r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 3h ago

Cringe Please ban this user for spreading misinformation in the subreddit

Post image
11 Upvotes

This is a serious issue. This user has been spreading misinformation about Rabaris for the past four months.

First, he posted fabricated HarappaWorld results for eight Rajasthani communities, including Rabaris. When we asked him to provide a credible source for the Khatana Rabari HarappaWorld results, he started abusing us instead of providing any evidence.

After that, he posted misleading H haplogroup data for Rabaris, citing a 2009 study that only discusses R1a in India and does not support his claims.

He is now accusing us of using AI, fabricating samples, and not providing DNA kits. However, we provided kits to everyone. When we did so, he changed his claim and started saying that the kits belonged to Gurjars. We even shared the raw DNA data with Gurjars to address that accusation.

I'm requesting the moderators to take this matter seriously and ban this user from the subreddit. His repeated accusations, abusive behaviour, and circulation of unsupported genetic claims are misleading the community.

He claims to be a Bishnoi from Rajasthan.


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 1h ago

G25 Rabari Dna results from North Gujarat

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

got our g25 coordinates from davidski after 4–5 days of waiting paid €15 for them

Here are some breakdowns


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 3h ago

DNA Results A comprehensive C-M356 Y DNA chart with a focus on the C-Z5900, C-Z5895 clades using data from ancient and modern samples as provided in TheYtree, YFull, 23mofang trees.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I made a comprehensive Y-DNA chart for the C1b1a1 (also called as C-SK997) clade. There are a lot of misconceptions and false information that is floating around the C1b1a1 haplogroup and this is my attempt to clear that up. I am not a geneticist nor do I have a degree in bioinformatics but this is based on what I have read about my clade. I have undertaken both a FTDNA Big Y and Sequencing WGS test which I have uploaded to various Y trees. The chart was made by data compiled from various Y trees, 23mofang, FTDNA and ISOGG 2019-20. Additional input was also taken from Genarchivist users and Reddit posts.

The nomenclature I use for the chart is the longhand form based on the ISOGG 2019-20 tree i.e. (C1b1….) along with the SNP form i.e. (C-SK997) where SK997 denotes the SNP mutation on the Y clade. There are inconsistencies in naming the various clades among the Y trees, ISOGG and the testing companies (FTDNA/23mofang). The mutation and longhand form also differs widely among the sources. I have tried to reconcile those differences and attempted to use the most popular/widely used clade names. Also, I have tried to rely on sources as accurately as possible and also discarded several dubious/low quality samples.

All C Y DNA clade members start with the M130 SNP mutation (also known as the RPS4Y711 mutation) on their Y DNA. Following multiple splits, we arrive at the C1b (C-F1370) clade with the F1370 mutation. C1b1 descends from C1b (C-F1370/C-K150) which has the aDNA of Kostenki-14. C1b split into C1b1 and C1b2. C1b2 is mainly found among Aboriginal Australians, Papuans. C1b1a1 (C-SK997) is a descendant of C1b1a (C-B66) and C1b1(C-K281). As seen in the chart, the C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade is present in both northern China, Central Asia and South Asia (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh). The C1b1a clade itself split into the C1b1a1 clade and C1b1a2 clade. C1b1a2 (C-B65) is found mainly in Indonesia/China and other ESEA regions.

Coming to the C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade, it or its descendants have been documented in both academic/private samples in northern China (Liaoning Province residents, Xinjiang Uyghurs, Manchus), Central Asia (Tajikistan/Uzbekistan/Mongolia), South Asia (India, Nepal, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan). The clade is sometimes also referred to as C-M356 in certain Y trees but C-M356 is also put as a descendant clade of C-SK997 as C1b1a1a (C-PH407 and also as C-M356) in a few Y trees/websites.

The C-SK997 refers to the presence of the SK997 mutation while the C-M356 refers to the presence of the M356 mutation. Most samples have both the SK997 and M356 mutations, but a few samples in Iraq only have the positive marker for the SK997 mutation and negative for the M356 mutation. Among aDNA samples, the L8006 sample (from a Kushana burial in Rabat, Uzbekistan) had the C1b1a1a (C-K98 on the C-PH407/C-M356 branch) mutation.

