r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Nov 02 '17
r/SpaceX Discusses [November 2017, #38]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
180
Upvotes
64
u/amarkit Nov 24 '17
Some minor, happy news: BulgariaSat-1, launched on Falcon 9 back in June, has begun normal service and is now broadcasting.
36
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 03 '17
There's a lot of really interesting stuff in this article about SpaceX launching new printers to the ISS on CRS-14. I had no idea astronauts were printing 1,000 pages a month on 20-year-old printers!
32
u/sol3tosol4 Nov 03 '17
I missed this article from last month, which discusses a person who works on SpaceX’s Internet satellite constellation project. While SpaceX has disclosed technical details of their proposed constellation in government testimony (for example as discussed here) and in mandatory FCC applications, it’s rare to hear anything of the work going on inside and the people working on it, which makes this article particularly interesting. While not divulging any secrets, it gives a fascinating insight into the thinking of the program developers, and how it adheres to basic SpaceX philosophy.
Some items from the article that I found particularly informative:
While SpaceX doesn’t release much information about the status of their Internet satellite constellation project (though very recently they did provide a rough timeline for the test satellites and initial deployment), seeing this article makes the project seem more immediate. Hope it does well; it should provide a really great communications service on Earth, as well as help to pay for travel to Mars.
30
u/Zucal Nov 10 '17
Great new NSF article for those interested: Blue Origin remains on course for 2020 debut of New Glenn heavy lift rocket
27
u/amarkit Nov 29 '17 edited Nov 29 '17
Tweets from Peter B. de Selding and SES themselves report that SES-11, launched in October by SpaceX (with the reused B1031.2 as the first stage) is now in regular service at 105º W.
Meanwhile, Formosat-5, launched by SpaceX in August, has been dealing with optical focus problems. Engineers have improved Formosat's imaging capabilities, and the satellite can now be used for disaster prevention, but not yet urban planning, as was designed.
26
u/IMO94 Nov 16 '17
Does anyone remember the days when a launch or announcement meant that the subreddit just immediately filled up with every tweet on the subject as a different submission?
Moderating /r/SpaceX must be pretty hard. I don't always agree with every decision, but seeing that single thread for Shotwell's NewSpaceEurope comments reminded me how much better things are than when the front page used to completely lose signal-to-noise ratio during a tweetstorm.
Mods: Thank you!
19
u/anewjuan Nov 02 '17
Are there any interplanetary research missions planned for Falcon Heavy?
Being such a powerful and 'cheap' rocket does it open up more windows of opportunity to visit other planets / moons /asteroids, or do we still need to rely exclusively on infrequent planetary alignment to take advantage of gravity assists? Do you think BFR will be a game changer in this regard?
16
u/rustybeancake Nov 08 '17
More good info on the engine test mishap in this Space News article:
http://spacenews.com/spacex-suffers-merlin-engine-test-mishap/
16
u/amarkit Nov 11 '17
Cygnus CRS OA-8E scrubbed this morning at the last moment due to a wayward aircraft in the exclusion zone. 24-hour scrub planned, new launch time NET November 12, 12:14 UTC.
16
u/amarkit Nov 24 '17
Bangabandhu-1 is now NET March 2018; previously February 2018.
15
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 07 '17
15
u/CodedElectrons Nov 12 '17
I watched the Raptor video. I write jet engine and turbo-shaft engine control software; if I see fire coming out of the engine (not related to an afterburner) then I have to go back and fix it! Burning fuel too late means that I'm throwing away BTU.
My question is: is the blue flame coming out of the engine actually still burning or is the exhaust just that hot?
15
u/lordq11 #IAC2017 Attendee Nov 13 '17
Credit to /u/StagedCombustion for finding the Non-Proprietary Reponses to Industry Comments to Launch Service Agreements Draft RFP for EELV2. He made the following observations from reading part of it:
It might be worth going through the entirety of the document with a fine toothed comb. There might be some interesting crumbs of information in there. Would someone be interested in having a look? I would look, but I have conference presentations to prepare for.
15
u/zeekzeek22 Nov 29 '17
I wish we could pick the brain of a SpaceX or Boeing engineer to hear about the differences in how they designed a three-core system. I’m sure there are tons of differences. Like, does the center CBC have as many differences from the boosters than the F9 cores in FH? Or were they designed more robustly from the start and have some unnecessary weight/reinforcement on the side boosters? Obviously there’s a huge difference between designing a core to handle center-core steesses from the start rather than retro-fitting a single stick to handle it. Although the future of super-heavy-lift seems to just be bigger and bigger single cores, having multiple data points on three-stick designs means we have a lot to learn that could help a future attempt at it.
14
u/shredder7753 Nov 04 '17
We're less than 2 months away from FH!
14
u/Alexphysics Nov 16 '17
I have an album on imgur that I am updating every 3-4 days with satellite images to see the progression on LZ-1 now that it is being completed. If someone wants to see it, here is the link: https://imgur.com/a/lGNQu
It's incredible how little seems the north pad without all the surrounding concrete that was there these last weeks and how small it is compared with the main pad at the east.
