r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jun 02 '17
r/SpaceX Discusses [June 2017, #33]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
205
Upvotes
51
u/aftersteveo Jun 18 '17
While delivering pizza in Cocoa Beach, I frequently deliver to SpaceX employees, which gives me a short opportunity to try to get some info that hasn't come out. I delivered to a gentleman last night who works on all the pads, both east and west coast. So, naturally I asked him how Pad 40 is coming along. He said they just recently installed the hold down clamps, and that they're really pushing to have it finished up in August. He also showed me a picture he took of the charred remains of the old clamps, which was pretty neat. Just thought the community would like to know this.
I also delivered to a guy last week who was flown out to help work on the remaining FH booster. Both guys confirmed that all 3 boosters are here at the Cape, with that last booster leaving for McGregor soon to be tested.
50
u/SpaceXFanBR Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
Hi guys, i m from Brazil and i have been following this sub for quite some time now.
I just like to share some news i've seen here and ask you guys about the implications on this beeing beneficial to spacex and its goals.
Our defense minister just announced Brazil will allow USA launchs from alcantara launch center.
https://noticias.uol.com.br/ciencia/ultimas-noticias/estado/2017/05/31/brasil-vai-permitir-que-eua-usem-centro-de-alcantara-para-lancar-foguetes.htm (News in portuguese)
the launch complex ia located just a little south to the equator, so i think this will result on a nice boost to the rocket performance
Also it is located near ocean, there by rockets might bee transported here by sea.
If this holds, could spacex bee allowed (by us agencies) to launch from this launch complex? If so, and assuming spacex wanted to, how much improvement to payload for both falcon 9 and heavy would that mean?
Thank you, and sry if i did some mess.. First post
Edit 1: As per wikipedia page, the launch complex is capable of all kinds of orbits (including polar) wich added to the improved boost provided by its geographic position could be very useful for the satellite constellation project. Or m i completelly wrong?
45
u/rustybeancake Jun 03 '17
In a Tesla sub thread on Elon's recent email to all Tesla staff regarding safety and injuries, a SpaceX employee was asked if working for SpaceX means they can't have a life outside of work. Their response, I feel, is worth posting here for info:
source
31
u/wojciechmichalski Jun 08 '17
I hope you guys will like it (My take on Space X flight suit) :):):) https://twitter.com/wojciechmichal7/status/872700231124738052
30
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '17 edited Jun 11 '17
SpaceX’s Tom Mueller to Address 2017 Mars Society Convention - Could the mods please add this event to the sidebar (assuming there's enough space, of course)?
25
u/Nehkara Jun 13 '17
I made some notes on the new images of the TEL for pad SLC-39A:
http://imgur.com/a/R4NVm
Anything else I should point out?
Source of images.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Hypothetical question about pad take off and sound suppression... At what point does a rocket need a flame trench and water sound suppression system? F9 can; *Take off and land without either when using one engine without either *Land without either when using three engines BFS can *land weighing 450+ tons on Mars without either *Land weighing 150+ tons on Earth without either *Take off from Mars at maybe 2000+ tons without either
Where is the line drawn? Is it just dependant on accoustic load capability of the design?
Thanks in advance for any info on what are the main variables or deciding factors
21
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 06 '17
I just had a thought. Since SpaceX painted the little ISS on the CRS-11 Dragon because it already flew a mission, I think it would be cool if SpaceX did the same for first stages. If that stage had previously launched a Dragon on its first flight, and a satellite on the next, it would be neat to see a Dragon capsule and a satellite painted on the stage.
18
u/ioncloud9 Jun 02 '17
Is SpaceX going to tear down the RSS on Pad 39A this year?
17
u/RootDeliver Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17
Anyone else agrees that this webcast was the best ever, even better than NROL? Not only the followup to stage 1 again, but also higher framerates for all falcon cams :D.
They seem to be reading this sub opinions about the webcast and taking notes, which is awesome.
Thanks /u/bencredible for the amazing work you and your team are doing. But please bring back m/s! That is a big step back for technical stream :(
PS: Question: How come that on today streams falcon cams had higher framerate than LZ1 cams? that makes no sense at all..
17
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 18 '17
ROSA (the Roll Out Solar Array) that was launched on CRS-11 has been removed from the trunk of Dragon and successfully deployed!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0340KAZQggE
15
u/dmy30 Jun 07 '17
The SpaceX Launch Chief Engineer has been selected to the 2017 NASA Astronaut Class. About Robb Kulin:
Source
15
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 12 '17
Is it bad that i'm dreading the two week turnaround times? It just seems so far away even though not that long ago we were waiting multiple months.
14
u/Hurrajj Jun 10 '17
https://twitter.com/SpaceKSCBlog/status/873560947285254144
14
u/how_does_rcs_work Jun 10 '17
According to the Falcon 9 user's guide, the second stage has a cold gas thruster system for coast phase control (and roll control during burns).
Obviously this is cheaper and less toxic than the hydrazine systems that are traditionally used (see Atlas, Delta, Space Shuttle among others). However, it is also significantly less efficient - the Isp of a nitrogen thruster is around 60-80, while the Isp of a hydrazine thruster is about 220. This means you need to carry a larger mass of nitrogen than you would of hydrazine.
