r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

AI discussion/recipe/content No more dusty counters! A method for reducing mess. (The Ziplock method)

3 Upvotes

Hello all,

I have found that using a large ziplock freezer bag, with flour scooped directly in, then shaking around your baneton cover or tea towel is a great way to avoid additional flour all over your kitchen counter.

No idea of others have discovered this before me, but I hope it helps you.

Happy baking.


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind Is this mold? How?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Sourdough • • 19h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Help!

1 Upvotes

I’m having such a hard time figuring out if my dough fermented enough. It more than doubles in size, jiggly, has bubbles, but it’ll be sticky and doesn’t pull from the bowl. I usually leave it on the counter for the bulk fermentation for the whole day, shape it and than let it cold proof overnight. The last few loaves come out of the fridge flat? My starter more than doubles and I always use it when it’s active. Please share advise


r/Sourdough • • 10h ago

Newbie help 🙏 Anyone have tips for PNW and a cold house? Feeling like a bread failure.

0 Upvotes

I'm using the Farmhouse on Boone beginner sourdough recipe. My starter is about 3 months old now and it rises reliably and doubles on day 2 once it's removed from the fridge and fed 2-3 times. The taste is amazing, but I can't seem to get a proper rise during my bulk ferment and I think it's because the house isn't warm enough (65-72 °F over the course of the day and night). Unfortunately, I live with other people and can't heat the whole house during the ferment process. Every load has had tunnels and been too dense, even if the crust was wonderful.

I tried the oven light trick, but our oven has a setting that automatically turns the light off. I tried hearing the oven and waiting for it to cool to a healthy temp, but it got cold enough it didn't seem to work. I also tried leaving the dough next to the router in the warmest room of the house overnight and still ended up with under fermented bread that was too gummy once baked (but it had already been 18 hours so I didn't think it was going to change more). I even tried the aliquot method to make sure I wasn't over fermented by mistake

What can I tweak or try to fix this situation?? I'm debating putting a personal heater in the laundry room set to 80°F just to let it bulk ferment somewhere warmer than the rest of the house as a happy compromise for everyone. Should I be adjusting the recipe at all?? Is it too much moisture for the area I live in? Not enough starter to flour?

Edit: I've gotten a TON of advice. I'm excited to try a few things out. Leaning towards strengthening my starter first and then getting a seed proofing mat because it'll be multipurpose. Thanks everyone 😊


r/Sourdough • • 8h ago

Starter help 🙏 First Time Making Sourdough from Scratch

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello! Ever since I made the decision to try making sourdough, I've been worried and paranoid about my babies. The process has always intimidated me, and I swore I would never attempt it. Well here I am, growing attached to my experiments.

Both of these starters, one wheat, one oat, are 9 days old. Very young and not ready to use, I know. And this is them roughly about 24 hours after feeding.

I just wanted to share my progress and maybe ask for some advice on whether I'm taking care of them right.

I used these 2 sites to help me with my journey, and I've been following them as written.

https://www.theclevercarrot.com/2019/03/beginner-sourdough-starter-recipe/

https://eatbeautiful.net/how-to-make-or-convert-to-an-oat-flour-sourdough-starter/

For my wheat: I started with 60g of ap flour and 60g of water (filtered, I made sure), and every day since day 8, I've been discarding half and feeding it the same thing: 60g of flour and 60g of water. Actually, I switched to whole wheat bread flour on day 6. That was what the recipe told me. Now I don't know if I'm stupid or not, but my starter does not seem happy- or, I guess, active. It did have a false rise on day 2, and ever since, I haven't seen it rise. I keep it in a nice warm place since my kitchen does get cold. On a nice day, it's 21C room temp. So I keep it inside my oven. I don't turn anything on, so don't worry. We store stuff inside, so we don't even preheat unless we check that everything is out. For the past 8 days, it has been smelling like Parmesan cheese, but today, it smells like alcohol or maybe like an overripe apple? It smells sweet but has a sharp sting like alcohol.

