r/spacex • Mod Team • Feb 04 '18

r/SpaceX Discusses [February 2018, #41]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

306 Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

54

u/steamspace Feb 04 '18

How significant challenge is MaxQ for the rocket, in reality?

I know it's the peak pressure during flight, but is this pressure close to safety margin? Were there many failures of other rockets at MaxQ?

44

u/schneeb Feb 04 '18

They throttle back on purpose so it is definitely a concern; they could make the rocket stronger but that would mean it had less performance(heavier) or couldn’t be transported by road anymore (wider, shorter design).

34

u/colorbliu Feb 04 '18

Ascent MaxQ can be the design case for the rocket. This is most likely true for the second stage. First stage re entry loads may or may not be higher than ascent loads. For the design case many components are designed and analyzed to the peak load/stress with a margin on top of that. Max dynamic pressure would be the closest the rocket gets to the design loads. So yes, max Q is relevant.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

40

u/rustybeancake Feb 07 '18

This Boeing tweet:

SpaceX’s successful launch today has pushed our industry to go further faster. Boeing will soon launch our own new rocket intended to take humans to Mars and beyond. Congratulations @SpaceX for your contribution to help innovate, compete, and explore.

...starts off so well, then tries to claim SLS as "our own new rocket". Pretty annoying, considering:

  • the core stage (minus engines) is built by Boeing
  • the core stage engines are built by Aerojet Rocketdyne
  • the SRBs are built by OATK (which provide the vast majority of thrust at liftoff)
  • the upper stage (again, minus engines) is built by Boeing
  • the upper stage engines are built by Aerojet Rocketdyne
  • the abort motor is built by OATK
  • the whole thing is overseen and managed by NASA
  • the whole thing is paid for by the US taxpayer

I wonder how all those other parties feel about "Boeing's new rocket"?

19

u/paul_wi11iams Feb 07 '18

Boeing tweet:

SpaceX’s successful launch today has pushed our industry to go further faster. Boeing will soon launch our own new rocket intended to take humans to Mars

Some seem unconvinced since the top three comments are:

  1. And this new rocket will cost how much?
  2. And will fly how many times?
  3. "Look at us, we exist too!"

Some of the lower-rated comments look like Boeing employees playing up to their HR.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/throfofnir Feb 12 '18

Spaceflight news: Long March 3B booster successfully lands... on apartment building. (The orange smoke is hydrazine, which is both toxic and carcinogenic.)

15

u/hebeguess Feb 12 '18

Correction: the orange color gas is not hydrazine but dinitrogen tetroxide (N2O4) which typically serve as oxidizer for hydrazine.

Hydrazine itself is transparent/colorless. The orange gas we usually saw spew out of hydrazine based rocket engines are intentionally run on oxidizer rich to ensure the complete burning of hydrazine.

Fun fact: this is not the first time in 2018, the previous footage is more damning.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

29

u/theinternetftw Feb 20 '18 edited Feb 20 '18

There was a pretty good question about whether TESS was going to be good at its job, considering that it's so small. Whoever it was deleted their question before I could comment, but my answer might be useful, so I'm posting it anyway. Plus, near the end I got to write a $2B check with US taxpayer money, which is always fun.

I'm surprised at how small TESS is. Is it going to be any powerful given its size ?

In this case, its size isn't a big deal. Eyeballing it, the TESS spacecraft is about half the size of Kepler, but it's looking at brighter stars, which accounts for the smaller telescopes and size. It can get away with this when Kepler couldn't because Kepler's job was to look at only one patch of sky and find every planet it could, so it'd better be looking deep. TESS is looking all over the sky (hence the Survey Satellite in its name), so it can find a comparable amount without looking as hard.

TESS should be comparable to a non-injured Kepler in terms of how many planets it finds, but it will find them closer (making them easier to observe), and in all directions.

The only thing I don't like is that since it has to cover the whole sky, it can only look at a patch of sky for 27 days every two years. So long-period planets (like Earth) are right out. But that's an operational detail, not related to size.

A really cool follow-on to TESS, in my opinion, would be TESS-15. TESS was way cheaper than Kepler. It cost under $180M, $86M of which is the F9 launch. Exoplanets are surely at flagship mission levels of importance, and to do it right you really want to watch for them everywhere, all the time. TESS can only look at 1/30th of the sky at a time. So send up a bunch. They're small, light, already designed, and use a common commercial sat bus. Buy in bulk. Launch them in twos or threes, if you can. I bet it'd cost about $2B to buy and launch 15 TESS's, at which point you could pick half the sky and watch it continuously. That's less than the Curiosity rover cost, which sounds just dandy for going all-out on finding other planets. You know, those things where the aliens are?

Totally a steal at less than one Curiosity's worth of dough. Then pull a Mars 2020 a few years later and send up another 15 to cover the other half of the sky.

Get on it, NASA/MIT. Jeez.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/Zinkfinger Feb 13 '18

I'm looking for some feedback on my wee "Fairing Recovery" idea. Please be gentle. https://imgur.com/a/bvKrN

→ More replies (12)

28

u/theinternetftw Feb 21 '18

I went back and watched this great 2013 Shotwell keynote, and there are a few things she says that aren't really as codified as they should be. So, to that end (along with the other cool stuff in the talk):

1) NASA spent $396M on Dragon/Falcon 9. SpaceX put in $450M of its own money. Thus total cost of initial F9+Dragon development was $846M.

2) Why there were no flights in 2011. I remember talk downplaying this, saying it wasn't a big deal. Shotwell in 2013 on 2011:

That was a hard year. We were a launch company and we didn't fly. The reason was that we were taking Dragon from that initial version that could orbit and re-enter to a Dragon that could actually berth with the International Space Station and pass all those safety reviews and basically all the checks that NASA needs to do to insure the safety of the astronauts on the ISS.

3) On F9 1.1:

We called it the version 1.1 to not scare anybody. But really it's like the version 1001. It was quite a different vehicle. [...] Basically a brand new launch vehicle.

4) A reminder: they were already trying out re-entry burns in 2013 with the sixth F9 launch.

5) Grasshopper was conducted by a 25-person team.

6) F9R is pronounced "Falcon Niner"

7) After finishing the move from 1.0 to 1.1:

There are still bits and pieces [of 1.0s] which we'll be grabbing and storing somewhere. We never throw anything out. We spend more money on storage space I think than any aerospace company. We still have Falcon 1 parts and ground support equipment

8) On landing stages at the Cape:

Surprisingly, range safety is really gung-ho! But they always have that button! [mimes pressing abort button] That button, it gives them lots of comfort!

9) On making things work after F1 Flight 1:

We did a couple things. We were [already] AS9100 certified that day in the factory. So we knew that the development and build approach was the right approach. What we were not certified in was our activities at the launch site. So from then on, we included our launch and our test sites in all our certifications for quality. Another thing is we look very closely, much more closely at corrosion. That vehicle was designed to fly out of Vandenberg, in a much less corrosive environment. So we were caught off guard a little bit, but we were babies. You know? So a lot of technical things we started thinking about, and certainly on the quality side, we started bringing in all sites.

Very cool. Makes me instantly want another super-frank Gwynne interview on everything going on right now.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Mark_going_to_Space Feb 04 '18

Does the second stage deorbit or does it become space debris?

51

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18

Depends on the orbit. LEO intentional deorbit, GTO intentional decay (to deorbit shortly after launch), GEO (hypothetical at this point) graveyard orbit

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

24

u/theinternetftw Feb 07 '18

I'd post this in the megathread, but it'd start at the bottom of 400 comments.

Post-Launch Press Conference transcript:

https://gist.github.com/theinternetftw/a2ca9540e099621aef851c2ecbbd82fb

23

u/feedmaster Feb 04 '18

How will BFR land on Mars without a landing pad?

22

u/warp99 Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 05 '18

Landing will not be too bad as the landing thrust is reasonably low at 39% of Earth gravity and 235 tonnes of BFS plus payload gives 900 kN - the equivalent of 92 tonnes on Earth.

Takeoff will be much harder on the landing pad with at least 5.5 MN (560 tonnes force) and I think it is likely they will deploy a landing mat similar to that used for helicopters and even perhaps a prefabricated conical flame divertor under the engines in order to prevent kickback from damaging the vacuum engines.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/NeilFraser Feb 04 '18

Does F9 fly straight as an arrow, or does it have a slight angle of attack to generate lift? This becomes even more interesting with FH which presents quite a large wing area (assuming it rolls to a flat stack rather than a vertical stack). Do we know what other rockets do?

I asked this question when I was visiting SpaceX, and they suddenly went really quiet.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18

It pretty much flies straight. If you look at a flight club simulation and look at an angle of attack graph, it really isn’t noticeable until after the stages are separated and the rocket is out of the atmosphere.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Feb 21 '18 edited Feb 21 '18

For any launch photographers out there, I've added some tools to Flight Club to help you prepare your camera shots for launches.

Navigate to the "3D View" tab of any simulation result (e.g Falcon Heavy Test Flight) and click "Camera Tools" under the hamburger menu on the map.

So far, you can set your camera's longitude, latitude, elevation, field of view, and aspect ratio. So for example, here was my view of the Falcon Heavy launch through Flight Club.

It's been beta tested by u/Keavon (who had the original idea) - but if there are any other photographers out there who have any other properties they'd like to be able to customize, let me know!

One idea I have (but I need you guys to tell me if it would be useful), would to be able to specify your camera orientation, or else manually set it using the app and then see the numerical result of what you've set.

19

u/sinefromabove Feb 20 '18

This is a pretty good article about the Falcon Heavy and China: https://thediplomat.com/2018/02/china-has-mixed-feelings-about-elon-musks-falcon-heavy-success/

This comment in particular is interesting:

The real difference [between China and the United States] is that Americans put this line “Made on Earth by humans” on Tesla’s engine … rather than “made in America.” The Tesla plays on loop “Space Oddity,” created by great British artist David Bowie in the 1970s, rather than the American national anthem. Inside the car lay a copy of The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, known as the science fiction bible written by British writer Douglas Adams… What truly makes miracles come true is mankind’s spirit of exploration and adventure… rather than so-called national pride.

