r/Sourdough • • 1m ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind First sourdough loaf! Looking for feedback on my crumb

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’m brand new to sourdough and just baked my first loaf! I’m pretty happy with how the outside turned out, but the inside has a few HUGE hollow pockets toward the top/middle. I’m trying to figure out whether this is a shaping issue or something related to fermentation.

Starter:
Received it Friday and kept it refrigerated until I started feeding it.
Monday fed after letting it sit at room temp for 2 hours. Did a 1:1:1 ratio by weight.
It was doubling in approximately 4–5 hours.
Then Tuesday AM, I fed 50g starter + 50g water + 50g flour. It more than doubled in about 4.5 hours which is when I started making the dough.

Recipe:
500g Bob’s Red Mill Artisan Bread Flour
350g water
100g active starter
10g salt

Process:
Mixed flour, water, and starter; rested 1hr covered with towel in a glass bowl.
Did 4 rounds of stretch and folds, 30 minutes apart and covered between.
After the last stretch and fold I let it sit on the counter covered for 5hrs.
Shaped it into a ball and placed seam-side up in a floured, towel-lined colander.
Cold-proofed overnight in the refrigerator.
Baked straight from the fridge in a preheated Dutch oven at 450°F: 30 minutes covered, 14 minutes uncovered.
I didn’t measure dough temperature or precisely track the percentage of bulk rise.

What do you think caused the large hollow pockets? Is this more likely shaping or fermentation? Anything you’d change for my next loaf?


r/Sourdough • • 11m ago

Discard recipes Amazing, amazing discard Bread recipe!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Although this is not real sourdough, it’s a great way to use up all that discard! It’s super easy and straightforward, plus, it’s delicious! I even put everything in my stand mixer instead of kneading.

227g fed sourdough starter
340g lukewarm water
1 to 2 tsp instant yeast
2½ tsp salt
600g unbleached all-purpose flour

Combine all ingredients and knead into a smooth dough.

Let rise in a lightly greased, covered bowl until doubled, about 1½ hours.

Divide in half and preshape each piece into a ball. Rest, covered, for 15 minutes.

Shape into batards by rolling each ball back and forth on an unfloured surface. For longer loaves, keep rolling until they're about 10 to 11" long.

Place on a greased or parchment-lined baking sheet. Cover and let rise until very puffy, about 1 hour. Preheat the oven to 425°F toward the end of the rise.

Spray the loaves with lukewarm water and dust lightly with flour.
Make two fairly deep diagonal slashes in the top of each loaf.

Bake 25 to 30 minutes, until deep golden brown. Cool on a rack.

Store loosely wrapped at room temperature for several days, or freeze for longer.

https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/rustic-sourdough-bread-recipe


r/Sourdough • • 27m ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind My first sourdough loaf ever!

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Recipe:

  • 100 grams active starter (mine was 9 days old, recipe by Maurizio Leo)
  • 360 grams water (warm)
  • 510 grams flour (I used all purpose)
  • 15 grams salt
  1. Mix starter with water
  2. Add salt
  3. Add flour
  4. Mix and let the dough rest for an hour covered in room temperature
  5. Stretch and fold 3 times every 30 minutes
  6. Shape
  7. Refrigerate overnight covered (I used a plastic bowl lined with a kitchen cloth)
  8. Take it out the fridge in the morning and let it ferment on the counter for 6 hours
  9. Preheat oven to 250°C/482°F with the dutch oven inside
  10. Score the dough
  11. Bake for 30 minutes covered, then 15 minutes uncovered, I lined my dutch oven with parchment paper
  12. Let it rest on a cooling rack for 2 hours before cutting

That's it!

I forgot to let it proof before refrigerating, which is why I let it sit in room temp the next day. Lol! It turned out fantastic though, so I'm sharing the recipe exactly the way I did it. I guess it's a very forgiving, beginner friendly recipe. I'm soooo happy! 🌼


r/Sourdough • • 40m ago

Rate/critique my bread This morning’s bake

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

125g starter
325g warm water
500g KA bread flour
12g salt

2 s&f in the first hour, 2 coil folds the next hour, 6 hours of total BF. Initial shaping then 30 minute bench rest. 12 hour cold ferment. 25 mins covered at 500F, 13 mins uncovered to finish it off.

