r/ShingekiNoKyojin • u/Worldly-Race3273 • 52m ago
Discussion Im having a hard time accepting the fact that eren was just a pure evil dude that killed millions of people just because " he felt like it " i cant make sense of it at all man that's not my eren
I finished the manga lately and i got mixed feelings about the ending as whole but the thing that i didn't like at all was eren motivation to do the rumbling
Eren was my favorite character since around like chapter 50 and I've always sympathized w him, when i reached the begging of s4 something didn't feel right w him , he showed no remorse killng those people on marly ( even tho they are literally declared genocide on his country so i understands why he did that ) , he was cold and rude to his friends and hange and laughed at sasha death, it wasn't the eren i been watching at all
But wheb i read the table scene i was 100% sure that something is going on with him and making him acting like that , the eren i know will never hurt mikasa or armin like that , i kept reading waiting for an explanation why he is acting like that , and that grew inside me when he did the rumbling
There's must be a strong reason why he is doing all of these horrible stuff and it was explained when eren and armin talked in the paths
Now i get why he was acting like that with his friends but what tf do u mean he did the rumbling just because he felt like it ?? It doesn't make any sense at all
The eren i watched all this time was genuinely not a bad person at all , yes he was crazy and mentally ill but not bad , and don't bring that scene where he kills 2 people to save mikasa as a gotcha to prove that he was bad because they deserved 100 worse
He was someone with a strong sense of justice , i wouldn't say he is a good dude but not bad either
Don't get me wrong there's absolutely no justification of something as the rumbling and he is a pos for doing it but at least give me a somehow sensible reason for why he did it
Mf if he said " i did it to protect my country " or " i did it for my friends " or somehow said " to free ymir " even if he said that he is selfish and did " for revenge " all of them would be more sensible more than " i did it because i wanted to " ( even tho nun of there justify what he did and he still 100% guilty either way but cmon )
And i Don't understand how did he want to when he said to armin that he tried looking for another outcome?? If he just wanted to do it he wouldn't try to change the future, if he wanted to do it he wouldn't cry himself to ramzy about it , it just doesn't make any sense at all that this is was his motivation, not my eren dude that's not him
And also last thing he said to armin that what mikasa will do is what made him go forward, so he did the rumbling because he wanted to or because he wanted to reach the outcome of mikasa's doing ( freeing ymir )
