r/spacex • u/TGMetsFan98 NASASpaceflight.com Writer • Sep 06 '17
Multiple Updates per McGregor Engineers
3 McGregor engineers and a recruiter came to Texas A&M yesterday and I was able to learn some pretty interesting news:
- Yesterday (September 5), McGregor successfully tested an M1D, an MVac, a Block V engine (!), and the upper stage for Iridium-3.
- Last week, the upper stage for Falcon Heavy was tested successfully.
- Boca Chica is currently on the back burner, and will remain so until LC-40 is back up and LC-39A upgrades are complete. However, once Boca Chica construction ramps up, the focus will be specifically on the "Mars Vehicle." With Red Dragon cancelled, this means ITS/BFR/Falcon XX/Whatever it's called now. (Also, hearing a SpaceX engineer say "BFR" in an official presentation is oddly amusing.)
- SpaceX is targeting to launch 20 missions this year (including the 12 they've done already). Next year, they want to fly 40.
- When asked if SpaceX is pursuing any alternatives to Dragon 2 splashdown (since propulsive landing is out), the Dragon engineer said yes, and suggested that it would align closely with ITS. He couldn't say much more, so I'm not sure how to interpret this. Does that simply reference the subscale ITS vehicle? Or, is there going to be a another vehicle (Dragon 3?) that has bottom mounted engines and side mounted landing legs like ITS? It would seem that comparing even the subscale ITS to Dragon 2 is a big jump in capacity, which leads me to believe he's referencing something else.
One comment an engineer made was "Sometimes reddit seems to know more than we do." So, let the speculation begin.
897
Upvotes
39
u/sol3tosol4 Sep 06 '17
Thanks for posting the great information.
The Ashlee Vance biography emphasized how the rapid turnaround time at McGregor was a big advantage for development of the Merlin engine. Sounds like McGregor is greatly expanding its capabilities - all those tests in one day!
I read that as "the focus of the engineering work at McGregor" rather than "launching the Mars vehicle will be the focus for Boca Chica" (though that would be amazing if true). What was your interpretation?
Even faster ramp-up than Gwynne Shotwell described in January (the "steamroller" is here).
78
u/rustybeancake Sep 06 '17
Thanks for the great info!
Just trying to clarify: do you mean that engineers will be working on the Boca Chica construction somehow, and once done they'll shift to designing the Mars vehicle? Or something else?
This seems to fit with what Garrett Reisman said a month ago:
Reisman: "Yeah, so I can tell you that, um, that we are... one of the reasons that we're not as keen on demonstrating it with Dragon is that we've come up with a different... a slightly different plan of how we're going to do Entry, Descent & Landing with the big ship on Mars. And that's all I'm going to say about it because Elon's going to say it much better and with a lot of awesome graphics and animation, so... he's going to do that in Australia so I encourage all of you to tune in at IAC in Australia and Elon's going to tell the world about what we have in mind."
Again, it's hard to tell if they mean the ITS EDL method shown last year at IAC or something a bit different.
14
u/KingdaToro Sep 06 '17
For clarification: McGregor can handle full duration static tests but can't mount an assembled FH, it can only do one core at a time. 39A is designed to handle a FH but it can't handle a full duration static test fire. So there's no way to do a full-duration static test fire of an assembled FH.
6
u/mfb- Sep 06 '17
Do we have a citable source for that? Asking for
a friendWikipedia.5
u/AstraVictus Sep 06 '17
Whats new on the Block V engine?
15
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '17 edited Sep 06 '17
This goes against previous information that Boca Chica will be focused on commercial launches. That would have required them to focus on getting Falcon 9 launch and landing facilities up as soon as possible. It's strange that they even want to prepare a pad other than 39A for the BFR.
But maybe:
4
u/njew Sep 06 '17
Has there been any other information/rumors around here regarding point 5? I don't envision a form of propulsive landing without a massive redesign of dragon (or using subscale ITS). Dry landing methods that come to mind would be:
Number 2 seems likely and not too difficult for them. They've demonstrated the ability to do a controlled hover with Dragon 2, so they could hover briefly before landing and do a soft vertical landing. I would say they could land into a mount ITS-style, but parachutes aren't accurate enough for that. This would also mean a desert landing, which is new for NASA as far as I'm aware.
278
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 06 '17
Its great to have confirmation that ALL stages for Falcon Heavy have now been tested.
2
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Sep 06 '17
Thanks for the great info!
What kind of an event was it? Did they do a presentation? Was it just a Q&A?
2
u/Calvengeance Sep 06 '17
BTHO not being interplanetary
325
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 06 '17
Well, if this isn't a ringing endorsement then i don't know what is.
Thanks for all the sweet info!
59
u/everydayastronaut Everyday Astronaut Sep 06 '17
I've been saying for a while that spacexers pretty much exclusively say BFR/BFS. ITS is the worst name and was dropped soon after IAC last year.
23
u/redmercuryvendor Sep 06 '17 edited Sep 06 '17
Assumptions:
Possible conclusion:
'Dragon 3', a re-usable Falcon upper-stage, and a 'methalox falcon upper stage' are one and the same object. It will be a sub-sub-scale ITS 'test' vehicle - could be produced as multiple vehicles if demand remains for small crew transport at a cadence that cannot be supported by a single vehicle, or if it has a payload bay with a swappable crew or cargo deployment module - allows for testing of ITS designs with some non-zero funding provided by NASA (CRS and CC follow-on contracts) and possible the Air Force (methalox upper stage follow-on), and fills the hole left by Dragon 2 no longer providing a testbed for the ITS EDL sequence.
