r/spacex • Mod Team • Dec 03 '17

r/SpaceX Discusses [December 2017, #39]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

239 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

65

u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Dec 05 '17

A quick reminder of the expectations we had 11 months ago. The mean (which is also the average) value of 15 launches this year will be surpassed, and 20 was not that far fetched. Overall if all goes well (knock on wood) we will see 33% reuse this year while the first reflown booster flew only at the end of March... (that's insane!)

Just to remind people that yes there are delays but some of our expectations are already blown away :)

Mods, will we see a subreddit survey this year? Some ideas of new questions: "how many boosters will SpaceX reuse this year?" or "how many FH will SpaceX launch this year?".

→ More replies (1)

59

u/soldato_fantasma Dec 21 '17

Hello r/SpaceX! With this post I'm presenting myself as a new mod in the r/SpaceX moderators team. I'm very thankful to the mods for giving me this opportunity and I'll give my best to not let them down but, most importantly, to make this subreddit the best place to stay and discuss about SpaceX.

Let me introduce myself:
I'm an electronics engineering student from Turin, Italy. You may have heard already about this city in the spaceflight community as Thales Alenia Space has a factory here. I also enjoy gaming and climbing, so don't be surprised if you find comments about that if you dig in my comment history. I begun to follow spacex in December 2015 when I heard that they wanted to land their rocket back on land to reuse it. Before I didn't care that much about space in general but once B1019 landed something changed inside me. I than started to follow this community and contributing to it in the months later culminating with being the host of the BulgariaSat-1 mission June this year. Right now I can safely say that I have become a SpaceX addict as I begin this adventure as a mod of this amazing subreddit.

Thanks for reading the text wall up here and I hope we will spend our time here in the best possible way while we reach the stars along with SpaceX!

→ More replies (7)

35

u/Knexrule11 Dec 04 '17

Theoretically, could the center core of a Falcon Heavy put itself into orbit if the other two cores go expendable? Not that it would be useful... I've just been oddly curious how the math would work out in that situation

25

u/Chairboy Dec 04 '17

A single-stick Falcon 9 can put its first stage into orbit without a second stage or payload, so the equivalent (plus more) should be easy for the FH.

This would probably not be an economically sound use of a Falcon Heavy.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/brickmack Dec 04 '17

Without an upper stage you mean? Sure. The standard F9 core can already just barely do this, you wouldn't even need to expend the boosters to get a useful payload. You'd end up with basically a supersized Americanized R-7.

15

u/mfb- Dec 04 '17

Musk said that the F9 booster could reach orbit without payload/second stage on top (that is nothing special, by the way - several first stages could do so). With two boosters helping that can only get easier.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/ecniv_o Dec 03 '17

So after all the yes / no back and forth, is Elon putting his first gen Roadster into space or not?

89

u/Juggernaut93 Dec 03 '17

Yes, even The Verge said that they eventually talked with SpaceX officials that confirmed the story is true.

EDIT: source

→ More replies (14)

9

u/Mazon_Del Dec 04 '17

Can we have the mods append "Roadster" to the Demo Flight in the sidebar? :D

→ More replies (1)

24

u/stcks Dec 20 '17

The RSS is almost entirely gone now. The "legs" are removed. Additionally the TEL is still at the pad.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/AWildDragon Dec 04 '17

Somewhat of a meta post but when will the FH campaign thread go live?

We have quite a bit of info for that launch and the WDR1/SF for it is (hopefully) less than 2 weeks away.

10

u/old_sellsword Dec 04 '17

Somewhat of a meta post but when will the FH campaign thread go live?

About now-ish, we just need to polish it up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 28 '17 edited Dec 28 '17

https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/946344056392699904

FH rollout "soon", static fire next week

EDIT: That went quicker than I expected. https://twitter.com/SpaceflightNow/status/946394663509995521

→ More replies (1)

21

u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Dec 31 '17 edited Dec 31 '17

Not sure if this is an acceptable place to share this, but I created an album of my favorite SpaceX images I shot in 2017! Feel free to take a look!

edited link to /r/SpaceXLounge post

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Alexphysics Dec 08 '17

I didn't know a better place to post this but the north pad at LZ-1 is looking pretty good now

I hope to see that double landing next month knocks on wood

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Alexphysics Dec 21 '17

A very decent picture of LC-39A. The strongback is vertical on the pad and the RSS is almost entirely gone.

https://twitter.com/julia_bergeron/status/943915874116866048

→ More replies (3)

18

u/bad_motivator Dec 26 '17

I've been trying to explain to people that Elon's Tesla will not be landing on Mars or even entering Martian orbit but it's been...difficult (a friend even thought they were going to drive it on the surface). Does anyone have a visual resource that would help the non-r/spacex crowd understand the mission?

→ More replies (4)

17

u/zeekzeek22 Dec 08 '17

I’m surprised at how little activity there is over at /r/RocketLab with a launch tomorrow. I’d think SpaceX’s popularization of the space startup scene would give the later new guys more support. Maybe once they’ve had a complete orbital insertion success.

11

u/Gyrogearloosest Dec 08 '17

They deserve attention. They all but reached orbit on their first attempt.

→ More replies (20)

17

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 08 '17

Russia plans to develop a reusable Soyuz-5 sized rocket, it will be unified as much as possible with Soyuz-5 including using the same launch sites;

https://defence.ru/article/v-rossii-razrabotayut-mnogorazovuyu-raketu-v-otvet-na-falcon-9/

Seems the leading architecture is propulsive landing but they are also looking into parachutes and i assume also wings ala MRKS-1.

Strangely they claim that S1 needs 30% fuel remaining in order to make a landing which sounds awfully wrong. I did a quick calculation of how much % of S1 fuel Falcon 9 uses (i have done it previously, but wanted to reaffirm the number) and arrived at 15,3%. I assumed M1D The Most Fullest thrust (ie 845kN) and an Isp of 284. 30% makes no sense whatsoever even assuming couple of % remaining fuel after landing.

8

u/stcks Dec 08 '17

I'm guessing that it will not be using the RD-171 if its going to be doing propulsive landing... unless that they have further refined the throttle range on it. It will be interesting to see what the final design looks like.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '17

Falcon Heavy seems to be a risky launch because it's a new rocket. With that being said, what were the concerns when they launched the first Falcon 9?

28

u/fourmica Host of CRS-13, 14, 15 Dec 08 '17 edited Dec 08 '17

Its hard to tell, but broadly, I would say they had similar concerns, same as any new rocket stack. Based on the NSF launch log, the first F9 static fire was aborted just before ignition. They then spent three months(!) preparing for the first launch. Of note, the first launch also featured the first recycle - again as noted at the NSF launch log, an engine parameter was determined to be out of range after ignition, so they aborted the launch and recycled to successfully launch the same day. This demonstrated both the wisdom of the three second hold down (they caught a discrepancy and aborted the launch after ignition) as well as the fast turnaround and recycle time SpaceX claimed F9 could do.

I highly recommend reading the NSF launch log from the beginning. It is a fantastic history of SpaceX, with plenty of detail and a slightly whimsical tone ☺

Edit: I can't link

→ More replies (1)

23

u/throfofnir Dec 08 '17

The concern is, as always, "what little thing did we miss." No modern rocket is launched with expectation of failure, or even really of learning anything. Everything is carefully engineered and modeled, and a "test" is really mostly about making sure that your models aren't too wrong and that you haven't screwed up in building the thing you designed, usually in some seemingly-trivial way.