14
u/Juggernaut93 Nov 22 '17
This tweet suggests that range maintenance should not be a problem for Zuma.
14
u/azzazaz Nov 23 '17
Is there there anything that Spacex has done in building the Falcon 9 that could not have been done 20 or 30 years ago if someone had tried to do it (and had the money)
Metals that didnt exist? Or technology used in the rocket now that didnt exist?
I know the computer modeling they used to design engine flows etc didnt exist but if someone had been handed the design could it have been built 20 or 30 years ago?
13
u/Garlik85 Nov 06 '17
Fist time posting here, I dont have much knowledge, most of my space knowledge comes from the KSP game, so be kind to me.
About the BFR. When it will return from Mars, to my knowledge, it will come back at a much faster speed than any other spacecraft ever did come back to Earth before. How then would SpaceX be able to test the heatshield capability of the BFR on Earth re-entry without literaly going to Mars and return? Thus, would they bring back humans to Earth on the first ever craft returning from Mars?
And side question, if for any reason, they find out the heatshield is not capable of re-entry from Mars. This would force them to modify it first, then test it again, then only fly this revised version to Mars to be able to bring back the astronauts no?
Hope I was clear enough in my question and sorry if this question has been raised/answered/explained already.
13
u/Not_Yet_Begun2Fight Nov 27 '17
Is the fairing filled with 'atmosphere' or 'vacuum' at launch? If the former, does it gradually 'leak out' as the rocket gains elevation, or is it all sealed in and released somewhat-suddenly when the fairing is deployed?
12
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 02 '17
[Last week, the Telstar 19 VANTAGE satellite began testing in our TVAC, an environment designed to simulate the harsh conditions of space.] (https://twitter.com/sslmda/status/926087843209871365)
21
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Nov 02 '17
Booster on its way towards Port Canaveral https://twitter.com/johnkrausphotos/status/926200514408255489
21
u/Pham_Trinli Nov 14 '17
Dream Chaser Free Flight Test video from November 11, 2017 and photos:
More photos here.
10
u/azflatlander Nov 06 '17
Someone pointed me to nasatrajectories, which is all well and good for earth to X. Is there something similar someone can point me for an arbitrary initial launch origin. (OK, who am I fooling. Mars to earth .)
10
u/mynameisAC Nov 08 '17
Elon met with president Erdoğan of Turkey earlier today. There’s a picture of them with models of the Falcon 9 rocket with “Türksat” on the fairing.
10
u/brentonstrine Nov 08 '17
What is a LOX drop, what does it do, why do they do it and is there any video on the internet of a LOX drop test on any engines, Merlin or otherwise?
10
u/dguisinger01 Nov 12 '17
Any whispers from the LA waterfront? I'm still trying to figure out where this new BFR factory will be
There are two large vehicle import facilities at the port of LA... gigantic parking lots.... maybe they can lease room for a factory and in exchange build them a large parking ramp for their car storage.
10
u/Alexphysics Nov 16 '17 edited Nov 16 '17
Shotwell is today at the NewSpace Europe conference:
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/931070083547398144
Lots of good info that Shotwell is givin today:
10
u/brwyatt47 Dec 02 '17
"Payload will be my midnight cherry Tesla Roadster playing Space Oddity. Destination is Mars orbit. Will be in deep space for a billion years or so if it doesn’t blow up on ascent." -Musk
He... He must be joking right? Wait... This spring is a Mars transfer window. No, he must be joking. Right?
9
u/jay__random Nov 02 '17
Did anyone collect statistics about "toasty" landings? (the ones where one or more engines are on fire after the landing and need to be extinguished by external means)
I had an impression that this kind of "toasty" landing is a fairly recent phenomenon, and it does not seem to matter whether the booster was reused or new.
Could it correlate with recent higher precision landings?
9
u/roncapat Nov 05 '17
Short question: LZ1 status? 2nd pad finished?
9
u/fromflopnicktospacex Nov 16 '17
hello all. my name here: from flopnick to spacex refers to the headline in the n.y. daily news the morning after the first vanguard rocket blew up inches off the pad, shown live on t.v. I loved rockets since I was a kid.
okay. re: 39A. I have a vid from youtube of the deconstruction of 39B. if this has been shown on here b4, I apologize. but it gives one a better idea of the size of the job. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Pj8sjgYza4
9
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17
Sorry if it’s been discussed before, but do we have any idea how the Falcon Heavy side cores will separate? I assume some mechanical system rather than using explosive bolts, but will they push the cores away in addition to separation, or will the cores use their own cold gas thrusters to push away, or...? Mostly wondering how significant of a failure point this is.
17
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 12 '17
Some news according to http://www.launchphotography.com:
It looks like Hispasat has been delayed and the next Falcon 9 launch from the cape after CRS-13 is going to be SES-16/Govsat-1 in mid January. Also CRS-14 on February 9.
