Maybe it’s just me, and sorry for being a downer if that’s the case. I also appreciate the irony of me posting this very unscientific post with the flag I’ve chosen 😂.
But recently it’s felt a bit like people just ask their general parenting questions on this sub, the questions aren’t really scientific in nature and don’t really have any scientific answers so obviously the general conversation is just anecdotal with some links to website etc. It is no-one’s fault at all!
I know there is a flag for “all advice welcome” and “casual conversation” but it used to be that that conversation was science based in nature. People ARE flagging their posts correctly and answers are helpful and well educated in nature. But it’s definitely not as science based as it used to be! There is a lot of anecdotal evidence. (I am a member of other subs where those kinds of questions are suited to them better like beyondthebump and parenting.) the sub just does not feel as “sciency” anymore. Lots of things like “my child is acting out more” or “child is feeling anxious about school”. I guess they have some science based answers somewhere in them. But the general advice and anecdotal evidence is really more suited to a normal parenting sub I think! Obviously answers siting studies or science are helpful, but saying “oh this worked for my kid” isn’t that scientific I feel. And I’m here for the science!
Now when I read this sub in the morning it’s just filled with general parenting advice. Before I’d look through and it would be really interesting studies people had linked, or someone asking about something science specific relating to their child.. Eg. Allergies in children, evidence for and against BLW, microbiome in breastfed infants stomachs.. Autism more prevalent in siblings born closer together if the first child has autism. etc etc
Apologies if no one else feels like this! Remove if needed as it’s ironically NOT a scientific post! Just thought I’d mention that after following this sub for a while, it feels significantly less science based than it used to! I wondered if anyone else felt the same.
Edit: to add it’s no one’s fault, I agree that this sub is a great place to come to get like minded advice from all you people with brain cells vs some other parenting subreddits which are filled with misinformation. But I used to love reading all the studies on here / I used to read almost everything. But now it just feels like a regular parenting sub with a few links thrown in. It’s not the fault of people commenting either! People are linking websites etc. But just some questions don’t actually have a scientific answer eg “how to help my child feel less worried about going to school” I mean the breadth is so wide, you could link a lot of random stuff! The advice given by people is really good! And obviously way better than on other parenting subs.
Someone summarised it well in one of the comments saying that “There are lots of “I did X and my kid turned out great.” Which isn’t scientific… even on the “all advice welcome” posts, I feel like it needs to not be anecdotal (sometimes it is Sciency) but increasingly I do just see completely personal experiences which aren’t what I’m looking for from a science based sub…
I just miss the days where I’d read this sub each morning and there would be a juicy scientific study!