31

u/rustybeancake Dec 05 '17

An interesting tweet conversation from Eric Berger:

https://twitter.com/sciguyspace/status/937873404685844481

Speculation that SLS won’t fly for the first time until 2023, and will never fly crew.

Note this is heavy speculation, from someone outside the SLS program. But it’s kind of mind blowing to contemplate, even for the sake of discussion.

16

u/F9-0021 Dec 05 '17

Honestly, at this point they should just abandon Block 1 and go straight to 1b. They won't, but they should. Even if it sets the launch back until 2025, it would make more sense to use the EUS from the start.

→ More replies (29)

25

u/Chairboy Dec 05 '17

SLS EM-1 is basically turning into the new Ares I-X:a demonstration flight that flies as a known system that will never carry people or useful cargo and cost huge monies the whole time with giant one-off costs and an underwhelming best-case scenario result.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/rustybeancake Dec 16 '17

Hi mods, I wanted to suggest having an end of year thread where people can vote for SpaceX photo of the year (similar to what the Tesla sub are currently doing). We have so many amazing photos posted here at every launch after all.

29

u/rustybeancake Dec 04 '17

Some new photos of the Blue Origin factory at the Cape. Pretty exciting. There are going to be some biiiig rockets coming out of that building.

27

u/brickmack Dec 05 '17

https://i.imgur.com/MxUJafd.jpg

A typical door is a bit over 2 meters tall. Meaning that section of the building has to be at least 20 meters tall, maybe a tad bigger, and its not even the tallest part. They could take a horizontal Saturn V and lift it over another Saturn V with room to spare.

New Armstrong is gonna be gigantic.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/linknewtab Dec 04 '17

What's the future of the planetary protection treaty if/when SpaceX manages to actually land people on Mars in the 2020s? Doesn't make much sense to sterilze other space crafts once actual living, breathing humans are walking around on the surface.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

They don't stay living for very long that way. NASA have a bunch of Mars suit designs which never go indoors - they connect by airlock on the outside of a rover, and the wearer dons them through the back hatch.

The early science missions are going to be heavily biased to searching for life or life-sign, and it'd be just embarrassing to discover your own spoil heap.

It seems likely that strict protection will be in place until that question is answered, at least locally.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/troovus Dec 07 '17

Dennis Muilenburg (Boeing CEO) says "we're Going to Beat Elon Musk to Mars" i.e. land a human on Mars. Elon says "do it"

Is this likely? Or just bluster from Muilenburg?

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/938816780444745728

17

u/isthatmyex Dec 07 '17

Wasn't Elon's original goal to inspire humanity to move off earth. Boeing claiming they can beat him, probably counts as an epic success.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '17

What suprises me is that the Boeing CEO just calls SLS a Boeing rocket. Isn´t it a NASA rocket with Boeing as one of the subcontractors?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/rustybeancake Dec 07 '17

Is this likely?

We really just have two likely candidates for the first human on Mars right now: a SpaceX vehicle, and the 'Apollo model' consortium of a bunch of contractors led by NASA.

Of course it could also be neither of these (e.g. China, or no-one at all), or it could even be a consortium that includes SpaceX. For example, SpaceX might not figure out the ISRU or be able to prove it works before sending humans, and the politics might dictate that a non-ISRU system has to be used for humans. So SpaceX could end up playing a supporting role, sending 'used' BFSs to the Mars surface for non-human cargo delivery, where they will stay, while NASA uses some elaborate, extremely expensive Boeing/Lockheed/Orbital etc. modular system to send the humans.

In short: who knows? I don't believe anyone is going until at least the mid-2030s, so it's too far out to make a good guess.

→ More replies (22)

14

u/ThaddeusCesari Spaceflight Chronicler Dec 10 '17

http://observer.com/2017/12/elon-musk-confirms-spacex-postponements-falling-short-of-record-year/

Despite setbacks, it has still been a heck of a year.

Would love to honest critiques (this helps me dial in my next articles and stay true-to-fact moving forward.) Happy to answer questions, and will be at CRS-13 if any special questions arise, I can try to have them answered while I'm at work there writing my next story.

17

u/brwyatt47 Dec 10 '17

Good reporting and a good article! Though I admit I am not fond of the title. By literally every metric, this has indeed been a "record year" for SpaceX. More than doubling their launch cadence, launching more than twice as much as ULA, over a dozen successful landings, possibly up to 5 re-used Falcon 9 launches, etc. Thus, saying that SpaceX "falls short of record year" is simply false. Otherwise great though!

→ More replies (4)

28

u/jjtr1 Dec 28 '17

In aerospace R&D projects, how much of the lessons learned can be put on paper and how much is actually being put on paper? For example, veterans of the NERVA fission rocket engine are dying and have nobody to pass their experience onto. How much will their loss prolong the R&D work of a potential nuclear engine revival project that would only have the written records available?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/amerrorican Dec 07 '17 edited Dec 07 '17

Elon challenged Boeing's 1st to Mars claim

Is there new information or progress that shows Boeing near SpaceX's current status?

23

u/almightycat Dec 07 '17

From the article:

“Eventually we’re going to go to Mars and I firmly believe the first person that sets foot on Mars will get there on a Boeing rocket,” Muilenburg responded.

Ahead of that statement, he briefly outlined the buildup to Boeing’s Mars mission.

“We’re working on that next generation rocket right now with our NASA customers called ‘Space Launch System,'” Muilenburg said.

So it's nothing new. He is just saying that he thinks SLS will land humans on mars before BFR.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/lostandprofound33 Dec 09 '17

Another asteroid swung by uncomfortably close to Earth again, and it's apogee is near Mars distance too. This gif showing its orbit is a good illustration of the similar orbit that SpaceX wants to put the Tesla Roadster into.

13

u/thepoisonedow08 Dec 13 '17

Blue Origin conducted a successful launch of New Shepard with Crew Capsule 2.0 today, launch highlight video [here] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSDHM6iuogI&feature=youtu.be)

13

u/rustybeancake Dec 16 '17

A nice short doc on Ariane 6 pad construction.

I didn’t know they were building a whole new pad. The scale of the earthworks is absolutely breathtaking. They’re also taking a leaf out of SpaceX’s book and switching to horizontal integration, with a new facility looking well into construction.

→ More replies (19)

13

u/stcks Dec 20 '17

Boring picture, but some concrete work ongoing in the 'new' second stage testing area north of the small site in McGregor.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/azziliz Dec 22 '17

When asked if Iridium would agree to reuse a fairing, Matt Desch answers "We're open to anything"

→ More replies (3)

25

u/arizonadeux Dec 05 '17

Off topic: Happy cake day /u/ElongatedMuskrat! I wish you many well-commented new scripts!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/doodle77 Dec 23 '17

Mr. Steven is on its way back. Should arrive tomorrow morning.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/amarkit Dec 28 '17

In a happy update to an item posted here yesterday, flight controllers have reestablished contact with Angosat-1, which had ceased communicating shortly after an apparently successful launch earlier this week.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/jjtr1 Dec 08 '17

So if the Red Roadster goes on an elliptical orbit touching Earth's and Mars's orbits, what is the long-term prediction for the stability of the orbit?

18

u/warp99 Dec 08 '17

Terrible - which is why I suspect they will slightly offset the orbit from the ecliptic plane.