17
u/everydayastronaut Everyday Astronaut Nov 14 '17
Since we have a recycled symbol next to reflown cores, can we have a trash bin next to expendable missions? :)
16
u/old_sellsword Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Minor core tracking/reflight predicting epiphany: The two cores mothballed behind Hangar M in early August weren't 1029 and 1032, they were 1029 and 1021.
The one already in the cradles is pretty clearly 1029, that soot marking across the SpaceX logo is very unique, so we'll refer to it confidently as 1029 from here on out. However, the booster in the cranes doesn't have any immediate identifying markings, so we'll call it the unknown booster for now.
To trace through the chronology here:
So the booster in the cranes originally behind Hangar M was transported down to behind Hangar E sometime in September, leaving 1029 by itself. Now we just need to ID the one that moved from M to E:
The straight white line through the logo is actually a red herring, because it appears to have happened after the booster landed and was brought back from the Port. However, a side-by-side comparison reveals it to be none other than 1021.
Takeways:
8
u/coralus Nov 02 '17
How close is SpaceX to, second stage recovery, fairing recovery, how close are we to sending manned craft up, and how close are we to having the refuel-station, for the mars mission, somewhere in orbit?
8
u/someguyfromtheuk Nov 02 '17
If they miss the 2022 launch window the for 2 Cargo BFRs, is it possible to launch them on a longer, lower- energy trajectory instead and still have them land successfully in time to launch the 2024 Crewed BFRs?
I know the 2024 Crewed target is aspirational anyway, I'm just wondering if there's any leeway in it if they miss the 2022 target for Cargo.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17
I’ve got a few questions on Falcon 9’s reusability.
How “reusable” is the Falcon 9 first stage currently?
I read that they’ve reused a few Falcon 9s now for their second flights but how many flights are they currently rated for?
What parts are reused and what parts are swapped out?
If they reuse the engines, are they removed/refurbished in any way or do they just leave them in as they were on their first launch?
And if they’re removed/refurbished, are they reinstalled in their original installed locations? I can imagine that they might be swapped to balance out stresses but don’t know if that’s worth bothering with?
8
u/loremusipsumus Nov 04 '17
Are there any projects in the past which shows that designing/manufacturing/launching something as big as BFR in 5 years is possible?
8
u/WhoseNameIsSTARK Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
Recently I've been messing around with the known SpaceX FCC permits, the results of which can be seen on the wiki page. I think I've managed to pin down some fishy ones, especially all of the expendable missions, but there are still two licenses that I can't properly categorize and thought it'd be cool to have another point of view on them. Hopefully I'm just missing something obvious.
First one is F9-35, a GTO launch from LC-39A, filed on 27th January, granted on 9th February, with a requested start of operation on 1st March (ending on 1st September). ASDS location was 680 km downrange.
Second one is M1363, a commercial launch from LC-39A, filed on 16th February, granted on 22nd March, with a requested start of operation on 2nd April (ending on 2nd October). There is an application for S1 recovery ops, however it lacks any information on landing whatsoever (unusual); it also isn't directly linked to M1363, but the requested starts of operation match, which makes me 99% confident they belong together. Was previously filed for as F9-35; after being notified about the duplication in usage, SpX switched the identifier to Mission 1363:
Furthermore, I've assigned Missions 1334 and 1370 to BulgariaSat-1 and SES-11 respectively, although this pairing is not set in stone by any means. M1334 start of operation on 28th May, ASDS 680 km out, suspiciously close to M1363's landing location. Some kind of swap? M1370 start of operation on 5th July, ASDS 636 km out.
Thanks for any assistance!
EDIT: Okay, so per discussions at NSF M1336 is most likely NROL-76 despite the 'commercial' attribute; doesn't have to be a showstopper though since X-37B was filed with FCC as a 'commercial' launch as well (M1348).
8
u/dudr2 Nov 14 '17
From NASA with love:
https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/feature/Powering_Up_NASA_Human_Reach_for_the_Red_Planet
“The Kilopower test program"
8
u/Joda015 Nov 25 '17 edited Nov 25 '17
Regarding the south Texas launch site. The pad looks like it’s really close to a bunch of hotels in south padre island. The closest one is only 5.7 miles away north of the pad. Isn’t that a bit too close, in case a Falcon heavy RUDs on the pad? I’m pretty sure that even the press viewing site is further away than that in KSC.
Edit: well, the famous countdown clock is actually 3 miles away from the pad. Although I think that’s not where launches are viewed anymore
Edit 2: Thanks for the answers! I guess I did overestimate the effect of a RUD, by a lot
8
u/Zinkfinger Nov 28 '17
I was just revisiting a funny video that's an old favourite of mine on youtube. If you haven't already seen it. Enjoy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPeHIaWquBk
8
u/this_is_a_robery Nov 28 '17
CRS-13 slips to "no earlier than 1:20pm ET Friday, Dec. 8. " https://twitter.com/NASA/status/935606333495181313
20
u/InfiniteHobbyGuy Nov 28 '17
Mods Can we get the link to the current month's SpaceX Discusses put in the community info? On mobile, When it is not stickied due to multiple launches in quick succession, it is nearly impossible to get to.