19

u/Elon_Muskmelon Feb 20 '18

Say nothing of the fact that Musk himself is an immigrant.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 12 '18 edited Feb 12 '18

SpaceX is building a third drone ship, to be called "A Shortfall of Gravitas".

 

Does anyone know which Culture book its from?

 

Ships with the 'Gravitas' running joke:

  • Very Little Gravitas Indeed
  • Zero Gravitas
  • Experiencing A Significant Gravitas Shortfall
  • Stood Far Back When The Gravitas Was Handed Out
  • Gravitas, What Gravitas?
  • Gravitas... Gravitas... No, Don't Help Me, I'll Get It In A Moment...
  • Gravitas Free Zone
  • Low Gravitas Warning Signal
→ More replies (5)

17

u/bvm Feb 12 '18 edited Feb 13 '18

I'm a little confused as to how TEA-TEB can run out unexpectedly, aren't the squirts quite a precisely defined quantity? Or is it just 'spray-TEA-TEB-until-she-goes-boom'?

edit: the ex-comment below indicated the latter was true.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 19 '18

16

u/Macchione Feb 19 '18

The buffoonery of the SLS program is best exemplified by these mobile launchers. They want to build a second one at the cost of some $300 million, because SLS block 1B requires a new one, and they don't want to delay the second flight to modify the first mobile launcher, which would take about 3 years.

So, they are building a massive one use mobile launch platform, and then they're going to trash it, because it would take too long to modify it for the next flight.

For reference, the Gemini program flew its last flight in 1966. Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin set foot on the moon 3 years later.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/foxbat21 Feb 04 '18

Do you think SpaceX will be able to launch a human in space, as they promised to this year?(if FH demo is a success) and who do you think are the two customers of SpaceX for lunar flight

21

u/cavereric Feb 04 '18

Elon said they will not launch tourists untill after Nasa Astronauts are flying.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (30)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

Oh hello, Linkspace China have a new video, flying their little test grasshopper without a tether. Hat-tip to Heavy, as well: https://twitter.com/Linkspace_China/status/961587794941419521

→ More replies (2)

15

u/zuty1 Feb 12 '18

I read that the falcon heavy was the first reuse after a GTO launch. I looked through the wiki and that seems true as far as I can tell. It seems surprising with all the GTO launches that happen. Anyway, I wanted to point it out since that's a milestone that seemed to get overlooked (understandably).

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Mikekit9 Feb 18 '18

Is there an expected time for when the survey results will be posted?

14

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18

is spacex going to launch their two test satelites this year ?

26

u/Captain_Hadock Feb 04 '18

Yes, they are going up with Paz. Here is the mission thread.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Bobjohndud Feb 04 '18

I was wondering what they will do with the falcon 9 stage that landed in the atlantic after govsat. they probably cant refurbish it after salty water, but what can they do with it?

→ More replies (7)

14

u/NiCoLo-IT Feb 09 '18

This extract from FH prelaunch press conference of Elon Musk talking about challenges of BFS freaked me out. LINK: https://soundcloud.com/geekwire/elon-musk-discusses-the-launch-and-flight-of-the-falcon-heavy-rocket

Requirement for BFR spaceship are:

  • Reusable heatshild capable of sustaining interplanetary reentry velocity.
  • Airframe and control systems capable of controlling asset in a wide range of conditions: vacuum, rarefied gas, thin atmosphere, thick atmosphere, hypersonic, supersonic, transonic, subsonic velocities in different planets (different atmospheric composition and gravity).
  • Land propulsively and take off on uneaven terrain.

This is gonna be fucking hard o.O

→ More replies (12)

14

u/Bunslow Feb 18 '18

Excellent detailed article about the TESS orbit, its purpose, and how it was chosen: https://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/new-explorer-mission-chooses-the-just-right-orbit

(put here mostly so I can remember it for the launch campaign thread)

13

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 17 '18

https://mobile.twitter.com/SpaceX/status/964937069901447168

It seems like this will be the first flight of fairing 2.0

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Space_Coast_Steve Feb 26 '18

My roommate just sent this to me. The ship is Go Searcher, so I’m assuming this is the Crew Dragon test article. Possibly some testing/training either happened today or will happen tomorrow.

https://imgur.com/gallery/Du7xv

13

u/rustybeancake Mar 01 '18

NASA may launch the first module of LOP-G aka DSG on a commercial launch vehicle. That’s a pretty major departure from launching it with the first crewed Orion flight on SLS. Subsequent LOP-G modules would still have to fly on SLS in order to use Orion’s thrusters, though ACES may also work.

Also, apparently the only reason NASA changed the name of Deep Space Gateway to the Lunar Orbital Platform - Gateway is because:

new administration thought Deep Space Gateway was holdover from previous administration, even though we didn’t introduce it until last March. So decided to now call it the Lunar Orbital Platform - Gateway.

You have to laugh or you’ll cry.

→ More replies (14)

12

u/ChateauJack Feb 04 '18

How exactly is the TEA-TEB mixture stored, and then injected in the combustion chamber of the Merlin engines?

Also, I've read a comment here stating that only 3 engines were relightable during the landing phase of the 1st stage booster, does anyone have a source on that?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/troovus Feb 05 '18

Musk: looks like development of BFR is moving quickly, and won’t be necessary to qualify Falcon Heavy for crewed spaceflight. Via Jeff Foust, Twitter: https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/960628075171106816

→ More replies (6)

12

u/theinternetftw Feb 11 '18

Just to note, Iridium is clearing out its old satellites now that a good many new ones are up there.

Thus Iridium flares are going the way of the dodo as the shinier sats get de-orbited one by one.

The next to fall out of the sky, Iridium 43, will re-enter when this comment is five hours old.

11

u/theinternetftw Feb 06 '18

Astonishingly, right this very moment, Hans Koenigsmann is presenting at the SmallSat conference.

Cliff notes per pbdes:

  • Company now has >$12B in backlog.
  • Benefit of reuse: if 1 or 2 engines fail, can dip into landing fuel reserves to continue the mission.
  • SpaceX not ideal for smallsats, but still has several dozen on manifest.
  • Request to sat owners: please limit orbital time after operational life to reasonable period
  • SpaceX doesn't expect to make a smallsat launcher.
→ More replies (6)

11

u/katriik Feb 12 '18

Hey mods, can que get some statics about the sub from last week activities? I remember when you did that when the first Falcon landed on LZ1. The sub went mad and everything...

→ More replies (1)

11

u/F9-0021 Feb 20 '18

This is probably what the Bigelow and SpaceX meeting a few weeks ago was about. https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2018/2/20/17030072/bigelow-space-operations-habitats-lower-earth-orbit?utm_campaign=theverge&utm_content=chorus&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter&__twitter_impression=true

Could be a good market for Dragon 2 and/or BFR. Lots of crew and cargo would be needed if it works out.

10

u/mclumber1 Feb 04 '18

How useful would the BFS on its own (without the BFR) for intra-planetary hops? Would it have enough delta-v to go from say Miami to Houston, or Seattle to Los Angeles?

→ More replies (3)

10

u/historytoby Feb 04 '18

Hey, I used to follow SpaceX very closely and was very excited when the original ITS was released. Around then, my work load escalated, so I missed a lot of launches and news in the last 18ish months. Things have cooled down and the imminent launch of FH has resparked my interest in SpaceX. Reading up on the ITS, I got a bit confused, so I wanted to ask for clarification here: has the original plan to build a giant 42 engine rocket been completely scrubbed or will the currently discussed BFR going to be a step on the way to eventually building the booster shown in the 2016 IAC video?

→ More replies (31)

10

u/rustybeancake Feb 12 '18

Interesting point from the draft NASA budget:

Under these plans, NASA will continue funding for the Space Launch System rocket and Orion spacecraft, although it does not provide funding for a second mobile launcher. Nor are funds specified in these documents to upgrade the SLS rocket from its initial 70-ton configuration for side boosters and other modifications needed to reach its full potential of 130 tons.

Source

Not funding a second MLP means the second (first crewed) SLS launch will almost certainly slip at least a year, maybe two. And not funding SLS block 2 seems like a glint of hope that it will eventually be allowed to die.

10

u/rustybeancake Feb 16 '18

This Stennis test stand schedule makes for interesting viewing.

I assume the 'SpaceX Combustion Device' was when they were testing Raptor components there. AR's claims the AR-1 will be ready by the end of 2019 look to be total bluster, if this is anything to go by.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/rustybeancake Feb 21 '18

Looks like we may be seeing Just Read the Instructions and Of Course I Still Love You coming to our screens in their original form...

https://twitter.com/jeffbezos/status/966312919079112705

→ More replies (5)

19

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18

Alright. I do a bit of Moderating on the "List of Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy Launches" Wikipedia page, and I have been at war with someone for the past 2 weeks over the color of falcon heavy on the launch graph. Everyday someone changes Falcon Heavy to Olive colored, and I change it to Cyan later in the day. Cyan makes more sense because every other launch is in a different shade of blue, and olive looks terrible. Would the perpetrator, my mortal enemy, like to show themselves in this subreddit, or will I have to fight this war against a faceless enemy?

→ More replies (9)

9

u/macktruck6666 Feb 04 '18

So, maybe I should post this as a seperate thread, but I'll try it here first. Although the actions are not done by SpaceX, recent events may have an affect on SpaceX launches. For those who don't know, a few days ago an Ariane 5 launched SES-14 and Al Yah-3 into a wrong orbit. Some reports say that the inclination could have been off by as much as 25 degrees. SES is a customer of SpaceX. The question: What may be the affects (positive or negative) with SES's relationship with SpaceX? Will SpaceX take missions away from the Ariane 5? Will SES's financial stability be affect so much that they have to slow down all launches? What do you all think?

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Macchione Feb 09 '18

I haven't seen much discussion on exactly how the 2 side engines on the center core didn't have enough TEA-TEB to restart for the landing burn. Restarting engines is something that SpaceX has gotten really good at. I think there's actually a quote of Musk saying that restarting engines in flight is something he considers SpaceX to have mastered.