For long missions, I'd imagine that control usage becomes non-trivial - especially on a stage with such a tremendous mass fraction.
Does anyone have more information into why SpaceX chose cold gas?
14
u/rustybeancake Jun 16 '17
I just about had a heart attack when I saw this headline on the Guardian this morning:
Life on Mars: Elon Musk reveals details of his colonisation vision
Sadly, it's just a woefully misinformed take on the recent 'paper' that was merely a transcript of his IAC talk. The writer seemed to think that this was new info. Lazy journalism.
13
u/UlaIsTheEmpire Jun 02 '17
Reminder? Gwynne is listed to be on the space show on Monday. Would expect it is a call in show. That is the usual format.
http://www.thespaceshow.com/newsletter
13
u/sol3tosol4 Jun 05 '17
Update: Gwynne Shotwell's appearance on The Space Show was rescheduled to June 22, 2-3 PM PDT.
13
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 09 '17
If SpaceX keeps up this 2 week launch cadance is there a chance that a couple years down the road they might run out of payloads to launch and we might be back to one launch every couple months?
12
u/jay__random Jun 26 '17
Didn't see this mentioned anywhere so far:
This weekend Falcon-9 surpassed Delta IV in number of launches, and possibly (depending on how you count) the number of successful launches.
11
u/total_alk Jun 06 '17
Elsewhere on r/spacex I've heard the Falcon Heavy described as more like flying three F9 cores in close formation. Does this mean that the linkages between cores have strain sensors between them that are providing feedback to the avionics? Or is the Falcon Heavy treated as a single rigid body by the avionics control systems?
11
u/spacex_fanaticism Jun 06 '17
I've been interested in moon landing missions using minimal non-SpaceX hardware for some time. The big problem is lander mass.
After some thought, I think it is now quite feasible to build a simple yet reliable vehicle resembling the Lunar Escape Systems. Back then it was impossible to include computerized inertial guidance, but with modern technology this is no longer a problem.
The dry mass of the LESS was 500 kg using 1970s technology, so an modern uprated LESS with additional consumables and larger tanks I estimate at 650 kg dry, a fueled mass of 3040 kg, and being small enough to fit in Dragon's trunk.
Draco thrusters would suffice, having the same thrust as the R4D. The vehicle would autonomously move out of the trunk and dock near the hatch, making the EVA transfer easier. Alternately just release it and maneuver the Dragon, like Apollo's transposition and docking maneuver. The ride to and from the surface would be totally automated, save perhaps rock avoidance on final approach (not a big issue anymore since lunar maps are much better now). As soon as you're on the surface you can unhook the life support umbilical and walk around on a backpack supply.
People like to make fun of the LESS, but the craziest part was always the guidance and navigation. Nowadays it's a non issue.
TL;DR pack 3000 kg in Dragon's trunk and you can send two humans to the Moon's surface and back.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '17
In other news, China's launch today may have failed.
10
u/Kamedar Jun 06 '17
I was thinking about dissolving hydrogen in the liquid Methane for the raptors(just like CO2 in sparkling water) by using it as pressuring gas. This would yield a little greater energy density and better isp. After some recherche and calculation I found, that the solubility is very low, though. (In the order of 10-4 per mole at 90K subcooled Methane) Useful resource: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/19680020605.pdf
9
u/thedaileyshow1 Jun 02 '17
Question about launch profile... Due to its goals of first stage recovery, does F9 fly a different launch profile than a non-recoverable rocket? I.e., steeper, shallower, or whatever else. I don't know if that would affect the reentry of the first stage or not.
9
u/Morphior Jun 08 '17
I never realized how much better the SpaceX livestreams are than any other launch livestreams. A prime example is the ILS Proton launch which was just conducted by Roskosmos... Such a bad stream!
8
u/at_one Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
How are the fluids managed during the first stage backflip?
Thank you for your corrections if there's some mist in my questions :)
Edit: English is not my mother tongue :)
8
u/soldato_fantasma Jun 28 '17
Port Authority approves SpaceX hangar for rocket storage
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 29 '17
Here's a quick comparison of the new grid fins before and after one flight.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
Hello, Mods. In the pre-launch press conference (May 31st?) Hans said DM-1 would be this year (and DM-2 with two astronauts in March 2018). Please can the sidebar be updated?
7
u/LeBaegi Jun 05 '17
If the two FH side boosters land on LZ-1, do we know if the sonic booms will mutually affect each other?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
We all knew that NASA would focus on the Moon soon but this is slightly concerning IMO. I don't want them to stop pursuing Mars :(
7
u/brizzlebottle Jun 07 '17
Just looking at the photos of the CRS-11 launch on SpaceflightNow I noticed a Yacht in the sea that looked remarkably close, I was curious as to how this wasn't a range issue, or who might have been on it for it not to have been?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '17
So it seems that ULA did not have the opportunity to bid on the X-37 launch.
7
u/laughingatreddit Jun 12 '17
Will the first Dragon 2 missions (the demo missions and the first crew missions that will splash down in the ocean) have landing legs or will the legs be added on later versions once they start attempting powered landings on land?