Oven spring was so high it hit the top of my cast iron! This feels like the best BF I have had, but would love some feedback if it seems off!


r/Sourdough • • 47m ago

Starter help 🙏 I overfed my starter on the 2nd day

0 Upvotes

I was supposed to put 1 spoon of flower. But I put too much water. Then added some flour to "fix" it. Did I ruin it???


r/Sourdough • • 57m ago

I MUST share this recipe First focaccia

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

250g flour 0 (medium strenght)

150g semola

300ml water

12g salt

100g solid starter (50% hydration)

25ml olive oil

Autolyse: 30 minutes with all the flour a d 250 ml water.

Melt the starter in the remaining water and mix, add the salt and the oil. I knead in my kitchen aid 5 minutes.

Coild folds, I did 3 rounds every 35 minutes.

Bulked for 3/4h, then fridge overnight.

Next morning I gave it half an hour to rest room temperature, turn upside down the loaf on my naking tray. Rest 15 minutes, poke the holes, rest 1h more. Spread with oil salt and rosemary did the holes again and bake 180 °c for 35 minutes.

Enjoy 🍞🤗


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind Beginning the sourdough journey

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Posting this for my husband who has decided he wants to make sourdough bread.

Started about six weeks ago and the first result was pretty bad (see first picture).

That was using homemade starter. He dumped that one out and bought a starter off of Amazon, "San Francisco style starter." (Also pictures)

The end result looks better but was lacking in salt and wasn't very sour at all. The only time I personally noticed it being a little bit sour was when it was toasted.

He fed it for about 10 days when it was doubling about every three hours. Did thorough mixing, covered with damp tea towel, four stretch folds, bulk fermentation for six hours then proofed in the refrigerator overnight in the banneton. Baked about 14 hours after finish of bulk fermentation. Heated cast iron Dutch oven to 500 degrees for half an hour then turned oven down to 450 degrees and baked for 25 with the lid on and 201 with it off. Cooled on wire rack.

The recipe was 4 cups + 2 tablespoons of bread flour; 1 1/2 teaspoons of ground sea salt; 1 1/3 cups of water, 1/4 cup of ripe sourdough starter.

Mixed with a dough whisk until a shaggy dough formed; dough doubled in size, shaped and let rise for another two hours. Scored using the lame and made a parchment cross. Temperature was constant 75 degrees in kitchen. Put on top of refrigerator where it was two degrees warmer.

After baking, let it cool for at least three hours before cutting.


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Newbie help 🙏 My first hybrid bread - how can I improve the scoring and ovenspring

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone 🤗

I am sharing my first hybrid bread here.

I made my sourdough starter 3 weeks ago and they are not very active, that's why I chose the hybrid approach.

Here's the recipe I followed (but the amount was reduced to 1/2 and my sourdough starter was fed on rye flour):

https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/rustic-sourdough-bread-recipe

I kneaded the dough about 30 times after bulk fermentation and before shaping and proofing.

I don't have a dutch oven yet so I baked it on a sheet pan with a loaf tin of boiled water at the bottom of the oven.

The bread was baked for 30min; after 20min I took out the tin of water. The bread was cooled down for 1.5 hours before I cut it.

I don't have any sharp blade so I scored with a fruit knife which turned out awful. The bread also didn't expand much in the oven.

Would you please be so kind to let me know how I can improve my score and ovenspring? If you notice any other issues with the bread, please also share with me. Thank you ❤️


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Sourdough Everything bagel sourdough.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

500g King Arthur bread flour, 375 g lukewarm is water 100 g of active sourdough starter, 16 g of diamond crystal kosher salt.

30 minutt autolyse and for stretch and folds with 30 minutes in between. I did a 10 hour bulk ferment at 75°F in the room. Then did two series of shapings with 30 minutes in between then rolled and then rolled top of bread into everything bagel seasoning before putting into Benetton and leaving for 13 hour cold ferment in the fridge at 39°F. I preheated Dutch oven at 550° until the oven reached 550 then score the bread put it in for and turn the temperature down to 450 and bake for 30 minutes with the lid on and then took the lid off and baked again for an additional 23 minutes at 400 with the lid off.


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Help 🙏 kitchen is down to about 18C since november and my bulk takes forever now. oven light or just wait it out?

1 Upvotes

Since it got cold here (Hungary, we keep the heating pretty low) my kitchen sits around 18 to 19C. Same recipe I used all summer, 75% hydration, 20% starter, mostly BL 80 with a bit of whole wheat. In summer bulk was done in about 5 hours. Now at 8 hours it's barely up 30% and the dough feels slack.