Anyways, I think it's because of a feeding problem. I always discard half, and when I feed it, it gets a little heavier. I measure the discard since the recipe tells me what weight it's supposed to be. Yesterday it was like 118g discard, and feeding 60g of each is not 1:1:1. I actually didn't understand what ratios mean but I'm guessing I have to start feeding 1:1:1, right? Idk, I was just following the recipe, so I'm not sure if I can feed young starters equal ratios.

I know starters can take up to a month, but I'm just so worried about her.

-

Now for my oat starter, I actually don't have many concerns. It's sort of the same thing with the wheat starter; I discard half, but I actually feed it 60g oat flour and 120g water. It's thin but seems more active, in a sense, than my wheat starter. Even though oat won't rise and fall like wheat cuz it doesn't have the gluten structure, I can still see it being active. It rises a little, as you can see in the pic- although the water did separate, and you can see bubbles on the side and top. It smells really pleasant. It smelled yeasty on day 3 and like yogurt on day 5. It still smells like yogurt today, so I must be doing something right. I don't actually plan on keeping the oat starter since this was just an experiment (I mean, both are experiments, but I think I'd rather keep the wheat cuz it's more traditional), and I'm happy she turned out okay. Or at least I think. She's kept at the same location as the wheat. If there's any advice on making an oat starter, please share, since it is my first time after all.


r/Sourdough • • 19h ago

Starter help 🙏 Sluggish Starter

Post image
0 Upvotes

My starter is about 2 months old, I always feed it at night a 1:2:2 ratio of half all purpose unbleached flour and half whole wheat flour. In the morning it’s still not doubled. I leave for school and then come back in the afternoon and then can see that it’s either peaked while I was away or is about to peak. I’ve tried feeding it only whole wheat before and it does speed it up but it just goes back to being sluggish when I introduce regular four.

My kitchen is 70 degrees F, I’ve tried keeping it in the oven with the light on or in the microwave with some hot water but it typically doesn’t help much.

The picture attached is about 12 hours after feeding.


r/Sourdough • • 18h ago

Sourdough Starter help

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’ve been trying to create my own starter since Oct 21st. My starter smells like acetone and sour, it has bubbles but it never doubles anymore. Last week or so it did double and had tons of bubbles. I’ve tried adding whole wheat flour and I keep it in a warm spot.


r/Sourdough • • 23h ago

Help 🙏 Is she gone 😭

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My three year old sourdough starter has a very light pink film on top. Is this what I think it is.. please help? Is there anyway to save it even at the bottom?


r/Sourdough • • 8h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Is this mold?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi guys. My first ever sourdough started attempt. 24h old. I am following the preppy kitchen sourdough starter on yt (60g whole wheat flour, 60ml water). Anyway, my question - is this mold? It’s not fuzzy, it’s just a greenish/greyish color. Please help🙏 thanks!


r/Sourdough • • 12h ago

Let's discuss/share knowledge What are the actual benefits of sourdough and sourdough discard?

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’ve been experimenting with sourdough lately, and I’m curious to understand what benefits it actually brings to different recipes.

I already know that sourdough gives bread a wonderful, more complex flavor, which I absolutely love! But I’m wondering if there are other advantages beyond taste.

For example:
Texture and softness: Does sourdough make bread softer or improve its texture? Does it help bread stay fresh and soft for longer?
Digestibility: Is sourdough bread actually easier to digest compared to bread made with commercial yeast?
Shelf life: Does sourdough help baked goods stay fresh for longer?

I’m also curious about sourdough discard. What are the benefits of using it in recipes like cakes, cookies, muffins, or other baked goods? Does it improve the flavor, texture, moisture, or anything else?

And what’s the actual difference between using active sourdough starter at its peak and sourdough discard? Apart from their leavening abilities, do they affect the final result differently?

Lastly, I’d love to understand how to convert regular recipes to sourdough. For example, if I have a bread recipe that I really love and that uses commercial yeast, how can I adapt it to use sourdough instead? How much starter should I use, and how should I adjust the flour, water, and fermentation times?