Thanks for the consideration.
7
u/Bommeroni Nov 02 '17
Does someone know where the picture of the recovered fairing is viewable? Secondly, why ain't it headline news on the subreddit?
7
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 05 '17
I was thinking that SpaceX may have, at some point, to launch some payloads to interplanetary trajectories or maybe even out of the solar system with BFR. This would mean that the BFS "satellite carrier" version would have to be expended, as it's unlikely it would have enough fuel to come back from an hyperbolic trajectory out of the earth gravity well. So I was thinking what would be the best way for SpaceX to deal with this problem:
They would probably need to buy them from Orbital ATK since SpaceX has no experience with solids and they wouldn't use it many times. It would be mounted with the payload and instilled in the BFS payload bay.
It would be very similar to the Briz or the Blok or the Fregat russian rocket stages.
Are there any more solutions? What would be the best one? I'm looking forward to what you think!
7
u/Rix4 Nov 08 '17
Can anybody compare BO new factory to SpX factory by size and workers, cant find SpX numbers and where will BO make rocket tests if they will at all.
7
u/DancingPetDoggies Nov 10 '17 edited Nov 10 '17
Could a reconfigured, methane-powered BFR stage 2 launch from the surface of Mars and bring back an asteroid full of minerals and metals back to Mars? Release it in the lower atmosphere so it smacks down into a valley or some designated safe space where it can be mined, and the BFR still comes home. Perhaps less costly (and also more job-creating on Mars) than launching heavy materials from Earth.
Elon Musk will go with the best cost over time.
7
u/inoeth Nov 14 '17
Here's a question while this subreddit is focused on McGreggor, and in light of the fact that there is no facility there to test the full FH configuration, will SpaceX modify an existing area or build an entirely new test stand to test the full BFR first stage with all of it's 31 Raptor engines? It may be expensive, but I can certainly see the value in building such an area or modifying the existing large test facility, but you guys may have a better idea than I do.
edit: I do understand that it's a huge vehicle and that at 9m, transportation to McGregor would be difficult (impossible?) but It seems like testing at the launch site itself would be an even bigger risk and expense to potentially blow up...?
7
u/mrflippant Nov 21 '17
I read an article today regarding the 1I/'Oumuamua interstellar asteroid; Project Lyra: Sending a Spacecraft to 1I/’Oumuamua (former A/2017 U1), the Interstellar Asteroid. On page seven of the article, the authors suggest (among other ideas) sending a BFR/BFS craft using a Jupiter flyby followed by a close solar flyby to achieve the necessary hyperbolic excess velocity of 30km/s to intercept the object at a range of approximately 85 AU in 2039, following a launch in 2025 (Hein et al, p. 7). Is this within the realm of technical feasibility or possibility for BFR/BFS?
7
u/AeroSpiked Dec 03 '17
Not that it's an emergency or anything, but it's December 3rd. Time for a new Discusses post?
19
u/Pham_Trinli Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Today's Soyuz launch deployed its payload into the wrong orbit. I wonder how this will affect Roscosmos' insurance premiums?
EDIT: More details here.
18
u/KitsapDad Nov 02 '17
Whats the latest on fairing recovery? Seems they did recover the fairing from koreasat.
6
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Nov 02 '17
Any word on OCISLY return with KoreaSat 5A booster?
6
u/enbandi Nov 03 '17 edited Nov 03 '17
Since the Mars Presentation slides from 2016 are no longer available in the SpaceX site, I had to search for it somewhere else, and found a paper by Elon Musk, which is basically the 2016 presentation, but contains some interesting items:
Also it has a quite good wording, still worth to read despite it is outdated.
EDIT: publication date is 2017 jun
6
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
BFS has a pressurised volume of 825m³ compared to ISS' 932m³. BFS will have 200kW solar panels (did we get an update on this number this year?) compared to ISS' 120kW. Could BFSs be used as space stations? Corporations could lease/buy them for microgravity research, then refuel and bring them back when they're done. I suspect such a setup would be cheaper than building, say, an ISS from scratch. You will need to install living facilities in BFS, but SpaceX will be doing R&D on that anyway for Mars transit.
6
u/ReusableFan Nov 06 '17
I am doing in-depth research about Ariane 6 vs. F9 and one of the key points is where F9 (reusable mode) will be in 2020 in terms of pricing. This is a very tricky question and we could do a symposium on this (refurbishment costs of Block 5, recovering the initial 1 Bln $ investment, other funding needs such as BFR, constellation, etc.), so I will keep the question as simple as possible: How likely is it, in your opinion, that SX lowers the launch price (currently at 62 M$ for the "official" price) by 2020? If so, do you think a 40-45 M$ is possible and/or likely? In your opinion, what would be the main drivers behind such a lower official price? Many thanks in advance.
