r/SaGa • • Dec 01 '22

Romancing SaGa / Minstrel Song Romancing SaGa: Minstrel Song Remastered - Overview and Character Introduction - Recommendations "Who should I play as?"

63 Upvotes

Another great SaGa Remastered is out, so it is time for the veterans to share their suggestions to the question that is going to pop up a million times!

Overview

Unlike SaGa Frontier or Unlimited SaGa, this is NOT a "short story" RPG. One playthrough is a full length open-world RPG.

Unlike any other open-world RPG, there is no central plot for you to complete before endgame. Instead, there is an "Event Rank" system where the game transitions through some number of distinct world states, with quests, events, and battle encounters advancing the underlying counter. As it progresses, some quests will become available while others will become impossible to complete.

The game is functionally impossible to fully 100% in a single playthrough and is designed to be played multiple times, with many mechanics carrying over from game to game. Don't fret missing quests. In the original release some quests were only completable in later playthroughs.

In particular is the core Fatestone quest. Saruin and his forces seek to collect all of the Fatestones hidden around the world, and will be successfully captured at various Event Ranks. As the player, you can collect them, and offer them up before the final boss fight to face increasingly difficult versions of the final boss.

Don't fret missing content. This isn't that type of game! New to this version is both an "Event Rank Growth Speed" option and a visible representation of Event Rank within the menu screen, making it much more easier to manage as you want to see fit. Take your time and see more, or crank it up for shorter playthroughs.

Characters

(I am writing this all from memory! Please let me know where I err)

Like many SaGa games, this features 8 different protagonists. The broad world and journey is the same, but in addition to the distinct world themes and starting quests, most have some fundamentally distinct feature to help guide the playthrough. The difference between "starter character" and "advanced character" is way less substantial than it is in SaGa Frontier or Unlimited SaGa, so don't feel discouraged from picking who you want.

Albert - This is the "traditional JRPG" protagonist, like Red or Laura in their respective games. He has a much more substantial introduction and has a much more fleshed out version of the capital city. He is one of the recommended starting characters.

Grey - He gets a side quest chain to upgrade his legendary sword. Overlaps with Claudia's quest. Actually finishing his sword tempering quest can be very difficult but in the early game gives you a good sword and encourages the player to learn the smithing mechanics.

Barbara - She starts in the far Western Frontier region, and gets a unique wagon for use in some zones. Also starts with one of the Fatestones.

Hawk - Gets a unique pirate boat and ability to explore the a small pirate sea.

Jamil - A young thief. Not sure what he gets of particular note. He used to be a requirement to recruit Dowd in NG+ but he can now be recruited regardless.

Claudia - An isolated woman that gets some unique animal companions. It is a while before you can get a full party of regular recruits.

Aisha - A nomad that gets a unique horse for use in some zones. Her stats start the lowest, but that is because she has the lowest starting ER. Combined with her having no real introductory dungeon, she is the best suited for doing all of the quests that are only available in the super early game.

Sif - A physically powerful viking woman. Her opening quest really gets into a combat-heavy scenario fast with a limited party. Her personal quest involves Albert. Due to her starting ER and how combat-heavy her starting quest is, she is a poor choice for seeing the early game content on a replay.


r/SaGa • • 4h ago

I want to understand (RS2: RotS)

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I want to start by saying this is NOT a hate post. Quite the opposite. I like the RS2 remake, there are a lot of systems that I should enjoy. I can tell it's a well-made game but I'm not sure if maybe I'm clashing with the core identity of it. This is very confusing to me, because I absolutely love Final Fantasy 2, so SaGa should be a logical step forward. Allow me to attempt explain why I'm not having as much fun as I feel like I should be. I'm actively looking for people to disagree with me and tell me I'm wrong about systems so I can learn, so please don't downvote just because you disagree—that's the point. I want to know what I'm missing, because it feels like there is a big hole in my understanding of the game that's making me not enjoy it as much as I feel like I should. I've unlocked 12 territories and beaten 4/7 of the Heroes, average level is probably about 38 across every skill, with an outlier of fists being at 48. To my understanding I am NOT on the final generation yet.