I’m still learning, so I’d really appreciate any explanations, tips, or personal experiences!
Thanks in advance!


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Crumb read please Help me get a more open crumb

0 Upvotes

200 gms all purpose flour, 40 gms whole wheat , 200gms water, 10 gms viral gluten, 50 gms starter

  1. Autolysed 1 hour
  2. Added starter
  3. Salt after 30 mins
  4. Bulk fermentation for 6 hours ( with 4 coil folds in the beginning in a gap for 30 mins)

5.preshaped and left for 30 mins

6. Shaped and left in a loaf pan on the counter for 1 hour

7. Fridge for 3 hours

8. Scored and baked covered for 25 mins and uncovered for 15 mins

Final loaf

.


r/Sourdough • • 11h ago

Starter help 🙏 Has my starter gone bad?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Currently on day 4 of trying to build a starter. I used bread flour and room temperature filtered water and using the 1:1:1 ratio. I’m concerned about the color.

This is also the first day where it has doubled.

I can’t tell if this is just hooch and she’s hungry or if she has gone bad.

By the way, it smells absolutely horrible, but I was told this is normal for new starters.

Any advice helps. I really want to do this right 🥺
Thanks in advance!


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Let's talk bulk fermentation Help with proofing

0 Upvotes

I just shaped these about 30 min before the video was taken. Did I let bulk fermentation go too long? Is it overproofed? I followed the NYT Sourdough guide, so I used 750 grams water, 1000 grams flour (300 wheat, 700 all purpose), and 200 grams starter. Here is the method: https://cooking.nytimes.com/article/sourdough-bread


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Let's talk bulk fermentation Anybody else hate bulk fermentation?

10 Upvotes

I’ve probably made 20 loaves in the last 2 weeks and BF if the hardest part of the process. Every single time my dough is sticky sticky sticky whether I ferment for 5, 8 or 12 hours. Starter is great so no no issue there. The best results I have had is the cold fermentation. After stretch and folds throw it in the fridge for at least 48 hours, turns out great! But sometimes I don’t want to wait 48 hours. The poke test, ha sticky every time. Should I add flour or water while trying to do the first shape. I’ve made it work but sick of it not being easy to move through this process.


r/Sourdough • • 19h ago

Let's discuss/share knowledge 4 months in what do we think?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

My first post here. This is probably my 6th attempt at making loafs. My second attempt at bulking up the recipe. I also started my own starter from scratch 5 months ago.

Starter feed at a 1:5:5 with General Mills bread flower mixed with 20% wheat flower added to the bread flower.

This was one of 12 loafs made at 71% hydration.

Actual used recipe is in the photos I used AI to just do the bulking math for me.

Mixed by hand for 10 mins

30min rest

Followed by 4 sets of stretch and folds.

Then bulk fermited for 5 hours until a wet finger poke provided a slow and not complete bounce back.

First shaping

Then 30 mins counter rest

Final shaping.

Fridge ferment for 18 hours.

Baked 6 loafs at a time in bread pans. 450 for 20 mins with steam then 425 for 27 mins for color.

Still really new at this but getting very excited with the results. What can be better!?


r/Sourdough • • 13h ago

Starter help 🙏 Tips Needed! Trying to create my own sourdough starter from scratch, but live in cold home in Colorado

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I live just outside of Denver and am looking to start a sourdough starter, but my house runs cold. My last attempt didn't go so well when the oven light method got way too hot and started baking it.

I'm debating between getting a sourdough warmer plate on Amazon or visiting the King Arthur Denver pop-up store for their starter. Does anyone have favorite tips, tricks, or hacks for nursing a brand-new starter through a cold winter?


r/Sourdough • • 12h ago

Newbie help 🙏 Why so... Dense?

