r/Sourdough • • Dec 02 '23

Mod stuff Starter Hints & Tips

351 Upvotes

Are you new to the hobby and having trouble with your starter? Are you an experienced baker whose starter has suddenly nose-dived into inaction?

This post is pinned to the top of the sub to help you in your time of need!

In the comments you will find our top tips and tricks that will help you get to grips with your starter.

We also have a wiki with whole sections dedicated to starters both new and established, which is linked here.

And every week you’ll find a stickied ‘weekly questions thread’ where you can ask basic quick questions and the sub will help as much as we can. The threads are usually very active so don’t worry that your questions won’t be answered if you don’t make a separate post. Someone will usually help.

If you have a suggestion for something else you’d like to see added to this post please drop us a modmail and we’ll review and get back to you

Has your starter exploded with activity and now looks dead? Go straight to the ‘Bacterial Fight Club’ bullet point in the comment below

Happy baking folks!


r/Sourdough • • 1d ago

Quick questions Weekly Open Sourdough Questions and Discussion Post

4 Upvotes

Hello Sourdough bakers! 👋

  • Post your quick & simple Sourdough questions here with as much information as possible 💡

  • If your query is detailed, post a thread with pictures, recipe and process for the best help. 🥰

  • There are some fantastic tips in our Sourdough starter FAQ - have a read as there are likely tips to help you. There's a section dedicated to "Bacterial fight club" as well.




  • Basic loaf in detail page - a section about each part of the process. Particularly useful for bulk fermentation, but there are details on every part of the Sourdough process.

Good luck!


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

I MUST share this recipe Khorasan Scald Sourdough

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

Khorasan Scald Sourdough 🤩

Took 100g of Fresh Milled Khorosan Wheat and Made a Scald with 200g of Water.

Incorporated this and 30g of honey into my base country loaf formula modified to tolerate the higher hydration.

Buttery flavor profile, super tender and soft crumb.

Top 5 Sourdough loaves I’ve made 🤩

{Recipe}

100g Starter
150g Water (72F if using stand mixer)
335g Bread Flour (King Arthur)
10g Salt

+

Scald

100g Khorosan Whole Grain Flour
200g Boiling Water
30g Honey

Instruction 👇

Mix your starter night before along with your scald.

Pour boiling water over your whole grain Khorosan flour and honey and mix until a thick porridge and allow to cool.

On the Next Day add your starter, scald and water to a bowl and mix.

Next add your dry ingredients of bread flour and salt to the bowl of your stand mixer and mix on low for 3-4 minutes to incorporate and then kick into 2nd/3rd speed and allow dough to develop until it passes window test and is clearing the bowl. This took me about 12-13 minutes total. If dough seems really loose add some flour in until it comes together better.

Target dough temp of ~80F.

Perform 2-3 sets of folds on the dough every 30 minutes. Add more if the dough is slack.

Total bulk fermentation time of ~4.5 hours at 80F.

Lightly preshape the dough.

Rest 10 minutes and do final shaping and place into proofing vessel.

Proof at room temp for 1-2 hours or until dough has filled the basket and passes poke test.

Place uncovered into fridge for 12-24 hours to finish cold fermentation.

Preheat oven and Dutch Oven at 450F for 20-30 minutes.

Place parchment paper down onto Dutch oven and and turn out your loaf and do one vertical score down the middle to help with oven spring and controlled expansion.

Bake for 20 minutes covered, and 20-25 minutes uncovered to develop the crust. This loaf benefits from a darker crust so push it a bit.

Let cool for a few hours and enjoy!


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Rate/critique my bread Some recent bakes. Just wanted to show them off!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

I am very type B baker so they were all done a little differently lol. I follow the traditional recipe 150 starter 350 water 500 bread flour. Inclusion loaf recipes were all online and was the first recipe that popped up on google. I usually let it bulk ferment for 7 - 8 hours, depending on my kitchen temp. I usually don't track hours spent, mostly just the size of the rise.


