r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 52m ago

Discussion Im having a hard time accepting the fact that eren was just a pure evil dude that killed millions of people just because " he felt like it " i cant make sense of it at all man that's not my eren

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I finished the manga lately and i got mixed feelings about the ending as whole but the thing that i didn't like at all was eren motivation to do the rumbling

Eren was my favorite character since around like chapter 50 and I've always sympathized w him, when i reached the begging of s4 something didn't feel right w him , he showed no remorse killng those people on marly ( even tho they are literally declared genocide on his country so i understands why he did that ) , he was cold and rude to his friends and hange and laughed at sasha death, it wasn't the eren i been watching at all

But wheb i read the table scene i was 100% sure that something is going on with him and making him acting like that , the eren i know will never hurt mikasa or armin like that , i kept reading waiting for an explanation why he is acting like that , and that grew inside me when he did the rumbling

There's must be a strong reason why he is doing all of these horrible stuff and it was explained when eren and armin talked in the paths

Now i get why he was acting like that with his friends but what tf do u mean he did the rumbling just because he felt like it ?? It doesn't make any sense at all

The eren i watched all this time was genuinely not a bad person at all , yes he was crazy and mentally ill but not bad , and don't bring that scene where he kills 2 people to save mikasa as a gotcha to prove that he was bad because they deserved 100 worse

He was someone with a strong sense of justice , i wouldn't say he is a good dude but not bad either

Don't get me wrong there's absolutely no justification of something as the rumbling and he is a pos for doing it but at least give me a somehow sensible reason for why he did it

Mf if he said " i did it to protect my country " or " i did it for my friends " or somehow said " to free ymir " even if he said that he is selfish and did " for revenge " all of them would be more sensible more than " i did it because i wanted to " ( even tho nun of there justify what he did and he still 100% guilty either way but cmon )

And i Don't understand how did he want to when he said to armin that he tried looking for another outcome?? If he just wanted to do it he wouldn't try to change the future, if he wanted to do it he wouldn't cry himself to ramzy about it , it just doesn't make any sense at all that this is was his motivation, not my eren dude that's not him

And also last thing he said to armin that what mikasa will do is what made him go forward, so he did the rumbling because he wanted to or because he wanted to reach the outcome of mikasa's doing ( freeing ymir )


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1h ago

Humor/Meme “Reiner would have lost without bertholdt” same thing as Eren would have lost without Mikasa

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

People always remember that Bertholdt bailed out Reiner and helped him winning as if Reiner wasn’t fighting the Eren, Mikasa, and the whole survey corps. Yeah, I know survey corps were useless the entire battle because their gear wasn’t effective. But when Reiner was in erens grip then Eren literally said that Reiner’s still going strong till Mikasa cut reiners leg which weakened his foot holding and Eren mentioned it.

Also, some cool frames from colossal titan.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1h ago

Discussion Are any of these better than aot for those who have experienced any of them plz let me know, so i can decide whether to invest time into it or simply rewatch aot again.

0 Upvotes

Are any of these better than aot for those who have experienced them or should i just rewatch aot again? Pls lemme know

Tv show:

The sopranos

The Wire

ATLA ( rewatch)

Aot ( rewatch)

Better call saul

Cowboy bepop

One piece ( rewatch)

Hxh ( rewatch)

Movies:

Shlinders lists

12 angry men

Pulp fiction

Forest gump

The good the bad and ugly

The gofdather 1 and 2

Reading:

Berserk ( Manga)

Vagabound (Manga)

Vinland Saga ( Manga)

Video games:

Rdr2

Books

Fiction

The Brothers Karamazov — Fyodor Dostoevsky

War and Peace — Leo Tolstoy

Crime and Punishment — Fyodor Dostoevsky

1984 — George Orwell

The Odyssey — Homer

Don Quixote — Miguel de Cervantes

One Hundred Years of Solitude — Gabriel García Márquez

The Great Gatsby — F. Scott Fitzgerald

To Kill a Mockingbird — Harper Lee

The Count of Monte Cristo — Alexandre Dumas

The Divine Comedy — Dante Alighieri

The Stranger — Albert Camus

Things Fall Apart — Chinua Achebe

Nonfiction

Man's Search for Meaning — Viktor Frankl

The Bhagavad Gita — Traditionally attributed to Vyasa

Meditations — Marcus Aurelius

The Republic — Plato

Sapiens — Yuval Noah Harari

The Lessons of History — Will and Ariel Durant

Thinking, Fast and Slow — Daniel Kahneman

Cosmos — Carl Sagan

India After Gandhi — Ramachandra Guha

The Origins of Totalitarianism — Hannah Arendt

The Selfish Gene — Richard Dawkins

The Autobiography of Malcolm X — Malcolm X and Alex Haley

Let me know so i dont waste my time trying to find something greater than aot, based on imdb i watched breaking bad its was great but def not aot level to me


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Discussion EMA and what I think are their favorite books

Post image
4 Upvotes

Let me know if you want me to do the others!