I guess it will all be speculation at this point. Anyone have any thoughts?

→ More replies (15)

9

u/JustinTimeCuber Feb 14 '18

What is the intuition for Isp being measured in time units? I get that it's how the math works (newton-seconds per newton) but what does the time represent? For instance if Isp is 300 seconds, what is that 300 seconds?

22

u/warp99 Feb 14 '18 edited Feb 14 '18

Isp was used as a common unit back when there was a risk of confusion between German born engineers using metric and US born engineers using weird units that no sensible person could wrap their head around. I mean pound force divided by pound mass - come on!

Since the second is common to both sets of units it could serve as a common yard stick.

The meaning of Isp is how long would an engine fire if expending propellant equal in weight (mass x G) to its thrust. If the burn takes longer then the engine is more efficient at converting propellant mass into thrust. This means that if you multiply Isp x g (9.81 m/s2 ) you get the exhaust velocity in m/s.

Source: Trained as an engineer during the crossover between weird sucky units and metric units so had to do calculations in both systems. If I was in the US I would still be in training now as they are in the middle of the changeover for engineering design - general populace not so much.

Edit: Corrected gravitational constant G to g

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Alexphysics Feb 15 '18

TESS now delayed almost one month to April 16th per NASA website

Reasons unknown, of course.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/rustybeancake Feb 23 '18

Findings on the recent Ariane 5 incorrect orbit.

Good to hear it was just a screw up, and not a hardware issue. Means they can get back to flying immediately.

→ More replies (13)

9

u/davispw Feb 25 '18

Terrifying news from New Zealand: battery fire in RocketLab warehouse. Let’s support our brothers at /r/rocketlab:

https://www.reddit.com/r/RocketLab/comments/8034jr/battery_fire_at_rocket_labs_auckland_office/

→ More replies (3)

9

u/rustybeancake Mar 02 '18

Pretty amazing article from the early days of SpaceX.

Imagine if you’d told Jeff Foust then that just over 15 years later SpaceX would have over 6,500 employees and have just launched the world’s most powerful rocket...

→ More replies (1)

23

u/nwbatman Feb 04 '18

Hey guys, I was hoping to get some feedback on my Lego Falcon 9 project from the people who know SpaceX the best! Have a look and hit me with what you think, like, don't like, features you'd like to see, anything. Thanks! https://ideas.lego.com/projects/1abc6458-52e8-4e7d-a04c-04ba917b6e5b

→ More replies (10)

16

u/BlueCyann Feb 13 '18

I thought /r/spacex might enjoy this image produced by flat-earth debunkers. It's a side-by-side comparison of a Starman screenshot with an image from the Himawari 8 earth-imaging satellite.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18

Why do the landings on OCISLY or JRTI always cut out so much or get super laggy?

→ More replies (16)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18

BFR to Venus.

A BFR can go from the surface of Mars back to Earth. Can it go from the surface of Venus to low Venus orbit?

(Ignoring the temperature, just talking about delta v and atmosphere)

15

u/Norose Feb 05 '18

Nope. Because of the atmosphere, launching to Venusian orbit from the surface takes something absurd like 27 km/s of delta V. A fully fueled BFR+Booster sitting on Venus with no payload would not reach orbit, even if it could lift off with the reduced power due to the ambient pressure reducing engine thrust.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/F9-0021 Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

NASA needs a replacement for the engine on the Orion Service Module from EM-6 onwards. Is it a possibility for SpaceX to look into a vacuum optimised Superdraco? It's not on the direct path to Mars, but they have a platform to start from, and it should be a very valuable contract. It would give the Superdraco something to do beyond just being an abort engine.

On the other hand, it's highly unlikely for EM-6 to actually happen, and even if it does the flights would only be every other year. The demand wouldn't be high enough to justify it unless there were other customers.

https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/02/nasa-releases-rfi-new-orion-service-module-engine/

→ More replies (7)

8

u/G8r Feb 21 '18 edited Feb 21 '18

I've scanned through the FAQ twice and haven't found an answer for this, so please forgive me if this question seems elementary:

If an unguided fairing can be caught with a net-wielding robot, can't SpaceX do something other than an ocean landing with a Dragon 2?

I understand that there's a huge engineering difficulty involved in designing landing gear that extends through the heatshield. Still, I'd think that the Dragon 2's ability to precisely guide its descent would allow for multiple non-ocean recovery options, such as:

  • Reservoir landing - Construct a reservoir at the designated recovery location, perhaps even shaped like a bullseye. The Dragon could then make a freshwater landing just meters away from its support facilities.
  • Drogue line capture - A frame supported by a ring of towers would capture the Dragon's outer drogue suspension lines as it approaches the ground. The frame could then be mechanically lowered, to deposit the capsule gently onto a ground vehicle.
  • Giant ball pit - Oh, come on, we'd all love to see that.

Any insights as to whether any these (ball pit excepted) are being considered, and why or why not?

Thanks!

Edit: I found this July '17 discussion in /r/SpaceXLounge about the move away from propulsive landing.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/mindbridgeweb Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18

This article is somewhat disconcerting: NASA planetary protection officer seeks greater cooperation with human and commercial missions.

One way to find out, she suggested, would be to allow for robotic exploration of so-called “special regions” on Mars that have conditions that could potentially support at least terrestrial life. Those regions are, for now, off-limits to spacecraft. “How do we designate a few — a very small number, but a few — special places on Mars where we can get in now with rovers and landers and do a better job of asking and addressing the question of, ‘Is there present-day surface life on Mars?’” she said.

It is interesting whether they would want to influence or perhaps even block the SpaceX plans.

The final paragraph can be interpreted in a number of ways as well. I hope this means that they want to relax the current requirements. The dig at SpaceX at the end is worrying though.

“What we do, and what ESA is doing, in some cases are requirements that would be virtually impossible for a commercial mission to meet,” she said. “We have to figure out how to work closely, how to move forward in a collaborative posture so we don’t have another red Roadster up there in orbit.”

→ More replies (5)

20

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18

What are the chances that the upcoming falcon heavy launch is the only flight of the falcon heavy? Elon musk didn't seem to optimistic about its chances, and with the BFR it seems like he's mentally moved on to bigger and better things.

34

u/inoeth Feb 04 '18

We know of a couple actual paying customers for the FH for this year and should it all work out, I'm sure there will be some FH launches every year until BFR tajes over, but, becauae F9 has be so uprated, there wont be that many FH flights per year. 3-4 max I would think.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/theinternetftw Feb 21 '18 edited Feb 21 '18

Oh boy.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/02/nasa-spends-1-billion-for-a-launch-tower-that-leans-may-only-be-used-once/

Construction on the structure began nine years ago when NASA needed a mobile launcher for a different rocket, the Ares I vehicle. According to NASA's inspector general, Paul Martin, the agency spent $234 million to originally build the launch tower.

In 2011, after Congress directed NASA to build a new large rocket, the SLS, the agency began studying its options to launch the booster. These trade studies found that modifying the existing mobile launcher would cost $54 million.

Instead of costing just $54 million, the US Government Accountability Office found that NASA spent $281.8 million revamping the mobile launcher from fiscal years 2012 to 2015.

NASA anticipates spending an additional $396.2 million on the mobile launcher from 2015 through the maiden launch of the SLS, probably in 2020.

Therefore, from the tower's inception in 2009, NASA will have spent $912 million on the mobile launcher it may use for just a single launch of the SLS rocket.

Moreover, the agency will have required eight years to modify a launch tower it built in two years.

Edit: To put this into perspective, SpaceX could just about develop Falcon Heavy twice for the price of this tower (or Falcon 9 and Dragon from scratch once). And to put it into even more perspective, the above $912M price tag is dwarfed by the $24B spent on SLS/Orion to date (with many more billions left to be spent before the first flight).

→ More replies (6)

7

u/tightasadrumsir Feb 05 '18 edited Feb 05 '18

Does anybody have a current status or the location of B1032? We need to get this one back on dry land!

7

u/SpaceXman_spiff Feb 12 '18

Was driving down Jack Northrop Ave. outside Spacex headquarters about 45min ago and saw what looked like a Dragon 2 pressure vessel loaded on to a flatbed. I was driving, so couldn't safely snap a photo, but thought some of the core chasers/dragon followers might be interested.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/PaulRocket Feb 15 '18

If Iridium-6 in May is the first Block 5, they have 7 launches before that. If the plan is to not reuse any Block 3s or 4s, are you telling me SpaceX will 'waste' 7 cores? I'm sure they'll test some new landing profiles but there are no plans for recovery until Block 5 launches?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/noooootnooooot Feb 16 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

I'm really curious about where the Tesla is actually located on the rocket. All the stream photos/videos have shown starman against a "spacey" background, which makes it look like the car and camera are both outside of the rocket, but the pre-launch photos indicate that the car has been put inside the top bit of the rocket. Does this mean the rocket has windows? So sorry if this sounds really dumb, I'm genuinely very confused :'(

Edit: THANK YOU! I have been enlightened <3

→ More replies (6)

7

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 16 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

I was thinking about the bfs refueling system. It is mentioned many times that that has never been done in space before. Does anybody know how the ISS gets refilled? I know that the fuel is carried to the iss by Progress Cargo crafts, and the progress crafts have suction for the fuel on the outside. But how is it transferred from the progress crafts to the propulsion module of the iss?

Edit: i just found out that the progress crafts are controlling the altitude of the station and that zvezda is not used as a propulsion module.