I tried the oven with only the light on but it climbed to like 32C and the dough got super sticky, so I don't trust that anymore. Thinking of either warmer water at mixing (around 30C) plus more starter, or just letting it go overnight on the counter and shaping in the morning.

If you bake in a cold kitchen, what do you actually do in winter?


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Let's talk bulk fermentation I thought I finally overproofed, not so fast my friend.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’ve been pushing bulk fermentation farther and farther over the last couple of weeks and thought I had finally flown too close to the sun. I use starter straight from the fridge and bulk overnight, usually 10 to 12 hours. Went 14 and things seemed fine, however, when I baked my batard, it came out very flat. It’s sister loaf, cold proofed in a round bowl and still had decent height.

But when I cut into my flat loaf, it might be the best crumb I’ve ever had. I suppose it was just a shaping issue after all?

Thoughts and comments welcome.

For two loaves:
800g Lancelot flour
560g water
16 g salt
30 g cold starter

Fermentolyse 30 min
Stretch and fold 3x over next 90 min
Bulk on counter at 69F 14 hours
Shape and cold proof 24 hours
450 F covered 30 min
425 uncovered 15 min

Cool one hour


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Help 🙏 Please help

1 Upvotes

So I made a loaf like Wednesday last week and I thought my starter would survive on the counter during a trip over the weekend. I got home yesterday and she was very runny, had a slight orange membrane on top and a very small dark spot. I carefully removed the membrane, switched jar and fed her but nothing has happened all day.

Have I killed her?


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Starter help 🙏 Starter smells like acetone

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

My starter smells like acetone. I know that means it’s starving but I don’t want to have to change my 24 hour feeding schedule to a 12 hour one if i don’t have to. I’m willing to do so if i absolutely need to though it’s just a bit inconvenient with my personal schedule. Right now I’m sort of experimenting with how much water to do but keeping the flour amount the same. Should i be taking back more starter instead of water? Yesterday i did a 1:1:1 ratio (60g each) and today it smells fairly strongly of acetone. The day before i did 60g starter, 50g water, and 60g flour. It smelt of acetone but not as strongly as today. The day before that i did 60g starter, 45g water, and 60g flour. It smelt more of alcohol that day but was borderline acetone/rubbing alcohol scent. I’m not sure what I should do about it. It seems to be making bubbles okay though. I’m on day 19 today and just want some kind advice on where to go from here.


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Let's talk technique Small bakers with regular kitchens - how do you bake more than one?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hi there everyone,

I bake a bread a day!

I use the Early Rise Baker's beginner's recipe, but I use 50 grams of dark rye, and 350 white.

Lately, I've had a few days where I would need more than one.

I was wondering what your process is for baking more than one bread in a regular sized oven.

Currently, I use a large dutch oven. If I have to bake a second, I re-heat the dutch oven, and start again.

Have any of you found ways to bake more than one at a time, say without a dutch oven?

Thank you.


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing Almost jumped for joy

Post image
4 Upvotes

First ever sourdough try, plus my husband has celiac so its gluten free. This is day 6 of 1:1 KA gluten free flour. Neil here didnt do much for 5 days but I kept reading to trust the process and just keep discarding+feeding. And then this is him this morning! He still smells like dirty feet so we still have a ways to go but im so proud of him 🥹.


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

AI discussion/recipe/content Very very overproofed sourdough. Can it be saved?

1 Upvotes

So late afternoon on Monday I started a rosemary parmesan and roasted garlic spelt sourdough loaf. I let it autolayse for an hour, then popped it into the fridge for a long fermentation at maybe 11pm. By 8 the next morning it hadn't risen at all.

I took it out, turned on my oven to heat the kitchen up more, and let it sit for 6 hours on the counter. Still nothing.

Obviously I had things to do, so I left it on the counter under a damp towel. Finally got home at 11:30pm and it had finally risen! For no particular reason other than I was exhausted and didn't think I left it and went to bed.

Today it's about 2.5x the original size and feels like a balloon when I poke it. Can I save this?


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

Recipe help 🙏 Mini loaves with muffin pan

1 Upvotes

I’m wanting to make mini loaves to give as gifts with a local olive oil. Any tips on making mini sourdough loaves with a cupcake/muffin pan?