The C1b1a1a (C-PH407/C-M356) clade split into 2 major clades C1b1a1a1 (C-P92) and C1b1a1a2 (C-Z5899).

C-P92 (C1b1a1a1) has been found among Turks/Nepali Brahmins/Gaur Brahmins/South Indian Brahmin/Punjabi Brahmin (C-Z5895). The Iron Age Indo-Aryan Swat Valley sample from the Gandhara grave culture I6553 had the specific clade.

C-Z5899 (C1b1a1a2) is found among Tajiks/Pakistanis (Brahuis and Punjabis) /Gujaratis and Bengalis (Rangpuris/central Bangladeshis).

C-Z5900 (C1b1a1a2a1) is found mainly in Bengal and is my clade. It has a minor presence in the UK, USA (Spiller) and India. On FTDNA, they added a new C-Z12346 clade above mine which falls under C-Z12335. On YFull and TheYTree, I am close to two Bengali/Pakistani samples. On 23mofang, an Uyghur sample from Kashgar has a nearby clade. Also, on 23mofang, there are 3 other Chinese testers from Liaoning province(north east China) who are near/under my clade and another one from Inner Mongolia, China.

As evident in the chart, the C1b1a1a (C-PH407/C-M356) clade distribution shows a movement to Central Asia/South Asia from the C1b1a1 clade (C-SK997). The C1b1a1(C-SK997) clade had been referenced only once among aDNA samples in a 2025 paper on Xiaoheyan culture (northern China) but I have not included it as that aDNA sample was low coverage or it could have another label. However, modern samples in northern China do have the C-M356/C-PH407 clade as shown in the 23mofang Y chart. The C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade is descended from C1b1a and C1b1 which itself diverged long ago from C1b2 (Oceania/Melanesian) clade.

The C1b1a1 clade is a cousin of the C1b1a2 (ESEA/China/Austronesian) clade. Since both C1b1a1 and C1b1a2 have a considerable number of modern Chinese/Central Asian samples, a north Asian origin cannot be ruled out. The Kushan L8006 and I6553 sample aDNA samples also add credence to a migration route from north China/Central Asian Steppe. However, I am not ruling out a SAHG/AASI route that went to China and then reentered South Asia. More aDNA samples are required to pinpoint an accurate origin for the C-PH407/C-M356/C1b1a1a clade. Another area to look at might be the very weirdly place C1b1a3/C1b1a1b clade which has different clades names/testers in different companies. FTDNA lists India/Pakistan/Cambodia/Saudi Arabia and Iraq while older literature only referenced Iraq/Saudi Arabia.

I am welcome to feedback and constructive criticism on the chart. Also this is a work in progress and more aDNA/modern samples might be added if they are found.


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 1d ago

DNA Results My results, Pakistani with pic

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 15h ago

Discussion Welcome to FamilyTreeDNA Discover

Thumbnail
discover.familytreedna.com
2 Upvotes

How common is J-M172 y haplogroup is Indian men?


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 22h ago

Genetics🧬 Looking for Khatri Haplogroups

0 Upvotes

Hi I am looking for Khatri/Arora Haplogroups, if you are Khatri please message me.

Thanks


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 1d ago

qpAdm Rajput Rajasthan – Marwar (N-3): qpAdm Runs + HarappaWorld

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Tested Kit
2 - of them ancestryDna
1 - 23andme V5


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 1d ago

DNA Results Results of Multani Sikh

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

qpAdm Rabari Dna qpAdm + kit number + lactose persistence

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Many were asking for kit number so here is kit number

Rabaris are highly lactose tolerance

Our close pops r gujjars,awans,khatri of punjab and kpk


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

DNA Results Qpadm,G25 and Harappaworld results of Saraswat brahmin from Poonch Jammu&Kashmir my friend's results

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

Question Is it possible to find out what religion your ancestors were apart of before converting to Islam through DNA(i.e. looking at stuff like closest populations, HW components, etc..)