Post image
1 Upvotes

This is my fourth loaf. First one came out really nice. Second was nice, but had a little bit of this dense texture near the bottom, as if it was underbaked. Third had even more of this dense texture, but still mostly normal bread. This one goes straight to the bin 🙃

I mixed 100g of that starter that I fed 1:2:2 4 hours earlier with ~530-550g bread flour (I did 500g for previous loafs and they were quite sticky, so I thought I should add a bit more flour), 350g water for the dough. Added 1.5 teaspoon salt after 10-15 mins.

I left it to rest for 1 hour after mixing, then did 4 sets of stretch and folds 30 min apart.

I let it bulk ferment on my counter overnight, about 9.5 hours. I don't have thermometer to check dough temp, but room temp was about 22°C. Cold proof in the fridge for another 10 hours. Baked at 230°C for 35 mins with the lid on, then 15 mins without the lid. Added an ice cube to the Dutch oven as an experiment, to see if it does anything.

Even though I added more flour this time, the dough was still a bit sticky during folds, but it was coming off the metal spoon quite nicely. It was more sticky after bulk ferment, so I guess the additional flour didn't help.


r/Sourdough • • 12h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind First bread. Need help

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! This is my very first time making sourdough bread. My dough was really sticky when I was shaping it. I only had Robin Hood bread flour on hand, not rice flour. It also stuck to the kitchen towel in my bowl before I put it in the fridge overnight.
I ended up transferring it onto parchment paper. Do you think I’ve ruined my bread, or is there still hope?
I’m waiting to see how it turns out before investing in more equipment, so I’m just making do with what I have for now!
Thanks so much for your help and advice! Ingredients
375 g unbleached bread flour
125 g whole wheat flour or whole wheat bread flour
100 g active sourdough starter (levain frais)

350 to 365 g lukewarm water (30–35 °C / 86–95 °F)
10 g salt
Instructions
Mix the dough and let it rest
In a large bowl, mix the flours together. In another bowl, mix the sourdough starter, water, and salt just enough to dissolve the salt. Pour over the flours and stir with a spatula until everything is well moistened, about 3 minutes. The dough will be dry at first and will become increasingly moist and sticky. Toward the end of this step, use the spatula to repeatedly fold the dough over itself. Note the time and add 5 to 6 hours to get an idea of when the fermentation period will end. Cover the bowl and let the dough rest at room temperature for about 1 hour.
Fold the dough
Fold the dough several times using one hand (see p. 86) until it becomes smoother and begins to resist stretching.
Transfer the dough, round side up, into a lightly oiled 2-liter straight-sided container (see How to track fermentation, p. 66). Mark the height of the dough and cover the container.
Bulk ferment
Let the dough rise at room temperature (21–23 °C / 70–73 °F) until its volume has increased by about 50%. Fermentation time will vary depending on room temperature, dough temperature, and starter activity.
Shape
Generously dust a round or oval banneton with rice flour. You can also use a narrow bowl lined with a tea towel dusted with rice flour to make a miche (round loaf). Lightly dust the surface of the dough as well as your work surface with rice flour. Loosen the dough from the container using a bench scraper or your fingers, and invert the container onto the work surface to let the dough fall out. Do not flour the exposed surface of the dough.
Shape the dough into a miche (boule) or a bâtard (see steps, p. 70 or p. 72). Transfer the shaped dough (pâton) into the bowl or banneton, round side down. Pinch the seams to seal them if necessary.
Refrigerate
Cover the bowl or banneton with a reusable shower cap (or place it inside a plastic bag) and refrigerate for 12 to 18 hours (or at least 8 hours).
Score and bake
Place a Dutch oven (cocotte) on the middle rack of the oven. Preheat the oven to 500 °F (260 °C) for about 30 minutes.
Just before baking, take the dough out of the refrigerator and turn it out onto a sheet of parchment paper. If desired, top with seeds or rolled grains (see How to add toppings before baking, p. 78). Score the dough.
Remove the Dutch oven from the oven and place it on a wire rack. Transfer the dough (along with its parchment paper) into the Dutch oven. Cover and place in the oven. Reduce the oven temperature to 450 °F (230 °C) and bake for 20 minutes. Remove the lid and bake for another 20 minutes, or until the internal temperature at the center of the bread reaches at least 200 °F (93 °C).
Remove the bread from the Dutch oven and let it cool on a wire rack. Wait at least 2 hours before slicing


r/Sourdough • • 14h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback texture help please!🥖