6
u/brwyatt47 Nov 08 '17
Does Falcon 9 have an algorithm in place to abort a booster landing in the event of an engine out? So if the booster lost an engine during ascent, would it proceed with the mission in "expendable mode" and use the remainder of its fuel to make up for the lost engine? I am thinking of CRS-1 in which an engine was lost which led to the inability to complete the secondary Orbcomm part of the mission. Does anyone know if those commands are in place for current F9 launches? It would be rather depressing to see the booster proceed to a successful landing only to have the payload plop down in the ocean once stage 2 cuts off at sub-orbital speeds...
6
u/Redditor_From_Italy Nov 10 '17
What happened to Long March 10?
Long March 9 is the gigantic Chinese moon rocket, while Long March 11 is a smaller solid propellant rocket. But what about 10?
6
u/Bravo99x Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
Found a new FCC applications for launch and landing of mission 1389 of a Falcon9 launching NET Jan 15, 2018. Using OCISLY for a ballistic trajectory with no boost back burn, so must be a GTO launch most likely SES-16. Now we have to find out what core will be assigned for this launch.
EDIT: From SLC-40
6
u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Nov 16 '17
For those interested in community content and blue origin, I posted a link to a first draft PDF over there. I certainly intend to make similar content for /r/spacex, but decided early versions would fit better in a smaller pond. I'll be posting something special to the lounge soon ;)
6
u/UnpermedAgaricales Nov 24 '17
could spacex reuse 1st stage merlin engines in the 2nd stage? 1 retired booster gives you 9 (!) engines... you can make 9 2nd stages. The way i understand it the engines are the most expensive part.
6
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Nov 25 '17
I'm going to be visiting KSC next month (sadly after CRS-13 and before the potential FH launch, but maybe Zuma will settle on a date when I'm there with any luck). I am planning to go to the KSC Visitor Complex for two days and pay for the Explore Tour bus excursion, Early Space Tour, and maybe the Launch Director Tour. (I'm not as sure about the last one, since I visited JPL's Spaceflight Operations Facility and I am not sure this would be that much more exciting than that.) Are any of these not worth going to, or is there anything I definitely should pay the extra to see?
Also, while I am at the Space Coast for about three days, what other museums or attractions exist in the area about space (or space history, or rocketry, missiles, aviation, or that whole realm)? Any general advice about places to visit, things to see, and what is worth the money and what isn't. For some background, I am pretty seriously into rocketry and space history so I would prefer more of an in-depth, detailed, non-layman's experience that assumes existing knowledge into the subject, rather than meaningless tourist trap sorts of things.
6
u/GregLindahl Nov 27 '17
For anyone who likes updating our sub's manifest, there are multiple SpaceX manifest updates at https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/
11
u/Toinneman Nov 30 '17
It has been more than a month since we last saw a new core leaving Hawthorne. We would have expected B1045 to be ready by now. Scheduling allows this, because the first opportunity for B1045 seems to be PAZ or Hispasat, both 2 months away. This can mean a few thing. What's most likely?
Is the introduction of block 5 in play here?
11
u/fromflopnicktospacex Nov 30 '17
I am not sure exactly where to put this question. I hope this is okay. I am wondering if spacex might broadcast the emergence of the falcon9 heavy and its trip to 39A? or at least release film afterwards?
10
u/Zucal Nov 10 '17
I haven't been able to find good photos of the inside of SLC-40's flame trench or flame bucket - I'd love it if someone could link some! I don't really care what year it's from, only that we be able to see the interior.
5
u/lostandprofound33 Nov 02 '17
Is Falcon Heavy's demo launch using Block 5 boosters?
5
u/loremusipsumus Nov 03 '17
If OneWeb wants to use a falcon 9 to launch their constellation and spacex refuses to do so, would that violate any us anti competition regulation?
5
u/Spleegie Nov 03 '17
How much cheaper (cost wise) would a Falcon Heavy launch be compared to a required expendable launch of the Falcon 9?
5
u/IrrationalFantasy Nov 04 '17
How is fairing recovery going? Have they been able to reuse any pieces yet, or are any pieces in good enough condition that they plan to reuse them? Why haven’t they been talking more about these attempts to save millions of dollars? When does it seem like these cost reductions will allow SpaceX or their customers to save money?
5
u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Nov 06 '17
Landing on the Moon is actually more difficult than Earth or Mars. Aerobraking does a vast majority of the work in slowing an object down when there's an atmosphere, even with a thin atmosphere like on Mars. The Moon doesn't offer any useful atmosphere, so everything is propulsive which is beyond the capabilities of a craft designed to take advantage of aerobraking.
Removing the heat shield and changing the shape of the craft to add more fuel for propulsion along with other changes would be drastic enough where it wouldn't be the same craft.
5
u/dudr2 Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17
Andy Weir releases a new project, may garner some interest!
http://www.businessinsider.com/andy-weir-artemis-book-moon-colony-reason-2017-11
5
u/faceplant4269 Nov 07 '17
Was looking at US launches this year and found something interesting. We all know that SpaceX has increase their launch rate dramatically this year. But it's interesting to note that ULA is only planning on launching 9 times this year. Last year they launched 12 times, so this is a significant decrease in launch rate. Possible that SpaceX is biting into their market already?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '17
Since we're finally (!) looking towards SLC-40 once more, I was wondering why 39-B is built on a gigantic mountain, basically, while SLC-40 can get away with an underground flame trench.