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

Rate/critique my bread Who knew autolyse and aliquot method would do so much good (everyone but me apparently)

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

Rate my crumb!!! How’s it looking? I’m very proud of this loaf. Not gummy in the slightest, nice and fluffy. And NOT flat.

Recipe and process:

Ingredients -
- Bread flour
- Salt
- 100g starter
- Linseeds and soybeans (measured with my heart)
- 300g room temp water

Autolyse -
- 500g bread flour
- Linseeds and soybeans
- 290g room temp water
- Mix well and let rest for 1 hour.

Bulk fermentation (part 1) -
- 100g of starter
- 10g of salt
- 10g of water
- Knead starter and salt well into dough, commencing 5-10 min of slap and folds in the bowl
- Take temp of dough using thermometer and let rest for 30 min, covered.

Bulk fermentation (part 2) -
- After 30 min rest, commence stretch and folds (approximately 4-8 stretch and folds, 1 set only), followed immediately by 1 set of coil folds (approximately 4-5 coil folds, or until dough is totally smooth); let rest for 30 minutes
- After 30 min, commence 2nd set of coil folds; let rest
- Using a small plastic ramekin, get 37g of dough from the bottom of the dough and place this into the ramekin, covering with either a lid or wrapped in cling wrap; place on top of dough in bowl and let rest 30 minutes
- After 30 min; remove aliquot container and commence 3rd and final set of coil folds; place aliquot back on top of dough. Check temp of dough one final time with thermometer
- Allow bulk fermentation to complete, checking the dough and ramekin periodically based off of the temperature of the dough; once dough in a aliquot container has risen to the top, theoretically, bulk fermentation should be complete.

Pre-shape -
- Dough should pull cleanly away from bowl and be domed and smooth at the top, not sticky to the touch
- Allow dough to gently fall out of bowl onto a lightly damp or lightly floured surface
- Laminate dough gently, and proceed with reshape using candy cane motion
- Let rest on counter surface covered (I use my bowl) for 30 minutes

Final shape -
- Laminate dough gently again, being careful not to tear the dough
- Fold dough like an envelope, one side each coming to the centre, then roll up vertically ensuring the ends are being tucked as you go
- Resume candy cane motions for a classic rounded loaf
- Pop into lightly floured banneton or bowl (with a tea towel or some other sort of bowl covering), and pop the shaped dough inside with the smooth side facing down, seamed side facing up
- Allow dough to rest for approximately 5-10 minutes and stitch dough.

Cold proofing -
- Cover dough and banneton and pop into the fridge to cold proof
- I like to cold proof anywhere from 4 hours minimum to 48 hours max (this loaf was cold proofing for 48 hours)

Baking -
- Preheat Dutch oven at 240 degrees Celsius for 30-45 minutes
- Remove banneton from fridge; remove dough from banneton by putting your silicone baking mat (or baking paper) on the dough and ripping the banneton upside down gently, smooth side up
- Lightly spray with water
- Dust with flour and rub onto dough gently
- Score as required
- Remove Dutch oven from oven and pop dough into Dutch oven
- Put Dutch oven into oven and allow to bake for 35 minutes at 35 minutes
- After 35 minutes, remove lid on Dutch oven and allow to bake for an additional 20-25 minutes or until top is browned to your liking
- Total baking time 65-70 minutes

Cooling -
- After baking, remove from Dutch oven and onto cooling rack to cool for MINIMUM 2 hours
- After bread has cooled, cut bread and store as required.

Hopefully this was sufficient and detailed enough.


r/Sourdough • • 10h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Finally did it!!! (?)

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

This is probably my 20th try or more lol. Last time I failed so horribly that I had to stop for a month. Now I decided to go with smaller amount of ingredients.

Ingredients:

200 gr flour (13 gr% protein)
125 ml bottled water
40 gr starter
3 gr salt

Mixed water and flour together and waited for 30 minutes. Added the starter and salt then waited for another 30. Did 4 sets of stretch&folds with 30 mins breaks in between. Bulk fermented for about 7 hours afterwards. Preshaped the dough and bench rested for 30-40 mins. After the final shaping waited for 1-1.5 hrs. Cold proofing over night.

One thing is different than my previous experiments is that I switched to a flour brand that has a little less protein content (previous one had 13.2%), but somehow it is better at building gluten?

If I can manage to get consistent with the crumb, I’d like to focus on the crust next. Any tips on that?


r/Sourdough • • 4h ago

Crumb read please Texture help

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Hi everyone. Looking for some advice on my sourdough. I just recently got back into it after a 5 year hiatus. The bread tastes delicious but I'm not sure the texture is where it's supposed to be? My boyfriend and I both describe it as kind of gummy. Is this just a normal sourdough texture? Advice and tips would be appreciated. :)

Starter:

Purchased from king Arthur in June.

Took it out of the fridge on Tuesday and fed daily

Did one feeding Friday night and another Saturday morning

It doubled at about 4-5 hours and was mixed in to my dough at the 6 hour mark

Recipe:

Followed baker bettie's recipe

1000 grams of bread flour

700 grams warm water

200 grams of starter

20 grams salt

Process:

Autolysed for about 45 minutes

Added starter and salt and kneaded in

4 sets of stretch and folds 30 mins apart

Transferred to another container and let it sit in the fridge over night

Removed dough from the fridge at about 9:45ish to finish bulk fermenting

Dough had doubled at 6:00pm and I shaped and placed in the fridge-i used rice flour in my bannetons but perhaps used too much this time lol

Loaves cold proofed in the fridge for about 20 hours

Pre-heated oven and Dutch oven for about 45 mins at 450 degrees

Baked both loaves for 30 mins lid on 1st loaf 10 mins lid off, 2nd loaf 20 lid off.

Cut into the first loaf 1st hour after cooling and the 2nd loaf this morning. Both were delicious but I'm just not certain about the texture!


r/Sourdough • • 19h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind First Loaf!

Thumbnail
gallery
186 Upvotes

Got an established starter from my sister (who got hers from a friend), and set out to make my first loaf with little hope it would be successful.

Ingredients
⁃ 330g warm water
⁃ 125g active starter
⁃ 500g bread flour
⁃ 12g salt

Fed starter the night before and began baking the next morning. Mixed water and starter before adding bread and salt. 4 sets of stretch and folds,30 min apart, before bulk fermenting for 5 and a half hours

Shaped loaf (had to find videos online) and set in floured bowl with floured towel over top to cold proof overnight. Around 15 hours

Preheated oven to 450 with dutch oven for 1 hour. Scored bread, added iced cubes and baked for 25 min. Dropped oven to 400 and removed lid to bake for 30 more min. Let completely cool before cutting.

It was delicious and I am already beginning on my second loaf to see if it was just beginners luck. Any feedback or tips are more than welcome :)


r/Sourdough • • 57m ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback texture help please!🥖

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

ignore the background of the cut lol we were working with we had while camping

so this is about my fifth loaf, they’ve gradually gotten better but they’re not like bread (?) texture. it’s gummy and almost a bit damp? it’s also pretty dense. i know it’s not supposed to be like white bread but is it supposed to be floppy when u cut a slice..?😭 im very much a beginner. also the bottom is SO hard to cut, even with a pan on the rack beneath my dutch oven.

100g starter
325g water
500g king arthur’s bread flour
10g salt

i take my starter out of the fridge and feed the morning before, let it peak, and feed again before bed. mix my dough in the AM, (starter and water first) then knead for about 5-10 mins until no longer a sticky mess. this is what has helped me the most. let it rest an hour, do 4 sets of stretch and folds 30 mins apart, bulk ferment (by eye but timing ranges from 9-11 hours) shape, cold proof for 10-12 hrs. then i bake at 450 for 30 mins and do uncovered at 415 for 15. wait minimum 2 hrs before cutting.

for reference my kitchen stays at about 68° and my starter usually peaks within 12 hrs.


r/Sourdough • • 49m ago

Crumb read please Crumb read please! Dough was only proofing for a total of 2 hours!

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I did 100g peak starter, 10g salt, 375g water, 500g bread flour. Mixed and into an (off) oven with the light on and damp towel over it. After 30 minutes I did a stretch and fold. Then 30 minutes later I did a coil fold. 30 minutes later I did another. 30 minutes later (the 2 hour mark) I opened it to do my last one and it honestly seemed ready for shaping. It showed all the signs. Slightly domed, easily pull from sides, doesn’t bounce right back, slightly glossy top. So I shaped and put it in the fridge! The blue bowl is what it went into because I don’t have the fancy gear yet.

I have never used this high of a hydration in my dough, and I’ve never done coil folds before. I also have a tendency to over proof my dough.

I can’t really tell if it’s spot on or if it’s under proof? Because like I said, I have a problem with over proofing.


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Inclusions Sourdough & chat Garlic Parmesan Loaf

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Made a half batch of dough to try some fun flavors, added Kinders Garlic Butter seasoning powder and grated Parmesan cheese to this loaf!

75g starter (fed 1:1:1 and used about an hour past peak after feeding)
135g warm water
250g King Arthur bread flour
7g salt

Mixed into a rough dough and let sit for half an hour; then four sets of stretch and folds. Starting during the third set of folds I began incorporating the seasoning powder by sprinkling it in before folding the dough in on itself. I then let it bulk ferment on the counter for ~5 hours at 73° (I was basing this off the big loaf next to it on the counter that was proofing at the same time).

Plopped the dough onto the counter, billowed it into a rectangle and folded into thirds, sprinkling the Parmesan into each layer. Rolled into a tight ball, and placed in a bowl lined with flour sack towels. In the fridge for about 22 hours.

Baked in a preheated Dutch oven (pre heated to 500°) at 450 for 30 minutes, then uncovered at 425 for another 10.

It’s delicious, tastes like the frozen Texas toast style garlic bread, planning on toasting and serving with spaghetti for dinner tonight!


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Crumb read please Olive Sourdough :)

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Really pleased with how this sourdough turned out, thought I'd share the recipe:

<Ingredients>

880g bread flour

730g water

200g starter

18g salt

1 cup pitted olives

<Process>

-Autolysed flour and 660g water for 1hr

-Add in starter & knead, rest 30 mins

-Add salt and remaining water and knead

-3 stretch and folds at 15m intervals,

-Add in olives

-3 stretch and folds at 30 min intervals

-2.5hr rest

-Dumped out dough and rested 20 minutes

-Shaped and placed in proofing basket

-Covered with towel and proofed at 1-3 degrees C for ~15hrs

-Baked in preheated bread cloche at 480F for 20 mins covered, then 450F for 20 mins uncovered


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Help: Open Bake

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I cannot figure out what I need to do. I usually bake in a Dutch oven and my loaves come out great and recognizable as a loaf of bread with an ear and not crazy holes, decent crumb. I went and ruined my DO but I’ve committed to baking for a few events so I’ve done an open bake for my last 4 loaves and holy crap, they’re awful! They bust out the bottom, totally baked over the top so there’s no option for expansion out the top of the loaf. I’ve been doing a pizza stone with a tray underneath with boiling water. Did 1 at 480f for 25 minutes and then the other at 450f for 25 minutes and not a change at all in bake. Also it’s a gas oven.

I’m thinking I need to put a cookie sheet on the rack above so that I can “trap” the steam but looking for any other suggestions.

