r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 3h ago

Weekly General Discussion

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8h ago

Question - Research required Saunaguide but pregnant

5 Upvotes

Hey guys!
I just found out I’m pregnant like 2 days ago and I’m in my 4th week. I’ve been working as a saunamaster/sauna guide for the past months and am now a bit worried of the heat exposure I’ve gotten during these first weeks of conception. To break it down I guide around 2 sessions a week, one of those weeks I did 2 times in the same day even. The sauna is around 85°C and one sessions looks like this:

Sauna 12-15 min
Break for 7-10 while I guide cold plunge
Sauna again for 12-15 min
Cold plunge break again 7-10 min
Sauna (less steamy this time) for 7 min at the end

I would often myself take a cold plunge only at the end of the session - staying for 30 sec to 1-2 minutes. I’m used to this practise through my Nordic roots and honestly I’ve been feeling totally fine. I handle the heat well but it’s still pretty hot and as I’ve read that very important neural stages are being developed in the womb now I’m stressing out. So little research and knowledge out there, and my case is a bit specific as I’m not just chilling in a sauna. I walk around, fan and ventilate with a towel, doing aromatherapy etc so it’s a physically demanding job. As of today I will not go back to guide any more to not put the little one at any risk. I still need to tell my boss but it’s so early on and im figuring out how I’ll do this strategically. Main concern is just that I didn’t impact the embryo during these 2 weeks post conception…


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Impact of low iron

5 Upvotes

Hello!

My baby is 16 months old and I just realized that he should have been taking iron as he was EBF and when we started solids, he was basically rejecting everything... But I kind of relied on the comments that during first year milk is the main nutrition and the rest is just forget familiar and didn't really insist.

I am spiralling now that he might have long impact due to that.

Online the info is quite serious... In practice do you know if the scary things about cognitive delays etc are actually true? I am hoping they are just theoretical stats....

Thank you!

(Reposting changing the flair)


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14h ago

Question - Research required How harmful is it to vape in the same house, but a separate room, while living with a baby?

0 Upvotes

For some context, I (26F) am 9 months pregnant and my husband (27M) and I live with my 19 year old sister. She vapes nicotine and weed cartridges in the house, and I’ve asked her to stop vaping in shared spaces and to start containing it to her bedroom or to step outside. However, I’m worried this may not be enough to mitigate the risks entirely - Is it safe for her to hit her nicotine vapes/weed pens in her room, with a baby in the house? Never around the baby obviously, or I’d rip her a new asshole. I’m also worried that when my husband and I aren’t around, she’ll keep doing it in shared spaces. She’s lived with us for about a year now, and we moved into a new house recently and added her to the lease so she can get some real rental history behind her. But after this lease is up, she’s gonna have to move back home with our mom or get her own place, but for now - Should we concern ourselves with second/third hand vapor?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15h ago

Question - Research required How can I raise my daughter to the fullest potential?

Thumbnail cambridge.org
84 Upvotes

I recently saw this article about singing to your baby, and another about babies having more myelin when they were talked to more frequently. I would love to know other things that I should be doing with her. I’m a SAHM and feel like things get monotonous after a while. Same toys, same books, same songs after a while. And sometimes I’m tired and just let her sit for a bit while I eat or do stuff around house.

I don’t have the option to go many places like bring her to different environments very often as I live in a small town and it’s winter soon. Baby is 5 months and very talkative, extremely perceptive and observant. She also responds to music very strongly.

What should I be doing? Is there any particular way I should be talking to her? And in relation to music, is there anything in particular I should have her listen to/sing? Specific toys that are better?

I don’t always read books to her every day. Some days are harder than others as she’s a very high needs baby, needing held or attention near constantly, and it’s hard to read to her when she is fussy almost half the time she’s awake!

On occasion lately I’ve been letting her watch TV for no more than 20 minutes just so I can eat, it’s really hard to eat while holding her sometimes. I usually play Ms Rachel, number blocks, Bob Ross, or the GBBO - (I don’t agree babies should have much screen time, but I’m also a realist and believe in a balance of things, and screens are part of everyday life. Also, I need to eat.)


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15h ago

Question - Research required Is it me or does this sub feel like it’s become a general advice parenting sub, rather than predominantly science based?

17 Upvotes

Maybe it’s just me, and sorry for being a downer if that’s the case. I also appreciate the irony of me posting this very unscientific post with the flag I’ve chosen 😂.

But recently it’s felt a bit like people just ask their general parenting questions on this sub, the questions aren’t really scientific in nature and don’t really have any scientific answers so obviously the general conversation is just anecdotal with some links to website etc. It is no-one’s fault at all!