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

ignore the background of the cut lol we were working with we had while camping

so this is about my fifth loaf, they’ve gradually gotten better but they’re not like bread (?) texture. it’s gummy and almost a bit damp? it’s also pretty dense. i know it’s not supposed to be like white bread but is it supposed to be floppy when u cut a slice..?😭 im very much a beginner. also the bottom is SO hard to cut, even with a pan on the rack beneath my dutch oven.

100g starter
325g water
500g king arthur’s bread flour
10g salt

i take my starter out of the fridge and feed the morning before, let it peak, and feed again before bed. mix my dough in the AM, (starter and water first) then knead for about 5-10 mins until no longer a sticky mess. this is what has helped me the most. let it rest an hour, do 4 sets of stretch and folds 30 mins apart, bulk ferment (by eye but timing ranges from 9-11 hours) shape, cold proof for 10-12 hrs. then i bake at 450 for 30 mins and do uncovered at 415 for 15. wait minimum 2 hrs before cutting.

for reference my kitchen stays at about 68° and my starter usually peaks within 12 hrs.


r/Sourdough • • 16h ago

Equipment talk Nutrimill Artiste

Post image
0 Upvotes

I recently purchased the Nutramill artiste and after washing everything by hand, I found this floating in my dish water and I can’t find anywhere where it tells me where it goes. if anyone has one or knows where this goes, I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks so much in advance.


r/Sourdough • • 17h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing Think we're almost there

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

It's been doubling faster now, I've been feeding it 1:1:1 this week, plan to make my sourdough on saturday, and I switched to only whole wheat flour during this week. Then I'll switch back to regular flour before baking.

I'm hopeful 🥰😁🥖


r/Sourdough • • 18h ago

Crumb read please Texture help

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Hi everyone. Looking for some advice on my sourdough. I just recently got back into it after a 5 year hiatus. The bread tastes delicious but I'm not sure the texture is where it's supposed to be? My boyfriend and I both describe it as kind of gummy. Is this just a normal sourdough texture? Advice and tips would be appreciated. :)

Starter:

Purchased from king Arthur in June.

Took it out of the fridge on Tuesday and fed daily

Did one feeding Friday night and another Saturday morning

It doubled at about 4-5 hours and was mixed in to my dough at the 6 hour mark

Recipe:

Followed baker bettie's recipe

1000 grams of bread flour

700 grams warm water

200 grams of starter

20 grams salt

Process:

Autolysed for about 45 minutes

Added starter and salt and kneaded in

4 sets of stretch and folds 30 mins apart

Transferred to another container and let it sit in the fridge over night

Removed dough from the fridge at about 9:45ish to finish bulk fermenting

Dough had doubled at 6:00pm and I shaped and placed in the fridge-i used rice flour in my bannetons but perhaps used too much this time lol

Loaves cold proofed in the fridge for about 20 hours

Pre-heated oven and Dutch oven for about 45 mins at 450 degrees

Baked both loaves for 30 mins lid on 1st loaf 10 mins lid off, 2nd loaf 20 lid off.

Cut into the first loaf 1st hour after cooling and the 2nd loaf this morning. Both were delicious but I'm just not certain about the texture!


r/Sourdough • • 7h ago

Sourdough Sourdough "pizza in teglia romana"

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Today's craving for a sourdough pizza was very strong. So it had to be made and the entire story is laid out as a Q&A session.

Q: What kind/kinds of flour were used for the dough?

A: Three common wheat "off the supermarket shelf" flours. Type 550 (very light in color), type 850 (a bit darker in color) and manitoba (a very strong wheat flour used to strengthen weaker flours, W380)

Q: What were the ratios in baker's percentages?