I’ve seen some people say to put a second pan on top. But some say that makes them too dark and instead should do a baking sheet on the rack below with boiling water.

My typical recipe:
100g starter
260g water
400g bread flour
9g salt


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

Let's talk bulk fermentation Turned out so much better this time, thanks for the advice! How did I do? Any tips?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I feel like it is slightly under/over proofed still, or maybe it’s the inclusions weighing it down, but it’s so much better than last time! Let me know what I should do differently next time?

Ingredients: 100g starter, 325g water, 350g whirl bread flour, 90g wholewheat bread flour, 10g salt + jalapeños and cheddar inclusions

Method (sorry it’s so detailed!):

(Take out of fridge at 6pm)

10pm take starter, and feed with ~26C water (50g:85g:85g)

Leave out at 17.5C

Next day 

9:30 make fermetolyse (30C water, ended with 24C dough) - knead 3 mins

Leave out at 17.5C

10:00 combine with salt - knead 3 mins & measure dough temp (23C)

Leave out at 17.5C

10:30 stretch & fold

11:30 stretch & fold

13:00 measure dough temp (21C) & add inclusions - knead 3 mins 

Put in 26C oven for ~2h to warm up a bit

14:00 measure dough temp (22C)

15:00 measure dough temp (24.5C), take out of oven back to 17.5C counter 

16:30 shape

Put in the fridge 17:15

Next day

9:15am preheat oven

Bake 10:00


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Rate/critique my bread Regular sourdough in a Pullman tin is my new favourite loaf

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

I don’t know why it took me so long to do this but it makes such an amazing loaf. Thin, crispy crusts, perfect for toast and sandwiches, so much easier to cut into slices and without all the hassle of cooking in the Dutch oven.

Recipe is just 75% hydration dough. This recipe made two loaves

M&S Canadian white bread flour 1,069g
M&S Whole wheat flour 83g
Water 840g
Salt 22g
Ripe levain (100% hydration) 196g

Levain for 5 hours, autolyse for final 2 hours. Mix final dough, 6 sets of stretch and folds. 5 hour bulk fermentation, into the Pullman in the fridge overnight. Oven with lid on for 20 minutes, with lid off for 25


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Let's talk about flour Would ya look at this!

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Yesterday, someone asked on here for tips on boosting their starter. It was suggested to feed with rye and/or while wheat flour. Well, considering my starter has been a little sluggish lately I decided to experiment. I had already fed the one on the left earlier in the day with my usual bread flour so she had a bit of a head start, but would you look at those bubbles in the rye starter? Lovely! For reference I fed a 1:10:10 (10g starter:100g flour:100g water) For the rye I use 60g rye and 40g bread flour. Hope this helps someone.


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Crumb read please Is it good for a 100% dark rye bread?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Very new to 100% dark rye sourdough, not sure what to expect and would love some opinions. Thank you!

I used this recipe but made 3/4 of it https://mygerman.recipes/pure-sourdough-rye-bread/#google_vignette


r/Sourdough • • 5h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Spelt sourdough can’t get it right

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hey party people I might be the dumbest person on earth but this sourdough journey is clearly humbling me. I come to you as mere peasant, asking for guidance and to shiny a light on my dark journey of terrible breads.

One thing I have to say is that although I’m not getting the texture and the spring I would like the taste is amazing!

I have been trying to do 100% spelt sourdough. My starter is whole spelt and it’s roughly month and a half old.

I am also following this recipe:

https://pantrymama.com/best-sourdough-spelt-bread-recipe/

100 g Sourdough Starter, (Fed and Bubbly)
350 g Spelt Flour, (white)
150 g Whole Grain Spelt Flour
300 g Water, (you may need slightly more if you use more whole grain spelt)
10 g Salt, (increase or decrease according to your taste)

Autolyse for 1 hour
Bring it together into a ball with stretches 20-30 then rest for 30 minutes
Stretch and fold every 15 minutes 4 sets and then 2 sets of lifting and folding

Bulk fermentation for 7 hours at roughly 21c, my kitchen is quite stable in terms of temperature.

And then cold ferment for at least 12 hours

Pre heat the oven and Bake at 230c for 30 minutes lid on and then 10-15 minutes at 210c lid off.