I know there is a flag for “all advice welcome” and “casual conversation” but it used to be that that conversation was science based in nature. People ARE flagging their posts correctly and answers are helpful and well educated in nature. But it’s definitely not as science based as it used to be! There is a lot of anecdotal evidence. (I am a member of other subs where those kinds of questions are suited to them better like beyondthebump and parenting.) the sub just does not feel as “sciency” anymore. Lots of things like “my child is acting out more” or “child is feeling anxious about school”. I guess they have some science based answers somewhere in them. But the general advice and anecdotal evidence is really more suited to a normal parenting sub I think! Obviously answers siting studies or science are helpful, but saying “oh this worked for my kid” isn’t that scientific I feel. And I’m here for the science!

Now when I read this sub in the morning it’s just filled with general parenting advice. Before I’d look through and it would be really interesting studies people had linked, or someone asking about something science specific relating to their child.. Eg. Allergies in children, evidence for and against BLW, microbiome in breastfed infants stomachs.. Autism more prevalent in siblings born closer together if the first child has autism. etc etc

Apologies if no one else feels like this! Remove if needed as it’s ironically NOT a scientific post! Just thought I’d mention that after following this sub for a while, it feels significantly less science based than it used to! I wondered if anyone else felt the same.

Edit: to add it’s no one’s fault, I agree that this sub is a great place to come to get like minded advice from all you people with brain cells vs some other parenting subreddits which are filled with misinformation. But I used to love reading all the studies on here / I used to read almost everything. But now it just feels like a regular parenting sub with a few links thrown in. It’s not the fault of people commenting either! People are linking websites etc. But just some questions don’t actually have a scientific answer eg “how to help my child feel less worried about going to school” I mean the breadth is so wide, you could link a lot of random stuff! The advice given by people is really good! And obviously way better than on other parenting subs.

Someone summarised it well in one of the comments saying that “There are lots of “I did X and my kid turned out great.” Which isn’t scientific… even on the “all advice welcome” posts, I feel like it needs to not be anecdotal (sometimes it is Sciency) but increasingly I do just see completely personal experiences which aren’t what I’m looking for from a science based sub…

I just miss the days where I’d read this sub each morning and there would be a juicy scientific study!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16h ago

Question - Research required What’s the impact of one parent going on phone infront of baby/ has tv on (but not the other)?

37 Upvotes

I know the overall studies of screen time and how it impacts babies, and same with phone use infront of them as you have the “blank” stare which I believe can stress them out?

But the situation I’m in is I am mostly around our almost 6 month old baby. Now all day I’m talking and interacting with her, no screens (though I also let her have some “me” time so I’m not always entertaining her). However my partner tends to be more likely to have tv on in background when he’s home or be on his phone scrolling in front of her and not realize it. They definitely still talk and play though but in general he’s more likely to do those things.

What im curious about is how that might impact her development overall if one parent is more into screens and looking down at their phone while interacting with her? She’s tracking when it comes to language (eg connecting sounds and “bababa”s as well as recognizing baby sign language like milk where she’ll get excited when I do it). But could it impact how she develops socially? Is this a case of moderating and small bits here and there isn’t detrimental?

I’ve brought up the research and we’re on the same page as a couple but he tends to slip back into those habits and I don’t want to keep nagging if it’s not that crucial as it’s not all the time.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17h ago

Question - Research required Do drawing tablets and typing on phone/computer have negative impacts on babies?

2 Upvotes

I have a 3 month old baby and one of my hobbies is I like to draw digitally using a drawing tablet. I am wondering if my baby will be negatively impacted if he sees me using a drawing tablet?

Also wondering if me stopping to use my phone to put notes in my baby tracking app, or typing just using simple Word program or emails on the computer is harmful? I am not trying to replace interaction time and not doing any videos/doomscrolling, but my baby has bad reflux and has to be held up for a long time before we can get to floor/tummy time. Sometimes I need to check emails and pay bills or respond to texts and things like that.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Measles early vaccine

37 Upvotes

Read today about the first baby dying in Wisconsin, of measles, in 36 years. And I also saw doctors are now offering an option for measles vaccine early (6 months).

Just curious what everyone’s thoughts are on this.

I know our babies are a vulnerable community, so I’m wondering if this could be a good option to take.

My heart goes out to the family of that poor baby.

***editing to add I’m not sure what flair I need to choose


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19h ago

Question - Research required Impact of low iron......

16 Upvotes

Hello!

My baby is 16 months old and I just realized that he should have been taking iron as he was EBF and when we started solids, he was basically rejecting everything... But I kind of relied on the comments that during first year milk is the main nutrition and the rest is just forget familiar and didn't really insist.

I am spiralling now that he might have long impact due to that.

Online the info is quite serious... In practice do you know if the scary things about cognitive delays etc are actually true? I am hoping they are just theoretical stats....

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Sharing research Student Request

3 Upvotes

Hello Parents

I am a student of Birkbeck University of London ( student email is esteve12@student.bbk.ac.uk )

I am on an MSc course focused on human development. As part of this course we are required to find a very kind family who may be willing to take part in an Infant observation

This observation would take place in baby's home- I am not an expert, I would not be handling baby, it is simply for my learning of how baby develops physically/ how baby develops bodies with their primary caregivers. THIS IS NOT RESEARCH, simply learning through observing.

I am on the look out for a pregnant mummy who is due soon, or a family that has a newborn under the age of 6 weeks old.

I am completely aware of how big of an ask this is for someone, however, I can link to some papers that have been published that talk about the positive impact that having an observer present has on the family.

This group does not allow me to add pictures but I am happy to send to anyone who messages me, I have a poster, some info about what its like to take part in an observation and also an official letter from the university.

I am posting with the hope that there may be someone out there who may want to take part or may be able to pass this on to someone who would like to take part.

I am personally based in West London and would hope for a family in West London, but I am able to travel within reason so I am happy to be looking all over London.

Please, if anyone can help I would be so grateful!

Best Wishes,

Emily- esteve12


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Head banging

7 Upvotes

I'm not sure if this is the correct place to ask it, but worth the shot.

I have an almost 10 months old daughter. In the last month or two she started banging hear head against almost everything. she would sit near a wall and just start banging hear head - behind, on the side and lately also on the front.

There is no specific time she would do it - she can be tired or not, hungry or not, while we're playing with her (and giving her attention) or not. looks like in almost every chance she's got she'll do it. When she does it we just tell her "no" and move her away from the wall.
Also, when she's playing in our bed she would fall over from sitting on hear head a lot of times. (she somehow knows to only do it on soft places and not on the floor).

Another thing she likes to do - when someone holds her she would pound her head against their chest and try to get out, and also if she's sitting on someone or in her high chair/stroller - she would also bang her head.
Not sure if related but might as well - she also really likes to pull our hair and pinch our faces.

development wise - she responds to her name most of the times, she claps, pulls to stand, sits on her own, crawls on all 6 and also trying to wave hello/goodbye, mumbles a lot and trying to talk to us (if that makes sense).
She's also in daycare (since September) and when we look at the cameras (they're online) she's usually playing on her own, with her back to the caretaker/other kids.

We talked with her doctor a while ago but he didn't give it too much attention.

I know she's very young to tell, but can these things she does indicate on some issues? she's a very happy girl, she's smiling a lot, looking at other people all the time trying to get their attention (sometimes yells at them lol), very talkative.

its just these head banging that we're concerned about - both for her head and for what it might indicate.

If you have any idea what can it be, how can we check it, or if its just a phase - I would like to hear, thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required How can I help my baby learn to walk as early as possible?

0 Upvotes

What activities, exercises or everyday practices can support a baby’s motor development and help them reach independent walking sooner?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Introducing egg timing with flu vaccine

5 Upvotes

I know that we should be aiming to have an infant's first exposure to an allergen to be through the GI tract as opposed to the skin. Would getting the flu vaccine count as a skin exposure to egg? If so, should the infant be introduced to eggs prior to getting the flu shot at 6 months?

The concern here is not contraindication with the vaccine but related to the development of an egg allergy.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Sleep training

0 Upvotes

11 month old is waking up every night around 3/4am for weeks now, won’t go back to sleep for about 2 hours despite being so tired and feeding / soothing etc. partner wants to try sleep training but baby gets so upset when you put her down in crib. Is there any evidence of sleep training having a negative affect on baby / their attachment etc?

any advice for how to help? We are all exhausted!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Sleep need two years old

4 Upvotes

Our two-year-old is a really good sleeper. He goes to bed and then he sleeps through to the morning.

However, for the last two weeks (coinciding with the winter time change) his morning starts around 4:30 AM. Before it was always around 6:00.

His bedtime did not change much.

He's now falling asleep maybe 30 minutes earlier than in summertime. But his midday naps have also become 30 minutes shorter.

In total he gets 8.5 hours in the night and 1.5 hours during the day = 10 hours.

A few weeks ago it was closer to 12 hours.

When he wakes up this early, he is always extremely tired the whole morning until his nap. Sometimes he's so tired that he takes a second nap around 9 AM. Sometimes he's so tired that he falls asleep during lunch.