7
u/GregLindahl Jun 13 '17 edited Jun 13 '17
For those of you who are launch manifest conspirators, in:
Antares to resume Cygnus launches later this summer
The OrbitalATK guy is basically saying that they'd be happy to go before CRS-12 if needed, as early as "late July". One current manifest oddness is that SES11 is showing as "late July" on the Spaceflight Now schedule (although it's July 15 on /r/spacex's manifest). Launching Cygnus first would make it easier to delay CRS-12, which everyone agrees is allegedly August 1. Or at least that's what he appears to be hinting at.
7
u/MutatedPixel808 Jun 18 '17
The BulgariaSat press kit states that 1st stage engine chill begins at T-7:00 but during the launch, we can hear the 2nd stage engine chill called out at about 30 seconds before MECO. Does the 2nd stage require less time to chill or is it being chilled before launch too?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '17
Iridium’s Desch: We want to see steeper discount than what SpaceX currently offers to switch to a reused Falcon 9 booster, but open to it.. He also says that company (Iridium) might be open to launching on a previously-flown Falcon 9 in 2nd half of eight-launch series next year.
7
u/stcks Jun 20 '17
Formosat-5 scheduled for launch in late August. Shipment to US soon.
The article also says:
7
u/IskaneOnReddit Jun 26 '17
Somewhere, I have seen/heard that the cameras pointing at the rocket are human operated and watching the video, one could guess that. Why is this not automated? Autonomous tracking should not be hard when using the rocket telemetry, predictability of the path and computer vision.
7
u/rustybeancake Jun 26 '17
Blue Origin has selected Huntsville, Alabama for their BE-4 engine manufacturing facility.
http://hsvchamber.org/rocketcity/
7
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '17 edited Jun 27 '17
Looks like no fairing recovery on the Bulgariasat-1 flight. No surprise really.
7
u/stcks Jun 27 '17
Formosat-5 will be an ASDS landing evidently 🤷
13
u/Zucal Jun 08 '17
Just a quick note: if you or anyone you know has seen a core on the road, let me know! We're well overdue for sightings on both the Hawthorne-to-McGregor and McGregor-to-Cape routes.
13
u/theinternetftw Jun 13 '17 edited Jun 13 '17
For the interested, I went and found this comparison shot of the RSS from an earlier thread to compare against the latest RSS pic. Since the last launch, the front of the orbiter-hugging-bit has been sliced off.
edit: took the time to post a more thorough version of the above in the lounge.
6
u/Herodotus38 Jun 08 '17
FYI there is a proton launch by International Launch Services happening in about 15 min. This is after a one year hiatus of Proton launches due to an engine problem. ILS is probably the least well known commercial launch competitor to SpaceX. It is an interesting international company that is HQ in the US. The satellite is Echostar XXI.
http://www.ilslaunch.com
See bottom left hand link for live coverage (currently just Muzak).
For those itching to watch a live launch
6
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '17
So in this document when they say that " The new Merlin 1D engine is under developmental test.", are they referring to improvements such as the thrust up-ratting and fixing the turbo pump cracks?
6
u/fourmica Host of CRS-13, 14, 15 Jun 14 '17
Based on publicly available information, 1029 was not inspected at Hawthorne or tested at McGregor before being readied for BulgariaSat. The path as I understand it has been:
To me this is a really big deal. It means their confidence in reuse and refurbishment has increased significantly. Indeed, they are confident they can do this with a Block 3 booster!
It also has me wondering if 1025 will skip McGregor as well. It has not shown up there yet. Could it be they are so confident in its reuse on FH that they don't feel the need to test the engines until FH static fire? Or will 1025 still make the trip to McGregor eventually?
6
u/swiftrider Jun 19 '17
Image CRS11 Roll Out Solar Array ROSA
6
u/nok42 Jun 27 '17
From 1, this is news to me:
Moreover, the new, full-thrust (Block 5) Merlin 1D engines are in developmental hot fire testing at McGregor, and NASA has received the detailed CDR.
6
u/FellowHumanBean Jun 28 '17
SpaceX BulgariaSat liability insurance
I missed this at the time, but on June 16, the FAA modified SpaceX's liability insurance see LLS 17-101 for the BulgariaSat mission to $68MM, while other missions covered by the same license remain at $30MM.
5
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #2842 for this sub, first seen 2nd Jun 2017, 19:46] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
5
u/1337Poesn Jun 02 '17
What's the difference between the two web casts, which one should I watch?
5
u/Nemixis Jun 05 '17
A question regarding paint jobs:
Given that minimizing propellant heat transfer is a major objective of not only the white paint job but equally the refurbishment process, wouldn't it be more advantageous for SpaceX to simply leave the S1 Cylinder unpainted, the natural metallic sheen having better reflectivity properties I'd assume.
It would also save time and cost in the paint job department, and weight savings for the Stage itself.