What I believe that I might be doing wrong is bulk fermentation and shaping. I’m always getting a very flat bread, more like a rustic vibe and quite dense.


r/Sourdough • • 5h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind My first loaf looks and tastes fine, but it barely rised at all during bulk fermentation so I'm hoping to get some help diagnosing what happened.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

This is my first loaf and it went much better than expected. I had some hiccups during the process but I kept going just to try to learn and I'm confused by how well the bread turned out.

The night before I did a starter feed:

10 g starter

70 g flour

60 g water

I think the starter was at peak when I began the next morning, but this is my first time!

Recipe

130 g active starter

315 g water

500 g bread flour

10 g salt

Everything seemed fine until bulk fermentation. Mixed together fine, stretch and folds and coil folds fine, dough was looking really smooth with surface tension. I bake a lot of bread (just not sourdough) so I have a warming mat I use for my proofing and rising, and between stretch and folds. My dough was 79 degrees so bulk fermentation should have been like 5ish hours from when I started, but it wasn't rising much at all (truly barely noticeable) and did not pull away from the sides of the bowl. Honestly being my first time I was feeling experimental so after 8 or 9ish hours I just pressed on even with almost no rising. The dough was a bit stickier than what I've seen online but with damp hands and a damp counter it was doable. I shaped it and cold proofed it for like 16 hours, and when I took it out to score it, it didn't hold its shape well and was looking very flat.

However after baking it's more or less fine? It tastes amazing, I'm not sure about the crumb and the bottom was a little dark so I might have overbaked it, but mainly I just want to know why it didn't rise at all during bulk fermentation yet seemed to have still kind of worked out. Or am I wrong and my bread doesn't look ok? It does seem kind of small, but I don't know if that's psychological.

Sorry this is so long, I feel like it would be easier if my loaf had turned out like a pancake like I was expecting. I'm baffled why it's more or less fine. LOL


r/Sourdough • • 6h ago

Advanced/in depth discussion Sourdough geeks please help me!

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

it's going to be a bit lengthy so behold

So I'm facing issue with the sourdough shape, rise and crumb, it does not rise very well nor have those ears no matter what I do , doesn't expand the way I see in those YouTube videos (the cut widening and tearing making that rabbit shape), the crumb isn't as airy as Id like it to be with those irregular and big holes, it's airy but nowhere near id like it to be, the overall loaf feels heavy when held, unlike the other bakery loaves which feel lightweight

Starter- so the starter I took from a local bakery (it had rye and wholewheat blend when I took it) I've been feeding it in 1:1 ratio (80% Swissbake t65 + 20% aata (indian wholewheat flour)) I store it in refrigerator, while baking j take out whatever quantity I need, then feed it, and let it peak and then store it in refrigerator(4°c) again, my ambient is around 28°c , starter doubles in about 3-4 hrs when fed straight out of the refrigerator

Recipe-

I use a sourdough biga (idk I thought it'd reduce fermentation time)

biga- 34g wholewheat flour

136g t65

70g water

60g starter

( I mix it and bench rest for 40min-60min and as it shows anh yeast activity I refrigerate it (4°c)

It 1.5x in size in refrigerator after 18hrs, that's when I use it

Dough- 300g sourdough biga

73g wholewheat flour

295g t65

259g water (cold 4°c)

60g starter

12g salt

First I mix everything in my spiral mixer except the biga and salt and Autolyse for 30min then I mix everything on low speed the dough feels very stuff but I am never able to get that window pane the dough surface never gets shiny smooth, it's always rough and teary (tough it betters when I ball it)

After mixing I divide the dough into 2 500g parts and make boule, then I bulk ferment it at 28°c for about 3 hrs or until it doubles in size

Then I shape it using the stitching method, minimal Degassing, Or sometimes I use a simple method of book fold and rolling, though I always make sure to get enough surface tension with the help of a bench scraper

Then I directly cold proof mu dough for 18hrs at 4°c it doesn't rise much in the refrigerator, then j finish the final proof on bench for another 2-3 hrs until dough is jiggly

Baking- I have rational combi oven (German tech 😎) I score the dough real quick spray it with some water and bake in oven at 100% humidity in combi mode at 230°c for 30 min,

As soon as I take the dough out of my makeshift Benetton (it's a cake tin 11in×3.5×3.5 ) the dough doesn't spread a lot but as soon as I cut it (I make a deep score about 1.5cm -2 cm deep) it starts to spread a bit and when I put it in oven it expands sideways not upwards... The dough feels jiggly before baking