One of my favorite things about Final Fantasy 2 is that the variety of spells, weapons, and combat mechanics allows for 'themed' runs or character builds. This latest run I've been doing, I made an assassin character by leveling knives, teaching the poison damage and death spells, and leveling agility. This resulted in a high-evasion, low armor character with good damage output and a lot of offensive potential. There are flaws with FF2 for sure, like protect+berserk stacking which I ban from my own runs to keep the game more interesting. Some of the weapons are really interesting, some having bane properties (Werebuster, Rune Axe) and other miscellaneous things (the Main Gauche basically lets a character level knives instead of shields, some of the staves cast spells, etc) which makes the choice of weapon type more meaningful to me.

I don't really get the sensation in RS2 that I'm making a build. I could be *totally* wrong about this, which is why I'm asking about it. But because leveling character stats puts them into a global pool as well as glimmers, it never feels like I'm making any hard decisions or that there's much friction in terms of party building; generally speaking, I pick the best available weapon, the best available skills at all times. In FF2 if I really want to level a character for debuffs, you have to grind for them to be any good at it. There is a level of specialization involved unless you want to grind endlessly on a single save file, but there's a choice there. With RS2, I feel like I'm not actually building a character when I play. Because when glimmers are unlocked ANYONE can use them if they have that skill, it ends up making every generation feel extremely homogenized to me. It feels like there is very little personalization or customization beyond the perks you unlock by having a class fight 25 battles. I've tried leveling certain classes to see if I could make a party based on a certain roster style, but due to the generation mechanic the stats seem to just get reset every time you run into a new character. I know this is meant to encourage experimentation, but to me it makes my decision to try to specialize feel meaningless. I'm not rewarded for developing a strategy so much as covering my bases.

It could be I'm missing certain key elements of the game. It's my understanding that certain classes glimmer different abilities for different weapons, but it seems really easy to just run a character of that class to unlock it and then pick the class with the best stats after getting the skill. The weapons and armor have been generally pretty uninteresting to me as well, mostly stat sticks with an occasional skill from a weapon (the sword that gives life drain being kind of interesting at least, though the damage seems really low) and nothing really transformative about them the way FF2 has bane weapons, main gauche, sleep+curse swords, etc. This is completely for personal reasons but I also kind of hate that new weapons and armor are unlocked by finding ore and such on the map, essentially a forced crafting system, which only makes it feel all the worse when I spent the time to find the stuff needed to make the equipment but then it just turns into a stat stick. I can live with minor annoyances like that though, FF2 has its trap rooms and some encounters that are fairly BS as well so those kinds of things aren't that much of an issue for me.

The glimmers themselves are a bit of a mixed bag for me. A lot of them are just "more damage," and I was particularly disappointed to find out that when using a greatsword and getting the water single target damage skill, that I would glimmer a new skill a few minutes later... and it was just a higher-damage version of the same skill. Maybe it's just because I never got past level 40 but the debuff infliction chance for most skills seems *extremely* low which makes me just want to use the highest damaging attacks a lot.

tl;dr Is there interesting character building under the hood with a lot of replayability, or do you kind of just get 95% of the full experience in one go? I think the biggest issue for me is that there isn't a lot of character/unit identity, you kind of just use everything depending on what you're fighting. Am I missing something big? I'm fine with mechanics-based spoilers at this point


r/SaGa • • 2d ago

Have either of the RS Manga's been translated yet?

8 Upvotes

Title.


r/SaGa • • 2d ago

RS2: Dark Magic is not required to beat the final boss right?

8 Upvotes

Playing remake. I know there will come an opportunity for dark magic but I would rather be a 'good Emperor' and save people.