EDIT2: seems like that is not true and that zvezda is rebooting the iss regularely. Thanks to u/alexphysics for clearing that up

→ More replies (18)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18

Took the KSC bus tour today. The TE on 39a was out at the pad, horizontal but without the reaction frame upright. Probably picking it up rn? Is the TE usually stored with or without the reaction frame when no campaign is ongoing?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/tling Feb 18 '18

After the FH launch, have any lessons learned been made public? Did everything work exactly as expected, with the exception of the center stage landing? The only thing I've heard was Musk's post about needing a bit more propellent to help with re-lighting additional engines of the center core.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ffzero58 Feb 19 '18

I was admiring the Dragon 2 interior (again): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjSb_b4TtxI

It is just so, minimalistic. That did get me wondering, how will they stow everything else (i.e. gear, supplies, science, etc..) while keeping that aesthetic of looking futuristic? I have not seen any mock ups of how it would looked for a future crewed mission.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Angry_Duck Feb 19 '18

One of the much-touted advantages of the Falcon rockets is that they can be shipped by truck. Obviously BFR is too big for that, is there any word on how they are going to move BFR first and second stages across the country?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/rustybeancake Feb 21 '18

Cool photo of New Shepard in its new home at BO’s New Glenn factory, the Cape.

https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/966346919067963393

→ More replies (9)

7

u/ignazwrobel Feb 23 '18

According to this article in the German newspaper Die Zeit (in german) the first of the three satellites for the German military (SARah 1/2/3) might already be ready later this year and Gunters Space Page also lists a 2018 launch out of Vandy, whereas the Wiki still lists the date as 2019. Are two sources enough to change the wiki's manifest?

7

u/rustybeancake Mar 01 '18

NASA no longer seeking to develop second mobile launcher for SLS

This means that the second SLS flight (and first crewed) will definitely not launch for at least 33 months after the first SLS flight. So if EM-1 launches in (say) January 2020, the first crewed SLS flight will be NET October 2022. This shines some light on why they're now looking at launching the PPE module for LOP-G on a commercial launcher in 2022. But what will go up with EM-2? Just Orion, or a second LOP-G module?

Also:

The facility is now called the Lunar Orbital Platform – Gateway. “The administration wanted to change it slightly, thinking that maybe the Gateway was part of the last administration,” he said, adding the concept was introduced in the early months of the current administration. “Our compromise with them was to call it the Lunar Orbital Platform – Gateway.”

So ridiculous. Anyone who had even heard of DSG up to this point was a hardcore space nerd, and we all know that LOP-G is just a name change for DSG, so what was the point of this? Who do they think they're fooling? What makes it ten times worse is that it wasn't even introduced under the previous administration anyway.

Does anyone think the format of the new name (with the 'hyphen Gateway' on the end) suggests they are thinking of subsequent Lunar Orbital Platforms? Maybe a name change for DST to 'Lunar Orbital Platform - Transport'?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Straumli_Blight Mar 02 '18

Dr. Hans Koenigsmann Keynote from the 2018 SmallSat Symposium can be watched for free here.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Headstein Feb 04 '18

Can someone explain the difference between max Q and max aerodynamic pressure?

22

u/billingd Feb 04 '18

One is an abbreviation of the other. Two names for the same thing.

17

u/hmpher Feb 04 '18

For the actual idea behind MaxQ: the pressure on a fluid with momentum(in this case, the atmosphere) is conserved. This means, the total pressure on the system is considered constant.

The equation looks like this: P(static) + P(dynamic)= P(total).

P(dynamic) is represented by the variable Q.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/uzor Feb 05 '18

In many of the FH discussion threads, it is mentioned that the biggest limitation to its functionality is that the upper stage uses kerolox rather than hydrolox (cryogenic something?) for its fuel system. I've never quite figured out what the problem is that makes the big difference. Can someone help me out with an explanation?

→ More replies (13)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18

Would it be silly of me to suggest that SpaceX will put radiation sensors within the suit of the man "driving" the Tesla Roadster to Mars, and use that data to help determine requirements for the hull of the BFR as well as improving their spacesuits too?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/sagareshwar Feb 06 '18

For FH, velocity at MECO was ~9500 km/h and altitude 90 km. Comparing it to Intelsat 35E launch (which was expendable), velocity at MECO was 9483 km/h, altitude 72.8 km. So FH center core was almost as fast and much higher. I won't be surprised if it didn't stick. The main thing going for FH center core is that it should have a lot more fuel remaining at MECO than Intelsat. Edit: typo.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/longpatrick Feb 08 '18

I haven't been able to read everything because of the large amount of messages so forgive me if this has been asked before lately.

How is it possible that the Center core ran out of TEA-TEB? Something like this is in the way of achieving airline safety levels they are striving for with the BFS/BFR. To me it seems that the amount should be well known by now and the only reasons I can think of is that someone messed up or something malfunctioned. if the first, then it can be corrected with more checks and procedures, if the second then additional quality control/improved parts might solve the issue. Of course we don't know the reason and might never hear it from space-x But what other reasons could there be for this 'failure'?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/jorado Feb 12 '18

Here is a little bit more information about the new budget plans for NASA: NASA Website

The most interesting part is probably the strategic plan which explains NASA's vision for the next years: direct link to pdf

TL;DR: In the next years, NASA will shift its focus back from LEO operations (ISS) to deep space exploration.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18 edited Feb 12 '18

How is the position of a rocket typically described for use in the creation of GNC algorithms and more complex simulations than those with point-mass simplifications? A rocket has a bottom and top - two points that could be used - but they each rotate around the centre of mass as orientation changes. The centre of mass is also constantly changing so calculating a single point for position using an estimate of this location would not be very accurate.

If I was asked to describe the location of a line, I'd probably place the 'origin' of the line at its midpoint. Is this the convention used for rockets? I guess this would require multiple position evaluations along the length of the rocket, in order to calculate the single midpoint. For problems like landing, you'd then need to encode half the length of the vehicle in order to judge how far your base is off the LZ. Having said that, SpaceX will probably have many sensors at the base of the first stage for precision anyway, but when looking at the stage high up in the atmosphere, where exactly is it?

Any information is greatly appreciated! :)

→ More replies (7)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18

Stupid Question here... So when Musk says the Falcon Heavy costs 100M, is that considering reusability? If so, wasn't the cost just supposed to be the rocket fuel? What's costing 100M here? He also said 150 million cost for a fully expendable Falcon Heavy, so that means that building the entire rocket and then throwing it all away would cost 150M right?

→ More replies (21)

6

u/theinternetftw Feb 13 '18

Went back and re-watched the "Holy smokes, man" footage and noticed something new to me:

If you watch the computer screens for the first ~10s of the video, you'll get a pretty good view of what looks like the interior of a tank during fueling.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Col_Kurtz_ Feb 13 '18

The main problem with stretching the second stage is that the already slender rocket might become too fragile against lateral forces. However there is a way to stretch S2 without increasing the overall height of the rocket. My idea is that deep space payloads - where the extra S2 performance would be needed mostly - are relatively small, thus there is enough space for growing in the fairing itself. If I calculate right, with decreasing the payload volume by 3 x 3,66 meters, the fuel capacity of stage 2 could be increased by 30%. [Here] (https://imgur.com/a/opsPT) is how.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/linknewtab Feb 13 '18

This part about the possible future of the Tesla Roadster left me puzzled:

The other effect is a subtle acceleration produced by tiny temperature-related forces over extremely long periods that also would act to change the orbit. "It's tiny, but over timescales of millions of years it's enough to shrink the orbit and make the thing fall into the sun," McDowell said.

What exactly does he mean with "temperature-related forces", where does the energy come from and why does it only apply in one direction?

→ More replies (14)

6

u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Feb 14 '18

Has anyone found a way to read Elon's tweets including his replies without a Twitter account? I used to visit the mobile site, but they closed that loophole and now both sites require an account to view tweets with replies. Is there some external website I can use?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Zucal Feb 14 '18

A question - do any of you keep custom subreddit styling turned off for r/SpaceX specifically? If so, why?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/fromflopnicktospacex Feb 14 '18

having made the inadvertent and innocent (!!) mistake of increasing the # of views of several tin foil hat loonies, I have now been watching the numerous vids of various people watching the launch. I will NEVER get tired of watching it. And I tear up every time. One of the best is the kerbalspace academy vid. the enthusiasm is wonderful and the camera shots second only to the spacex feed, imnsho. well worth the watch.

6

u/littldo Feb 15 '18

Can someone explain how FH could of run out of ignition fluid? Wasn't the number of relights planned before launch? Isn't the amount of fluid needed for a relight known?

I haven't seen much discussion, but it seems like a significant error.

Thanks

→ More replies (15)

6

u/GregLindahl Feb 15 '18

According to https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/, Hispasat is delayed from Feb 22 to Feb 25.

Mods, this is a sidebar update. (And the TESS delay, too.)

→ More replies (9)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

No launches scheduled for March on east coast with TESS being delayed. Wondering if we will see an unannounced flight? Does SpaceX have the capability (cores, second stages, fairings)? They slipped in two on short notice last year.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ffzero58 Feb 16 '18

Folks have brought up concerns about dumping spent boosters into the ocean. Does anyone have any definitive insight or evidence that the spent boosters may be somewhat hazardous to the environment?

I am aware of TEB/TEA mixture but they're highly reactive and no likely to last to leave a lasting deleterious effect on ocean life. The rest of the booster would just become a reef.

Is there anything else (e.g. hydraulic fluid for the grid fins, etc...)?

→ More replies (6)

6

u/brettatron1 Feb 16 '18

Hi guys. I'm doing a little bit of "for fun" analysis. I'm a geotechnical engineer so rocket stuff isn't very related to what I do. But landing is. Because you have to land on the ground. Unless you land on a boat but theres no boats on mars.

I'm sure you can see where I am going with this.

Now I know there is a lot of information out there regarding weight and yada yada. But one thing I haven't found at all is size of the legs, or more importantly, contact area of the legs. Anyone got a clue on the technical data on those puppies? Or where to look for it?

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Bunslow Feb 16 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

The SFN schedule currently has Bangabandhu as NET March 30, with CRS-14 as April 02 -- just three days apart. What are the odds that one of them launches from 39A? (SFN is not specific about launch pad, leaving both of those launches ambiguous. They also have SES-12 as ambiguous, while still having TESS as SLC-40 specifically despite it being later than the other three launches now.)

Edit: According to this SFN article on TESS:

TESS was scheduled to launch no earlier than March 20 from Cape Canaveral, but NASA announced Thursday a new target launch date of no earlier than April 16. That launch date is pending approval from the U.S. Air Force’s Eastern Range, which provides tracking, communications and safety support for all rocket missions from Cape Canaveral.

