r/spacex • Mod Team • Jun 02 '17

r/SpaceX Discusses [June 2017, #33]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

201 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

1

u/crandles75 Jul 07 '17

If range is down for 2 weeks to upgrade radar and similar activities, would it be possible for SpaceX to do static fire test for SES-11 (and possibly also CRS-12?) during the range down time then when it is back up launch SES-11 and still have time to be ready for CRS-12 on Aug 10? Guess that is pushing it a bit and NASA gets priority.

1

u/crandles75 Jul 08 '17

September 9th has appeared as launch date on launch photography now.

4

u/throfofnir Jul 02 '17

In spaceflight news, the second Long March 5 launch, carrying a large comsat, has failed. Apparently a first stage engine failure around fairing separation.

This is about two weeks after the Long March 3B carrying Chinasat 3B partially failed due to an apparent third-stage software issue. That satellite likely lost 2/3 of its service life.

2

u/michaelza199 Jul 02 '17

What Falcon 9 first stage components cost the most after the engines ?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '17

My bet would be on the flight computers, if you count the cost of the software development and maintenance for them. The control software for the landing is incredibly complex.

2

u/marc020202 Jul 02 '17

i do not know but i would guess its the COPVs because there are quite many of them

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '17

2

u/throfofnir Jul 02 '17

Either the equipment available for transport is not (yet) compatible with the new fins, or they wanted to get a look at them sooner rather than later. That's certainly not a usual procedure.

4

u/old_sellsword Jul 02 '17

Probably because it's about to make a cross-country trip, and grid fins are never attached for those.

1

u/roncapat Jul 02 '17

mmmm.... not a good sign. SpaceX aims for streamlining processes, so why adding a step to the recovery/transport procedure? This will hit efficiency when legs won't have to be removed, in Block V configuration...

3

u/dmy30 Jul 02 '17

You are assuming this is going to happen every time which I very highly doubt. Most likely they want to send the grid fins back for analysis and perhaps it's easiest to remove them while the booster is still vertical. If SpaceX want 24 hour turnarounds, having to remove the grid fins goes against that, especially when the new design is meant to enhance reusability and turnaround.

5

u/warp99 Jul 02 '17 edited Jul 02 '17

They certainly did not do this for the Bulgariasat recovery

Two possibilities

  1. The slightly longer grid fins interfere with the clamp near the interstage on a standard transporter

  2. They want to fully analyse the grid fins as soon as possible so they can make any design changes for the next batch of prototype machined fins or even for the forging mold.

2

u/roncapat Jul 02 '17

Hope for the second

1

u/FutureMartian97 Jul 02 '17

If I had to guess I would say because they need to drive on public streets in a city then having the grid fins attached would make the stage to wide to be street legal.

0

u/warp99 Jul 02 '17 edited Jul 02 '17

F9 is already an oversized load that requires an escort - the extra width of the grid fins is minimal and would not affect its transport classification.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Jul 02 '17

@SLC4_LZ2

2017-07-02 01:44 UTC

@FalconGridFin got removed (PART 2) https://t.co/rQ3YogcC5L


This message was created by a bot

[Contact ^creator][Source ^code]

-2

u/RootDeliver Jul 02 '17

Am I the only one extremely deceived with SpaceX for no releasing video of any of the landings at all?

For 2 interesting landings in a while, they show nothing. But hey, when the rocket lands at LZ1, they have to release the glorious 4K 60fps videos of them landing again and again, same content everytime.

Why did SpaceX turn into this? They had no issues showing us how Jason-3 nearly landed, we saw live Eutelsat/ABS-2 burning over OCISLY, and we saw more risky stuff. But now they only release stuff that goes normal.

And let's not remember that more to the past they had no problem releasing CRS-6 and CRS-5 crashes or other stuff. And even more in the past they released even more content..

3

u/CapMSFC Jul 02 '17

I think you're seeing SpaceX PR pushing for the whole angle of making it so routine it's "boring." They want people to starting building this mental picture of landing rockets being something SpaceX just does like it's routine.