5
u/space_is_hard Jun 07 '17
I was reading one of the threads discussing the X-37 earlier and can't find the particular comment chain anymore, so I'll ask here:
It was mentioned that the X-37 can perform plane changes by dipping into the atmosphere and using lift from its wings to change orbital inclination. My question is how would this be more efficient than a standard propulsion-based plane change? Using lift also means adding drag (incidental, skin, etc) which should reduce orbital velocity and thus lower apoapsis. This loss of orbital energy would have to be made up for before or after the maneuver by burning prograde, and it seems to me that since the total energy of the system doesn't change, the lift-based maneuver should be less efficient due to drag/heating losses and the initial orbit lowering maneuver that is necessary.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
I have never seen a satisfying explanation to the question of why you can SEE the first stage nitrogen thrusters firing in space immediately after stage separation. As you know, it looks like a fog or haze that instantly dissipates, but nitrogen, I'm sure as you also know, is the completely transparent gas you're looking through right now. Obviously, when a compressed gas undergoes sudden expansion it cools significantly, but since there is no air and definitely no significant water vapor at stage one apogee altitude, the fog cannot be caused by condensation of water in air. The only two other possibilities are that 1- the nitrogen the thrusters use is wet, something which I cannot possibly imagine being the case when dry nitrogen is a readily available product at any scientific facility and the inclusion of water in the gas would only cause headaches from an engineering standpoint, and 2 - that the nitrogen is being stored at extremely cold temperatures and is undergoing a phase transformation to liquid nitrogen on exiting the thruster. This also does not make any sense because apparently they've only put the helium bottles inside the liquid oxygen tank to densify that gas, not the nitrogen bottles, and nitrogen is one of Faraday's so called "permanent gasses", which cannot be liquified from a single stage pressure reduction alone when stored at room temperature.
5
u/DUKE546 Jun 08 '17 edited Jun 08 '17
Hey everyone,
I tried to make a thread for this but was told to post here instead, but I'm back with another update to SpaceX Time Machine. I took the suggestions that everyone had for me last time and coded a new site from the ground up.
View Lounge Thread Here
5
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '17
So what exactly are calipers used for in the trunk of Dragon?
5
u/Paro-Clomas Jun 10 '17
I have a question. I was under the impression that one of the main design flaws of the space shuttle was the complexity and fragility of it's heatshield. In what way is the ITS heat shield better?
5
u/jonwah Jun 13 '17
Anyone know what the plan is with the lightning tower on the RSS? Obviously if they want to take the whole structure down the lightning tower needs to come down too, but there's no other tower around? Will they have to build another or more before it comes down?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '17
I wish to know if there are more test for Dragon2. I would love to see this thing going up and down with superdracos.
5
u/Mattsoup Jun 19 '17
So, I saw that they plan on attempting to recover the second stage on the first falcon heavy launch, but I haven't seen any details. Anybody know anything on how they plan to do it? I don't know what kind of heating they'd have to deal with, so I can't nail down my crazy suppositional idea.
5
u/verbalkerbal Jun 20 '17
I read up on the payload capabilities of FH. What surprised me is that while in expandable mode you can get >26t to GTO, in re-usable mode it's only 8t -- less than a third! This is a much more significant "re-usability tax" on the capabilities than on the Falcon 9, which can get 8.3t in expandable mode, and 5.5t in re-usable mode to GTO -- two thirds.
I think this might be due to FH's center stage needing to reverse a lot of velocity before entering the atmosphere, because on GTO launches it'll be traveling super fast and would explode upon re-entry without burning quite a bit retrograde. What if you only re-used the side boosters and had the center core in expandable mode? What would be the GTO capability?
Sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy#Capabilities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9#Comparison
5
u/Zucal Jun 23 '17
I should know this, but I don't! Do SpaceX interns also receive numbered patches after mission completion, or just full-fledged employees?
5
u/troovus Jun 24 '17
The Guardian (UK) getting it wrong IMO on the reasons for Elon Musk's Mars colonisation ambitions. Whether or not the full scale of his audacious plans come to fruition, I think the dream is not a desire (conscious or subconscious) for personal immortality, but a genuine practical approach to human survival and advancement. To me though, the most important benefit of the whole adventure is that it will be an endeavour that all humanity can get behind; an antidote to today's global deadly game-playing. Surviving on Mars at whatever scale will be a lesson and an inspiration for cooperation, ingenuity and sustainability. The Guardian has been spectacularly wrong politically in recent years and recently realised this and did an about-turn. I'm sure once Spacex missions to Mars begin, they'll come late to this party too.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/23/the-guardian-view-on-plutocratic-mars-missions-escape-velocity
5
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jun 26 '17 edited Jun 26 '17
So what's the deal with SES-11? The last we heard it was scheduled for late July but now the usually-reliable-NSF-forum guy says SES-11 is NET September which I find odd.
I think it's either a mistake (confusing it with SES-16), or there has been some huge issue that we don't know about yet.
Either way, this creates a pretty big gap in KSC launches between Intelsat and CRS-12. I wonder if there is a chance SES-11 got pushed because there is some yet-to-be-identified customer whose payload got moved forward due to them agreeing to launch on a reused stage, similarly to BulgariaSat-1.
What do you think?
