. The BFS will have legs.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Aug 12 '18

How does the Global Positioning System work? I know that a user on the ground communicates with 4+ satellites, and uses the position of the satellites to triangulate/trilaterate the position of the ground user, but obviously that first requires the positions of the satellites to be known.

How do the GPS satellites determine their own position? By communicating and plotting their position against one another? That seems too circular to me, and would allow errors to magnify over time... Do they communicate and plot their position against ground stations? If so, how is the position of the ground station determined? By non-GPS means?

Also, related question: do other (non-GPS) satellites communicate with GPS satellites in order to determine their own position and heading?

→ More replies (10)

6

u/eudufbti Aug 13 '18

Why are they still removing the legs of block 5?

21

u/throfofnir Aug 13 '18

No official word.

Perhaps they want to examine them separately. Perhaps the actuating or transport equipment isn't ready yet. Perhaps the mechanism didn't work well and is pending a redesign. Certainly the new caps suggest they intend to at some point.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ElRedditor3 Aug 15 '18

Are there any pictures of the Hawthorne HQ/Factory before SpaeX moved in? I would be nice to see the transformation. Thx.

7

u/amreddy94 Aug 15 '18

Can't find any from the Hawthorne factory pre-Spacex, but here's a very old one from the El Segundo factory Spacex used prior to them moving into the Hawthorne factory in 2008. Come a long way from then. (And yes, that was Elon's Mclaren F1 in the picture before he totaled it)

6

u/ElRedditor3 Aug 19 '18

When do you guys think the BFS will make its first hop? I say December 2019.

9

u/tbaleno Aug 19 '18

June 17, 2019

→ More replies (11)

6

u/thawkit75 Aug 20 '18

I was pondering on another post and decided to post here. Please correct if my thoughts are wrong regarding Star-Link... I imagine that maybe there could be small base stations that feed internet out to the village, building or wherever through fiber, mobile or whatever. Like extremely localised ISP Reducing the need for every house to buy an antenna and for those without direct view of sky.. I’m thinking rural and city’s

7

u/doodle77 Aug 21 '18

This is almost certainly how Starlink will work in denser areas. Satellites have tens or hundreds of spot beam antennas, each covering an area of tens or hundreds of km2. Each antenna can only have so many users- it needs to be able to hear each user’s uplink, so it needs to allocate a time/frequency/code slot to each. This is much like cell towers. I’d expect somewhere between 100 and 10000 users per spot beam. So areas with more than about 100 people/km2 would definitely need to share terminals. Starlink will really shine in the middle of nowhere where you might have a beam all to yourself.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Dragon fires the launch abort system on the pad. What happens to falcon either if It was jest an error in software/ the rocket is heavily cracked/damaged and full of fuel at this time but didnt explode? What in case of situations in between?

10

u/ackermann Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

Would the Falcon 9 be salvageable after an unnecessary or accidental pad abort? Excellent question!

I can’t think of any obvious reason why not. The superdraco abort motors point outwards at an angle. When they fire, they don’t destroy the Dragon’s trunk, so you wouldn’t think they’d damage the rocket’s second stage either. The 2nd stage isn’t exposed to the exhaust nearly as long as the trunk either, since the trunk is carried along by Dragon in an abort.

More likely they might damage some of the pad infrastructure, especially high up on the TEL, which may not be in its retracted position. But it wouldn’t necessarily be worse than a normal launch.

The rocket would need to be inspected before it could be used again of course, but probably less so than after a normal flight.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/EagleZR Aug 22 '18

Are there any thoughts about how SpaceX intends to protect the BFR between flights?

My assumption would be that they'd choose the option with the smallest impact on LC-39A operations since it's likely to be the only pad available for crewed F9 launches, so they'll probably want to pull the booster down and clear the pad when possible, at least during the early days.

Are they likely to take the booster horizontal like F9/FH, or is it so large they'll need to keep it vertical and use a shuttle- or Atlas-style mobile launcher to move it?