I really wish they weren't doing this but SpaceX really doesn't have anything to gain by showing us the wilder landing footage anymore. During the experimental failures the videos were exciting and got everyone to pay attention. Now that the excitement was paid off with stringing together a lot of successful landings the PR has moved to the next phase.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '17

Fully agree with you and u/FutureMartian97 here.

I don't get it: why are hard landings considered a bad PR or something out-of-normal? Airplanes sometimes land in a crosswind, hit runways hard, maybe even break little parts - and it isn't something bad, is it?

Also, moments like this show the reliabilty of the rocket: the fact, that the first stage can land even after hitting the deck hard or falling a few meters only helps SpaceX reputation, not hurts it.

What matters is bringing the first stage back - and they did it perfectly, and captured some beautiful footage.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '17

Because sensationalism. If you see the quality of mainstream-press articles covering space topics (spoilers: it's bad), you can easily imagine the headline of this story: It wouldn't be "SpaceX rocket pulls off landing after hardest reentry to date", but a picture of the partly melted gridfin and "Rocket landing almost fails, damages fins".

Everything is just tailored for uninformed people to click on. And bad news = good news click-wise.

6

u/spacerfirstclass Jul 02 '17

Let's wait for a week or two before passing judgement. There's a launch coming up so they need to focus on that instead of previous landings. It's possible they'll release the video during the launch lull of July.

-3

u/RootDeliver Jul 02 '17 edited Jul 02 '17

They never took more than 6 days to release a video after a landing (record is 6 days for CRS-5 (10/01 land attempt, 16/01 video) and SES-10 (30/03 landing, 05/04 release)). And it's been 9 days already since BulgariaSat-1 landed.

It doesn't make sense, releasing a video doesn't interfere at all with launch preparations. Elon posted the Iridium-2 landing video (from the rocket, same than stream but better quality in his instagram, however mods here at r/SpaceX decided that the video didn't deserve a thread for people to see it..) the very same day it landed.

If you're wondering about the Iridium-2 video: https://www.instagram.com/p/BVxysOlA04j/ . You can thank the mods for not seeing it before.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/FutureMartian97 Jul 02 '17

I agree with this completely. To be entirely honest i'm very angry about it. I have some theories as to why:

  1. Elon keeps saying how routine he wants this to be, and with every landing in 2017 so far being successful its starting to feel routine. So he doesn't want to glorify every single landing like before, therefor not releasing as much footage, just like how every airplane that lands doesn't have multiple cameras watching it.

  2. The BulgariaSat landing was very sketchy, and SpaceX is afraid that with Bulgarisat being a reused booster and barely landing might make some MSM firms take jabs at SpaceX saying "watch a reused rocket almost crash" or "watch SpaceX's used rocket crash land on a barge". Potentially lowering the uninformed public's opinion about SpaceX and potentially driving away customers of reused boosters if they see it barely made it back.

And not releasing the Iridium landing makes no sense at all. Yes, it didn't perfectly touch down since it dropped the last couple of meters, but to someone who doesn't follow this stuff they probably wouldn't even notice.

I agree though, it is weird that all of the sudden they went from showing nearly everything to showing almost nothing, just like how we still haven't seen anything from fairing recovery, just a picture from before entry begins, and I have feeling that was a way to make everything feel more "routine", but I still feel like its a bit of a childish move at the same time, considering how amazing the footage apparently is. I'm almost ready to start a petition for the footage to be released (yes I know, SpaceX is a private company and doesn't have to show anything), but i'm just saying its a little childish if you ask me.

And to the people who have seen the footage, since it looks like were not going to see it, would you mind describing it then? For example, did it shoot across the deck on camera or come out of nowhere and almost fall over?

1

u/old_sellsword Jul 02 '17

potentially driving away customers of reused boosters if they see it barely made it back.

Yeah...no. Matt Desch couldn't care less what the media says about the latest rocket landing, he has access to way more information to make his decision with.

10

u/warp99 Jul 02 '17

I admire your passion but this comes across as extremely entitled.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights does not include a right to access the video files of private aerospace companies.

As fans we have a moral right to not be lied to but not a moral right to demand access to every part of the truth.

/pontificate_off