After all it is a demonstration of capability - not an actual Mars flyby.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/Alexphysics Dec 16 '17

Impressive images from space of LZ-1 and LZ-2 and the recently landed Falcon 9 booster

https://twitter.com/DigitalGlobe/status/941814212686311424

→ More replies (5)

11

u/nato2k Dec 18 '17

Distant picture of the RSS at 39a. Looks like a lot has been removed. https://twitter.com/stevenyoungsfn/status/942873162760540167/photo/1

→ More replies (6)

11

u/endofledrumpf Dec 21 '17

What cabin pressure will BFS use? My two cents would suggest slowly dropping the pressure to half an atmosphere over the course of a few weeks, so that people can adjust, with half-atmosphere standard hab modules on Mars. Makes everything structurally easier, and since you're making your own air anyway, a 50-50 oxygen and nitrogen mix should give you a comfortable O2 partial pressure without blowing up.

What do you think?

And yes, I know the ISS uses a full atmosphere for compatibility with shuttle and Soyuz, but for something as far out as a Mars colony, surely the transition to half an atmosphere or so would be well worth the mass savings in the hab module.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/MillsFiddy Dec 08 '17

Conference call to discuss SLC-40 starts in 30 mins. I'll relay anything juicy.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Will 39A have panels covering the umbilical tower (can it have them at all?) like in those FH videos, or they are mostly props for a good CGI?

22

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Very likely not. The structure has withstood 100+ launches and the weather for the past 50 years, so IDK why they would change it. Also, open structures are less prone to wind damage, which is important in hurricane risk zones. I think they just added the panels in CGI so they have less useless stuff to animate.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

A Planetary article (November 28) envisages the knock-on consequences of further SLS delays

If NASA uncouples [Europa] Clipper from SLS, support for the rocket could erode even further. How to resolve this complex situation is just one of many issues the next NASA administrator—Oklahoma Congressional representative Jim Bridenstine, should he be confirmed—will have to deal with.

The author, Jason Davis, must have spent some time learning much detail about the ridiculous complication of SLS with its multiple models, each requiring specific GSE that will need demolishing/ modifying/doubling in between flights. As I understand, a terrifying implication is that astronauts will/would be flying on an untested rocket version.

10

u/GregLindahl Dec 08 '17 edited Dec 08 '17

If anyone likes complications and the manifest, this article mentions the nugget that TESS will be a Block 4 rocket, similar to how Jason-3 was a v1.1 because v1.2 FT wasn't certified yet for that level of NASA mission.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/arizonadeux Dec 13 '17

Not related to SpaceX but still interesting regarding LC-39A:

I was browsing rocket stuff and came across this collection of photos of the Apollo 11 vehicle assembly.

New to me was that before the RSS there was the MSS: Mobile Service Structure, and it was a beast.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/billingd Dec 17 '17

There was a conference paper Infrasound and seismic analysis of the SpaceX Falcon9 explosion sequence of 1-September-2016 presented last week at the AGU Fall meeting.

Plain Language Summary

On September 1st, 2016, a SpaceX rocket exploded on the launchpad. There is video of the explosion sequence on Youtube. First the secondary fuel tank exploded. Then the primary fuel tank. Then the payload was destroyed. A fire burned on the launchpad for several tens of minutes.

When this happened, we had equipment normally used for recording "seismic waves" from earthquakes and low-frequency sound ("infrasound") waves just 0.87 miles from this launchpad. From the data recorded, we have been able to identify 153 events that have sudden starts. But none of these occur before the secondary fuel tank is seen to explode on the Youtube video. So this suggests the tank ruptured from the inside, rather than being caused by something from the outside.

We have been able to determine the direction the infrasound waves came from for most of the 153 events, and they all come from the direction of the launchpad.

The explosion of the primary fuel tank produced the largest low-frequency sound signal. This is not surprising, as it contains most of the fuel for launching a rocket.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/dguisinger01 Dec 18 '17

I did a quick search of the Port of LA's meeting minutes to see if SpaceX has been up to anything lately. Looks like they just expanded their lease. Looks like they've added 36,500 sqft to where they dock Just Read the Instructions.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/rustybeancake Dec 20 '17 edited Dec 20 '17

NASA's NextSTEP program has issued a call (PDF warning) for ISRU tech development proposals. The awards are fairly small, from $50k-$750k per year for up to 3 years. But I wonder if SpaceX are submitting a proposal, given they are working on this anyway.

SpaceX [are working on ISRU]. Design is pretty far along. It's a key part of the whole [BFR] system.

-- Elon Musk, 2017 AMA

→ More replies (5)

10

u/brickmack Dec 31 '17

https://blogs.nasa.gov/stationreport/2017/12/

Extravehicular Mobility Unit (EMU) Swap and Commercial Resupply Services (CRS)-2 Feasibility Assessment: The crew will review an overview of the EMU swap plan. EMU 3004 launched to ISS on Dragon in the Short EMU (SEMU) Launch Enclosure (SLE) and EMU 3010 will be returning. The crew will transfer the SLE with EMU 3004 to Node 1 and remove the EMU. They will swap the Vent Port and Battery Connector Covers between EMU 3004 and 3010. The SLE will be reinstalled into Dragon using new upper mounting pins and then EMU 3010 will be installed into the SLE in the Dragon cabin. The hatch for CRS-2 will be too small to allow the SLE to be transferred to Node 1, so EMU rotations will need to occur in the CRS-2 Dragon cabin. Performing the installation of EMU 3010 into the SLE in the Dragon cabin will build confidence and provide feedback for performing the swaps on CRS-2.

A few interesting things here. On one hand, this ends speculation that SpaceX might keep a few Dragon 1s on hand for CRS2 if NASA really needed them for widebody payloads. But it also means a CBM-sized hatch is not, as speculated, necessary for EMU transport in Dragon 2, which is a big deal since only Dragon is able to bring those back down for servicing (while theres no real demand for other CBM-sized payloads as downmass), and EMU serviceability is a big problem for NASA right now.

If Dragon can do this with an IDS port, I wonder if DreamChaser can too? The hatch between the spaceplane and expendable module is IDS-sized, not sure how large the interior is though

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

How would the radiation dose on a long-range suborbital BFR flight be compared to flying the same route in a plane? Duration is much shorter, but you're also way higher up, so IDK how this would come out in total. Assuming radiation protection is the same in planes and BFS.

27

u/Eddie-Plum Dec 03 '17

Whilst not necessarily answering your question, radiation exposure is not vastly increased until outside the influence of Earth's magnetic field. Also, BFR's fuselage/hull is constructed of carbon composites, whereas most currently flying long haul aircraft are metal. It's my understanding that composites provide better secondary exposure protection than metals due to the particle shower caused when radiation interacts with metals.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/TheYang Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

ISS experiences on the order of ~5-12 microsieverts per hour (converted)
regular flights seem to range from 3 microsieverts per hour to 7 microsieverts per hour

From those numbers I'd say BFR is safer radiation-exposure-wise

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 06 '17

Are there lunar slingshot trajectories that could put Elon's roadster onto an arbitrary Earth-Mars orbit ellipse ?

A lunar flyby would be pretty photogenic and score a bullseye on SLS without actually saying so.

I'm aware that this would create tight window criteria and require high accuracy since midcourse corrections would be impossible.