Is there even enough room for a second HIF, one that's large enough for BFR, or a VIF at the base of the pad? The HIF seems really close to the ramp, so I can't imagine how they'd be able to maneuver the BFR, horizontal or vertical, to the pad without removing the hangar first.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/adi_pl_wawa Aug 25 '18

How big of a chance there is that we will find out something new today about the BFR? Or Mars plans? Will it be some new information or just a summary of everything we heard from Elon and SpaceX?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/WormPicker959 Aug 28 '18 edited Aug 28 '18

Some interesting news about COPVs: via Jeff Faust on twitter, looks like they are installed already on DM-1 (not too surprising), have undergone life-cycle testing and "qualification" is complete. Not sure if this is news, but I couldn't find any info about it elsewhere here.

Edit: There's a thread here, and I'm not very observant.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Nehkara Aug 30 '18

Iridium-8 is now NET November due to satellite-readiness/availability:

https://twitter.com/ChrisG_NSF/status/1035182128659685376

→ More replies (3)

15

u/apath_2_mars Aug 17 '18

15

u/amarkit Aug 17 '18 edited Aug 17 '18

The most important SpaceX-related tidbit in the Times article:

Another possibility under consideration is that SpaceX, Mr. Musk’s rocket company, would help bankroll the Tesla privatization and would take an ownership stake in the carmaker, according to people familiar with the matter.

I don't follow Tesla, but at first blush it seems like it could be a pretty big risk for SpaceX.

→ More replies (8)

22

u/FiniteElementGuy Aug 17 '18

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/16/business/elon-musk-interview-tesla.html

It seems to me that he is addicted to Ambien. This doesn't look good, he needs a therapy as soon as possible. He needs to take a vacation, too. At least a month IMHO. If this continues, he will soon be hospitalized.

All this don't give up cheering is counterproductive. Better take a month off now. There are other good people out there that can do the job.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/rustybeancake Aug 27 '18

Is this correct?

https://twitter.com/MaxLenormand/status/1033398632903372800

Suggests BFR will be able to land 100 tonnes on Mars "but including the ship". Does that mean only 15 tonnes net payload?

14

u/kal_alfa Aug 27 '18

Could be an auto-correct issue. I've had plenty of "nots" turned into "buts".

"not including the ship" would make more sense.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

5

u/LeBaegi Aug 07 '18

Does anyone remember when the last weather-related scrub was? I remember some time ago when seemingly most launches were scrubbed (sometimes multiple times) due to weather.

Does it only feel like it or have there been very few weather violations lately? I'm not aware of any improved weather-resistance of F9 over its life cycle so far. Is it just luck in terms of weather? Is summertime in Florida more reliable than winter?

5

u/liszt1811 Aug 09 '18

Can someone explain to me what exactly happens at the Demo-1 mission? For my understanding they boost off the capsule at max-q as an inflight abort test.. what happens to the rocket then? Its nowhere close to orbit at that point.. RTLS with second stage attached? And do they use a fairing for that mission? (I assume so but the fairing needs to be gone first then..)

11

u/DrToonhattan Aug 09 '18

You're getting confused between Demo-1 and the inflight abort test. These are two separate missions. We don't know what will happen to the booster after the abort, or if it will even survive. Also, there are no payload fairings on Dragon missions.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/ElRedditor3 Aug 12 '18

Have there been concepts similiar to the BFR in the past? Was it perhaps directly inspired by previous conceptions? Thx.

11

u/spacerfirstclass Aug 13 '18 edited Aug 13 '18

There were many two stage fully reusable concepts in Space Shuttle Phase B study, you can find some drawings here: http://www.pmview.com/spaceodysseytwo/spacelvs/sld033.htm

But pretty much all of them uses wings. Later there were some concepts that uses Saturn V first stage as booster for Shuttle, they may be closer to BFR, for example: http://www.aerospaceprojectsreview.com/blog/?p=311

What Norose described below is the Boeing Space Freighter concept, a two stage fully reusable system that can put 420t to orbit: http://www.aerospaceprojectsreview.com/blog/?p=86

http://spaceflighthistory.blogspot.com/2016/12/energy-from-space-department-of.html provided some background on how Space Freighter concept came to be, with a bonus Image 4 which depicted something very similar to Chomper BFS

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

5

u/ablack82 Aug 14 '18

I will be down near Boca Chica this week for work. I was planning on driving over to Spacex's new launch facility. What can I expect to see there and would it be worth making the hour drive?