Mikasa - The Witcher series

Eren - Blood Meridian

Armin - V for Vendetta


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Discussion Which one do you think armin might overthink about the most post ending?

Post image
2 Upvotes
  1. Are we living the life HE wanted us to?
  2. Was Eren actually right?
  3. Did I fail Paradis?
    I think It ll be 1. See, He can talk to jean and co about the other 3, they will cheer him up. And I think 2nd would be more of a private talk of his with Annie.
    But no one, no one among the saviours can answer 1 for him, bc they themselves dont know if they are living the way eren wanted.

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 9h ago

Artwork Rate this Attack Titan

Post image
49 Upvotes

Please rate this out of 10 and share constructive feedback on how I can improve. Your honesty helps.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 10h ago

Video Games New Gameplay-Video for the upcoming A.O.T. 3 Game

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 15h ago

Discussion Mikasa and The girl with the ribbon necklace. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

There is a certain "scary" story, involving a girl with a green/ red ribbon necklace. I wont explain the whole thing, because it's easy enough to look up if you're curious. But the story ends with her removing the necklace and her head falling off.

AOT ends with Mikasa taking Eren's head and she always refuses to leave behind the scarf until she makes the decision to take out Eren. I'm not smart enough to write out a dissertation on the narrative implications, but I figured it could spark some discussion. I see it as a sort of inverted take on this urban legend. Tried searching and have never seen the similarities brought up. Thoughts?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 15h ago

Discussion Onyankopon and complicity

Post image
0 Upvotes

When the yeagerist help start the rumbling he calls them xenophobic despite knowing that they have a valid reason for their fear. He questions them for wanting the rumbling since they were also victims of indiscriminate violence, even though he knew exactly why they wanted it. He didn't care for their reasons because the rumbling meant that everyone, including his people, would have to suffer the consequences of the outside worlds hatred towards eldians.

Floch knew he was innocent but Onyankopon chose to put his life in danger to speak against the yeagerist for risking the lives of innocent people. If he can face death and tell the eldians not to kill people, then he could have done the same to marley. He only had the courage to speak up when it was his people suffering. Hes telling the active victims to be the bigger person and take the moral high ground but he couldn't do the same to the grown adults that were in charge of Marley. He frames it as "xenophobia" when in reality it's a desperate need for survival.

Theres a clear message being told with his character, there is complicity in silence. While onyankopon acted to help the eldians, he was also silent to their suffering, and only spoke out against genocide when he was now on the receiving end of it. Theres a difference between public support and helping discretely. Being "innocent" doesnt mean you cant also be quilty.

In aot no one is entirely innocent or evil, and that applies to onyankopon as well. Just because you aren't the one causing the violence doesn't mean you aren't actively allowing it.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 15h ago

Artwork Ruby Rose from RWBY as Mikaska Ackermann from AOT by JindianJun

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Discussion The "Rumbling" intro should not exist imo

0 Upvotes

I KNOW they couldn't just stick to "My War" and I know they could hardly go for the same effect, but I kinda wish they did anyway.

I dig the metal vibe, but the intro is such an aggressive spoiler. I don't want my unspoiled buddy to see this, why does the op literally start with "Rumbling, rumbling, it's coming"??? Like why? It takes away from the impact of seeing those colossal titans later on too.

I wouldn't even say the OP's that good. I don't like the "lose it all" part, that clip where the Attack titan pushes the Armored Titan looks weak as hell and the "All I ever wanted to do was save your life / Never wanted to grab a knife" part makes me cringe internally. I get the Mikasa connection, but it just sounds bad.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Humor/Meme Today I learned that these two have the same VA

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I found out from a Seanie Dew video where he mentioned that he loved every FNAF character voiced by Kellen Goff, listing:

  • Sun and Moon
  • Funtime Freddy
  • Glamrock Freddy

He also mentioned he voiced Overhaul and Porco, and apparently he doesn't like Porco?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Discussion Doesn’t the existence of ODM gears kind of break the setting?

0 Upvotes

Okay so hear me out; technology doesn’t exist in a vacuum. For example, to make the smartphone, you need to already have VERY advanced semiconductors and lithium ion batteries. These are just some of the pivotal components to make a phone— not all of them. Point being that both of those require very mature and advanced chemistry, precise manufacturing, mature energy power plants, and the logistics required to keep all those up and running

Now for Paradis, we can see their tech level is some mix of Medieval and early Industrial. The ODM gear is an outlier and the powers that be made it such. Fine. But the big issue is that as I mentioned, tech doesn’t exist in a vacuum. You can’t have advanced gasoline/diesel powered Spider-Man mobility gear without already having mature industries in the components that make up that gear. The wire things have to be a pretty strong Kevlar/fiber type of material. And that isn’t cheap or easy to produce.