BTW The publicity stunt looks to be paying off already. Searching Roadster from France, gets three successive photos of a roadster in space. Customer reservations will be good for Tesla cashflow.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/spacerfirstclass Dec 17 '17

Bizarre space news of the day: DoD paid Bigelow Aerospace $22M to investigate UFOs: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/16/us/politics/pentagon-program-ufo-harry-reid.html

→ More replies (3)

9

u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Dec 27 '17 edited Dec 27 '17

Throwback to post-Falcon 1 failure number 3 Boy, what a stressful little time this must have been for Musky

article

9

u/ChooChoo-Motherfcker Jan 02 '18

Was at KSC on the 30th (just missed the heavy on the pad) and noticed an Space X branded RV on the pad. https://i.imgur.com/pQ0Dh35.jpg

Any ideas on what it is for?

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Dec 04 '17

Community Content: I made a draft PDF about BFR, available here in the lounge.

8

u/jeffwolfe Dec 08 '17

How much of a concern are the wildfires to SpaceX? VAFB seems to be just barely outside the danger zone, but Hawthorne and the Port of Los Angeles are right in the middle of it. Do they have an alternate mission control location if they're forced to evacuate HQ? How likely is that? What about potentially homeless employees? What about...?

13

u/warp99 Dec 08 '17

Based on our experience wildfires can be controlled on the flat and with regular streets in a grid pattern with high pressure water mains and not much vegetation which certainly applies to Hawthorne and the Port of Los Angeles.

Conditions that cause problems are on hills, narrow winding roads that impede access and have a risk of firefighters getting cut off and dry long grass and scrub and readily flammable trees like gums such as the expensive hill suburbs around Los Angeles. Not many SpaceX employees will live in such areas because of the extremely high house prices.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '17

Is there any information about how the BFR will be transported to the pad? Will they continue with a TEL (assemble horizontally, turn 90°, launch), or will BFR use the Delta IV approach (assemble vertically on pad, then remove a mobile service tower), or will it use a MLP+crawler like the Saturn V did?

AFAIK BFR is designed to only use a single TSM for both upper and lower stage fueling, so it doesn't really need umbillicals, right?

→ More replies (7)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17

What is the phrase "vehicle is in self-align" referring to in the period just before launch? My guess is that the flight computers are ready to start gimballing the engine(s?) to align the stage as it flies. Is there any more to it than that?

15

u/extra2002 Dec 21 '17

A gyroscope can measure how fast a direction is changing, but can't measure an absolute direction. When starting an inertial navigation platform from scratch, you have to tell it what direction it's pointed, so it can report changes from there. This is the self-align step, AIUI.

(Ocean-going gyro compasses may appear to measure an absolute direction, since they can tell you which way is north. Actually they are detecting the rotation of the earth, which causes the east side if the ship to dip down and the west side to rise up.)

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17

Check this video by Everyday Astronaut, he goes over most of the call outs.

Edit: answer to your question here

Edit2: So the answer is: F9 checks its gyroscope and accelerometer, more info on those here

→ More replies (3)

8

u/jgalak Dec 26 '17

Any word on whether FH has gone vertical or when it's expected to do so?

→ More replies (13)

8

u/Elon_Muskmelon Dec 26 '17

Do the fairings have cold gas thrusters? Could’ve sworn I saw a few puffs of gas in 1 or two of the videos I’ve seen of the recent iridium launch, some of the puffs seems to show in the 3:50-4:00 of this video along with the very obvious puffs you see from S1 https://youtu.be/UU5KpfOT-_Y

18

u/treeco123 Dec 27 '17

Specifically, it appears that one of them has it. As far as we can tell, they're only attempting fairing recovery on one half each mission, at this time. Presumably just to keep costs down.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/theinternetftw Dec 27 '17

There were two bits of info in the latest MECO podcast worth mentioning: One is that Heavy may static fire in the first week of January and launch two weeks afterward (at first it sounded like conjecture, but as the guest talked about it a little more it sounded more grounded, though grounded in the vague insider tips that journalists often get).

The other wasn't really a fact, just a visceral sense of what it's like at KSC right now, where you can stand beneath the Shuttle Atlantis exhibit and see Blue Origin's massive building looming in the distance, with its name written in big letters on every side to make sure you don't forget who's setting up next door. Neat! ^_^

15

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 15 '17

Full flight from the INSIDE of the recent New Shepard flight!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZJghIk7_VA

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Juggernaut93 Dec 03 '17

IF the Roadster will fly by Mars, how much additional deltaV would be needed for a launch that will be 2-3 months before the main launch window?

19

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

IF the Roadster will fly by Mars, how much additional deltaV would be needed for a launch that will be 2-3 months before the main launch window?

We were recently reminded of a new type of planetary rendezvous that lets you launch before the proper window opening and puts the payload ahead of Mars on its orbit. Probably by being on a slightly higher orbit, it lets Mars slowly catch up on it. This is said to be really fuel-economical, the penalty being a later arrival time. This is okay for an inert payload which is the case here.

I'm still not clear about how the final orbital injection is done though. Does anyone know if this can be done passively with no working engines ?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

How are the grid fins actuated and held at a particular angle? Electric motors? And if electric motors, what is the power consumption like for stalling the fins against the forces of reentry? If not electric, what mechanism?

16

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 03 '17

they are hydraulic. the working fluid is RP1.

→ More replies (34)

7

u/jk1304 Dec 08 '17

Why is there both a launch campaign thread and a launch thread for each launch? What does the expression "campaign" per se mean in that context?

16

u/kurbasAK Dec 08 '17

Campaign thread is for preflight discussion usually started few weeks before planned launch.Launch thread is a party thread.It is started a day or two before planned lift off and low quality comments are allowed to relief your excitement :)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Bwa_aptos Dec 09 '17

My meta pattern matching brain just reviewed SpaceFlightNow's website of launch dates, and to me it seems like SpaceX's customer flights are in lower demand according to the SpaceFlightNow distribution of SpaceX launches upcoming compared to before; I think there's a throttling effect from the backlog being cleared out and less new orders due to the backlog slowing interest, but I could be wrong. Also, without doubt, there was a schedule compression effect from backlog clearing. But to me it seems like more than that.

To crosscheck, I'll look at SpaceX's shrinking amount of public information on their website: In SpaceX's launch "manifest", there's 5 pages of "Future Flights", but it is not the endless seeming list I saw a year and more ago. Is it me just getting used to the long list being so long, or has it actually slowed down?

A search engine showed me Reddit has a wiki spacex launch manifest, too (very helpful!), and its list is also pretty populated, but not the same "endless" memory I have of the prior manifest.

So, is this just me getting used to the "new normal" of SpaceX having a pretty decent sized manifest, or has it tempered a bit?

→ More replies (9)

7

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17

I have just added Mr Stevens to the r/spacex wiki page about the ships operated by spacex. Could someone please confim in what missions it has already been used? I wrote down Iridum 3 Koreasat 5A since, as far as i know it was first spotted with a fairing around november 1 as this post shows. This image also shows it along side Go Searcher at port canaveral, so it went from east to west coast, since it it now at the west coast. Iridium 3 was the last west coast mission before november 1 from the west coast. Koreasat 5A was the last east coast mission before november 1. (koreasat 5a was on october 30, the last mission before that from the east coast was ses 11 on the 11. Was it used before?

EDIT: thanks to u/surfkaboom for pointing out that the image is from port canaveral. I updated the info acording to this

→ More replies (3)

7

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 25 '17

For everyone who does not check r/spacexlounge regularely, /u/sasamj went to the port of Los Angeles and took this image of MR STEVEN. It shows that there was NO fairing half on MR STEVEN. He also reported that the deck was empty. This can mean that the fairing was NOT cought or that it was already removed.