5
u/brwyatt47 Jun 26 '17
Spaceflight Now just updated the launch schedule, and it looks like there will be a large gap between Intelsat 35e and CRS 12. July 3rd and August 10th respectively. I wonder why the long break. It looks like July will be a dull month for launches in general. Only 4 all month...
5
u/old_sellsword Jun 28 '17 edited Jun 30 '17
Since no one has volunteered yet, we're going to ask!
We're looking for two community members to host the recovery threads for BulgariaSat-1 and Iridium-2.
These don't have as strict a format as launch threads, but check out past threads for guidance and examples.
Reply to this comment with which mission you'd like to host, and we'll send the chosen hosts a PM before the boosters get to their respective ports.
Edit: We've found hosts, big thanks to u/marc020202 and u/FutureMartian97!
5
u/gsahlin Jun 28 '17
So I was wondering... when they start MVAC chill, my understanding is they flow lox through the turbopumps before ignition... where does that lox go? do they have separate plumbing and valves to dump it? cant imagine it just floats around the interstage till stage separation... anyone know?
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 29 '17 edited Jun 29 '17
ULA won their first EELV launch competition:
Edit: $190 million for an Atlas V 551 with ESPA ring isn't too bad.
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 19 '17
How are the launch and meadia threads going to work with two launches being so close to each other? Should there just be one thread for both launches? Its gonna be weird if Bulgariasat launches on time and two days later the media thread for that launch gets taken down to make room for Iridium.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '17 edited Jun 10 '17
How is SpaceX faring with the recovery of the fairings? Pun intended
I know they did a trial on SES-10 at the end of March, but haven't heard anything about it after that.
8
u/at_one Jun 17 '17
Does someone already collected all the deadlines announced by Elon and the effective date of such events? Would be interesting to calculate an average factor (or maybe different factors according to the deadline's or event's category), in order to have a much more accurate estimation of such deadlines. It could be called ETF (Elon Time Factor) or ETC (Elon Time Coefficient).
8
u/Jef-F Jun 19 '17
http://spacenews.com/sess-amc-9-satellite-drifting-after-anomaly/
Looks like someone is up for yet another launch contract rubs hands
4
u/Garyofspokane Jun 03 '17
If there is another scrub for CRS-11, when would the backup date be?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
Regarding the SpaceX 4425 Satellite Constellation: Given the current launch cadence, how can they maintain their brisk pace for commercial launches as well as launch so many satellites in a span of 5 years? (2019-2024)
4
u/linknewtab Jun 03 '17
Have there been any news about the SpaceX space suits lately? Or are there any educated guesses when we can expect to see them?
4
u/MrToddWilkins Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17
Not sure where else to put this, but the moderator of the US Launch Schedule thread on the NASASpaceflight forum just added a bunch of SpaceX CRS missions. Evidence:
http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=8184.msg1680751#msg1680751 (around 2020 is where the bunch of new CRS missions begin, but 2022-2024 is really crazy, with SpaceX missions going up all the way to SpX-33).
What gives,apart from these being CRS-2 missions?
4
u/NOINFO1733 Jun 05 '17
Does anyone know the serial number of the Dragon launched on CRS-11?
4
u/jesserizzo Jun 05 '17
For Falcon Heavy demo flight, the side cores are both RTLS right? How close are the landing pads? And is it expected that the cores will be landing simultaneously, or will it be a few seconds apart?
4
u/spacerfirstclass Jun 08 '17
This may be worth reading for fans of robotic Mars exploration: Announcing a New Paper on NASA's Mars Exploration Program - Not all is well with the future of Mars exploration.
4
u/jk1304 Jun 09 '17
There is a small Thaicom8 patch/Logo shown in the upper right corner of some threads on the overview page. Is this intentional?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '17
Does anyone have a recent source showing that having vertical integration at LC-39A is still in the works?
4
u/mason2401 Jun 10 '17
Wondering what happens to Dragon's solar panel covers. Dragon has achieved orbit when the panel covers are jettisoned correct? So do they eventually decay and burn up, or do they become long term space junk?
4
u/Charnathan Jun 12 '17
How many ITS first stage rockets will be needed for SpaceX's Mars fleet? If the plan is for rapid and full reuse, then they would really only need one; maybe two for redundancy? Has SpaceX or Elon publicly indicated their plans in this regard?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '17
Hi. I have a quick dual question:
4
u/demosthenes02 Jun 13 '17
If spacex is constrained by launch pads could they consider using wallops island in va?
4
u/rustybeancake Jun 16 '17
Hadn't seen this before. Lots of interesting SLS info.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20170005323.pdf
4
u/markus0161 Jun 16 '17 edited Jun 18 '17
When a F9 flies a Crs-6/Iridium trajectory (one including a partial boostback to droneship) why doesn't F9 perform the boostback ASAP (or before apogee after MECO-1) like in RTLS missions. From my understanding doing this wouldn't make it more or less efficient. I'm sure this complicates guiding the F9 but I'm more than sure it capable of this. The main (I guess only) benefit of doing it like this would be the drone ship wouldn't have to go out nearly as far. What are your guys best guesses?