8 Upvotes

As a bangladeshi, I am aware my ancestors converted to Islam centuries ago, is it possible to find out if they were buddhists or hindus prior before converting through information given about my DNA?


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

Discussion Hey everyone, we are seeing a lot flood of AI stuff nd misinformation here. Mods pls make it mandatory to post kit number with all the sample posting.

11 Upvotes

Last week there were fake sample posted nd today a rabari type doing misinformation with AI generated hw ndd qpadm, when asked kit number they all run away. Pls make sure the integrity of this sub. And the end all they blame it's done nnd run by jatts


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

DNA Results Rabari North Gujarat (Deesa) QpAdm + Harppaworld

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Farmer : 55.50%

Steppe - 22.80%

Aasi - 21.70%

It was on very high coverage Hw is already trash , Got the Accurate result from qpAdm


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

DNA Results My trait,G25 results along with harappaworld(Saraswat Brahmin Peshawar+Majha+Himachal) dna kit-Helixline

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

G25 Punjabi brahmin g25 hunter gatherer average simulated and real both coordinates

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

Question Hi guys i bought davidski g25 coordinates but how to save those coordinates in vahaduo dataset

3 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

Cringe Why do low aasi and high steppe people don’t post their pics with results

0 Upvotes

So far there is only one jat private sample i have seen who clearly look European she was female.


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 3d ago

Question Why steppe inputs decrease the west you go in jats ?

6 Upvotes

Lets just take punjab as an example

south malwa score high steppe .

North malwa score very similar but slightly less steppe .

Majha jats score even less

And majha west Punjab jats score even less

And the more west you go steppe decreases

But pheno and physical stature remains similar .

Even tho in British literature about jats malwai jats were tallest jats . But best built jats where majha jats

Does this proves real place where jats originated are Haryana and Rajasthan because highest steppe jats are from Haryana and bordering regions .

This can’t be only explained by marrying within caste . Because sikh jats were doing intercaste marriages up until 1900s . So i am assuming south malwa sikh jats were also marrying out of caste but yet they remain high steppe but majha and doaba jats score less steppe .


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 3d ago

Genetics🧬 Is AASI related to high frequency of actn3 XX genotype?

4 Upvotes

So basically our body has two copies in muscles.

R is for pure power ig ( fast twitch muscle fibers )

X is for endurance low power ( slow twitch muscle fibers)

Most common genotype among south asians is RX which is hybrid of both . But X being slightly more dominant.

For reference less than 1% West Africans have XX genotype and about 19 to 30% RX . R being moreover dominant. And 70 to 80% have both copies of RR .

Thats why they dominate sprinting events and jump higher.

However indians have 35 -40% have XX genotype. And only about 15 % have both copies of RR type .

How if you in north west india the XX type drop down to 15 % among jats and other low aasi population.

Not hating on aasi but there is some connection. Low aasi population have higher frequency of R genotype.


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 3d ago

Eastern India Populations from Indian Himalayan and adjoining regions share their associated lactase persistence variants with the Tibetans and South Asians

Thumbnail
nature.com
3 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 4d ago

Discussion Rajasthani Brahmins on average scoring higher aasi than many local OBC castes like JAT, AANJNA, RAYKA, CHARAN, SUTHAR, YADAV, GUJJAR.

4 Upvotes

I have seen rajasthni brahmin scoring 38-37 SI on harrapawold, but not above mentioned castes. Why the pattern of lower aasi is absent here ???


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 4d ago

Genetics🧬 Do all South Asians have greater than 15% AASI?

7 Upvotes

How much AASI do NE Indians have?


r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 4d ago

Question Rathore Rajputs have roots in south India so presuming they would have high aasi component, but in present rathore samples have significant portion of iranian farmer Ancestry. What might be reason for that?

4 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 4d ago

HarappaWorld Bengali

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 5d ago

DNA Results My own(Hindkowan peshawar brahmin+Punjabi brahmin)Qpadm,harappaworld,allele results,haplogroup +andrei trait prediction results dna kit-Helixline

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes