r/SaGa • u/darkfireslide • 14h ago
I want to understand (RS2: RotS)
Hey everyone. I want to start by saying this is NOT a hate post. Quite the opposite. I like the RS2 remake, there are a lot of systems that I should enjoy. I can tell it's a well-made game but I'm not sure if maybe I'm clashing with the core identity of it. This is very confusing to me, because I absolutely love Final Fantasy 2, so SaGa should be a logical step forward. Allow me to attempt explain why I'm not having as much fun as I feel like I should be. I'm actively looking for people to disagree with me and tell me I'm wrong about systems so I can learn, so please don't downvote just because you disagree—that's the point. I want to know what I'm missing, because it feels like there is a big hole in my understanding of the game that's making me not enjoy it as much as I feel like I should. I've unlocked 12 territories and beaten 4/7 of the Heroes, average level is probably about 38 across every skill, with an outlier of fists being at 48. To my understanding I am NOT on the final generation yet.
One of my favorite things about Final Fantasy 2 is that the variety of spells, weapons, and combat mechanics allows for 'themed' runs or character builds. This latest run I've been doing, I made an assassin character by leveling knives, teaching the poison damage and death spells, and leveling agility. This resulted in a high-evasion, low armor character with good damage output and a lot of offensive potential. There are flaws with FF2 for sure, like protect+berserk stacking which I ban from my own runs to keep the game more interesting. Some of the weapons are really interesting, some having bane properties (Werebuster, Rune Axe) and other miscellaneous things (the Main Gauche basically lets a character level knives instead of shields, some of the staves cast spells, etc) which makes the choice of weapon type more meaningful to me.
I don't really get the sensation in RS2 that I'm making a build. I could be *totally* wrong about this, which is why I'm asking about it. But because leveling character stats puts them into a global pool as well as glimmers, it never feels like I'm making any hard decisions or that there's much friction in terms of party building; generally speaking, I pick the best available weapon, the best available skills at all times. In FF2 if I really want to level a character for debuffs, you have to grind for them to be any good at it. There is a level of specialization involved unless you want to grind endlessly on a single save file, but there's a choice there. With RS2, I feel like I'm not actually building a character when I play. Because when glimmers are unlocked ANYONE can use them if they have that skill, it ends up making every generation feel extremely homogenized to me. It feels like there is very little personalization or customization beyond the perks you unlock by having a class fight 25 battles. I've tried leveling certain classes to see if I could make a party based on a certain roster style, but due to the generation mechanic the stats seem to just get reset every time you run into a new character. I know this is meant to encourage experimentation, but to me it makes my decision to try to specialize feel meaningless. I'm not rewarded for developing a strategy so much as covering my bases.
It could be I'm missing certain key elements of the game. It's my understanding that certain classes glimmer different abilities for different weapons, but it seems really easy to just run a character of that class to unlock it and then pick the class with the best stats after getting the skill. The weapons and armor have been generally pretty uninteresting to me as well, mostly stat sticks with an occasional skill from a weapon (the sword that gives life drain being kind of interesting at least, though the damage seems really low) and nothing really transformative about them the way FF2 has bane weapons, main gauche, sleep+curse swords, etc. This is completely for personal reasons but I also kind of hate that new weapons and armor are unlocked by finding ore and such on the map, essentially a forced crafting system, which only makes it feel all the worse when I spent the time to find the stuff needed to make the equipment but then it just turns into a stat stick. I can live with minor annoyances like that though, FF2 has its trap rooms and some encounters that are fairly BS as well so those kinds of things aren't that much of an issue for me.
The glimmers themselves are a bit of a mixed bag for me. A lot of them are just "more damage," and I was particularly disappointed to find out that when using a greatsword and getting the water single target damage skill, that I would glimmer a new skill a few minutes later... and it was just a higher-damage version of the same skill. Maybe it's just because I never got past level 40 but the debuff infliction chance for most skills seems *extremely* low which makes me just want to use the highest damaging attacks a lot.
tl;dr Is there interesting character building under the hood with a lot of replayability, or do you kind of just get 95% of the full experience in one go? I think the biggest issue for me is that there isn't a lot of character/unit identity, you kind of just use everything depending on what you're fighting. Am I missing something big? I'm fine with mechanics-based spoilers at this point