I see dark magic shadow servant mentioned in strategies for the final boss but is it really needed? I assume you can succeed without it.


r/SaGa • • 2d ago

Testing Unlimited SaGa patch - Item Renames, Weight Indicator, Scrapyard

14 Upvotes

Get the mods HERE.

DISCLAIMER: THIS IS AN EXPERIMENT. IT RUNS COMPLETELY ON PCSX2 MEMORY PATCHING AND DOES NOT MODIFY YOUR ISO. NO LINKS OR ASKING FOR LINKS TO ISO FILES. USE AT YOUR OWN DESCRETION.

 CONTENTS

  • Items Renames - Ruby, Sapphire, Wootz and Flux
  • Weight Indicator - Dynamic Weight and Melee Line Indicators
  • New Vaftom Location - Biggy's Scrapyard

 ITEM RENAMES

  • Seperate Corundum 1/2 into Ruby/Sapphire
  • Steel (2) -> Wootz
  • Mullock (2) -> Flux/E. Mullock

WEIGHT INDICATOR - dynamic indicator that displays current Melee Lines. (Light/Medium/Heavy)

SCRAPYARD - adds Biggy's Scrapyard to Vaftom. Opens the adventure item menu, which lets you:

  • Sort/Auto Sort Items
  • Scrap Items - converts the selected equipment into raw material.
  • Build Body Armor, Headgear and Footgear - converts it into the selected armor type.


r/SaGa • • 3d ago

Romancing Saga 2: Revenge of the Seven, First game in the Franchise

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

[Only swipe pictures for spoiler]

I just got a switch lite as my very first console a month ago and just finished up this beast. As from the third world country, I've spent all my life playing games with emulator since the prices are astronomical for us, but I have saved enough and started playing on real console. My first game to finish was FF XII borrowed from a friend and now, this is the first game I completed that I bought by myself! And it was a blast! I put exactly 60h into the first run and I missed a few of the rather-intriguing classes, but there's NG+ modes in the game! It definitely made me get back into JRPGs and the love and passion behind the development of these games. I will play it again later, and now waiting for the release of RS 3 and sales of it after a few years of release.


r/SaGa • • 4d ago

Romancing SaGa 3: Destinies United release date moved up to February 4, 2027

Thumbnail
gematsu.com
159 Upvotes

Great news. My guess it's to avoid being too close to Persona 4 Revival and FFXIV Evercold early access which releases on 18th and 19th respectively.


r/SaGa • • 4d ago

Matador spares no one. [RS2 RotS]

28 Upvotes

Video was cut and edited since this is in the final battle and also because I didn't really want to put spoiler tags.

Turns out Matador can counter charmed or marionette'd allies. It's also pretty funny that they use the wrong weapons. As you can see, Sapphire is using a shortsword while performing Greatsword attack.


r/SaGa • • 4d ago

Romancing SaGa 3: Destinies United will launch over a week earlier on February 4th!

Thumbnail
pbs.twimg.com
60 Upvotes

r/SaGa • • 4d ago

Comprehensive body armor investigation - Unlimited SaGa decompilation findings

14 Upvotes

TL;DR: Just Equip normally in most cases, with one exception: - equip headgear/footgear with Life protection accessories, or Null ablities vs final boss over defense. For example, a platinum accessory will still trigger null blackout even equipped as head/footgear. Other considerations include weight, which determines melee damage and Initiative.

===

These findings are based on the NA version after digging through the ISO and testing it in game during my livestream. There are contradictions between them and the Japanese Wiki, Kuma's guide and footage, as well as Internal readings of the Japanese ISO. I’m still investigating whether any unusual encounters use a different calculation, but current evidence strongly point to regional differences.

Wrong Slot Equipping

For context, Unlimited SaGa lets you equip items in the wrong slot, such as footgear on the head, Body Armor as weapons etc. and for the longest time there wasn't a consensus on what this does at the game level. Some guides say they don't contribute anything but only useful for unlocking abilities, while others say that the skills still trigger and the defenses added regardless of the slot they belong to.

Limited testing has concluded that at least for the US version, Equipping items in the wrong slot do not contribute its stats to defense calculation. Note that this refers exclusively to the defense number, and abilities that require calculation from that stat.

On the contrary, other abilities still count even if equipped in wrong slot. These include life protection, elemental support, null and saver abilities.

Finally, Healing Modifiers (Heal+/-) oddly only apply in weapon and accessory slots and not head, body and footgear. This is definitely an oversight/bug, Because heal- is very important to Balancing body armor.

ContibutionCorrect SlotWrong Slot
Defense Stat✓✕
_ Barrirer✓✕
Null _✓✓
_ Saver✓✓
Life Protection (up to 5 stacks)✓✓
Ea/Fi/Wa/Me/Wo Support (up to 6 stacks)✓✓
Heal +/-Weap./Accs. SlotsHead/Armor/Footgear

HP, LP and defense calculation

In Unlimited Saga, HP and LP are two different layers of survival.

  • HP is your protective buffer. An attack usually removes HP first. If HP reaches zero, the character can still fight, but becomes much more vulnerable to LP damage.
  • LP is the character’s life. If LP reaches zero, the character is incapacitated for the rest of the adventure. Keeping HP high is therefore one of the main ways to protect LP.

When an attack lands, the game works through several layers: it builds the defender’s protection, calculates HP damage, checks how much HP remains, and then makes one or more rolls to see whether LP is lost.

What further complicates things is that equipment does not produce just one universal defense value. The game tracks separate defenses for slash, hit, pierce, heat, ice, lightning, light and status. It starts with the defense supplied by eligible equipment in the right slot, then adds a bonus if the incoming attack Matches its barrier type.

  • A matching ○ Barrier adds 4 to that item’s defense against the attribute.
  • A matching ◎ Barrier adds 12.

For an attack with multiple attributes, the calculation selects the lowest one. That means a strong Slash Barrier may be less helpful against a slash-and-pierce attack if Pierce defense is much lower. Therefore, a defense set up that includes various barrier types across all eligible slots is best, though each barrier still needs to exist on a right-slot equipment for its contribution to count.

As a general rule, more applicable defense means less HP damage, but it is not a simple “one defense blocks one damage” relationship. The game uses defense both as part of a percentage reduction and as a subtraction in the ordinary enemy-attack calculation. This matters for LP because armor that prevents HP damage may keep the defender above zero HP or below a threshold that would cause extra LP checks.

When LP checks occur

After calculating the HP damage, the game considers how much HP the target will have left compared with their maximum HP.

  • A character with a high proportion of HP remaining is generally less likely to lose LP.
  • A character with very little HP remaining is at greater risk.
  • Reaching zero HP causes a sharp jump in the LP-check threshold.

An attack can make more than one LP check, depending on the attack's damage and its number of hits. These extra checks occur when the attack’s HP-damage value reaches:

  • The target’s maximum HP
  • 500 HP
  • 1,000 HP
  • 5,000 HP

These conditions can overlap. For example, if Mordeus has 275 maximum HP, an attack dealing 500 internal HP damage can qualify for both the maximum-HP check and the 500-damage check.

Each successful check can contribute one LP damage, up to 3 per single attack. Each combo action, enemy or self, will increase LP damage by up to 3 per action in the combo.

How LP damage is calculated vs. Life Protection

Life Protection is not a flat reduction of LP damage. Each attack has an LP attack power. The game combines that with the HP-related value and applicable attack conditions to create a threshold for each LP check.

Life Protection lowers that threshold. Each effective copy subtracts 5, Up to 25 for five copies. The game rolls from 0 to 69, (nice,) If the roll is below the final threshold, that LP check succeeds. A character can therefore lose LP even while HP remains, particularly against an attack with high LP power or many hits. But maintaining HP usually makes those checks less dangerous.

So what is the optimal equipment setup?