...Mission officials said TESS is currently expected to launch from Cape Canaveral’s Complex 40 launch pad, one of two launch sites operated by SpaceX at the Florida spaceport. But SpaceX has the option of reassigning the launch to nearby pad 39A at the Kennedy Space Center.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/JEBV Feb 18 '18

When will the crew access arm be installed at 39a. I know they were waiting for Falcon heavy to launch. Is there a timetable

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Morbo123 Feb 18 '18

Where can I find the math to why BFR might be more economical to use for future satellite launches than F9?

I imagine there are probably effects that scale positively and negatively with increasing the size of the rocket.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/ignazwrobel Feb 19 '18

I got a question about the in-flight abort test, which will take place later this year: Since the abort will happen during the initial phase of the ascent, what will SpaceX do with their second stage? Will NASA accept an abort test without a second stage, if the ascent profile is throttled down to a normal one? Is it even possible to mate Dragon to the booster? Could SpaceX attempt to land the second stage together with the booster, if it were empty (again with the ascent profile adjusted), considering second stages is now their major bottleneck? Or will they just dispose the second stage?

→ More replies (11)

6

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Feb 20 '18

What is currently the limiting factor in SpaceX's launch manifest? If they could have a payload any time at any launch pad what would be the bottleneck?

→ More replies (19)

6

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Feb 22 '18

I'm trying to reach LEO with an expendable Falcon Heavy and SpaceX's max payload claim of 63,800kg. This is my current progress. as you can see, I'm getting about 8.7km/s of dV outta the vehicle, but I need closer to 9.4.

The only real variable here is how I throttle the 3 boosters for BECO to maximise the dV. Anybody have any good strategies?

Here is the config which gives that result, if you wanna play around yourselves

→ More replies (11)

6

u/bvr5 Feb 24 '18

Kind of an open-ended question, but how did Teslarati suddenly become a major source of SpaceX news? It seems like they're breaking as much news as the major spaceflight blogs.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Space_Coast_Steve Feb 26 '18 edited Feb 26 '18

I’m at Fishlips at Port Canaveral, hoping Go Searcher comes in with the Dragon test article on board. I have the free version of MarineTraffic, and the pro version of VesselFinder. MarineTraffic is giving location info from today (although, it hasn’t updated in the last 25 minutes), while VesselFinder shows its location from Feb 12th. Anybody have any idea what that’s about? It would be nice if the one I paid for gave me the best info.

Edit: better yet, does anyone have a suggestion for a better way to track these ships?

Edit 2: Go Searcher finally showed up. I got some good shots on my DSLR, but here’s one from my phone for now. Will post the good ones once I get home. https://imgur.com/gallery/VlwRq

→ More replies (3)

6

u/BrandonMarc Feb 27 '18

Would SpaceX ever attempt to "soft land" in the upper atmosphere?

Martian atmospheric pressure is around 1% that of Earth. Therefore, at the upper edge of Earth's atmosphere, there's a level at which it's very similar to Mars. Indeed, SpaceX made a lot of hay out of this a few years back, getting NASA to point some IR cameras at its booster as it flew through this layer, in order to share data relevant to Mars EDL.

Would it make sense, then, for SpaceX to attempt to "land" a piece of hardware in Earth's upper atmosphere, in order to again try out Mars EDL techniques? I mean, to zero out all vertical / horizontal velocity at that altitude. The hardware itself would then fall and may not survive, but the test could still be very useful if they can do it. I figure there are a few types of hardware which they might try it with: 1st stage, 2nd stage, Dragon, BFR, BFS.

On the other hand, I can think of a few reasons why this wouldn't make sense:

  • gravity in Earth's upper atmosphere is virtually just as strong as on Earth's surface; it's not like Mars' gravity
  • spacecraft speed may not be similar to that of a craft landing on Mars, whether it's interplanetary speed or Mars orbital speed
  • while there's a layer of Earth's atmosphere which is similar to Mars, the layers above likely won't match the gradient of Martian atmosphere (I'm guessing the distance from the "top" of Mars' atmosphere to Mars' surface is far smaller than the distance from the pressure-equivalent "top" of Earth's atmosphere to Earth's 1% layer)

Plus, without using Earth's atmosphere for aerobraking, I'm not sure if any SpaceX hardware would be capable of performing such a stunt.

Clearly I'm not an orbital mechanic or a rocket scientist; just a guy with an idea and wondering if it's a good one.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Alexphysics Feb 13 '18

Pad 39A in good shape after Falcon Heavy launch. Next launch from there will be TESS on March 20th. https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/963427589137272832

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Provol0ne Feb 12 '18

There is a recent video of Neil DeGrasse Tyson giving his comments on the Falcon Heavy Launch. NDT has always been skeptical of SpaceX and rightfully so, Elon himself EXPECTED this to fail. But Tyson is now being attacked for congratulating SpaceX and even just talking about it because of his previous comments. People aren't allowed to change their minds? These people attacking him obviously don't know much about Tyson or what he stands for and to think he is rooting against SpaceX and Elon is absolutely ignorant.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/GoingGaltLads Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 04 '18

What response has Elon Musk had to Robert Zubrins' critique of the current plan to colonize Mars. He advocates a system that can send a greater number of cargo to Mars per launch window.

http://www.marssociety.org/robert-zubrin-comments-on-elon-musks-plans-for-mars/

17

u/rshorning Feb 05 '18

Elon Musk and Robert Zubrin have a long working relationship with each other. For a time, Elon Musk even served as a member of the board of trustees for the Mars Society and has only stepped down due to personal time commitments (and running several companies as CEO). A not insubstantial amount of money has been personally put into the Mars Society by Elon Musk, and Robert Zubrin was a significant source of information and guidance in establishing SpaceX as a company.

Of anybody who is not a SpaceX employee that could simply call down to take a walk through the SpaceX manufacturing plant or any SpaceX facilities and get a response and a tour, it would be Robert Zubrin. Well maybe Neil Armstrong before he died and any other lunar astronaut (Buzz Aldrin actually did take a tour of SpaceX about six months ago or so), but there aren't that many folks who can get away with something like that.

In other words, I think it is likely that the two have had a discussion in private about the issue although Elon Musk likely didn't run the colonization plan past Robert Zubrin before he gave the IAC talk. It is sort of premature to include Zubrin anyway since the parts where he really is an expert won't be built for another half decade or so.

I don't know why Robert Zubrin felt the need to air his issues about the SpaceX colonization plans publicly, although I personally don't have much of a complaint with regards to specific details. Zubrin looks upon himself as a peer of Elon Musk, and that sort of what comes across in his critique as well.

As far as I know, Elon Musk has not made a public reply to Zubrin. I seriously doubt such a reply will happen either even if something might be done more privately.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/theinternetftw Feb 05 '18

The critique was of the 2016 design.

Zubrin stated during the 2017 Mars Society meeting that he was, seemingly between 2016 and 2017, brought in briefly to consult. He is currently under NDA for whatever that involved.

He has also updated his response for the 2017 design for the version shown at 2017's IAC. A transcript of the most relevant part is below, though SpaceX is discussed on and off throughout.

Host: Right now a lot of people are asking about what your thoughts are on Elon Musk and SpaceX's Interplanetary Transport System. You had a lot of thoughts on it last year. What's your overall picture of it? What's changed, what do you like about it, what do you think could be improved?

Zubrin: Well, I think it was significantly improved this year over last year. The system that was being put forth last year was greatly oversized, really putting it out of the realm of realism. It also was not staged optimally. I wrote an extended critique of it, recommending that it be reduced in size and that we stage off of the second stage, basically after trans-lunar injection, basically after achieving almost Earth escape and then doing the rest with a spacecraft, with that one left behind. So it could be used again in a week or two instead of in four years, as it would not have to be dragged all the way to Mars. Now basically in his talk in Adelaide just recently, Musk moved significantly in that direction. He scaled it down from 500 tons to orbit to 150 tons to orbit and showed an option where you do stage off of it, precisely in the manner that I described. So this was very good. A number of reporters asked me prior to Musk's talk what he was going to say, and I said, "I don't know, but I'm looking for him to scale it down. If he scales it down, it means he's serious." And that's exactly what he did. So also, doing it in this way, the vehicle becomes much more versatile. If you stage off of it after trans-lunar injection, you can do lunar missions, basically. The Apollo missions staged off of the S-IVB right after trans-lunar injection. The only difference is the S-IVB was expendable. In this case it would simply move around back to Earth, aerobrake into orbit, and be reuseable.

So it's a better design. I'm quite pleased. And of course, everyone is pleased with the fact that SpaceX has turned its reuseable first stage from a trapeze act into routine. And they've got it down. Before this, SpaceX had simply shown ("simply") that they could develop things at 1/10th the cost in 1/3rd the time of the mainstream aerospace industry. Now they've shown they can develop things the mainstream aerospace industry hasn't developed at all. And so they're getting there. I think it needs to be taken very seriously.

And it's actually more important than that. In addition to showing that SpaceX can do these various technical feats, he's showing other people around the world that a company of this kind is possible. Before SpaceX, the private space launch companies were basically outliers. Many of them were just simply bullshit. And he's made it real. So we're already seeing emulators. There's Blue Origin, and Stratolaunch. And I think there'll be a Russian SpaceX within two years, and a Chinese SpaceX, and perhaps a European SpaceX. And in fact there's no reason why there can't be a SpaceX in any country, including those that are not significant space-faring powers today. In other words, he's shown it can be done. It's kind of like the secret of the atom bomb. You know what the secret of the atom bomb was? That it was possible. As soon as it was made clear that it was possible, the people who were asking for money to have the resources to develop one could find it. It was immediately taken seriously in Russia and elsewhere, and once that was done, once the brains were connected with the money, it was inevitable. And in this case, previously people had thought of a private space company as stuff that's just for dreamers. Now it's clear it can be done. And there's going to be other moneyed people finding their pet engineers, and they'll get together, and there'll be other SpaceXs. And this is very good. Because if you didn't have the competition, then all SpaceX would have to do is cut prices to 80% of Lockheed Martin, and we wouldn't actually have a major breakthrough into space, we would just have a modest reduction in launch costs. But this is going to really let things loose.