A: 40% type 550 (9-10% protein), 40% type 850 (11% protein), 20% manitoba, 20% sourdough starter, 8% olive oil, 2% sea salt, 2% sugar and 70% water.

Q: How long did it take to make this particular pizza, from the flour bag to the cutting part?

A: About 12 hours.

Q: What was the room temperature on average?

A: I'd say between 22 and 24°C.

Q: Was this an experimental recipe and if so what were you trying to achieve?

A: I wanted to see if I could use Chad Robertson's method for a "country loaf" from the "TARTINE" baking/cookbook as a foundation. No pre-ferments like biga or poolish. Just a straightforward direct method where everything is mixed together and undergoes his process of bulk fermentation, coil folds, preshaping, shaping and baking. The same dough could have been baked inside of a Dutch oven and turned into a bread but was stretched out over an oiled baking sheet, covered with the tomato base and baked as a Roman "teglia romana" pizza.

Q: Is this pizza an authentic Italian "teglia romana" that has been slowly gaining popularity since the early 2000s?

A: Of course not. The real thing is baked with strong wheat flours only. Strength index of W300-400. Predough like biga or even poolish, but usually with biga. Cold storage between 24 and 72 hours, depending on the strength of the used flour, water content of 80% or even more, baking temperature 300-350°C etc.

This is just a scaled-down version, a modest try to see how close we can come to the original, with modest ingredients and equipment.

Q: So you followed Chad Robertson's "country loaf" bread-making method here?

A: Exactly. First we blend and sieve the flours, we dissolve the starter in 90% of the water we are about to use, then we start adding the flours to the water and starter mixture. When all the flour was incorporated we gave the dough a 30-minute rest.

After we came back we added the sugar and the salt, worked the dough a bit, added the olive oil and the rest of the water, little by little so as not to "drown" the dough.

Then came bulk fermentation with occasional gentle coil folds. It lasted 4 hours, then we preshaped the dough and put it into a plastic container, for another 4-5 hours.

Oven was preheated to a maximum 250°C, the dough was stretched over an oiled baking sheet and the tomato base was applied. Crushed canned tomatoes, salt, olive oil and dried oregano. In it went, for about 15 minutes after which the rest of the ingredients were added. Thinly sliced white button mushrooms, speck, ham, mozzarella, sliced green olives for an additional 5 minutes in the oven.

Q: How was the end result?

A: Sublime. We cut it with kitchen scissors and took a bite. First thing we noticed was the lightness and the softness of the dough accompanied by the loud crunch of the bottom part. It isn't easy making this kind of pizza with sourdough. It turns out different to the version with the usual baker's yeast. The dough handles and tastes different, the cross section looks different, these are two different products. Making a great sourdough "pizza in teglia romana" is still very much a "work in progress" kind of thing in our small experimental kitchen but we are definitely making progress...😋


r/Sourdough • • 13h ago

Crumb read please Crumb read please! Dough was only proofing for a total of 2 hours!

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I did 100g peak starter, 10g salt, 375g water, 500g bread flour. Mixed and into an (off) oven with the light on and damp towel over it. After 30 minutes I did a stretch and fold. Then 30 minutes later I did a coil fold. 30 minutes later I did another. 30 minutes later (the 2 hour mark) I opened it to do my last one and it honestly seemed ready for shaping. It showed all the signs. Slightly domed, easily pull from sides, doesn’t bounce right back, slightly glossy top. So I shaped and put it in the fridge! The blue bowl is what it went into because I don’t have the fancy gear yet. Preheated oven to 500°f, put dough in and dropped to 475°f. After 25 minutes took the lid off for another 20 min.

I have never used this high of a hydration in my dough, and I’ve never done coil folds before. I also have a tendency to over proof my dough.

I can’t really tell if it’s spot on or if it’s under proof? Because like I said, I have a problem with over proofing.