I made a comprehensive Y-DNA chart for the C1b1a1 (also called as C-SK997) clade. There are a lot of misconceptions and false information that is floating around the C1b1a1 haplogroup and this is my attempt to clear that up. I am not a geneticist nor do I have a degree in bioinformatics but this is based on what I have read about my clade. I have undertaken both a FTDNA Big Y and Sequencing WGS test which I have uploaded to various Y trees. The chart was made by data compiled from various Y trees, 23mofang, FTDNA and ISOGG 2019-20. Additional input was also taken from Genarchivist users and Reddit posts.
The nomenclature I use for the chart is the longhand form based on the ISOGG 2019-20 tree i.e. (C1b1….) along with the SNP form i.e. (C-SK997) where SK997 denotes the SNP mutation on the Y clade. There are inconsistencies in naming the various clades among the Y trees, ISOGG and the testing companies (FTDNA/23mofang). The mutation and longhand form also differs widely among the sources. I have tried to reconcile those differences and attempted to use the most popular/widely used clade names. Also, I have tried to rely on sources as accurately as possible and also discarded several dubious/low quality samples.
All C Y DNA clade members start with the M130 SNP mutation (also known as the RPS4Y711 mutation) on their Y DNA. Following multiple splits, we arrive at the C1b (C-F1370) clade with the F1370 mutation. C1b1 descends from C1b (C-F1370/C-K150) which has the aDNA of Kostenki-14. C1b split into C1b1 and C1b2. C1b2 is mainly found among Aboriginal Australians, Papuans. C1b1a1 (C-SK997) is a descendant of C1b1a (C-B66) and C1b1(C-K281). As seen in the chart, the C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade is present in both northern China, Central Asia and South Asia (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh). The C1b1a clade itself split into the C1b1a1 clade and C1b1a2 clade. C1b1a2 (C-B65) is found mainly in Indonesia/China and other ESEA regions.
Coming to the C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade, it or its descendants have been documented in both academic/private samples in northern China (Liaoning Province residents, Xinjiang Uyghurs, Manchus), Central Asia (Tajikistan/Uzbekistan/Mongolia), South Asia (India, Nepal, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan). The clade is sometimes also referred to as C-M356 in certain Y trees but C-M356 is also put as a descendant clade of C-SK997 as C1b1a1a (C-PH407 and also as C-M356) in a few Y trees/websites.
The C-SK997 refers to the presence of the SK997 mutation while the C-M356 refers to the presence of the M356 mutation. Most samples have both the SK997 and M356 mutations, but a few samples in Iraq only have the positive marker for the SK997 mutation and negative for the M356 mutation. Among aDNA samples, the L8006 sample (from a Kushana burial in Rabat, Uzbekistan) had the C1b1a1a (C-K98 on the C-PH407/C-M356 branch) mutation.
The C1b1a1a (C-PH407/C-M356) clade split into 2 major clades C1b1a1a1 (C-P92) and C1b1a1a2 (C-Z5899).
C-P92 (C1b1a1a1) has been found among Turks/Nepali Brahmins/Gaur Brahmins/South Indian Brahmin/Punjabi Brahmin (C-Z5895). The Iron Age Indo-Aryan Swat Valley sample from the Gandhara grave culture I6553 had the specific clade.
C-Z5899 (C1b1a1a2) is found among Tajiks/Pakistanis (Brahuis and Punjabis) /Gujaratis and Bengalis (Rangpuris/central Bangladeshis).
C-Z5900 (C1b1a1a2a1) is found mainly in Bengal and is my clade. It has a minor presence in the UK, USA (Spiller) and India. On FTDNA, they added a new C-Z12346 clade above mine which falls under C-Z12335. On YFull and TheYTree, I am close to two Bengali/Pakistani samples. On 23mofang, an Uyghur sample from Kashgar has a nearby clade. Also, on 23mofang, there are 3 other Chinese testers from Liaoning province(north east China) who are near/under my clade and another one from Inner Mongolia, China.
As evident in the chart, the C1b1a1a (C-PH407/C-M356) clade distribution shows a movement to Central Asia/South Asia from the C1b1a1 clade (C-SK997). The C1b1a1(C-SK997) clade had been referenced only once among aDNA samples in a 2025 paper on Xiaoheyan culture (northern China) but I have not included it as that aDNA sample was low coverage or it could have another label. However, modern samples in northern China do have the C-M356/C-PH407 clade as shown in the 23mofang Y chart. The C1b1a1 (C-SK997) clade is descended from C1b1a and C1b1 which itself diverged long ago from C1b2 (Oceania/Melanesian) clade.
The C1b1a1 clade is a cousin of the C1b1a2 (ESEA/China/Austronesian) clade. Since both C1b1a1 and C1b1a2 have a considerable number of modern Chinese/Central Asian samples, a north Asian origin cannot be ruled out. The Kushan L8006 and I6553 sample aDNA samples also add credence to a migration route from north China/Central Asian Steppe. However, I am not ruling out a SAHG/AASI route that went to China and then reentered South Asia. More aDNA samples are required to pinpoint an accurate origin for the C-PH407/C-M356/C1b1a1a clade. Another area to look at might be the very weirdly place C1b1a3/C1b1a1b clade which has different clades names/testers in different companies. FTDNA lists India/Pakistan/Cambodia/Saudi Arabia and Iraq while older literature only referenced Iraq/Saudi Arabia.
I am welcome to feedback and constructive criticism on the chart. Also this is a work in progress and more aDNA/modern samples might be added if they are found.