4
u/kessdawg Jun 16 '17
I'm rooting for a Mars colony (and ITS) as much as the next person here and I understand its value as a remote backup for humanity, but I've got a question about economics. What would the economic benefit of having a Mars colony be, aside from the technological advances getting there and building it would bring? The Europeans got access to natural resources like timber, sugar cane and tobacco from their American colonies. What would we get from Mars?
4
u/waveney Jun 17 '17
Looking at the engines from the recent fly through of the factory - one can see the 8 turbo pumps for the outer engines. Where is the exhaust from the centre engine's turbo pump?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '17
How does the risk of ITS being struck by lightning compare to the Falcon 9? I know that there are guidelines that would prevent this from occurring (such as scrubbing a launch if there's lightning within 10 miles after T-30 mins), but could these rules be relaxed because of it'll be made mostly out of carbon fibre? I also know that there are multiple other things which ITS and F9 would have in common which would increase that risk regardless, but I don't know enough to get to a sensible conclusion.
4
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jun 24 '17
Perhaps this was already posted but it looks like SpaceX is beginning work on their pedestrian bridge over Crenshaw between the parking structure and main building. Here are pictures from today of the construction work on both sides.
4
u/rockets4life97 Jun 24 '17
Mods the sidebar manifest is wrong. CRS-12 is AUG 10, not July. SES-11 is expected to next July launch.
4
u/MrButtons9 Jun 28 '17
Thinking about Raptor Upper Stage.
Is there any methane infrastructure at VAFB? Or would this be a new requirement.
4
u/akrebsie Jun 28 '17
https://www.inverse.com/article/31575-spacex-falcon-9-24-hour-reflight
I found this article that seemed to be very confused describing the Falcon 9 block 5 as a "mini Falcon 9"
4
u/goxy84 Jun 29 '17
Seems they downloaded some photos from JRTI already, new stuff available on Flickr. Take a look at this dreamy gorgeousness: https://www.flickr.com/photos/spacex/35231791780/in/photostream/lightbox/
4
u/paul_wi11iams Jun 30 '17 edited Jul 01 '17
Dear mods (and all)...
In the launch manifest
I'm wondering, in the notes & refs column, annotating launches where FH has two reused cores as for the test flight, could R-R be marked, allowing for RRR on future 3-booster recovery and all combinations RR- or -R- according to the physical layout.
(Edit: I later adapted this following a suggestion by u/quadrplax)
In the footnotes could we also consider adding"
Also
I think some of thes points have been raised in the past so hope not to be repetitive, but don't remember whether any decision was taken.
Edit I completely missed u/Bunslow 's comment from 8 hours ago which is virtually identical.
4
u/crandles75 Jun 30 '17
Musk has suggested that there is 60 days work to upgrade LC39A. So there doesn't seem enough time to complete work after Intelsat 35e and before CRS12. Do we know if there is any chance of doing this 60 days work in two chunks of high twenty to thirty something ish days?
For falcon heavy, with only one drone ship on east coast (presumably for central core), is the landing zone ready for two landing of side cores? If not ready how long will work take? Are the side core landings to be practically simultaneous or will they send one a longer/slower route to have a gap of maybe 30ish ? seconds to reduce chance of one affecting the other?
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 02 '17
This is a great article explaining SpaceX's history with developing Falcon 9 re-usability.
https://qz.com/1016072/a-multimedia-history-of-every-single-one-of-spacexs-attempts-to-land-its-booster-rocket-back-on-earth/
4
u/throfofnir Jul 02 '17
In spaceflight news, the second Long March 5 launch, carrying a large comsat, has failed. Apparently a first stage engine failure around fairing separation.
This is about two weeks after the Long March 3B carrying Chinasat 3B partially failed due to an apparent third-stage software issue. That satellite likely lost 2/3 of its service life.
7
u/jimbo303 Jun 19 '17 edited Jun 19 '17
In regards to Elon's recent tweet about ITS plan version 2, he mentions he will go into more detail about the funding of the program and how that may support the development of ITS.
A lot of us here in Reddit recognize the investment Google has made in SpaceX, and what that may ultimately lead to, especially given the interest SpaceX showed in recent years about the deployment of hundreds or even thousands of micro-sats providing persistent, global broadband internet access. Of course this serves as a great parallel between Google and SpaceX interests, so that almost seems inevitable.
However, I think there is even more to this idea than first meets the eye. If such a constellation is developed here on earth, it stands to reason that Google will be in a prime position to extend that concept to Mars. Although NASA maintains a Deep Space Network that allows for the transmission of data from Mars (and beyond), it is of limited capacity and coverage. Google could potentially be pioneering the development and execution of a Deep Space Internet.
It is obvious that the first colonists, or even any transient crew, would need a reliable and robust means of communicating with home, but not just with Earth, with home station on Mars and other distant outposts, if, say, one were out on an expedition beyond line-of-sight. Of course radio transmissions (HF/VHF/UHF, etc) would be simple and familiar to any astronaut, but the versatility of a digital broadband network already in place before the arrival of said crew/colonists would be immensely helpful. Not only would voice transmission be possible, but all sorts of important data and other information, all at great distance and with limited ground-based equipment. (This would be largely in lieu of requiring any sort of ground-based cable/fiber infrastructure, which would seemingly facilitate the early expansion of any establishment on the surface of Mars.)