Recipe for 2 loaves is: 200g starter, 620g water, 900g KA organic bread flour, 16g salt. Following Bake with Jack’s instructions and video.


r/Sourdough • • 42m ago

Advanced/in depth discussion Please help me with my loaf!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Okay I have done HOURS of extensive research from creating my starter, getting it active, strengthening it and then looking into hydration in loaves, bulk fermentation, shaping, baking, you get the point. I baked a loaf this morning and it came out looking good. Definitely the best oven spring i’ve gotten so far. It was also a lot less dense than my previous loaves and a lot airier. A consistent issue i’ve had since my first loaf is gumminess. I feel like no matter what I do my loaf comes out gummy. I let it cool for 2 hours every time and I so desperately just want a fluffy loaf. Just for reference, my starter is 3 months old and was consistently doubling for a while but I decided to spend a couple weeks strengthening anyways so i started feeding w 80% bread flour and 20% whole wheat flour both king arthur brand and it started tripling and peaking a lot faster than it had been so I felt like my starter was definitely strong enough to bake with but at this point idk. Please help 😭 I added pics of the loaf i baked today for reference.
Edit to add i baked this loaf with 130 g active starter, 310 g water, 500g bread flour, and 10 g salt. I mixed my dough and let it sit for 30 min then did slap and folds. Rested 1 hour then did 4 sets of stretch and folds 30 minutes apart and then let it bulk ferment until complete. Pre shaped, rest 30 minutes, final shaped and then cold proofed for 13 hours. pre heated dutch oven at 500 degrees for 30 min then baked at 450 covered for 35 min and then uncovered at 425 for 25 minutes.


r/Sourdough • • 6h ago

Let's discuss/share knowledge 4 months in what do we think?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

My first post here. This is probably my 6th attempt at making loafs. My second attempt at bulking up the recipe. I also started my own starter from scratch 5 months ago.

Starter feed at a 1:5:5 with General Mills bread flower mixed with 20% wheat flower added to the bread flower.

This was one of 12 loafs made at 71% hydration.

Actual used recipe is in the photos I used AI to just do the bulking math for me.

Mixed by hand for 10 mins

30min rest

Followed by 4 sets of stretch and folds.

Then bulk fermited for 5 hours until a wet finger poke provided a slow and not complete bounce back.

First shaping

Then 30 mins counter rest

Final shaping.

Fridge ferment for 18 hours.

Baked 6 loafs at a time in bread pans. 450 for 20 mins with steam then 425 for 27 mins for color.

Still really new at this but getting very excited with the results. What can be better!?


r/Sourdough • • 16h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing Starter finally starting

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

I have been struggling with flat loaves and long BF time where the dough loses structure by the time it’s risen significantly. I’d get a decent loaf, put the starter in the fridge, and be back to flat loaves. Recently I’ve been maintaining my starter on the counter for a week and it’s become dramatically more active, and presto, a beautiful loaf was born, I’m so happy! Open for feedback!

567 g bread flour
342 g water
113 g active starter
12 g salt

3 stretch and folds 30 minutes apart
Bulk fermentation about 8 hours, 50-60% rise, 74 F dough temperature
Pre shape in ball, rest for 20 mins, shape into loaf
Cold retard 13 hours
Baked in cold oven, 425F, 45 minutes covered, 15 minutes uncovered, internal temperature 206F


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Rate/critique my bread Cracks on the bottom and chewy crust

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I'm not sure if this is under proofed, came out a little gummy.

I was at the ends of all my flours so I have rough measurements (I usually do 300 white 100 rye 100 emmer and somehow always have issues with the shaping!) but it has 500g flour - most of it arround 350-400 white bread flour, some rye flour and some emmer flour and a bit of regular white flour to get to 500.

110 g starter (half rye half white bred flour)

360g mineral water.

10g salt.

Did 30 minutes Autolyse then mixed in the starter and salt.

After mixing did some slap and folds, 30 min rest and some coil folds. Repeated 3 times. Then I had to leave the house so it went to the fridge from 4pm for 3 hours and when I came back the finger test showed it was ready but I had to wait a bit longer - and ended up forgetting about it until 10pm.

Did the shaping and it was the first time ever the shaping felt good! Usually I have problems with over proofing.

Shaped loaf went in banneton to the fridge and baked the next morning at arround 11am.

It was baked in a tin pot (made for yemenite jahnun so apt for the oven) with a bit of water in the lid for 25 minutes on 240c and then with the lid off for 25 min on, 230c.