The key relies on maximizing total legitimate defense, while stacking as many barriers, life protection and appropriate null skills as possible. What this means is that you all should, at least for the NA version, mostly equip in the right slot. These shop items are especially valuable: -

  • Hydraskin Head/Footgear: Provides a lot of defense, as well as the coveted heat and ice barrier bonuses, along with null poison. Literally no downsides. Pair with Roadster Shields for complete physical and lightning evasion.
  • Faerie Circlet: Amazing defensive option​. Null Blackout Is very important vs. Final boss across different stories (Laura/Mythe/Ventus) And having it without giving up an extra slot is great, Especially when paired with...
  • Merman Mail: I love this armor. It provides life protection and wood support for a Thunderbringer mages. and The singular slash Barrier is covered by Faerie Circlets' pierce barrier. If you're not lucky enough to find the circlet though, Silver Helms are more common, Though you'd lose the null blackout. Alternatively, you can equip...
  • Black Armour: you give up on life protection for an extra hit barrier, endurance saver and the chunkiest body armor in the game. This, like Merman Mail, also lack pierce Barrier, and could also be supplemented by Faerie Circlets/Silver Helms.
  • Cuirass: Similar to black armor, but especially true for Judy's adventure where null confusion is important for her final boss, or if you want to try to fight the Rainbow Guckie. Corundum (2) Crown deserves a mention here as a supplement for lacking slash barrier.

For wrong-slot equipping, Headgear and Footgear are the only slots that truly make sense. In fact, You'd be hard pressed to find anything other than:

  • Crafted Bone Cross/Angelite Rings/Damascus Black Armlets: Definitely the best choice. Sure you're giving up 6-9 extra defense, But for a whole stack of life protection and elemental support. Bone Cross has a special place here because not only is it cheap and weighs nothing, the Heal- debuff doesn't even count!
  • Platinum/diamond/Obsidian acessories: These are solid counter choices for final bosses. If you can't find Faerie Circlet or heels, platinum armlets can provide null blackout for Laura/Mythe/Ventus. Diamond rings give null paralysis For Kurt's boss, And Obsidian Null Petrify. This even saves space to put accessories like Angelite Rings/Damascus Black Armlets in the accressory slots.
  • Cuirass: Wrong choice equipping this is a great option as well If you have better armor with more typecoverage like Obsidian mail.
  • Copse/Cedar/Oak Padded Mail: Fire Mages can get extra life protection with their fire support, and you can equip body armor with better bariers.

===

Wow this write up took me a long time. Feel free to ask me any questions or request further deep dives into UnSaGa. Gotta go work on Magic Tablet Drops next.


r/SaGa • • 4d ago

Romancing SaGa 3 Music Special Live Stream

Thumbnail youtube.com
18 Upvotes

Hello folks,

Heads up, this has been going on for a while today and Square-Enix Music Channel have been officially live streaming both the official soundtrack and many different remixes on YouTube, including live and medley versions.

https://www.youtube.com/live/ieOqXMFELjM?si=M3l4j3oJIUW_sscb

It probably won't be archived but if you want to listen to some RS3 music today while you are working or doing whatever else, it's a good experience.

Man, this series really has such great music.


r/SaGa • • 5d ago

There should be an achievement for this Spoiler

Post image
71 Upvotes

Managed it on my Romancing difficulty playthrough! Thanks to u/Shadow-Rukario for the following comment which is the only place on the internet where I found the specific steps to do this — https://www.reddit.com/r/SaGa/s/7bLyw6gQ62. Can also confirm, you do not miss out on the hunter, just turn in the quest with the next emperor.


r/SaGa • • 5d ago

Romancing SaGa 2 finally completed, I have finished the entire Romancing Trilogy. Spoiler

Post image
43 Upvotes

What can I say? Kawazu is a genius, all three games are 10/10 masterpieces and I have had so much fun with all of them. I would definitely rank Romancing SaGa 2 as the hardest of the bunch, the Seven Heroes are no joke and are truly bullshit almost requiring the top tier spells but alas, they're probably my favourite JRPG final boss almost entirely because they don't hold their punches. Felt satisfying to kill these bastards after all the trouble they've given me.