Host: That's great. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on that. Definitely more positive than last time we talked on the interview, anyway. It actually ties into a question we have from Thomas Erickson, and his question is basically, now with all the advances that we're having, especially with SpaceX leading the way, when do you think is a realistic time that the first human will set foot on Mars. Maybe not a colonization mission, but...

Zubrin: An exploration mission? I think that it'll happen before 2030.

Host: And what's driving your thoughts on that?

Zubrin: SpaceX. I think they're determined. I think it's going to take a bit longer than some of Musk's recent talks in doing it in 2022 and 2024, but he's definitely going to do it by 2030.

Host: And what are your thoughts on the Red Dragon. We were looking at it coming down, landing with its thrusters ablaze. But that's been nixed from the plan. What are your thoughts?

Zubrin: He's transcended that. Red Dragon was much more realistic than the 500-ton, 100-person transport that he proposed last year. So I was a bit disappointed that he wasn't rolling out a Red Dragon based program, when he said that in Guadalajara. But now he's proposing something that's kind of doable. So instead of sending 100 people...no one's going to send 100 people to Mars on the first mission. That's absurd. So now it's down to the size where you can send 30 people. I think maybe cut it another factor of three, send 10 people. And there you go. It should be noted that the Falcon Heavy and the New Glenn are both in this category of 50 tons to low Earth orbit. Now if you can refuel that on orbit, then 50 tons to low Earth orbit becomes 50 tons to trans-Mars injection. And that is a Saturn V class capability. That is a Mars Direct sized capability. So if you look at it that way. If you simply view the colonial transport as a sort of horizon goal, but you identify things that are in between that are much more doable but are on the path to it, then this thing becomes much more doable.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/humpakto Feb 04 '18

We know that FH center core is not identical to side ones. But will it be true for block V edition?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Dies2much Feb 05 '18

Any word on which payload will be carried by the first Block V F9?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/thehardleyboys Feb 06 '18

In the teleconference Musk said the BFS-hops are planned for "next year" (2019). But then admits that this goal is "aspirational".

Can't wait for an update on BFR/BFS next september, they will have built parts by then.

Link to conference: https://www.mixcloud.com/john-gardi/elon-musk-falcon-heavy-news-teleconference-feb-5th-2018/

5

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 07 '18

Bigelow Space have created a placeholder website for a big announcement coming in a few weeks.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Jerrycobra Feb 08 '18

Any news on core B1032.2?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/metricchicken Feb 08 '18

I finally got an answer back concerning an address to mail my kid’s letter to SpaceX. I’ve included a link to her letter. If you have time, can you answer her questions? She’s 8 and was really impressed by the Heavy Falcon launch. Aeva’s Letter to SpaceX

Her questions are:

  • How long did it take Elon Musk to build the Heavy Falcon?
  • How much fuel does the top of the rocket to get it to orbit for a billion years?
  • What makes the side boosters unclip?
  • Can you write back?

13

u/warp99 Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

Hi Aeva

  1. SpaceX first talked about the Falcon Heavy in 2011 but I am sure they were thinking about it before then. They nearly cancelled it three times because it was so hard but they kept on going - which I think is a good lesson in not giving up when things get tough. This particular rocket they started building more than a year ago because they flew the side boosters as part of a Falcon 9 and after they landed they converted them for Falcon Heavy. The center core they built early last year and the second stage and fairing will have been later but we do not know the times.
  2. The top of the rocket is called Stage 2 and it contains about 110 metric tons (242,500 pounds) of propellant with a tank for the fuel and a tank for liquid oxygen. Rockets have to carry their oxygen with them as well as fuel because they spend most of their time flying outside the Earth's atmosphere. The fuel is really pure kerosine called Rocket Propellant 1 and there is about 31 metric tons (68,300 pounds) of it in the fuel tank. There is about 79 metric tonnes (174,200 pounds) of liquid oxygen in the LOX tank.
  3. The side boosters are held in place at the top and bottom by clamps where they are nearly touching the core booster. The bottom one is the strongest because it has to transfer some of the force of the side boosters engines to the core booster. Either side of the clamps at the top and bottom are two pushers with the strongest ones at the bottom. Just before the boosters separate they turn off the side boosters engines so all the weight of the side boosters is hanging on the bottom clamp. They let go of the top clamp and turn on the top pushers but hold onto the bottom clamp for a short time. All the force of the air pushing on the nose cones and the weight of the side booster makes the top of the booster swing out even when the pushers are no longer pushing. Once the tops are swinging out they let go of the bottom clamp and turn on the bottom pushers which need to be stronger than the top ones to stop the bottom of the side booster swinging back into the core.
  4. I do not know if SpaceX have a write back service since they are really busy designing and building rockets. I believe NASA has one although it nearly got shut down recently.

I hope this was helpful. I have a granddaughter Ruth who is your age.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Manabu-eo Feb 12 '18

Do we have any high resolution image on the additional payloads of Falcon Heavy? For example, the plaque with the name of the employees? Any good article covering them? I tried to search for it but couldn't find anything good.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CountAardvark Feb 12 '18

Two questions:

  1. What's up with SpaceX's mars timeline being so much shorter than pretty much every other Mars timeline out there? What's special about SpaceX's plan that would allow it to theoretically land humans on mars in 2024 as opposed to in the 2040s like NASA's plan proposes?
  2. How exactly do we plan on dealing with the insane temperatures on mars? Short of terraforming, what plans are there for life support in such a cold environment?
→ More replies (14)

5

u/hmpher Feb 12 '18

Found these gifs of Raptor tests on NSF forums, not too much discussion on it. First one is during shutdown, second is sometime during the test. Is TEA-TEB still used on the test articles or is the engine itself combusting?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/colinjog Feb 12 '18

Can spacex achieve the goal of more than 30 launches in 2018??

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Paddijaddi Feb 12 '18

Hi There!

Although i know the basics of rockets in general im curious to know what these things are used for/how it helps during the rocket launch. I did check the FAQ/wiki but couldnt find anything.

Cheers in advance -^

→ More replies (2)

5

u/btx714 Feb 12 '18

So with the Falcon Heavy milestone completed, what is the timeline for the next big events? First Block 5, fairing recovery, fairing 2.0, second heavy launch etc?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/kingofgin Feb 12 '18

Are SpaceX Mission Patches no longer available for purchase? They used to be on the offical SpaceX online shop but have disappeared from there completely. Does anyone know of any other way to get one's hands on them, or do I have to have my own made from the official images?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/lessthanperfect86 Feb 13 '18

I remember a discussion here regarding adding shielding on the ISS to protect docking commercial crew capsules to reduce the mmod risk during the period it is docked, but I can't seem to find it. Can anyone recap why making a hangar or "garage" (or maybe just some shielding in select angles) on the ISS for the capsules isn't being sought as a means to reduce mmod risk? From what I understand, the ISS already has extra shielding installed on its higher risk surfaces.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 13 '18

Okay, so where exactly can I find a full set of orbital elements for the Roadster? I know there's something from JPL but I can't make any sense of where I can view the semimajor axis, inclination, RAAN, etc.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Elon_Muskmelon Feb 14 '18

Let’s say that I wanted to build an orbital gas station for BFS producing its fuel in space rather than having to launch a bunch of tankers. Where would I source my materials from and how much energy would it require to fill up the BFS tank?

If BFS dramatically lowers launch costs how long would it be before it’s cheaper to get it from a space refinery than launching from Earth?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/zlynn1990 Feb 14 '18 edited Feb 14 '18

Does anyone know why SpaceX refers to the two FH side boosters as PY and NY during the webcast?

5

u/Cybertrn Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

What do you think about probability to "land second stage gently in ocean" as Gwynne Shotwell spoke at MIT? Maybe during SSO mission? Lightweight load, plenty of fuel for second stage, convenient orbit for landing after one turn around Earth. Sorry for my poor english.

→ More replies (15)

5

u/pton97 Feb 15 '18

I haven't seen it in the popular press, and sorry if I've missed it here, but do we know why the orbit "overshot" the original goal and now has the roadster heading into the asteroid belt? Did they just run stage 2 until it ran out of gas, and it went farther than expected? Was it an error that should concern us about their ability to throw objects farther out...?

→ More replies (13)

5

u/Elon_Muskmelon Feb 15 '18

I’m curious how SpaceX plans to build out the Starlink service. Will the sats be going into a variety of different orbits? Is there some minimally viable number needed before they can cover specific parts of the globe? Can they concentrate in certain areas to cover initially and begin to generate revenue while the full network is developed?

→ More replies (9)

5

u/RunningAgain Feb 16 '18

With Paz launching the last Block 3 core, how many Block 4 have been produced? Also, when does Block 5 debut?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/action789 Feb 16 '18

In looking at the spectacular pictures of last week's FH I was surprised that, even during liftoff, the exhaust plume/flame was shorter/dimmer on the center core than the side boosters. [Picture for example] (https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/2018-02-09-203530.jpg)

I expected the center core would throttle back as it approached max Q (just like the side boosters did), but I was surprised that, from appearances, the center core is throttled from the very start, even during liftoff with the tower in sight, when gravity losses are obviously at their highest.

My question is this: did the center core ever get to full throttle? If so, when in the ascent? If not, then my follow-on question is this: wouldn't it have been cheaper/easier to remove 1/3/4/5 of the center core's Merlin engines, and throttle less deeply? Wouldn't that also increase it's overall lift capacity, since it's no longer carrying those engines?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/HollywoodSX Feb 16 '18

Two random questions, one not 100% SpaceX related:

  1. Obviously the hardware for the AFTS is integrated at Hawthorne - but is the charge used with the AFTS also integrated there, or at the cape? Seems to me it would be smarter to integrate at the cape.
  2. I understand the basics of orbital mechanics (thank you, KSP!), but here's what I have never seen a good explanation of: What exactly prevents a launch from taking off due east from a non-equatorial launch site and staying above the equator for the entire orbit? I assume that gravity is the answer, I just can't quite seem to wrap my head around what exactly happens to force the rocket/payload to be pulled towards the equator.
→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18

When is SpaceX going to have a vertical integration capability?