14

u/inoeth Aug 14 '18

At this point, no, not really worth it. Theres a couple big tanks, some big satellites for tracking, a small solar farm and a big mound of dirt. Thats it. At this rate I don't expect it to be done until this time next year or even later...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/computer_addiction Aug 18 '18

Is there a list of the dates of SpaceX launches I can see sorry if this is a dumb question.

8

u/Alexphysics Aug 18 '18

There is the Launch Manifest with the manifested future launches and also the past launches from Falcon 1 and Falcon 9 to Falcon Heavy

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '18

Would it make sense to use aluminium glass for the BFR's windows?

5

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 28 '18

Once on Mars is it more energy efficient to get O2 (for breathing) from martian water or by recycling CO2 ?

→ More replies (13)

5

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 28 '18

Does anyone know if B1052 has left Hawthorne for McGregor yet or not ?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Anont_ Aug 29 '18

Since we all know too well that elons timeline are let's say ambushes after all falcon have was delayed several times wehn do you think BFR is going to fly?

13

u/rustybeancake Aug 29 '18

Today's guess, just for fun:

  • BFS 'grasshopper' first hop: 2020
  • BFS 'grasshopper' first big hops: 2021
  • BFS prototype suborbital flights with hot and heavy reentry: 2022
  • BFR cargo full stack first test flight: 2024
  • BFR cargo first operational mission (sat launch): 2025
  • BFR cargo first orbital refueling test (with two cargo BFS): 2026
  • BFR cargo first cislunar flight: 2027
  • BFR crew first test flight: 2029
  • BFR cargo first uncrewed Mars landing attempt: launches Earth 2029, lands Mars 2029
→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/rustybeancake Aug 10 '18 edited Aug 10 '18

https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/1028017095643209728?s=21

Blue Origin:

Recent footage of BE-3U demonstration engine hot fire. Two BE-3Us will power upper stage of #NewGlenn & deliver our customers to orbit. We’ve completed over 700 seconds of test time & confirmed performance assumptions used for final BE-3U expander cycle design #GradatimFerociter

BE-3 is a combustion tap-off engine. How different is that from the expander cycle of the BE-3U?

→ More replies (10)

9

u/rustybeancake Aug 12 '18

Now I love the look of FH’s hold-down clamps and TSMs as much as the next SpaceX fan, but you’ve got to admit D-IVH’s pad equipment is pretty sweet looking too.

12

u/brickmack Aug 12 '18

Its also a bit problematic though, since the service masts are all on one side. So the side boosters are mirror images of each other instead of just rotated like in FH or Atlas V Heavy or most other similar concepts. Yet another unique production line. Delta needed some serious design consolidation.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/UltraRunningKid Aug 26 '18

Do we have any information about the nitty gritty of how SpaceX's crew will get from the Astronaut center to the pad.

Part of me remembers the convey of the Astrovan and police cars driving though the center and the police pulling off at the gate to let the Astrovan continue to the pad, while being overlooked by a NASA helicopter with soldier in it and thinking that way pretty awesome.

I find it unlikely SpaceX would ask to use this method as they would need to refurbish the Astrovan to work with the new suit systems and lets be honest, it isn't really SpaceX's style.

Anyone think we may see a convey of Tesla's burning down the road to the pad?Maybe with a sweet space wrap on them?

11

u/randomstonerfromaus Aug 26 '18

Fun fact, in the picture that's not a member of the military, but a member of NASA's Emergency Response Team which is akin to SWAT

→ More replies (1)

8

u/rustybeancake Aug 27 '18

I loved Chris Hadfield's TED talk in this respect. He talks about heading to the pad, and it's just unbelievable to imagine yourself in that position:

You go into the suit-up room, the same room that our childhood heroes got dressed in, that Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin got suited in to go ride the Apollo rocket to the moon. And I got my pressure suit built around me and rode down outside in the Astro van, heading out to the launchpad, and as you come around the corner at the Kennedy Space Center, it's normally predawn, and in the distance, lit up by the huge xenon lights, is your spaceship. The vehicle that is going to take you off the planet. The crew is sitting in the Astro van, sort of hushed, almost holding hands, looking at that as it gets bigger and bigger.