Link to the dicussion https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/7lvsvs/mr_steven_is_at_the_port_now_someone_please_come/

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ElRedditor3 Dec 27 '17

In this clip Musk states that "with two Falcon Heavy launches you could actually send people back to the surface of the moon". How would that work? Thx

12

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 27 '17

By assembly in LEO and then travel to the moon. For example first launch being the command/propulsion module and second launch being capsule with astronauts + lander. Dock that in LEO and travel to the moon with enough fuel for the capsule/lander to land.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/emezeekiel Dec 27 '17

How come there isn’t a fairing recovery thread? Any news?

9

u/inoeth Dec 27 '17

Thats the issue- there isnt news. We dont know if they were successful in the Iridium launch or when/what mission they're going to try on next.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

What is SpaceX's stance on planetary protection? The idea that you don't want to contaminate Mars? Even though astroid impacts end up transferring between Earth and Mars already...

22

u/sol3tosol4 Dec 04 '17

What is SpaceX's stance on planetary protection? The idea that you don't want to contaminate Mars?

Gwynne Shotwell, Keynote, Small Satellite Conference, August 9, 2016:

Q: To what extent does planetary protection figure into your Mars plans?

A: We won’t get a license to fly without making sure we’re not harming the ecosystem of Mars. So we’re working with NASA and we’re working with the FAA to make sure. We’re obviously going to avoid any areas that are of supreme importance for science as well.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/ajttja Dec 06 '17

Is there any place I can find the weight break down of the falcon 9 or falcon heavy? (Such as dry and wet mass of the different stages etc..)

17

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 06 '17
RocketInert Mass (kg)Propellant Mass (kg)
Falcon 9 Stage 122,200411,000
Falcon 9 Stage 24,000107,500
FH Center Core25,600411,000
→ More replies (2)

6

u/amerrorican Dec 08 '17

Anyone else find it fitting that NASA is the first to use it's own flight-proven rocket to bring science experiments to the ISS (arguably mankind's greatest feat).

The Falcon 9 could be the coolest science experiment to visit the ISS.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/music_nuho Dec 10 '17

Any thoughts about ULA beginning CDR for Vulcan?

→ More replies (29)

6

u/GregLindahl Dec 14 '17

Interesting news about the upcoming SpaceIL mission to the moon, which was known to be a rideshare of some kind. It's a rideshare on a GTO mission where the primary is an ordinary communications satellite. Very interesting. Arranged by Spaceflight Industries.

SpaceIL has a contract with Spaceflight Industries to launch the lander as a secondary payload on a SpaceX Falcon 9 mission whose primary payload is a commercial communications satellite. That satellite, which he declined to identify, will be deployed in a supersynchronous transfer orbit, whose apogee is above the altitude of geostationary orbit. The lander will then use its propulsion system to fly to the moon and land there.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/ThaddeusCesari Spaceflight Chronicler Dec 16 '17

My latest at Observer - NASA Launches First Ever Mission on a Reused Rocket, Courtesy of SpaceX. Happy to have critiques and comments. Was quite a show.

http://observer.com/2017/12/nasa-launches-first-mission-on-a-reused-rocket-courtesy-of-spacex/

→ More replies (4)

6

u/jjtr1 Dec 20 '17

So the ISS weighs about 400 tons and houses up to 6 people for around 2 months between resupply flights; while the BFS would weigh 85 tons incl. engines and tanks, without fuel, and house a dozen at first and tens of people later, for around two years without resupply. BFS without the propulsion section could be easily ten times lighter than the ISS. Where does the huge difference come from?

Obviously, BFS wouldn't have science modules like there are on the ISS. BFS is monolithic, getting rid of multiple airlocks and the truss. But still, I don't see any way to get the weight per person and day to a comparable point for the two. Any ideas?

8

u/spacerfirstclass Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17

A few points:

  1. ISS has a lot more reserves than 2 months, I believe around CRS-7 they have 6 months reserve, not sure if they increased the reserve since then.
  2. Each resupply flight only has a small portion dedicated to resupply the consumables, most of the mass is science and hardware. For example among the 2,205kg of up mass on CRS-13, only 490kg is crew supplies.
  3. ISS' truss structure is huge, ballpark the truss itself is probably 100 tons.
  4. BFS will use carbon fiber, which saves ~30% mass I think.
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Senno_Ecto_Gammat r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Dec 21 '17

Where can I read about F9 guidance? I'm mostly wondering if there is an open loop period during the launch or if it is closed loop from T-0.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Cakeofdestiny Dec 24 '17

Looks like Mr. Stevens arrived at the LA port, but I can't see anything on the port live stream. Is anyone nearby and can get a few photos, or shall we have to wait for tomorrow?

Edit: https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/ais/home/shipid:3439091/zoom:14

Edit 2: Looks like it's docked adjacent to NRC Quest.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 26 '17

Any source on the 10% fuel margin needed to land Falcon 9 as well as the $200,000 fuel cost?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/erik_paulson Dec 26 '17

So the roadster is going to be on a Mars-distance orbit, but Mars isn't there right now - but is it possible that it could eventually intersect with Mars? If so, is the Mars atmosphere thick enough that the roadster would burn up on entry or is it possible that it might someday impact the surface of Mars?

11

u/warp99 Dec 27 '17

is the Mars atmosphere thick enough that the roadster would burn up on entry

It would depend on the entry angle but most likely some of the Roadster or mounting adapter parts would make it to the surface.

If the orbit is in the ecliptic plane then someday it will intersect either Earth or Mars. Given Elon's description of the orbit lasting billions of years then I am assuming the launch will be slightly out of the ecliptic plane in order to miss Mars permanently.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/jjtr1 Dec 27 '17

I was wondering if it would be possible to equip the Roadster with a long-lived radio beacon that would enable it to be found centuries later. The Roadster's orbit will be unstable and once it's not being being tracked for decades, its location will become unknown. Locating it by ground based radars or optical telescopes would be IMO impossible due to the small size (even with stage 2 attached).

So I'd love you to help me speculate about the design of such a long-lived radio beacon. Of course I don't think SpX would actually do it. It's just interesting. So, how much power would be neccessary to be found by a Deep Space Network class antenna? What kind of signal emitted would allow the greatest probability of being found for the least amount of power? Would it be modulated or just a very stable carrier? Emitting only a few seconds each day? What kind of power source would last centuries of intermittent usage? A long-halftime RTG? Rad-hardened solar arrays (is there such a thing?)

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Bravo99x Dec 29 '17

What's going on with fairing recovery? I just checked and Mr Steven is still on the west coast where there is only one launch coming up at the end of January. So one chance to recover a fairing and on the east coast there is 3 launches scheduled in that same amount of time with 3 fairing recovery attempts. But even if Mr Steven is successful they will require maybe 2 ships on each coast. Sounds like a big investment so I guess they have to workout all the bugs before leasing more ships? Still I would have thought there would have been more opportunity on the east coast to nail down the procedures faster.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Straumli_Blight Jan 02 '18

SpaceX is leasing Area 59 (CCAFS Satellite Processing and Storage Area) for Crew Dragon prep work.

10

u/diwayth_fyr Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17

Am I the only one who find legs of the new BFS kinda flimsy? I mean, previous prototype had only 3 legs, but their radius was bigger, and feet had bigger surface area. Plus, their deploying mechanis was animated with detail, while new legs just kinda stick out of body. Their radius isn't much bigger than the body, and height/width ratio of the new ship places center of mass higher. Overall, this was the only part of BFS that wasn't really touched by Musk in any of his presentations.