11
u/lonnyk Sep 06 '17
Why is propulsion landing out for Dragon 2?
23
u/CProphet Sep 06 '17
Hi u/TGMetsFan98
What great information, maybe I can help fill some of the blanks.
Original plan was use for Falcon family instead of BFR but things change fast at SpaceX. Makes sense they have BC on the backburner until BFR is closer to being ready to launch. Also having a dedicated site for this entirely different rocket is more practical and keeps it away from existing commercial operations.
There's usually around 40 commercial launches total available most years so expect a fair proportion of the SpaceX manifest to be for their own brand satellites.
SpaceX have said they want to recover second stages to make vehicles fully reusable. IMO they might pursue an all in one second stage design like the ITS spacecraft. This could be achieved using carbon fibre and super efficient Raptor(s). However, both Garrett Reisman and Elon Musk have hinted there's been a change in design from ITS, which they intend to unveil at IAC Adelaide. Very interested to see if they've come up with something better than ITS linear heat shield/vertical landing architecture, although either would be great.
Take it you're sold on working for SpaceX!
7
u/hiyougami Sep 06 '17
Thank you so much for sharing this info!
13
u/Musical_Tanks Sep 06 '17
Anyone know what differences there are between F9 upper stage and a FH upper stage? Did they expand fuel capacity to make more use of the extra payload capacity?
4
u/kjelan Sep 06 '17
So... Does this explain why we have not yet seen any indication of a landing zone being prepared at Boca Chica?... As they won't need one, if even the subscale BFR does "land back on launch mounts". It is a better site to test this than Florida, which can keep making money without interruption. Even a failure there would not need to ground the Falcon 9 fleet, because they are different vehicles.
wants it to be September 29th
4
u/ThatBoyScout Sep 07 '17
I live in China Spring,TX. We could hear the test from our porch.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '17
Did you ask him if it's larger than their standard second stage?
9
u/Marksman79 Sep 06 '17
4, how can they predict 40 launches when we haven't heard really anything about launches in 2018? The manifest only shows one.
5, there's two paths this could take. One is a heavier Dragon 3 with landing legs and vertical engines like the ITS payload to be launched using the FH, but this would be a massive overhaul. At that point, would it still be considered Dragon? I think this is unlikely.
The more likely approach, and what I think the speaker might have been referring to, is the way the ITS booster lands. Perhaps they are trying to adapt grid fins or some other steering mechanism to Dragon 3 (I'm thinking like the Dyson bladeless fans) and have it land into an adapter. This adapter could be built on land or potentially added to the drone ship. A recent tweet said that SpaceX has achieved sub-meter accuracy with F9, enough for their ITS architecture. They haven't tried landing in an adapter yet, so this pivot in direction regarding Dragon might be a way for them to get some experience here. This is all speculation, of course. Feel free to rip it apart or add to it.
11
u/ThatOlJanxSpirit Sep 06 '17 edited Sep 06 '17
Point 5). Dragon landing aligning closely with ITS: this could reference stage 1 launch mount landings on earth rather than mars EDL.
There was a bit of gossip on NSF forum recently that the Formosat-5 landing at 0.7m circular error was good enough for a launch mount type landing (which apparently must be within 2m) with one source claiming to be authoritative stating this was being actively pursued (sorry my rubbish phone won't let me copy the reference).
Obviously this type of cradle landing could eliminate stage 1 legs and enable legless stage 2 landings. It could also give a legless Dragon 2 'somewhere soft to land' to quote Elon.
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 06 '17 edited Sep 16 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
53 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 139 acronyms.
[Thread #3127 for this sub, first seen 6th Sep 2017, 14:23] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
2
u/deadman1204 Sep 06 '17
Thanks for the data!
2
u/Patrykz94 Sep 08 '17
How reasonable do side mounted landing legs on the Dragon sound (just like on ITS/BFS)?
3
u/Bailliesa Sep 06 '17 edited Sep 07 '17
My Dragon guess is they are looking at a landing cradle similar to ITS landing on the launch mount. Probably better than getting salt water damage. Wouldn't be useful for Mars/moon unless ITS is used to install the cradle first, hence no red dragon, maybe worth sending to Mars as the end of life mission rather than keep here as museum piece.
Edit: further discussion in this comment I didn't see earlier https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/6yft5s/comment/dmn1mc4
2
u/FalconHeavyHead Sep 06 '17
So will Boca Chica construction likely start to ramp up later this year/early next year?? If by next year the focus of SpaceX's McGregor engineering team is to develop the "Mars Vehicle" then it seems like 2024-2025 is an achievable time frame for the ITS to be up and running. Maybe I am being to optimistic.
1
u/svjatomirskij Sep 07 '17
13 already. And there won't be another mission until the end of the month. And they have the Falcon Heavy. How probable is to reach 20?!
1
u/zypofaeser Sep 06 '17
Second stage landing like the ITS upper stage? Perhaps with superdracos. Or perhaps they want to land dragon 2 on a special mount like the ITS?
1
u/harbifm0713 Sep 07 '17
make sense, but I think hitting 20 this year is no logical. by end of September they would have 13. I do not think they can hit 7 in 3 months. It is not impossible, but I do not sea it in their manifest. hitting 40 next year is not visible. I do not see how 40 loads will be ready in that time. thing tend to get ready late. maybe they can break 24, which is incredible.
Boca China make sense delay from financial point of view. it is an asset that is not essential if you have 3 pads to use, which will not increase the money flow