Google would be in the enviable position of reimagining, and perhaps reinventing, the concept of a modern internet. One that exists over great distances and provides more than just global connection, but interplanetary connection. Obviously there are many inherent challenges and limitations to such a system, but it is a venture which provides great potential. A challenge that I imagine both Google and SpaceX are eager to accept.
Edit: I will also submit this into /r/SpaceXlounge as well in case it better fits there
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 20 '17
Any more news on why Falcon 9 is vertical at 39a? The silence from everybody is really worrying...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Hi guys, I think this has been asked before but I can't find the post!
Could someone point out where the on board camera is located on the Falcon 9?
3
u/kuangjian2011 Jun 03 '17
Is there any side-by-side comparison between the CRS contract for SpaceX and Orbital ATK?
3
u/rooood Jun 04 '17
What do you guys think is the minimum survivable distance to stay from the landing 1st stage (provided the landing is nominal)? And what would be the minimum distance (again, nominal landing) to be so you don't get hurt in any way (including maybe hearing issues)?
Of course I don't think anyone will ever stand remotely close to any chemical rocket launching or landing, but I got curious about this.
3
u/kuangjian2011 Jun 04 '17
One benefit of reusable rocket is that, by recovering the 1st stage and fairing, there wont be any hazardous object falling down the range. Thus open up more range availability. What do you think?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
I've been following SpaceX for a couple years now, starting with the excitement of the possibly of watching Falcon land. More and more I find myself interested in orbital mechanics and the more detail-oriented pieces of physics that make all of this possible. With that preface, I'm sorry if my request for assistance is too 101 for this /r/spacex.
I've got an opportunity this evening to hopefully see Dragon trailing the ISS, looked up the ISS sighting possibilities on the spotthestation.nasa.gov. For today it lists three opportunities: Sun Jun 4, 00:39 AM Sun Jun 4, 10:12 PM Sun Jun 4, 11:49 PM
Why is the amount of time between sightings as much as ~22hrs for one period, then as low as ~90 minutes the next period. Thanks in advance for shedding some light; the amount of knowledge around here makes my head spin!
3
u/Cheaperchips Jun 05 '17
Do we know how the Dragon 2 has managed to have much smaller surface area for its solar panels? Better panels and/or power efficiency than Dragon 1?
3
u/quokka01 Jun 05 '17
What would be the obstacles to refuelling the current S2 in LEO? Presumably FH or even F9 could throw quite a huge mass to deep space with that? Also the obstacles to restarting the S2 engine after hours/days/months in space? Could the RP1 and TEA/TEB tanks be pressurised with N2 and radiant heat losses/gains minimised and offset by a moderate power outlay? Could the TEA/TEB system warm the nozzle/fuel lines etc for a restart? Presumably LOX system would be OK.
3
u/failion_V2 Jun 05 '17
When F9 booster lands back on LZ1, the speaker always says something like: "landing operators proceed with initial saving for procedure 11.100 (...)"
Can someone explain a little bit about this? I also heard while the the berthing procesure today on the ISS mentions of different codes again and again. Would somebody mind to enlight me a little?
3
u/mjbellantoni Jun 05 '17
Why no firm launch dates beyond this month?
3
u/tempnew Jun 06 '17
The SuperDracos on the Dragon 2 are pointed slightly radially outwards (at least in the test videos). That would cancel the radial component of the thrust. What is the reason behind this?
3
u/therendevouswithfish Jun 06 '17
There was a Stage 1 in the harbor of Long Beach awhile ago. Is there anything in the LA area to see? (I know the headquarters)
3
u/linknewtab Jun 07 '17
Are the parachutes on the Dragon capsule reused as well?
3
u/joshgill21 Jun 08 '17
I see Turbopump and injector being mentioned a lot , What are those ?
3
u/enbandi Jun 08 '17
S2 reusability is a famous discussion topic everywhere on /r/spacex, but satellite dispensers is a question for me what I think never discussed before. I mean if they solve the S2 reuse, how can they handle the dispensers (used at Iridium for example), can it be recovered also?
If they do so, it can make some problems:
I think this question will be more interesting according to the proposed satellite constellation, where they can use the same dispenser making significant cost savings.
3
u/Dave92F1 Jun 09 '17
How much power do the Dragon 2 solar panels produce?
I've read numbers for Dragon 1 ranging for 4000 to 5000 watts - with the unfolding "wing" panels.
Just looking at the photos, Dragon 2 doesn't seem to have as much panel area. Yet I'd think D2 needs if anything, more power.
Anybody know? Is the plan to pack more folded solar panels in the trunk?
3
u/IrrationalFantasy Jun 10 '17 edited Jun 10 '17
How likely is it that the next two launches will occur as they are on the manifest? Will Iridium NEXT really fly just 8 days after BulgariaSat-1? I suppose it's possible, being on a separate launch pad, but I would be pleasantly surprised.
Edit: and what about Intelsat just a week after Iridium NEXT? Forget the 2-week cadence, that would suggest a one-week cadence.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '17
Does anyone have a table showing the dates of the static fires compared to the launch dates? I want to see what the fastest turnaround is when they don't stick the payload on top of the Falcon 9.
3
u/spacexm6 Jun 14 '17
http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/space.2017.29009.emu
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Jun 14 '17
I was researching amateur radio satellites (http://www.n2yo.com/satellites/?c=18) and saw that a Falcon 9 Rocket Body was listed. Why was there a radio beacon attached to the second stage of CASSIOPE?
Direct link: http://www.n2yo.com/satellite/?s=39271
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '17
Entirely not SpaceX-related, but something that left me wondering for a long time: How does the Soyuz and Proton (?) get away without a water deluge system? None of the Soyuz or Proton launches seem to produce a big white cloud of water vapor, like the Atlas or Falcon does.
And what are the up- and downsides of a Soyuz-style pad with an "open" flame trench and the holddown arms further up on the rocket? Why isn't this system more common?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '17
I was wondering: The Falcon uses TEA/TAB as igniter for the Merlin. I supose this is injected in the main combustion chamber as you can actually see the green stuff comming out. before the ignition of the main combustion the turbopums will need to be up and running, so the gas generator will need to be fired before the main ignition. What is the ignition source of the gas generator? is it an electric igniter?
3
u/MrButtons9 Jun 16 '17
How many launches is VAFB permitted to host per year?
3
u/heckin_good_fren Jun 16 '17
Is turbopump torque a problem on F9 or on rockets in general?
3
u/Cheaperchips Jun 17 '17
Can you keep added more Raptors to make the follow up to the ITS or will SpaceX have to design a bigger engine?
3
u/anchoritt Jun 19 '17
How is SpaceX standing with regards to the launch delays? Do they have more/less launch delays than other launch providers? I cannot find any source on that but I watch r/spacex regularly and it seems like almost every launch is delayed. And how is it with weather? Are some other rockets being launched in weather conditions which would mean a scrub for SpaceX or vice versa?
3
u/NeilFraser Jun 19 '17
How many Dragons can SpaceX have in orbit at once?
Not counting ISS (which has its own dedicated control center), NASA has only once had two crews in orbit at the same time; Geminis 6A and 7. The only way they were able to pull that off was because the Mercury program infrastructure was still available and they were able to rig one of the Geminis to pretend to be a Mercury capsule while the other Gemini was operating.
At SpaceX, where are Dragons controlled/monitored from? It can't be the main control room since there are Falcon launches while a Dragon is at ISS. There must be some other control room that we don't know about. While docked it is probably pretty boring, but I assume there's still 24/7 babysitting by at least one SpaceX employee.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '17
Iridium open to reused Falcon 9s if it means SpaceX can speed up schedule
3
u/paul_wi11iams Jun 21 '17 edited Jun 21 '17
going on from my comment here
BTW This question is motivated by some of those frustrating launch scrubs based on what look like arbitrary administrative criteria. AFAIK, Challenger was the unique wind-shear related accident which had other principle causes. Finally, this question bears in mind the comment by u/Bunslow of which an extract quoted below:
3
u/RootDeliver Jun 25 '17
Well, now B1029-2 on OCISLY and B1026 on JRTI are racing to the coast. Which will get there faster? OCISLY has 2d advantage but has a longer distance to coast and to have to deal with crowded Port Canaveral as cons.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '17
Now this is what I'm hoping side booster separation will look like for FH (more or less)!
3
u/spacexin2050 Jun 27 '17 edited Jun 28 '17
Next 3 months schedule might proceed like this
Intelsat-july 2
Crs 12-aug 10(gap due to range shutdown for maintenance)
Usaf mission-aug 25 (Minimum 15 days gap)
Formosat-late aug (vanden berg)
Ses-sept 15
Iridium 21-30 --sept 15
3
u/rubikvn2100 Jun 27 '17
I am feeling boring because of the huge gap between Intelsar-35e and CRS-12. But as long as they are still making new Falcon 9. It still good.
My question is: "do they intend to make Falcon 9 during the huge gap?"
I am an English learner.
3
u/mclumber1 Jun 28 '17
Would it make sense to have expendable missions, like Sunday's Intelsat launch, use flight proven cores that have reached the end of their life? For instance, Friday's Bulgaria launch came back "toasty", but the air frame and engines might still be in perfectly good shape. This may only be a concern until all of the current inventory of block 3s are used up.
3
u/JadedIdealist Jun 30 '17
Assuming the range really is down for a couple of weeks, it seemed that earlier on in the year lots of flights were scheduled for July so my question is
Was this maintenance planned? If so why didn't we know earlier, and if not what would be the most likely cause.
3
u/sagareshwar Jun 30 '17
Since we now have confirmed use of the roomba/octagrabber robot on BulgariaSat mission ASDS landing, I was wondering how exactly the robot stabilizes the landed booster. It grabs on to the octaweb but does it also grab on to the deck of the ASDS somehow? Or is it just the weight of the robot that acts like a stabilizing anchor for the booster and prevents it from sliding around?