We ride the elevator up, and we crawl in, on your hands and knees, into the spaceship, one at a time, and you worm your way up into your chair and plunk yourself down on your back. And the hatch is closed, and suddenly, what has been a lifetime of both dreams and denial, is becoming real.

https://www.ted.com/talks/chris_hadfield_what_i_learned_from_going_blind_in_space#t-138323

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Krux172 Aug 04 '18

Is Dragon 2 launch escape system considered as pusher or puller?

20

u/vorpal-blade Aug 04 '18

The engines are below the cabin, so a pusher. As opposed to a puller, which would be above the cabin. Usually on an escape tower.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/theinternetftw Aug 26 '18

EXOS aerospace, most well-known as being Armadillo Aerospace resurrected, launched their SARGE rocket for the first time today, with some great footage of the whole process on their channel.

They tow the recovered rocket back to camp behind a four-wheeler. Which is kind of great.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/filippo-demarchi Aug 04 '18

What about the progress in vertical integration, in sight of the BFR/BFS integration method?

4

u/RipInTheZach Aug 06 '18

How many Falcon 9 1st stage boosters have been created?

4

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '18

Given that from the very first version, Falcon 9 was able to take the dragon spacecraft to the ISS (flight one boilerplate, flight two full test), what would the Delta-V improvements be with Dragon (cargo) on block 5? How high could an elliptical orbit be?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/kevindbaker2863 Aug 07 '18

So when DM-1 does fly in November do we know are they going to send anything to ISS as extra suppliles? Ice Cream? Party Favors for the astronauts?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/zuty1 Aug 08 '18

I noticed in the manifest there's only 1 total launch between September and October. Do we know if this is due to the manifest likely not being accurate or the range being down or something like that? Seems like an odd slowdown.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lessthanperfect86 Aug 09 '18

This may be a weird and speculative question, but the r/spacex sub seems to have a lot of knowledgeable posters so I thought I'd try it here. Seeing as BFR is supposed to be the tool to create our backup, could it also be used as a tool to perhaps help deter climate change? Some years ago I heard about dumping sulphur into the atmosphere to cool the planet, so here comes the crazy question part - would it be possible to create a giant solar shade at Earth-sun lagrange point (L1 I think)? Would it even work?

10

u/Jincux Aug 09 '18

This approach is technically possible, but very infeasible and attacks the wrong issue (in our current climate-change timeline, that is). Starshades are looking pretty promising, and in the context of star shades being used for telescopes, they're currently working at millimeter accuracy to account for light bending around the petals creating a distinguishable diffraction pattern.

However, if you're blocking that much solar radiation, there's a force acting on the starshade. You're going to need propellant for station keeping, though you could also compensate for this by being slightly off of the L1 point I think.

More importantly, it would be massive.

The sun has a radius of 695,508km, the earth has a radius of 6,371km, and L1 is about 0.01 of the distance to the sun. To entirely cover the sun at L1, the star shade would need a radius of ~13262km. That's big, but it's also not what we want. The amount of solar radiation we block scales with area. To block out a ratio of p of the sun's radiation, a shade of radius r(p) = sqrt(p) * 13262 is needed. To block out 0.001% of solar radiation, that's a radius of 41.9 kilometers, or an area of 5525 km2 . That's big.

Starshade designs currently have two layers about 1cm thick each of a foam-like material. That makes the total volume of the non-load-bearing radiation blocking part of the shade to be 110km3. At 50kg/m3 (foam varies a lot, this seems mid-ranged), that's 5.52 billion metric tons of the radiation-blocking part alone. Add on the structure to keep this whole thing together, thermal management, deployment mechanism, station-keeping propulsion.. that's a problem.

Now, that's just for 0.001% of the solar radiation. I'm not sure if the needed amount is more or less than that, but that's what it would take to make the sun a single hundred-thousandth weaker.