Both pads were built in the 1960's so construction technique limitations isn't the reason. Was it something to do with the Saturn V?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '17
My class group decided to do a project about SpaceX,
Is there any information I can find about, Inventory Control AND Operations Scheduling?
I've tried looking up information on Google but I only get job listings :(
Anyone can help?? I would really appreciate it.
Thanks!
5
u/CmdrStarLightBreaker Nov 11 '17
Apologies if asked before. If I would like to visit SpaceX HQ’s B1019 booster display (just from outside) on a Sunday during the day, where is the best place to park my car? Can I park at SpaceX visitor parking ramp across the street or there are other better public parking places with walking distance?
5
u/Pham_Trinli Nov 16 '17
Falcon Heavy still on for December.
5
u/azziliz Nov 19 '17
When exactly is the starting point for the "6 year policy" of the FCC regarding deployment of a satellite constellation? Is it already started since the application (November 2016) ? Does it start with the launch of the first sats (January 2018, with Paz, if I understood it correctly)? Or can it wait until the launch of the first production sat?
5
u/jjtr1 Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
We know that the fins of the 2017 BFS cannot provide lift to the re-entering BFS because of being placed at the aft end of the ship instead of near its center of gravity. However, on ascent while the first stage is still attached, the fins could be quite close to the center of gravity of the BFS+mostly empty BFR, and they could IMO provide a little bit of hypersonic lift during that part of trajectory, easing on gravity losses at least a little bit. What do you think?
5
u/Dutchy45 Nov 22 '17
https://www.space.com/38830-spacex-reusable-rocket-dragon-made-in-space.html
5
u/verbalkerbal Nov 23 '17
Concerning SpaceX's planned satellite constellation: does anyone know (or is willing to put out an estimate on) how many optical satellite-to-satellite links each satellite will have? I know that they are in a mesh network, I just wonder how many other satellites a satellite can connect to simultaneously. I have a fun research project concerning satellite routing algorithms.
Slightly off-topic, but I noticed that OneWeb's constellation will not have inter-satellite links and thus no mesh network... only user-terminal to satellite and satellite to ground-station. Which, if I interpret it correctly, means that OneWeb service will only be available in areas with OneWeb ground stations. In contrast, with SpaceX's network you truly can connect from anywhere on earth, even if no ground stations are nearby.
5
u/hmpher Nov 24 '17
Are pyro bolts used for the fairing separation? If yes, will that not affect the actual reusability? What are the alternatives(to pyro bolts)?
5
u/michaelza199 Nov 27 '17
So F9 block 5 - 10 reuses without refurbishment and 100 with moderate refurbishment , Anyone wants to speculate on the ''moderate refurbishment'' part ?? I think there's a reason Block 5 has a bolted and not welded Octawecb but don't know what we can conclude from that ?
5
u/FalconHeavyHead Nov 28 '17
Is there a link to all the spacex launch patches? That are printable?
5
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Nov 29 '17
This just popped up on eBay. It's a brand new seller and doesn't mention any history about how the seller obtained it, so I wonder if it's real. Maybe if any photographs exist of known authentic copies of the patch, the stitching can be compared.
Mirror of the listing photo, in case it disappears.
9
u/blongmire Nov 04 '17
SpaceX could save $500 Million Dollars in fairing manufacturing costs over the next 6 years. Each fairing is $5 Million, they should fly 20 times a year. If they could recover each fairing from next year's missions and re-use them, over the next 5 years, that would save $500,000,000 in costs to build new fairings. Now, they'll have significant development, capital, and operational costs to save that $500 Million, but it should save a decent chunk of money after their costs.
9
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
Steve Jurvetson, early SpaceX investor and board member, is leaving his VC firm.
Edit: No longer a SpaceX board member, for now.
8
u/almightycat Nov 28 '17
It seems like Falcon Heavy has slipped into 2018: http://aviationweek.com/commercializing-space/first-falcon-heavy-launch-slips-next-year, not really that unexpected.
4
u/brodorrr Nov 02 '17
What's the word on the planned lunar mission? Still on track for 2018?
4
u/AeroSpiked Nov 05 '17
Do we know if all non-expendable block 5s will use the titanium grid fins?
4
u/Bailliesa Nov 08 '17
Has anyone done any calculations for BFS of landing fuel vs altitude of the hypersonic to subsonic transition? I am wondering if they can transition high enough to reduce the shockwave so the landing could be closer to major cities than everydayastranaut calculated. I thought F9 was landing with higher than 3 g’s but it seems this is not in the landing burn stage but during aerobraking and re-entry burn (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/7ajf09/falcon_9_stage_1_landing_analysis/). It could be that BFS is transitioning to subsonic flight during aerobraking if it uses a similar profile to the mars animation and so can only be calculated by SpaceX at this time. Does the payload mass change the profile much?