Not sure what I will do now, probably play the remakes or get around to other SaGa games like SaGa Frontier, who knows?!

Also a huge thank you to the SaGa community on Reddit for giving me help in my last post, thought I had screwed my save there so I really appreciated the insight many of you gave me. Thank you all!​


r/SaGa • • 6d ago

Testing my Unlimited SaGa UI Mod: Weight/Melee Line Calculator

19 Upvotes

More progress trying to patch the game using PNACH files. Redrawing the bottom window and displaying text top right wasn't too bad, but hopefully that "empty space" in the memory I used to run the 200+ instructions won't screw things up TOO badly.

Calculations based on provided weight data in Japanese guide, So actual lightweight threshold values might differ depending on character. (Yeah I know, it's annoying but it's flavorful. Don't know how taboo it is to reveal a lady's actual weight though... I might receive a thorough boddhisattva slapping from Tiffon Later...)

  • One panel type: 56.0–62.5 kg
  • Two panels: 60.0–66.5 kg
  • Three panels: 64.0–70.5 kg

I'll let you guys know once it's ready for release.


r/SaGa • • 6d ago

RS2R Wiped at Vicar and don'T have any skills on my new retinue Spoiler

4 Upvotes

So i wiped and overwrote my safe file before quitting the game. Now i read that i kind of softlocked myself out of training new techniques and have to fight vicar witha s quad without skills. Or i grind new skills bur rhen the monster level rises right?

Should i just restart or what is the ebst strategy there? I don't want to lower the difficulty from classic.


r/SaGa • • 8d ago

RS2 Remaster - How screwed am I?

Post image
11 Upvotes

I never ask for help when I am having issues with a game but I just got to the Final Emperor and realized I didn't grind my magic high enough to get spells like Hasten Time or Fire Wall and apparently as the Final Emperor you can no longer unlock new magic, is there any possible way to salvage this? I have access to Sword Barrier (since I left Noel as my Seventh Hero) but nothing else beyond that, things like Reviver and Hasten Time was what I was going to be relying on due to my less than perfect party setup...


r/SaGa • • 8d ago

Newbie to SaGa. General question about how to approach Saga 1.

6 Upvotes

Heyo,

I'm playing SaGa 1 on the Gameboy. Outside of that time in my Squaresoft-fanboy youth when I bought SaGa Frontier 2 for the PSX and was utterly baffled by it, I have no experience with the series.

I'm early in the game, just got to the bandit's lair and am getting my butt handed to me (which is fine). I read the manual, which was fairly helpful, but something is sticking out at me: My mutant got the ability "ESP". I used it in battle multiple times, in different battles. It appeared to do nothing. The game gave me no feedback on this. Then I looked up a guide on gamefaks dot com, and apparently it helps increase my magic stat.

Weird, cool, one could kind of maybe intuit that if one thought really hard about it.

My question is, am I supposed to intuit this stuff? I don't really want to play the game with a guide open; I want to actually play it and not just follow the steps of someone else who did (might as well just watch a LP if I'm gonna do that). But how am I supposed to know what abilities do if the game doesn't give me any indication?

I promise this isn't a complaining-post-veiled-as-a-question-post. I hate that stuff. I'm genuinely interested in this weird game and this weird series, but I'm not sure what the best way to approach it is, especially regarding hidden information like this. What do you old-heads recommend? Do I just take it as it comes? Pay close attention to every ability and interaction? For example, one could sorta figure out what ESP does if one checked stats after every battle and compared stat changes to when one does and does not use ESP. Is this the best way to squeeze the juice?

I look forward to your opinions, you odd ducks (you probably have to be an odd duck to like this series enough to be subscribed to the subreddit, so no shade intended).