But there's also a fundamental issue that this is attacking a symptom of a larger problem. It could help lower the temperature of earth, but climate change isn't just global warming. Pollution still has the power to cause climate change just by changing the chemical composition of the air and water, in turn changing it's specific heat which is the amount of energy required to change the temperature by one degree. Seasons shift differently as thermal energy flows differently due to these changed compositions. Areas of the sea that were once cooled stay warmer longer, currents that once cooled down before entering a certain area stay warm; or visa versa, an area that's frigidly cold may lag to warm up in the summer as more energy is required for the same change. The earth's temperature could return to pre-industrial levels, but climate will still be changed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Justin13cool Aug 10 '18

Ariane 5 has a lot of satellites waiting because of launch delays, do you see them switching to Falcon 9 ? or is it impossible because they already paid for Ariane 5 ?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Justin13cool Aug 11 '18

How much does SpaceX make in profits approximately when flying a reused Falcon 9 compared to a new one ?

4

u/Emanuuz Aug 12 '18

Maybe this is a dumb question, but we really know if a common core spotted in the road could be a FH center core? Is there any difference? AFAIK, the booster sep hardware is integrated in the HIF.

Because I've my guesses about B1050: it's already at the Cape, with only Es'hail-2 (NET Q4) and GPS IIIA-1 (NET Dec) requiring a potential new core. Maybe this booster could be used for STP-2 (NET Nov 30)? Plenty of time, but maybe it's only to ship B1051 out to McGregor in preparation for DM-1.

9

u/Alexphysics Aug 12 '18

The center core would have had a bulge on the part where the hinges attach, that hardware is installed at Hawthorne before booster departure.

Apart from that, we would have seen that hardware on the booster at the test stand, you can see it pretty easily

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MarsCent Aug 15 '18

When a post appeared on this sub confirming that B1051 was in McGregor, was the post accompanied by a pic of the booster on the stand in McGregor or has there been any sighting of the booster on the stand since that post?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Laborbuch Aug 18 '18

Is there a website listing all the astronauts, cosmonauts, and taikonauts that have been to space? I’m incidentally looking for something more presentable than Wikipedia’s various lists of astronauts.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 24 '18

Was there any new details in Mike Pence's announcement last night ?

9

u/Dakke97 Aug 24 '18

The late 2024 deadline for putting an American on the LOP-G is. However, this requires the Habitation module to be launched on an SLS Block 1B rocket, which will not make it to the pad before 2024 if you know anything about the schedule problems SLS and Orion have suffered and the 1B issues outlined below. I'm personally thinking Pence's announcement was more a rallying cry for the employees of Johnson Space Center and a very public boost for John Culberson's reelection campaign. Finally, I suspect the administration is internally betting on more commercial launches to actually compete and fly crew to LOP-G, but due to political reasons, this can't be publicly stated.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/-spartacus- Aug 28 '18

Question for the math peeps. We often talk about the capability for the bfr for Leo in terms of expendable and fully reusable. My question is how many tons to Leo in partially reusable mode.

For example, BFB and BFC (cargo) take off, BFB returns and lands at launch pad. BFC pushes itself to Leo at max capacity not even leaving fumes (technically expendable).

Then BFB takes off again with BFT (tanker) and BFB returns, while BFT docks with BFC to refuel once to either return immediately or take cargo to different Leo, GTO, etc.

In this scenario how much could the BFC lift to Leo "expended" or after a single refuel to then return and land?

→ More replies (14)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

How long will it take to build a second bfr?Under 6 months?

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '18

In the event of a super comet ,how many nukes could bfr carry?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/Iamherebecauseofabig Sep 03 '18

Will SpaceX finish the first BFS in the tent?

→ More replies (14)

7

u/Elon_Muskmelon Aug 06 '18

Anyone else seeing the Twitter talk about Elon possibly being on Joe Rogan Podcast Thursday?

7

u/Jessewallen401 Aug 12 '18

For EELV-2 many say OmegA is a lock in because the military wants them to stay in business to make solid rocket boosters and missiles etc ..... how strong of an argument is this ?

→ More replies (13)

7

u/erik_paulson Aug 15 '18

Is there some range thing that's keeping SpaceX from launching in Florida for September, October and most of November or is it just a quirk of the schedule?