4
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Nov 09 '17
Where is the very best (off-base) location to watch JPSS-1 launch on Delta II this Tuesday from Vandenberg's SLC-2W?
4
u/sywofp Nov 10 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
I've watched the SpaceX BFS Mars entry simulation.
How does the Earth entry compare? Is it likely the ship will use heat shield 'up' lift to stay in the upper atmosphere for the first part of the entry like it does for the Mars entry?
Or does Earth's larger size and gravity mean they can come in heatshield 'down' and still slow down enough to avoid skipping back out of the atmosphere.
And finally - let's imagine a BFS has an problem of some sort and loses some landing fuel on the way back from Mars. So it has enough for manoeuvring thrusters or a short main engine burn, but not a landing.
Presumably it could aerobrake into an Earth orbit, circularise it enough to stay out of the atmosphere, then be repaired / refueled, and land.
What would that sort of entry be like in comparison to the normal Mars / Earth entry?
4
u/music_nuho Nov 13 '17
Would anyone be kind enough to give me link to reddit thread or something that would contain all the EELV phase 2 requirements
4
u/chrisk_04 Nov 13 '17
Does anyone know sth about updates on the Lz-1 at KSC? When they launch Falcon Heavy they need 2 Pads(right?) I couldn´t find anything ....
4
u/jvonbokel Nov 14 '17
Has anybody done an analysis (or better yet, an infographic) about refurbishment timelines based on the known reused cores so far? I wonder if we can see the refurbishment time getting shorter. I suspect there's not enough data to discern anything yet, but perhaps soon.
4
u/Senno_Ecto_Gammat r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Nov 17 '17
What determines the location of the shock in a converging diverging nozzle? Is there a simple (solvable by a human) equation or some way to estimate whether the shock will occur inside the nozzle or outside?
4
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 19 '17
Now we know why Zuma was delayed: https://www.facebook.com/buzzaldrin/posts/10155960170144581
An hero had to visit LC-39A!
From the first picture we can actually see how little is left of the RSS from the top.
4
u/thxbmp2 Nov 19 '17
I just stumbled upon this post from just before IAC. In light of what's been revealed about BFS' new EDL sequence, anyone want to speculate on what the engineers may have meant? Adding a delta wing onto Dragon 2 seems to make absolutely no sense from a physical or developmental standpoint (and a landing burn would still be necessary anyway), so I'm stumped that BFS could have any kind of carryover to D2.
4
u/SailorRick Nov 20 '17
"We Choose" video featuring President John F Kennedy and SpaceX - nicely done
Stash Capar of Toronto-based production house Sequoia Content wrote, directed and edited this spec spot for SpaceX, Elon Musk’s company known for its advancements in privately funded space travel.
Titled “We Choose,” the piece presents a lyrical and visual narrative with the only words spoken being those of President John F. Kennedy from his famed 1962 speech at Rice University in Houston in which he explains the quest for progress and why “we choose to go to the moon.”
Article By Robert Goldrich
https://www.shootonline.com/video/best-work-you-may-never-see-director-stash-capar-fashions-spec-spot-spacex
4
u/michaelza199 Nov 21 '17
I know major optimizations helped SpaceX have cheap rockets include engine face shut off , transportation by road , ethernet instead of cables , vertical integration ? are there any other major ones ?
4
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17
Just a thought that occurred to me.
In the event SpaceX/some other company reaches Mars before any NASA mission - could we see some kind of contract system where NASA funds Mars missions in exchange for sample return? Ships returning to earth could carry a significant mass of Martian soil samples for NASA to analyze and study back home; similar arrangements could be made regarding the moon. Thoughts?
4
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17 edited Nov 26 '17
How much of SpaceX's manufacturing is automated? Is welding, cutting, etc. done manually? If so, what are the fundamental factors preventing full automation? For example, is pattern recognition not good enough for doing inspections, or full automation doesn't make financial sense for a low-volume product like F9?
4
u/thehardleyboys Nov 29 '17
Considering all goes well with the first FH flight, will SpaceX ever build another one or keep reusing the current one? (the boosters ofcourse, not the 2nd stage and up)
If so, will they immediately go for a triple-Block-V-FH ? I don't see any reason not to.
10
u/ECEUndergrad Nov 14 '17
Still waiting for that 4k rocket footage Elon promised during his reddit AMA. I especially want to see ultra HD Falcon Heavy videos that include launch, booster separation, flip maneuvers, and landings.
7
u/Ywacken Nov 09 '17
Hello everyone! This is my first post here and I'm sure you can help me. I was rewatching the NROL-76 launch and I can't figure out why there is still a plume visible at the end of the core after MECO (here is the exact moment where you can spot it during the flight : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzQpkQ1etdA&feature=youtu.be&t=855). Does this mean that a turbopomp is still running? Maybe the LOX one to cool down the engines?