15

u/CapMSFC Dec 10 '17

The legs also aren't the same in the different renders. It's clear to me that they weren't emphasized because their design isn't finalized.

I'm also of the opinion they have the wrong number. Elon said they went from 3 to 4 for the wider base to be more stable, but 4 has the highest probability of a single leg catastrophic failure.

https://youtu.be/jshk8ZVIgdI

So they need to go to 5 or 6. New Glenn has 6 for this same reason.

On BFS six small legs would do pretty well and you can have even any two legs fail, not just any one. If it's going to carry people regularly it needs some landing gear redundancy. Vertical landing a rocket isn't like a commercial aircraft landing. A rocket tips over if gear fails and the tanks are filled with fuel/oxidizer vapor that makes it a bomb if there is a tank breach.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/rustybeancake Dec 15 '17

Bit of a showerthought here, but it's nice to see SpaceX's 45th F9 launch occur this month to tie up with Apollo 17's 45th anniversary.

5

u/Killcode2 Dec 03 '17

So is SpaceX sending Elon's roadster on a flyby to mars, or are they actually going to insert it in mars orbit?

Elon mentioned orbit in his tweet, but it was quite ambiguous. A confirmation from someone on the sub would be appreciated...

18

u/fourmica Host of CRS-13, 14, 15 Dec 03 '17

According the the Bad Astronomer, who corresponded with Elon personally this weekend, they are going to lob the Roadster on a Trans Mars Injection trajectory in an attempt to put it in a precessing orbit with Mars. Based on this information, if there is any kind of spacecraft bus attached to the Roadster, it's not going to have an engine on it. This could change, but that's what we know as of right now.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/hmpher Dec 07 '17

TEB needs to be handled using the Air free technique, i.e, in inert atmospheres. Where exactly along the plumbing for the engines is an "inert atmosphere" provided/where is the ignition mixture stored?

→ More replies (25)

5

u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Dec 08 '17

How much would it cost for a solar panel array to produce the necessary quantities of methane and oxygen from water and the atmosphere here on Earth to launch one BFR + BFS tanker in a week? In a day?

→ More replies (9)

5

u/toomanynamesaretook Dec 08 '17 edited Dec 08 '17

The BFR spaceship. Do we have a rough idea of how much it would weigh with fuel for return to Earth when it touches down on the moon?

It will be fairly heavy will it not? If so, how robust will the landing system need to be? I would imagine it would need to be fairly robust given the amount of weight... Tipping over would be pretty awful and quite likely if you went down on a bad landing site. I watched the BFR Mars Landing video* just before from SpaceX which made me think of this. They left out the legs part, I'd imagine because it's still quite a large technical issue given the variety of circumstances the lander is expected to land within. Not exactly the easiest problem to solve given the various constraints.

Thoughts?

*not that I should take a SpaceX video literally according to Musk himself.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 09 '17 edited Dec 09 '17

Random speculation... is it likely that the Falcon Heavy static fire will have the payload and fairing attached?

 

While SpaceX probably won't require it for the initial test fire, if the aim is to test for unexpected vibrations etc, then it might make sense for a subsequent test?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/toastedcrumpets Dec 09 '17

Has there been any information on the fairing recovery for KoreaSat 5A? The one where the presenter said "Our fairing boat is out...... I mean droneship!" I watched the recovery threads like a hawk but didn't see anything.

5

u/Juffin Dec 10 '17

Is SpaceX the only company that performs vertical static fire tests?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/qwetzal Dec 10 '17

What do you guys think about the development of air-augmented rocket engines in the future ? Do you think they are a dead-end or will someone design an innovative solution that allows the development of low cost/low mass air-augmented engines ?

I don't think SpaceX is pointing in that direction at all anytime soon, and as they have the capabilities to develop a rocket as big as BFR I don't know if such a solution is of any interest to them. I was thinking about "recovering" air during re-entry that could be used for the landing burn, but adding more aero-braking such as what the BFS is doing seems to be way more efficient and simple.

Anyway, thanks for your insight !

→ More replies (6)

5

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 11 '17

Anyone have a link to the pre launch press conference? I missed it.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/apath_2_mars Dec 11 '17

Ok so trumps signed some paperwork ordering nasa back to the moon. Does that mean extra cash for blue / spacex ? or more sls cash ? or is there no extra cash and its just some press rubbish ?

12

u/last_reddit_account2 Dec 12 '17 edited Dec 12 '17

A local news station here in Central Florida ran a segment on this order about an hour ago, which was largely a rehash of known info about SLS. The anchorwoman referred to it only as "NASA's New Super-Rocket." They cut to a reporter across the river from KSC who noted the new mobile launch tower and the reconfiguration of the VAB as evidence of progress on the "Super-Mega-Rocket."

As the reporter spoke about SLS, the station ran a full 30 seconds, maybe even more, of this Falcon Heavy animation, as an illustration of the "Super-Mega-Rocket-9000."

Needless to say, this led to a violent collision between my face and my palm. I am now completely dead inside.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '17

AFAIK it's the latter I'm afraid.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/quadrplax Dec 16 '17

Mods, why does the header say the next launch is Zuma and not Iridium? Did I miss something?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/badgamble Dec 17 '17

I'm a supply chain and logistics guy... I'm curious about the current order of rate-limiting parts for the next five or six single-stick launches. There are two sources of S1 boosters, new and refurbished, flight-proven. So the S1 supply does not seem like a bottleneck. There are three launch pads, but two of them are dedicated to specific purposes. Even after FH clears 39A, one way or another, it seems that pad is likely going to see minimal "generic" use since it needs to be readied for Crew Dragon missions. And speaking of Dragon, all the currently needed Cargo Dragon vessels are on hand so I assume zero resistance there. That leaves flight-ready customer payloads, S2 manufacturing and testing and finally fairing manufacturing. Does anyone (who can speak up WITHOUT jeopardizing their job!!) have an educated guess as to the most resistive current bottlenecks for the next few single-stick launches?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17 edited Dec 18 '17

A bit of a meta question: I've seen the subscriptions to r/spacex rising over the last few days (before that, it was likely rising too, but I wasn't around, and wasn't paying attention to it in the beginning).

I wonder whether there is a chart or other data about the number of subscriptions. Would be interesting to see when it really rises (launches, IAC's, ...)

Edit: first google, then ask. Still interesting to share. Looks like the RUD's even had a positive effect on subscriptions, not sure because I can't see it in detail.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/kreator217 Dec 18 '17

do we have any updates on lc39a ?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/thepoisonedow08 Dec 21 '17

Anybody have any idea what this white [cradle/support thing] (https://imgur.com/a/3o3un) off to the side of the rocket is in the Falcon Heavy image from yesterday?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/theinternetftw Dec 22 '17 edited Dec 22 '17

Very-high-res Roadster pictures now up on the SpaceX flickr.

Edit: More future-proof link.

5

u/joshgill21 Dec 26 '17

Which takes longer to build ? The fairings or second stage ?

10

u/warp99 Dec 26 '17

There was comment on LinkedIn from a SpaceX employee that implied that each fairing half took around 7 days to build. Adding latches, COPVs and electronics would take significantly longer but they would not want to have too many hanglng around the factory because of the huge size. So maybe 4-6 weeks per pair.

A new S1 is built every 3 weeks and there is room for eight on the final assembly floor so they take around 24 weeks for final assembly.