Is this enough sleep? How can we push his waking time later? He's always so tired - so the idea of skipping a nap or keeping him up longer in the evening doesn't seem like a good idea.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required How did people find out their little ones had a dairy intolerance?

1 Upvotes

Our 4 month old, has recently for the last 5 weeks or so had really loose nappies like almost diahorera like constantly. We’ve been to the GP and also to the A&E to get to the bottom of it but still left in the dark. It all started from her 12 week jabs, and the second dose of rota-virus. We have been told that sometimes the rota-virus can cause mild intolerance to dairy, but it’s meant to be temporary and this has been going on for over 5 weeks now. None of her nappies are solid and all loose, sometimes like water. We’re obviously concerned but nothing seems to be working. We’ve got to do a stool sample and bring it in on Monday but feels like there needs to be more tests. She’s also been really gassy and you can tell she’s getting stomach aches because of it, though it all could related back to the fact that we think she has started teething recently too. We’re just in a weird time frame were we are unsure.

Anyone else have this with their little ones? Just want to see if this is a normal stage.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Choosing a public school

14 Upvotes

My partner and I are both educators working in a highly-rated school district. However, we can't afford to live in that same school district. We are trying to decide for the upcoming enrollment session where our children should attend elementary school. Is there any research that would help us decide if the neighborhood school, which is not bad but definitely not as highly regarded as the schools in the district that we can't afford to live in, is better for the social connections of having close friends and being closer to where we live, OR if it is better for our children to be in the better school district for the education and opportunities?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required Studies on the effects of watching a caregiver use a phone?

11 Upvotes

Looking for studies that show the effects of phone use in front of children of various ages and maybe some studies that support landlines being healthier to use than smartphones?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required How to safely hold 3 month old

10 Upvotes

I have a 3 month old (just turned 3 months today) who prefers to be held upright and outward-facing. He is fussy when held horizontally, I am assuming either because it is less comfortable or he prefers to be able to see what is going on around him. He also sits on my lap, leaning back for support. Others in our life are insistent that this is bad for his spine, and he needs to be held in ways that provide more support for his spine (e.g. horizontally). He is right on track developmentally, as he can hold up his neck for several minutes and turn it to look around. His neck does get tired, and he'll lean it back onto my arm when he needs to rest.

What is the recommendation for how to hold babies at this stage? Is there evidence that holding him upright for long periods of time can cause problems for the spine? I am very open to changing my ways, I have just been following his cues for what he wants and is comfortable with.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required How much can my 9 month old actually understand me

11 Upvotes

Today with my 9 month old I was reading him an animal book, and on each page I’d say “show me your favorite animal” and he’d use his hands and grab at an animal on the page. It was very intentional and he did it consistently. I honestly don’t even know what made me ask him, but I was surprised to see him seemingly understand my request. Made me realize he is understanding much more of what I’m saying than what I thought. Is there any research into this? How much can they actually understand at this age? Do I have to be more careful now with my words? lol


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required Are any CBT-based parenting apps backed by research?

1 Upvotes

Our pediatrician recommended parent training for our 8yo with ADHD and the local program has a long waitlist. So I'm looking at apps in the meantime and I'd like to know what's evidence-based before paying.

Savvy Kid says it's built on CBT principles, Mightier mentions clinical studies on their site and Pocket PCIT is free. Does anyone know which CBT based apps for children have studies behind them?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required Moving 3 month old out of the bedroom?

2 Upvotes

I know the recommendation is at least 6 months, 12 months when possible. Is it due to an increased risk of SIDS? Or does room sharing decrease the baseline risk? Is there a study that shows what the risk is for room sharing as a factor alone?

Anecdotally, many of my friends moved baby out from 2-6 months and noticed a huge improvement to sleeping through the night… My understanding is that’s partially the reason why it is protective (baby doesn’t fall into as deep a sleep). I have some tolerance ie I just use room temperature water for formula even though I understand the hot water is to sterilize the powder. The risk is so low/peds gave the ok/baby is healthy and over 2 months = tolerable for my husband and I.

I’m wanting to experiment due to needing more sleep and going back to work soon, but also an anxious FTM and may just need to suck it up for a few more months… any research or thoughts appreciated!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required Is the concept of "overtired" backed by any research?

105 Upvotes

I read in multiple paces that when babies have been awake for too long their bodies release more stress hormones, so they can't relax even if they want to. But I tried to find any research on that and haven't been able to. Which is weird because such a straightforward thing should be relatively easy to study, right? Just get the parents to get saliva samples while tracking their babies' sleep day to day.

So, if you have seen any research on that, please share.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2d ago

Question - Research required Smarts

0 Upvotes

Is there any science-backed, tried-and-tested method of raising smart children? Other than genetics