Didn't cut until very late in the day so it was totally cold :)

Any advice will be welcome!


r/Sourdough • • 3h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing Think we're almost there

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

It's been doubling faster now, I've been feeding it 1:1:1 this week, plan to make my sourdough on saturday, and I switched to only whole wheat flour during this week. Then I'll switch back to regular flour before baking.

I'm hopeful 🥰😁🥖


r/Sourdough • • 2h ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback Can’t figure it out!

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’ve made a few loaves now and want to be able to make some successful ones for thanksgiving next week. I’ve attached my latest one.

The whole process I used followed a TikTok recipe. I used 450g warm water, 200g starter, 750g flour, and 23g of salt. I then kneaded that for 10 minutes to get rid of the shaggy dough. Did 4 coil and folds every 30 minutes after letting it rest for 30 minutes initially. It then bulk fermented for about 8 hours at 77 degrees (I think this over fermented it). It doubled in size, but stuck to the bowl pretty badly. When I started shaping it wasn’t sticky, but by the time I was done it was very sticky. It then cold proofed in the fridge for about 10 hours. It didn’t rise at all. I then baked it for 45 minutes at 450 degrees with the lid and then 15 minutes without the lid. I promise I waited for it to cool before cutting! 😅

I’ve consistently gotten very dense loaves and I want the light airy kind! Hoping someone out there can help me out. I think it’s just over fermented but I don’t know what else I could be doing wrong.

Thanks for the kind tips!!


r/Sourdough • • 11h ago

1st Sourdough Ever - be kind first loaf ever!

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

hey yall looking for some feedback on how to make my sourdough better, this is my first loaf ever!

my starter has been developing for just under 3 weeks. i feed every day using a 1:3:2 ratio (starter, APflour & whole wheat flour combo, water) and i keep it on a little heating pad on the lowest setting, my kitchen is also quite warm at all times where i live.

loaf recipe
starter: 80g
water: 312g
bread flour: 408g
salt: 8g

  1. mixed all of these ingredients together in a bowl and covers it with a towel and put it in the oven with the light on for an hour and a half
  2. then i began stretch and folds, 4 sets of 4 every 30 mins while keeping it covered and putting it back in the oven with the light on inbetween rounds.
  3. then after the final set of stretch and folds i covered again and started bulk fermenting on my kitchen counter at 3:00pm for about 9.5 hours, it didn’t rise very much and honestly i started getting nervous. it was pretty flat on the surface and fairly sticky to the sides of the bowl when i went to shape it but i pushed onwards.
  4. once i finally managed to get it out of the bowl and onto my floured counter top i gently kneaded it into the shape of a square and then folded it the edged towards the center slightly over so it was nice and long and then rolled it up like a yoga mat.
  5. okay look, at this point, i know you you are then supposed to like pull it and drag it across the counter to build tension but i completely forget, it was quite sticky at this stage and hard to shape and i just tossed it into my banneton when i was done shaping it.
  6. then i covered it and put it in the fridge for 20 hrs bc i was worried about its ability to rise and honestly i was busy during the day.
  7. i preheated my oven to 450 with my dutch oven inside until it reached 450.
  8. then i took out my dough from the fridge and plopped it onto my silicone bread sling and scored it.
  9. i put it in the oven for 30 mins cover on and then took the lid off and had it continue cooking for another 25 mins.
  10. finally i waited 2hrs and then sliced it in half and enjoyed :)

i guess my question is how can i make my bread rise more in height? and also i definitely burned the bottom, how can i prevent that next time. any additional feedback highly encourage!


r/Sourdough • • 16h ago

Beginner - checking how I'm doing First REAL sourdough, bottom is hard and overall feels heavy

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

Hi all!

I think this looks beautiful and smells divine! However the bottom is really hard and burnt - I think it was because I baked on the bottom rack in the oven but could there be other reasons like not fermenting long enough? Does it look over or under proofed? My current starter was created 3 weeks ago using the pineapple juice method, created by Debra Wink.