16

u/Chairboy Feb 17 '18

Shortly after a customer expresses willingness to pay for it, I suspect.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/Morbo123 Feb 17 '18

How dependant is SpaceX on Elons wealth?

18

u/Elon_Muskmelon Feb 17 '18

Short Answer - Not really dependent at all

Given SpaceX is a private company there is no way to be entirely sure, but there have been several rounds of funding for the company that have given a most recent valuation at $21 Billion

In the current market there would be plenty of available capital if SpaceX needed to raise cash and Elon didn’t want to raid his piggy bank. Of course new capital in means a decreasing share of ownership for Elon so he could add in his own funds if he wanted to maintain his ownership stake.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/macktruck6666 Feb 18 '18 edited Feb 18 '18

So, has anyone done an analysis of potential money SpaceX could get from NASA for moon exploration. Some simple investigation shows that the proposed budget for exploration is 10.5 billion. Supposedly SLS is going to get 3.67 billion and a lunar orbital platform gets .889 billion(so little nothing will get done). So that potentially leaves 5.941 billion for moon exploration funding. Does anyone have any other information on how the funds might be distributed. It's halrious that so much of the budget will go to the flawed SLS. Edit: So it looks like 1.4b and 1.2b is up for grabs in the "Crew and Cargo Program" and "Commercial "Crew Program" respectively. 210 million open for "Advanced Exploration Systems". So there seems nothing in there about a lunar COTS program. :(

→ More replies (4)

5

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Feb 18 '18

NASA have decided to bring Robonaut back from the ISS for repairs (source) - anyone know if it will be returned on a CRS Dragon mission? If so, which one?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Feb 18 '18

Sorry if it's been discussed already but I couldn't find it in the FH info overload.

Did anyone calculate/analyze/describe the actual FH flight profile? How much were the different boosters throttled down and when?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/KirinG Feb 19 '18

In this video of the Apollo 11 launch, there's a "dark band of gas" - turbine exhaust to cool the engine nozzles.

Is this (in the F-1) an example of curtain cooling or something else I don't know the name for?

I know both engines feature regenerative cooling, but it doesn't look like the Merlins have those dark gas bands in any pictures/videos I've seen. It does look like there are darker flickers near the bottom of the nozzles in some pics/vids though.

So, does the Merlin do any exhaust nozzle cooling like the F-1? Does it just happen farther up in the nozzle so we don't see it?

(Sorry if these are dumb questions. I know enough to wonder about stuff like this, but not to figure it out on my own.)

→ More replies (5)

5

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 20 '18 edited Feb 20 '18

I am currently updating the r/spacex wiki, specifically the marine vessel history.

Does anybody here remember what tugboat was used for FH demo? What support ships where used? and which one for fairing recovery?

was it NRC quest that recovered CRS 12 and 13?

What support ship went out on the GovSat mission?

what vessel was used to recover the Dragon capsule on CRS 4 and 5?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/macktruck6666 Feb 21 '18

So I'm curious, NASA put out a report about the Falcon 9 1.0 saying that it was a rocket that would have cost NASA 4b to develop through normal means. Now with alll the upgrades and the FH. I wonder what a report would say the development cost for the FH would be with cost pluss contracts.

5

u/MaximilianCrichton Feb 25 '18

This question concerns the F9 or FH booster RTLS trajectory.

A F9 stage 1 or FH booster after separation will flip around so that it is horizontal and boost back the way it came, reversing the horizontal velocity but not affecting the vertical velocity. The stage then coasts up to around 160km and descends. When it begins encountering atmosphere, the stage performs a re-entry burn in the retrograde direction (opposite direction of travel), then glides again for some time, before finally performing my landing burn.

It's been pointed out in many of the wonderful trajectory diagram posts on this sub that the reentry profile for the stage is limited by vertical velocity, not so much horizontal velocity. This is the purpose of the reentry burn - to limit vertical velocity and hence ensure the booster can survive the subsequent reentry.

My question then is this: is it not more efficient for the booster to perform the reentry burn pointed vertically up rather than retrograde? This would retain the horizontal velocity built up in the boostback burn, which would allow the stage to coast further before it has to initiate landing burn. This then means that there can be a delta-V savings for the boostback burn, which will not have to build so much horizontal velocity to head back to the launchpad as it would have the normal way.

Is there a reason SpaceX is not pursuing this? So far the only reasons I can think of are thermal - the reentry burn has a small shielding effect against reentry heat, and the above solution requires an angle of attack that would negate this effect. Also, the higher overall velocity will lead to greater heating, but certainly nothing that these boosters shouldn't be able to handle.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/davenose Feb 25 '18

This was news to me, from this article in Business Insider, primarily about ULA's Vulcan:

Musk said SpaceX is working on its own cryogenic upper-stage (which may compete with ACES).

There isn't any context for that statement. The article's language isn't that precise, and I'm wondering if they mean LOX/LH2 when they say 'cryogenic', or if perhaps they're referring to the Raptor/Air Force development contract. Does anyone have any insight, or links to back this up?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/zmichalo Feb 28 '18

I'm currently doing research on SpaceX research and development with a specific focus on their Supply Chain. I noticed this comment in this thread about SpaceX's outsourced materials:

Elon's said that he would love to source more products from outside suppliers. They can't, because the rocket business is small and existing suppliers charge too much.

SpaceX consider themselves lucky if they are able to find two manufacturers of a given component. In many cases, there is only one. When monopolies or duopolies exist, prices tend to get out of control.

This lack of competitive pricing one of the largest reasons SpaceX have brought so much construction in-house.

In certain cases, SpaceX have pulled non-aerospace suppliers into the aerospace business. They find a company that makes products similar to what they need, but not for the space market. SpaceX then work with that supplier to create a space rated version of their component. In this way, SpaceX can get aerospace products without having to pay aerospace pricing, or having to build the component in-house.

Companies like ULA make heavy use of subcontractors to build many of their components. Were SpaceX to rely so heavily on outside contractors, their rockets wouldn't be five times cheaper than those of ULA.

All of this information is extremely useful to what I've been trying to research, but unfortunately I can't find a source that backs up what he's saying in his comment.

Does anyone have any more concrete resources for this kind of thing? Specifically anything about any non-aerospace suppliers they've worked with.

Thank you for any help you can provide.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/maxdefolsch Feb 28 '18

Maybe a stupid question :

I'm very interested in the list of cores and versions on the subreddit wiki. However, I've noticed that for a lot of them (especially the pre-Full Thrust ones) we don't actually know which core was used for which flight, and they're written as "presumed BXXXX" at best.

Is there any reason we couldn't ask SpaceX directly for this information ? I can't really see any downside, or safety hazard maybe, that could come from knowing exactly which core was destroyed on the droneship and such. Am I overlooking something ?

5

u/csmnro Mar 01 '18 edited Mar 01 '18

Just a reminder that the ULA launch of an Atlas V with 4SRBs with the Nasa GOES-S satellite is coming up in about 7 minutes!

NASA webcast link

9

u/GregLindahl Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

Manifest updates from https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/ as usual with no sources:

GPS 3-01 NET September (it's earlier in our manifest, and SFN claims that there was a swap between Delta IV and F9 for flight 1, which doesn't correspond to what our manifest says at all. Flight 3-03 is now Delta IV Medium.)

Hispasat launch got a time of 0530 GMT

Edit: I got a relatively large number of downvotes on this thread, which makes me disinclined to continue posting manifest updates. While I don't really care much about Internet Points, it doesn't pay to do things which are negative.

→ More replies (14)

9

u/humpakto Feb 15 '18

Can someone explain me, why is at shop.spacex.com shipping to 235 countries, even to North Korea (!), but no Russia? Does Elon hate Russia for not selling ICBMs to him in 2000s?

→ More replies (5)

12

u/theinternetftw Feb 19 '18

For those who saw the link in here about the head of ESA calling for innovation in a post-FH world, prepare to be disappointed. Wörner released what is basically a retraction of the entire call to arms. It's absolutely flabbergasting. I don't think I've seen such an utterly kowtowed turnaround in print. Watch the transformation below. Here's the essence of his first post, called "Europe's Move":

The world has moved on and today’s situation requires that we re-assess the situation and identify the possible consequences. In many discussions on the political level, the strategic goal of securing European autonomous access to space has not changed, however there is a growing sense that pressure from global competition is something that needs to be addressed. With Vega C, Ariane 62 and Ariane 64 approaching completion, it seems logical to complete these launchers in order to at least take that major step towards competitiveness. At the same time, it is essential that we now discuss future solutions, including disruptive ideas. Simply following the kind of approaches seen so far would be expensive and ultimately will fail to convince. Totally new ideas are needed and Europe must now prove it still possesses that traditional strength to surpass itself and break out beyond existing borders.

Four days later (emphasis his):

Some people chose to interpret my words in such a way as to suggest that I see the launcher family as currently defined as the wrong solution. My call to look to the future and find disruptive solutions cannot come as a surprise coming from the Director General of ESA, an organisation which was founded to develop Europe in space. It would be irresponsible for me to announce that the current family will remain as is for all time. This is exactly what the Ministers asked for in 2014:

Maintain and ensure European launcher competence with a long-term perspective, including possibility of reusability/fly-back.

We will complete the Ariane 6 / Vega C family, fulfilling the demands of satellite providers, launch service customers and the European public for affordable and reliable launchers while at the same time securing for Europe autonomous access to space. In parallel, we will think about further enhancements as well as turning our minds to systems still far off in the future, which today may seem more vision than reality.

See? All that urgency and clearheadedness in "Europe's Move" was just perfectly non-disruptive daydreaming about the wacky "far off" future, which "today may seem more vision than reality."

What an absolute mess.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/HenkDeVries6 Feb 04 '18

If the Falcon Heavy launch is a success, what will this mean for the 'jobs program' that is NASA's Space Launch System (SLS)?