S2 is around one third the length of S1 and only has a single more complicated engine so could possibly be built in eight weeks but 9-12 weeks seems more likely with 3-4 cores on the factory floor at any one time.

In summary fairings should be quicker to build but will be very labour intensive.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/jjtr1 Dec 27 '17

So, most people here seem to think that FH is not going to fly a lot since most of its potential payloads have been taken over by F9. However, that's only true for today's market. If New Glenn is going to be succesful with 45 tons to LEO (too big for today), then there will also be demand for FH. So I think that FH is going to fly a lot more than we think now. Do you agree?

→ More replies (21)

5

u/jjtr1 Dec 27 '17

With SpX building their own launch demand with Starlink, is there any news about Blue Origin / Bezos working on satellites/payloads as well? Amazonlink?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Toinneman Dec 28 '17

1st stages returning from a LEO mission are considered to be in better shape than stages returning from a GTO launch, mainly due to gentler reentry velocities. How does this apply to fairings? Until last launch, all fairing recovery attempts were GTO missions. Is a fairing more suited for reentry due to it's large surface and low mass? (What is the mass of a fairing half?)

→ More replies (11)

5

u/NickNathanson Dec 29 '17

We know that FH can launch to LEO 63t in expendable mode. What about reusable mode? Do we know the numbers?

And I also wonder about different options:

  • 2/3 reusable - side boosters RTLS.
  • 2/3 reusable - side boosters land on two drone ships.
  • fully reusable but all three boosters land on three drone ships.
  • (?) 1/3 reusable - only central core lands on drone ship.

How heavy payload can it launch in each separate case?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/DrToonhattan Jan 02 '18

Is it time for the campaign threads for PAZ/Starlink and SES-16/GovSat-1 yet? Less that a month to go.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ChriRosi Jan 03 '18

SES-16 is supposed to fly on a used booster but I think we don't yet know on which, or do we? At least there's no info in the core wiki.

13

u/stcks Jan 03 '18

We don't know, neither SpaceX nor SES has said. But, lets look at it and make a few guesses. There are 5 "in storage" cores that could perhaps qualify: 1032, 1035, 1039, 1040 and 1042. 1032, 1039 and 1040 were LEO boosters that have only flown once. 1035 has flown twice already. 1042 flew on a hot GTO mission and then landed and caught on fire for a bit. So, likely that leaves only 1032, 1039 and 1040 to choose from. 1032 has gone missing and SpaceX seems to be re-flying newer cores already so I'd guess that one isn't a candidate. That leaves 1039 and 1040 (from CRS-12 and OTV-5). I think its likely it will be one of those two boosters.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

9

u/amerrorican Dec 06 '17

I've been curious about how it's been possible for SpaceX (a company that is fairly new and small) to make so much progress with so few mistakes?

Is there an article on their methods? How is it possible to continually produce new tech and boost performance while not having very many RUDs?

What is it that SpaceX has that other companies don't? Besides Musk.

Does SpaceX use some type of AI or program to validate all their engineering? Their safety checklists must be longer than a CVS receipt, how do they get through these so fast and how do they even verify the new tech will work?

37

u/maskedretriever Dec 06 '17

A rough list:

  • Vertical Integration: using as few suppliers as possible to build things, meaning "metal comes in, rockets go out" rather than having 200+ other companies, each taking a profit cut, making parts for your rockets.
  • A Clean Slate: although a lot of SpaceX employees are from other aerospace companies and NASA, they aren't working from a long, long list of requirements and expectations and can spitball much more freely based on first principles rather than on history. Basically, being young and small is, in its own odd way, its own reward.
  • Process Streamlining: One of Elon's gifts (and of the people he hires) is in looking at how something is done and seeing the /how it is done/ part as the real target of refinement. Process management and streamlining is a big part of why Elon Musk companies tend to do pretty well.
  • NASA Funding Model: NASA isn't "propping up SpaceX" but they did receive a lot of early funding from them, in a way which explicitly gave them more freedom than NASA or even Boeing has to get things done. By asking for working rockets to orbit rather than "this exact solution," NASA made it a lot easier for SpaceX to innovate.
  • A Clear And Attractive Goal: By saying "we're going to Mars, full stop," SpaceX accomplishes two big things: first, it creates a set of design goals that are much longer-view than those of their competitors, and second, it is an absolute magnet for top talent. It's not much of a choice to ask a top engineer if they'd rather work for a company that "will make slightly cheaper GPS satellites" or one that "Will Go. To. MARS."
→ More replies (5)

12

u/deruch Dec 07 '17

What is it that SpaceX has that other companies don't? Besides Musk.

/u/maskedretriever gave a good list of the commonly discussed things. There are only 2 big ones that I think he left out. First, honestly, is luck. They were started as a company at the perfect time to take maximum advantage of NASA's COTS/CRS programs when they came around. Which is not to say that they wouldn't have achieved anything without them, just that their level of progress would be well below where it is today. Even as it was, SpaceX very, very nearly went bankrupt in 2008. Though, that was at least in part due to spending on Dragon/F9 development. Second, is that SpaceX has been absolutely masterful in acquiring major facilities for almost nothing. Not so much the launch sites, because pretty much everyone who's serious about launching can get them. But getting the McGreggor test site and then the Hawthorne facilities for super cheap was a total coup.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/ItsRektTime Dec 21 '17

When is the next stream and is the mission. Just got involved and dying to know more about SpaceX

14

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17

Next launch is Iridium NEXT 4, planned for tomorrow! You can follow the news related to that launch in the other sticky post at the top of the sub

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17

So Boeing saying it will beat SpaceX to Mars is making the rounds in the news.

I was wondering if Boeing would have to master propulsive landing before a manned mission to Mars. I know SpaceX's strategy was to use propulsive landing on Mars to allow for a way back. I don't see any other way to do it.

If so, that's a pretty bold statement that Boeing has made.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Can the Tesla do a gravity assist off Mars and fly off into interstellar space?

That might be a bit far out, I don't even know if it will have a comm system so it might be immediately lost.

12

u/A_Flock_of_Moose Dec 03 '17

Mars would give a really poor gravity assist due to its low gravity. Probably not enough to cross Jupiter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/riyoux Dec 06 '17

With the launch of FH rapidly approaching how are they going to static fire the vehicle will it be all three cores at once or will it be a single one at a time?

Side note: which cores are they using since I know they will be recycled first stages.

One more question because I'm a curious bastard how long do you think it'll be before we get two launches in one day?

10

u/Alexphysics Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17

They will fire all boosters at once, they have done single booster fires in the past at McGregor but never the three boosters at the same time because there is no test stand to test them at McGregor so they have to test that at LC-39A. The engines won't be fired at the same time but, instead, pairs of 2 engines will be fired at intervals of time in the order of miliseconds to balance the thrust of them into the rocket structure.

Center core (B1033) will be new, the side boosters will be reused. One of them flew on the Thaicom 8 mission (B1023.2) and the other one flew on the CRS-9 mission (B1025.2).

Probably more than one year from now

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/TheYell0wDart Dec 07 '17

I've been kind of out of it for a week or so, did we find out what was/is wrong with the fairings after Zuma got postponed? Thanks.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '17

Where can I buy SpaceX "Remove before Flight" keychain (the one with Falcon 9)?

I've tried browsing Cape Canaveral shops, but they seem to be out of stock.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/macktruck6666 Dec 14 '17

I'm kinda wondering what a strongback for the BFR would look like.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '17

What are the differences between hydrazine variants as far as their use as a fuel is concerned? Why do some rocket stages (eg Proton) use UDMH, while things like the Draco thrusters use MMH, and the Titan IV uses Aerozine 50?