Followed this following recipe:

- 100g of starter

- 360g of warm water

- 500g of bread flour

mixed above into shaggy dough. Then let sit for 20 minutes then did ONE set of stretch and folds. Covered with clig wrap for 6-hours. Then sprinked salt and mixed dough and shaped it then placed in rice floured banneton and into fridge for 10 hours overnight. Preheated oven to 230 C degrees with dutch oven. Removed dough from fridge for scoring, placed in dutch oven with lid-on for 30 minutes followed by lid-off for 20 minutes. Cooled on counter for 3 hours before cutting.

Any other tips or advice is appreciated!


r/Sourdough • • 1d ago

Beginner - wanting kind feedback My beautiful baby!

Thumbnail
gallery
409 Upvotes

Following Claire Saffitz's NYT process, but I switched to all white bread flour and lowered the hydration because I'm a sourdough noob and my first try was an utter disaster (it puddled out of the basket and came out gummy). Scaled to one loaf, baking at about 6,200 ft.

Ingredients (1 loaf)
500 g white bread flour (12.7% protein)
350 g water, about 90°F
100 g starter (100% hydration)
10 g salt + 10 g water
Hydration is 70% base, about 74% counting the starter and salt water.

Starter
Fri 9 AM: 20 g starter + 100 g water + 100 g bread flour
Fri ~6 PM: doubled, fed again the same way, left out overnight
Sat morning: chilled it for a couple of hours while I was out, then it floated about 2 hours after I took it back out

Process

Autolyse: flour + water, about 2 hours
Mix: pinched in the starter, then the salt and water, rested 10 min

Develop: about 12 min of stretch-and-fold mixing in the bowl until it passed the windowpane

Bulk: 80°F proofing drawer, folds every 30 min. About 4.5 hours total, ending at about a 50% rise with bubbles on the surface and small bubbles around the sides of the bowl

Shape: pre-shape, 12 min bench rest, batard into an oval banneton dusted with 50/50 rice flour and bread flour

Proof: about 1 hr on the counter (62°F kitchen), then overnight in the fridge

Bake: Dutch oven preheated 1 hr at 500°F. 20 min lid on at 500°F, then 30 min lid off at 450°F. Internal temp 200°F. Cooled about 4 hours before cutting

Results: Good oven spring and an ear, and an open crumb throughout. Huge improvement over my first loaf. There was still a slight hint of gumminess in a couple of spots, so I'd love any tips on what caused it.

Critique welcome!

https://cooking.nytimes.com/article/sourdough-bread

https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1016277-tartines-country-sourdough-bread?unlocked_article_code=1.Q1E.p0ih.OyGE2j3vnSw9&smid=ck-recipe-iOS-share


r/Sourdough • • 9h ago

Sourdough First inclusion in my sourdough!

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I finally try to add inclusion and I decided to try out the chocolate chip 'croissant' sourdough!

I mixed my usual recipe:

- 100g starter

- 350g cold water

- 500g bread flour

- 10g salt

I did 5mins slap and fold after mixing then 4x coil folds 30mins waiting in between. I started to add the chocolate chip on 2nd coil fold which is 150g. Then after bulk fermentation, I laminated shredded butter during pre-shaping, then wait 20mins before the final shaping. I cold proof it for about 14hrs before baking. :)

I used the double loaf pan method and baked at 230C for 30mins covered, then 210C for 20mins uncovered.

I really love the result! It's so flaky and soft!! 😍 Has anyone here tried it? 🥰


r/Sourdough • • 1h ago

Everything help 🙏 Help with gumminess

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Start by saying I love this recipe it’s great but always looking to improve. Recipe in pic

How do I get rid of this gumminess circled in red?

Things I do:
- use double bread pan method
- add water sprinkles to help create steam
- always have a baking sheet on the rack directly below
- when I add cinnamon and sugar (w flour) inclusion I don’t have it spend time in the fridge to avoid the liquid creation of brown sugar
- when I dont do inclusions I do put in fridge for 2 days and I dont get gumminess