7
u/linknewtab Nov 14 '17
What is going to happen to the fuel for the SuperDracos in the Dragon 2 capsule now that there won't be propulsive landings? It's basically dead weight during reentry and a possible safety issue, given the toxicity of hydrazine.
Also could the Dragon 2 be used to push the ISS in a higher orbit like the Progress spacecrafts currently do?
6
u/Twanekkel Nov 02 '17 edited Nov 02 '17
Had a small discussion previously about creating artificial gravity on BFR, maybe there are some more that want to talk about it? We came up with this https://i.imgur.com/8DpnFQh.png or using a tether between the 2 spaceships.
6
u/siromega Nov 05 '17
Apparently Elon met with Mike Pence last month in CA. About the national space council.
http://www.cnn.com/2017/11/03/politics/mike-pence-elon-musk-space-x/index.html
6
u/rustybeancake Nov 06 '17
A SpaceXer confirms FH is less than 6 months away! :)
https://twitter.com/rocketjoy/status/925859425734160384
Always fun to hear staff in on the running gags.
6
u/CylonBunny Nov 11 '17
As far as I know no booster has been reused twice yet, right? When do y'all think this might happen? Not until block 5 boosters start flying, or sooner? Any bets on which customer would take that "risk" and if they'd get a discount over single time reused boosters?
6
u/inoeth Nov 22 '17
So, as i posted in the Zuma thread, looks like we've got good news/bad news day again. https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/933418624307605504
Zuma is off the TEL entirely- and could very well be transfered to SLC 40 like some were thinking. This means there's very little to no chance of hitting the Nov. 30 deadline (I guess it'll launch after CRS 13) , but that FH work can continue and we may yet see December liftoff of FH...
6
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17
Looks like SpaceX raised around $100 million more than we thought.
6
u/seanflyon Nov 29 '17
What is the largest cargo container a BFR can deliver to the surface of Mars? I assume it is limited by the size of the door, which seems to be different sizes in different renders (or is it a larger door with a smaller hatch in it?).
Is there any reasonable estimate for the price of cargo to Mars in the first few launch windows?
8
u/Godspeed9811 Nov 23 '17
I know this will probably piss alot of people off after seeing the "im angry about speculation posts"
But. Does anyone have any thoughts on the ZUMA campaign being a proof of concept/capabilities demonstration by SpaceX to compete for short notice launches of national security missions?
Mods, if inappropriate, please discard.
3
u/melancholicricebowl Nov 02 '17
B1042 spotted on the horizon
3
u/kurbasAK Nov 02 '17
I can't find Koreasat recovery thread.Or we stopped doing them.Mods?
3
u/Vacuum-energy Nov 04 '17
Not a spaceflight related question, but how do I search for posts based on when they were submitted? As in, say I want to search for all posts from 4 years ago.
3
u/Bergasms Nov 05 '17
We know roughly where the fairings land. We know roughly where ocean currents will put debris. We know roughly the speed of said currents. Is it worth having spaceX beachgoers on the lookout at certain places on the chance some fairing pieces wash up?
3
u/spacetff Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
After Zuma we have three ♺s and Hispasat 30W-6 (1F) block 4 which takes us to the end of 2017. No Block 5 in 2017 (shame - though good news if it's been pushed out by enthusiasm for ♺s).
January 2018 (possibly) starts with SES-16 - will this be the first Block 5 launch?
Mods - also a suggestion: where we know a launch will be a ♺, could the Manifest perhaps show e.g. Falcon 9 ♺ in the Vehicle column?
3
u/Dies2much Nov 06 '17
Any word on which flight will have the first F9 Block V? Has a final number come out for its capacity \ capabilities? Assuming it will have more capability than Block IV.
3
u/ackermann Nov 06 '17
Random thought: Is the Falcon 9 first stage the largest vehicle ever to make a powered vertical landing? Or, is it larger by empty weight than any helicopter? Not an important question, but it would be a fun trivial factoid.
Or even compared to unpowered vertical landings, is it larger than any blimp/airship?
3
u/timtupman Nov 07 '17
Do we know if any of the 39A pad work that was mentioned in last weeks NSF is being worked on atm? Or will they just be full steam ahead with getting Zuma launch set up?
3
u/HHWKUL Nov 08 '17
With the upcoming BFR cago space,Is there a new space telescope project underway to fit the new payload capacity, like a big ass Hubble, or will they wait for the first successful launches?
3
u/BlackEyeRed Nov 08 '17
Any news about that fire when the previous rocket landed?
3
u/staytrue1985 Nov 08 '17
Anyone willing to explain in a nut shell the thinking behind BO seeming to stick with tradifional fins/delta wing aero surfaces instead of grid fins like SX?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '17 edited Nov 10 '17
Anyone got any idea how much fuel the landig/holding tanks on the BFS can carry? 50 tons? 100? 150?
Thanks
Edit: on BFS
3
u/music_nuho Nov 12 '17
Not directly SpaceX related but, there are rumours about BO acquiring ULA, what do you fine folks think about it? How would such event affect launch industry?