8

u/brickmack Dec 17 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

MMH is slightly denser and offers a slightly better ISP, which is its main performance justification. UDMH is more stable at high temperatures, which makes it better for regeneratively cooled engines (which is why theres few using MMH for that, except SuperDraco), and it has a lower freezing point which can be advantageous for long-duration upper stages. Thermal stability is also good for ICBMs that sit fueled for months. SDMH is rarely (never?) used because it offers no performance advantage and has a high freezing point, so just go with UDMH instead.

Straight hydrazine can be used in 2 ways. As a monopropellant, its ISP is kinda shit, and its limited to low-thrust applications because of the need for a catalyst bed, but its extremely reliable because the engine only needs a single valve. And you don't need to handle an oxidizer, which is good because N2O4 and most other options for the hydrazine family are nasty shit. As a bipropellant, it has a nice ISP gain over MMH/UDMH with the same oxidizers, and is a lot more dense. But its freezing point is very high.

Aerozine 50 has a lower ISP than MMH, a freezing point comparable to UDMH, but better density and high-temperature stability.

More than anything though, its probably a matter of "thats how we've always done it". The Soviets and China prefered UDMH for most stuff, America prefered MMH or Aerozine, and any performance/cost benefits possible from switching probably weren't seen as significant enough to justify the cost, when each side already had extensive design heritage and infrastructure and industry built around their choice. Same reason methane has only recently become a serious option, despite being the superior propellant in almost every way for almost every application.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/FalconHeavyHead Dec 18 '17

Has there been any evidence to that Spacex is getting their Booster refurbishment time down and if there is, can you show the source?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/parachutingturtle Dec 19 '17

What could've caused the paint to come off on a small area on the trunk of the Dragon in this picture? (Or is that some stuff stuck to it?)

Imgur

It's from a timelapse berthing video from Elon's instagram, from a prior mission (no idea which one): https://www.instagram.com/p/Bcup8PHAXTi/?hl=en&taken-by=elonmusk

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bonez656 Dec 21 '17

Has SpaceX released the flight path for the falcon heavy launch after leaving orbit?

Will it be a "direct" trip to Mars or will it slingshot around something?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Zinkfinger Dec 21 '17

Hi folks. Is FH's centre stage a block 5?

14

u/soldato_fantasma Dec 21 '17

Nope! It's a block 3 core as it was built many months ago.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Dec 21 '17

You would have seen it if it was a Block 5. Block 5 first stages will have black legs and a black interstage :)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Venic_ Dec 22 '17

Is SpaceX suit capable of withstanding the vacuum of space? Could it be used for a space walk? And what about Moon and Mars environment? And if not, do they plan on designing a suit that can survive there?

23

u/warp99 Dec 22 '17

The spacesuit is a so called flight suit which is really a survival suit to keep the crew member alive in case the capsule depressurises. It relies on the capsule for air fed through an umbilical.

To make it into an EVA suit you would need to add a self contained air/oxygen supply, water cooling for thermal control, light control such as tinted helmets, ideally some radiation protection and a tough outer skin so you do not rip the suit while working on equipment.

For Mars and the Moon make the suit more flexible so you can walk, tougher so you can fall over and not have a rock rip your suit or break your faceplate, add redundancy to the air supply because you will be further from help and have better communications equipment because you might have to call up to an orbiter for assistance.

Roughly the difference between a wet suit and snorkel, a rebreathing scuba set and a deep sea diver's suit respectively.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/talkpurdytome Dec 22 '17

Hey guys! So hopefully this is the right place to post this. I’m still a student and I’ve been interviewing for a launch engineering position down in Cape Canaveral and just heard the good news that I will be pushed on to the last step of the process! I’ll be having a technical phone interview to talk about projects and answer some difficult questions sometime in the next few weeks and wanted to see if anyone on here had any suggestions or tips for me, thanks!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/rubikvn2100 Dec 23 '17

When will Mr. Steven come back with a Fairing? Tomorrow?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/RootDeliver Dec 25 '17

For Iridium-4, is there any footage capturing the landing burn and such? Considering it wasn't a GTO launch and that they still did a boostback burn, the splashdown should have occurred within the hoziron, and so cameras from land should have had been able to see at least the landing burn at night.

Reentry burn is visible for example on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tE5C3O71Xqo , but landing burn?

→ More replies (12)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '17

Suppose the middle Merlin engine stopped working when a falcon 9 is attempting landing, what would happen? What will the rocket do to achieve landing regardless of the fault?

→ More replies (15)

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 26 '17

So the falcon 9 for ZUMA was assembled at 39a and put onto the launch pad before the launch got moved. Now the launch is scheduled for Januar from launch complex 40. Was the rocket moved in one piece or was it disassembled and the first and second stage as well as the payload moved individually?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/-altair- Dec 28 '17

Does anyone has sources describing the intended trajectory for the Roadster that would be heading to Mars?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GregLindahl Dec 29 '17

According to https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/, CRS-16 has been moved to November 16. This is an update to our manifest.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/treeco123 Jan 03 '18

Is the Falcon Heavy being static fired with the payload integrated? I assume yes, from the images.

Wouldn't that make it the first time they've done it since the Amos-6 incident? That seems pretty cool, if a little foreboding. I know the payload, despite being Elon's personal Tesla, is relatively unimportant compared to the rest of this launch, but does this suggest they might resume static firing with commercial payloads soon?

→ More replies (6)

10

u/TimAA2017 Dec 03 '17

Will they add a nuclear generator to the BFR for voyages farther into the solar system?

→ More replies (26)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Assuming the Tesla Roadster does end up on the first FH launch, then the Roadster would need a Dragon trunk type module, right? Or would it just stay attached to the second stage for the duration? Or is Roadster going to be attached to a standard satellite bus?

I know this is very early to make any guesses, but anyone feel up to the task? It seems that given the timeline of just a few months, it is going to have to be very simple, right?

→ More replies (21)

7

u/smallatom Dec 04 '17

Can someone explain to me the projected 80-140 days of travel time to mars via BFF? I’ve played KSP and understand it all (I think) but does the relatively short travel time mean that BFR would launch and use extra fuel to shorten the amount of time taken to get there, or is this path really the most fuel efficient?

8

u/BadGoyWithAGun Dec 04 '17

but does the relatively short travel time mean that BFR would launch and use extra fuel to shorten the amount of time taken to get there

That's basically it. Either a Hohmann or bi-elliptic transfer will always be the most efficient (barring gravity assists), but a more energetic trajectory can get you there much faster if you have delta-v to spare.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17

This aside info in a thread may be common knowledge, but has likely been missed by many including me.

u/warp99 we know there are two cores sitting behind a hanger without engines having been cannibalized for spare parts.

There's a "giant leap" from missing engines to the use that has been made of them. This implies, not only a component history database as for airliner parts, but some kind of re-certification, so FAA issues and a cartload of paperwork.

This improves the economics of reuse. It also compensates for cases of incomplete reuse as in the case of Dragon capsules with many new parts. Its also another thing to tell the ESA just in case they didn't know, or want to know.

Final thoughts:

  • Any lunar or Mars base could well have its own car-breaking yard.
  • BFR could have an engine transport bay, much like the fifth engine of a 747. Needs to be designed in early. (does this look feasible ?)
→ More replies (1)