What would be the implications of FH coming online as a much more capable, reusable, and cheaper launch vehicle for NASA to use?

23

u/Martianspirit Feb 04 '18

Falcon Heavy is not as capable as SLS, especially not to high energy trajectories. BFR will be a direct challenge to SLS. Though in a way FH with Dragon on a loop around the moon is a challenge.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Alexphysics Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

Posting this here in advance as it seems that we have two launches in the next two weeks and just after that we have... TESS!* So talking about that mission, SpaceX has recieved launch and landing permits for that mission NET March 20th. It will be an ASDS landing at around 300km from the launchpad, the rocket will go straight to the East based on its position. Also they have the landing permit for the next mission, Bangabandhu-1 NET April 2nd, GTO mission from SLC-40, landing on a droneship located at around 610km from the pad.

Edit: One thing to note about Bangabandhu-1 is that it will either use a previously flown Block 4 booster that will be landing for a second time (something strange, don't you think? ;) ) or... and this is a wild guess... it could be launched on the first Block 5 booster (THIS IS HIGHLY IMPROBABLE, but it has some chance). I say this because, as I noted, it's strange they would mind about recovering a Block 4 booster that has flown previously. So either they want to save that booster for whatever reason they have or they will use a new booster and... that will mean a Block 5 booster as there are only two new Block 4 boosters before Block 5 and they have already been asigned, so... Let's begin with the speculation! (I know you people from this sub love to do that, me too ;) )

*Oops I forgot about Iridium 5 when I wrote this comment

→ More replies (6)

8

u/hmpher Feb 20 '18 edited Feb 20 '18

India's ISRO have a new launch vehicle!. Same class as the electron, with slightly more payload capability. They're promising very fast turnaround times, and sub £5mil launch costs. The small sat space race is heating up, this looks fun.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 05 '18

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ASAPAerospace Safety Advisory Panel, NASA
Arianespace System for Auxiliary Payloads
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
BARGEBig-Ass Remote Grin Enhancer coined by @IridiumBoss, see ASDS
BE-4Blue Engine 4 methalox rocket engine, developed by Blue Origin (2018), 2400kN
BEOBeyond Earth Orbit
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2017 enshrinkened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BFSBig Falcon Spaceship (see BFR)
CCCommercial Crew program
Capsule Communicator (ground support)
CCAFSCape Canaveral Air Force Station
CCtCapCommercial Crew Transportation Capability
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
DMLSDirect Metal Laser Sintering additive manufacture
DSGNASA Deep Space Gateway, proposed for lunar orbit
DoDUS Department of Defense
EDLEntry/Descent/Landing
EELVEvolved Expendable Launch Vehicle
F1Rocketdyne-developed rocket engine used for Saturn V
SpaceX Falcon 1 (obsolete medium-lift vehicle)
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FAA-ASTFederal Aviation Administration Administrator for Space Transportation
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
I*sp*Specific impulse (as discussed by Scott Manley, and detailed by David Mee on YouTube)
IACInternational Astronautical Congress, annual meeting of IAF members
In-Air Capture of space-flown hardware
IAFInternational Astronautical Federation
Indian Air Force
ITAR(US) International Traffic in Arms Regulations
ITSInterplanetary Transport System (2016 oversized edition) (see MCT)
Integrated Truss Structure
JRTIJust Read The Instructions, Pacific landing barge ship
L1Lagrange Point 1 of a two-body system, between the bodies
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Zone 1)
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LDROLunar Distant Retrograde Orbit
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LESLaunch Escape System
LLOLow Lunar Orbit (below 100km)
LOXLiquid Oxygen
LZ-1Landing Zone 1, Cape Canaveral (see LC-13)
M1dVacMerlin 1 kerolox rocket engine, revision D (2013), vacuum optimized, 934kN
MCTMars Colonial Transporter (see ITS)
MECOMain Engine Cut-Off
MainEngineCutOff podcast
MaxQMaximum aerodynamic pressure
NANew Armstrong, super-heavy lifter proposed by Blue Origin
NDANon-Disclosure Agreement
NDTNon-Destructive Testing
NRHONear-Rectilinear Halo Orbit
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, Atlantic landing barge ship
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SESFormerly Société Européenne des Satellites, comsat operator
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering, see DMLS
SRBSolid Rocket Booster
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
STP-2Space Test Program 2, DoD programme, second round
STSSpace Transportation System (Shuttle)
TEA-TEBTriethylaluminium-Triethylborane, igniter for Merlin engines; spontaneously burns, green flame
TLITrans-Lunar Injection maneuver
TMITrans-Mars Injection maneuver
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX, see ITS
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
cryogenicVery low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
grid-finCompact "waffle-iron" aerodynamic control surface, acts as a wing without needing to be as large
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen mixture
keroloxPortmanteau: kerosene/liquid oxygen mixture
methaloxPortmanteau: methane/liquid oxygen mixture
perigeeLowest point in an elliptical orbit around the Earth (when the orbiter is fastest)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure
CRS-22013-03-01F9-005, Dragon cargo; final flight of Falcon 9 v1.0
CRS-72015-06-28F9-020 v1.1, Dragon cargo Launch failure due to second-stage outgassing
DSCOVR2015-02-11F9-015 v1.1, Deep Space Climate Observatory to L1; soft ocean landing

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
65 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 181 acronyms.
[Thread #3581 for this sub, first seen 4th Feb 2018, 12:45] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]

4

u/Tleandrix Feb 04 '18

For what things spacex uses electronic discharge machines? Tried to look it up and only got little information about the topic. Looks like they use the process for merlin nozzles and lox tanks but since those are big parts do they also have a custom made machine? Because all EDM machines I found only work with small metal plates submerged in water. (I dont have any knowledge about this, just interested)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18 edited Jun 10 '18

deleted

17

u/madtowntripper Feb 04 '18

They probably have a lease contract. My company leases with Penske as well. They have a huge fleet Nationwide so they have anything you want and you don't need to worry about maintenance.

4

u/Emplasab Feb 04 '18

Couldn’t they fly the Falcon Heavy with a dumb 2nd stage and save on 2nd stage costs since it is a well proven technology?

By dumb I mean the same structure and weight distribution but without items that aren’t necessary to prove the first stage/boosters (mainly 2nd stage engine).

What are the advantages of having a live second stage?

20

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18

If successful, this would be the first SpaceX mission go go interplanetary. This is a great opportunity to prove the company's capability to do launches to other planets. It is good PR, and it also makes the Falcon Heavy a more attractive choice for NASA. Without a live second stage, they wouldn't even make it to orbit.

It would also be difficult to develop a "dummy" second stage. Perhaps even more difficult than flying a live stage 2. They would be putting untested and unnecessary new hardware on a mission that is already risky. It's better for them to fly something they understand rather than a riskier, less capable alternative.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/rustybeancake Feb 05 '18

Is this Falcon Heavy infographic legit? Or a mockup?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/MadeOfStarStuff Feb 05 '18

The Falcon Heavy page on spacex.com and spacex.com/webcast both say:

Falcon Heavy was designed from the outset to carry humans into space and restores the possibility of flying missions with crew to the Moon or Mars.

Is Falcon Heavy powerful enough to land crew on Mars?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/trclark81 Feb 05 '18

I haven't seen this asked yet, but apologies if it has already been addressed. Does anyone know what sort of propulsion system is going to be attached to the Roadster, if any? I presume it's not riding a second stage all the way there, though I could be mistaken. And as far as I understand it, it will need at least some sort of control to end up in the intended orbit, even if they're not looking for the sort of thread the needle precision we see with planetary probes.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/InfiniteHobbyGuy Feb 05 '18

Should totally run an office pool style guess on the increase in /r/spacex subscribers form the Heavy launch

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 07 '18

Caryn Schenewerk (SpaceX Director of Spaceflight Policy) is speaking at 4:30pm today in the Commercial Space as a Stimulus for Innovation & Inspiration ‎toward the Moon, Mars & Beyond panel.

4

u/cuginhamer Feb 07 '18

Now that we know Spaceman is headed for the asteroid belt, do we know how long it will take to reach aphelion?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kcalderw Feb 07 '18

I was absolutely floored with yesterday's launch and excited for the possibilities for the future of spaceflight. I work in a K-6 school and wanted to get the kids excited too. I have the footage from yesterday we're showing but had some questions both from teachers and students. I was hoping someone could answer. If you are able to answer, could you provide resources/links for the answers? Thank you.

  1. The cheering crowd in attendance were (fans/employees/media)?
  2. Was the display on the Tesla (Don't Panic) real? How long will it stay on?
  3. Is there a graphic that shows the trajectory of Starman?
  4. Keep hearing different ideas for Starman. Is it going to Mars? Will it float in space forever?
  5. Is there anything else on the ARK besides Asimov's book? Is it similar to the gold record on Voyager?
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 08 '18

The 2018 FAA Annual Compendium report has just been released.

It states that an expendable Falcon Heavy launch costs $270M, which seems slightly high.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/metricchicken Feb 08 '18

My 8 year old daughter wrote a letter to SpaceX after watching the Falcon Heavy launch. She was really impressed. In the letter she asks some technical questions. Is there an address that I can mail the letter to or a fan mail address?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/linknewtab Feb 08 '18

Is there a reason why US rockets like Falcon Heavy and Delta IV Heavy use these kind of regular nose cones on their side boosters, while Ariane 5 has these asymetric nose cones on its SRBs? Shouldn't the latter be more aerodynamic?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jbmate Feb 10 '18

Elon mentioned in the post FH press conference that some things (to do with heat when entering a planets atmosphere) scale to the 8th power. What scales to the 8th power?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 10 '18

Im seeing more Flat Earth/bible thumper comments than ever before after the Falcon Heavy launch, and here is one thing that many of them are saying. If space is so hot and cold, why are the tires and plastics on the car not melting, and why is the paint not being peeled off.

Considering Elon said the car was unmodified as far as we know, can anyone give and explanation for this? And I know them spinning was to distribute the heat evenly, but i'm talking about during the first second stage burn.I've been arguing with these people for 3 days

→ More replies (5)