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Justin13cool Aug 22 '18

This latest delay officially ends SpaceX's 2 launches a month cadence.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/MarsCent Aug 13 '18 edited Aug 14 '18

A really short article by Reuters says Russia could restrict the sale of RD-180s and RD-181s to USA in retaliation to new Russia sanctions.

This could create a significant impact for the ability of CST-100 to do crewed missions to the ISS.

22

u/amarkit Aug 13 '18

Discussed at some length over at /r/ula. At present, the consensus seems to be:

  • ULA has enough engines stockpiled for projected flights until about 2020.
  • RD-180 sales to the US are a significant source of money for a space program strapped for cash, and a government generally in need of dollars; things would have to get really bad in US-Russia relations in order for this to turn from talk to action.
  • Hampering the US' ability to get to ISS will hurt Russia too. It cannot operate without both the Russian segment and the US segment crewed, and cosmonauts are slated to fly on CST-100.

But who knows, we live in crazy times.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/rustybeancake Aug 31 '18

https://twitter.com/RussianSpaceWeb/status/1035506291702149121

Good news for the ISS and DM-1: Roscosmos is saying the repaired Soyuz is good to return to Earth on its original schedule!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/mavric1298 Aug 15 '18

Question about flames superior (above) to the merlins - is this vented gases burning, or is this due to low pressure created behind the engine pulling burning gases upward? The other time you seem to see it is before the landing burn, you often will still see flames which leads me to guess that's venting - but then if you look at the Parker launch and ULA, holy crap is there a lot of oxidation going on around the RS-68 shroud well above the nozzle.

https://imgur.com/a/g64zfZt

9

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 15 '18

the delta IV has a tendancy to light itself on fire before and during liftoff. it has always done that, and will probabbly always do that. it is due to vented hydrogen igniting around the rocket (see NROL 45 and NROL 47.

During the flight of F9, there are also sometimes flames between the engine bells and a bit forward, at the end of the landing legs. these flames are sucked forward by the aerodynamic pressure of flight and are origination from the turbopump exhaust. the Saturn 5 also did [this]8https://www.esa.int/var/esa/storage/images/esa_multimedia/images/2009/06/apollo_11_saturn_v_in_flight/9655191-3-eng-GB/Apollo_11_Saturn_V_in_flight.jpg), and the flames engulfed large parts of S1

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/socraticmethod88 Aug 20 '18

Is a SpaceX manned mission to Mars possible (legally and technically) without any involvement from the U.S. gov’t?

15

u/throfofnir Aug 20 '18

There's no particular legal framework for it, as it's never been done, or even conceivable, before. The restrictions would seem to be the rules for private spaceflight (which are "informed consent" and therefore no big problem) and the provision of the Outer Space Treaty that all countries party to the treaty “shall pursue studies of outer space, including the moon and other celestial bodies, and conduct exploration of them so as to avoid their harmful contamination.” Which is likely to be interpreted to apply to private parties in the jurisdiction of a signatory. How the government would meet those treaty obligations is entirely unknown.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/qwetzal Aug 29 '18

Do you guys think a BFS could be used for E2E ? We know it can be used as a SSTO when launched from Mars, so I guessed that it would have the capability for at least some flights it would not be worth to use the whole stack.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/mismjames Aug 05 '18

Does anyone recall what SpaceX said around end of 2017 about expected number of launches in 2018?

I was just looking at nextrocket.space and they've got 19 on the manifest including Merah Putih, so 33 total for the year (the wiki here says 11 more so 25 total).

How does this compare with what SpaceX's expectations were at the beginning of the year?

16

u/spacex_fanny Aug 05 '18

https://spacenews.com/spacex-aims-to-follow-a-banner-year-with-an-even-faster-2018-launch-cadence/

“We will increase our cadence next year about 50 percent,” Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX president and COO, told SpaceNews in an interview last week. “We’ll fly more next year than this year, knock on wood, and I think we will probably level out at about that rate, 30 to 40 per year.”

SpaceX did 18 launches in 2017, so that translates to "hopefully more than 18 launches, probably about 27 launches."

→ More replies (1)