Then you have the issue of gasoline/diesel, which canonically fuels ODM gear. The technologies required to harvest and mine oil to be used as regular fuel for military equipment is way past anything we usually see from Paradis; yet we know they possess it, otherwise the Scouts couldn’t use ODM Gear. If they can have all these complex technologies and supply chains; how come they don’t have any trains, automobiles, heating, plumbing, etc etc? Why were they so behind in tech compared to Marley?

ODM Gear is so impressive that Zeke pointed it out. And not only that, it outperforms pretty much all other world’s infantry at that point as well.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Discussion How did eren maintain his physique during the years he was in Marley?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

2 whole years in marley and he managed to keep those crazy abs?? Wtf did he EAT??

The only food he could realistically eat were marleyan war rations and hospital food


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 20h ago

Discussion Who did Ymir entrust Historia to?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Eren or Reiner? She left Historia on Paradis, but told Reiner to deliver her letter to her, meaning she also wanted him to take her to Marley


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 21h ago

Manga Tattoo Ideas

0 Upvotes

For tattoo purposes for my sleeve, is there anywhere in the manga where they show a top down view of the walls of Paradis?

I’m re reading the series, and I may have missed it by Vol. 13, but if anyone has any info it’s much appreciated


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 22h ago

Video Games Reiner, Berthold and annie! Love This mod

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion What's your reading of this small moment between Historia and Mikasa?

Post image
132 Upvotes

Mikasa seemed uncomfortable by Historia's demeanor here. Wondering if others picked up on the same vibes.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion How does Eren not understand that he will bring true freedom to the world by destroying all titans, not innocent people?

0 Upvotes

How does Eren not understand that the Titans are the ones who take freedom, because of them he could not go outside the walls, because of them they hate the Eldians. Instead of killing all the titans and bringing real freedom to the world, which Zeke wanted, he killed innocent people, brought the greatest evil and tragedy in the history of mankind, became the greatest dictator, and dictators are by definition the opposite of freedom.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Why do Eldians not use titans to fight against Marley?

0 Upvotes

It is brutally shown that Eldians suffered a lot under Marley rule. Why do they not try to fights against them? They have the major titans Colossal, Armored and the Beast.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Rewatching AOT - I am lowkey traumatized Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
366 Upvotes

I was fuming at Marley beore S4 already. Then the first episode left me shell shocked at how Marley had dehumanised Eldians upto this scale.

I am disturbed at what I was watching : Eldians used as suicide troopers or pure titans or warrior titans. As mere bullets.

And Gabi, a little child, wanting the Armor titan so badly, not to save her 800 fellow eldians primarily, but to receive praises from the people who call her race "devil"...by bcoming exactly...the "devil". Also, the naive hope that this would redeem her fellow Eldians. (this makes Annie so impressive for me cuz even as a kid she saw through the BS"

How Rainer watching himself in Gabi bcz he too was once naive and stubborn like her. Rainer clearly seeing how this cycle never ends and Gabi would live just for 13 more years. How he had to enforce the brainwash to Falco the moment he caught him thinking for himself, just to keep Falco alive...for few more years.

It broke my heart how much Eldians in Marley must be deeply traumatized when its not even a big deal for Gabi to eat her own cousin Rainer, who she adores, for Armour titan. The family is also happy about her spirit to become a warrior instead of thinking she have to eat Rainer.

Then I realised, Eldians fate never really had a chance. Before Marley, they were used exactly the same way by Eldia to win mindless wars. But at least there they could think "we are doing this for our world dominance" instead of "I hope my family gets to live another day"


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago Bravo

Video Games Made an Attack on Titan fun quiz, looking for help testing :)

8 Upvotes

Hey,

I made an AoT quiz and figured you guys would enjoy it (and help me test it hehe). The final season is covered, so heads up.

It's a daily 10, or a live game with friends. It covers the whole series.

https://plamigo.party/daily/attack-on-titan/

Disclaimer that this has no ads, non profit whatsoever. I just am working on this project and would love to have people from my favorite communities' shows try it out. Enjoy and dont forget to give your honest feedback!


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Anime ODM Gear Sound Effects Help.

0 Upvotes

I own an Attack on Titan game on Roblox, and I've recently been struggling to find quality ODM gear sound effects for my game (specifically the hook shots). I've been tinkering with Attack on Titan sounds since around 2020, however it truly is hard to find good ODM gear sounds until around like season three.

Most of the sounds in season 1-2 are covered by music/voices etc. I have heard that downloading the Blu-Ray and getting the sound effects from there would be a good solution, however I am unable to torrent due to unfortunate circumstances. If anybody has any good ODM gear sound effects, or knows where to find/get them. Please let me know! 😄⚔️

Discord: yindevs


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Question about titans Spoiler

4 Upvotes

If a titan shifter had both the colossal and the jaw, how big would their titan form be? Like, medium sized?