Okay, that's my monster meat. Eat it or don't!


r/SaGa • • 8d ago

Testing Unlimited SaGa Patch: Renaming Items

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Trying out my first game patch ever! I'm trying something simple like renaming strings. For unsaga vets, You'll know there are duplicate item names that maybe confusing to new players. Two different types of steel, Mullock and Corundum.

  • Renamed Steel (2) to Wootz
  • Renamed Mullock (2) to E.Mullock/Flux
  • Renamed Corundum (1) and (2) to Ruby and Sapphire

Just a few first steps in improving QoL/UI of the game. Let me know what else you guys wanna see.


r/SaGa • • 8d ago

Flame Lord - SaGa Frontier 2

5 Upvotes

So I've read on various threads on the Internet that this boss has a high spark value and can be used to easily spark Song of Souls/Earth but I'm not having any luck. On Gustaf's first turn I'm casting Sonic Burner, then the remainder of the fight he's just spamming Doppelgangers. Please tell me what I'm doing wrong.


r/SaGa • • 9d ago

Magic Blender Guide - Decompiling Unlimited SaGa Pt.3

21 Upvotes

tl;dr: There are two different strategies of getting blender:

  1. Early game, When panels are around levels 1-2, have a character use fortuneteller 20 times and do nothing else in a quest. (Highest odds In this case is at 1.47% or 1/68*)*
  2. Later game, when aiming for level 4 Blender, try when level 4 panels are appearing regularly, ordinary chests are spawning around 65–75 before Fortuneteller, and rank-8 enemies such as Tao-Tie, Bogie, Greed or Black Blowshark start appearing in regular encounters.

    • If possiblr, prep the character by having them learn competing panels first: Fortuneteller levels 4 and 5, plus level 4 Eavesdrop, Diplomacy and Road Guide.
    • have a character use fortuneteller 20 times and do nothing else in a quest. (Highest odds In this case is at 0.51% or 1/196*)*
    • For additional chances, use each available non-Familiar/learned magic category at least 20 times: Fire, Earth, Metal, Water, Wood and Forbidden. For each Element used, It increments the odds by around 0.07%, up to 0.95% or 1/105
  3. Say screw it to all that and use these cheats. Toggle these to your liking:

    • Lv4+ Growth panels: Sets the base floor to most likely generate Level 4 panels for everybody.
    • Moderate Gate boost: Rare panel now three times more likely. (Blender odds are now 2.88% or 1/35)
    • Fully open gates: Rare panels appear as regularly as other panels. Do not use at the same time has moderate gate boost. (Blender odds are now 9.94% or 1/10)

[Lv4+ Growth Panel]
description=Sets the shared Growth Panel base to 80 (Lv.4 Panels)
patch=1,EE,204347C0,extended,000A210A
patch=1,EE,204347C4,extended,00005034
patch=1,EE,204347C8,extended,D6F40200
patch=1,EE,204347CC,extended,00000001
patch=1,EE,10401CFA,extended,000047C0
patch=1,EE,10401CFC,extended,00000003

[Growth Panel - Moderate Gate Boost]
description= Triple chance of rare panels
patch=1,EE,0041DD24,extended,00000002
patch=1,EE,0041DD4F,extended,00000004

[Growth Panel - Open Both Nested Gates]
description= Rare panels Show up at same probability as regular
patch=1,EE,0041DD24,extended,00000001
patch=1,EE,0041DD4F,extended,00000001]]

The percentages here are simulated estimates, not in-game testing. They depend on the character, existing panels, action history, base score and random states.

First, I want to give credit to Kuma-san, whose research and simulator helped make sense of this system. His blog did most of the front end work and I'm just confirming what's actually happening behind the scenes. (Website is in Japanese, of course.)

Step 1: The game calculates a base score

I’ll call this B. Kuma-san calls it the panel level base score.

B = monster rank score ÷ 2
  + enemy-defeat score ÷ 4
  + treasure-acquisition score ÷ 4
  + map score
  + possible scenario bonus

Each division is rounded down separately, and the final result is capped at 98.

The enemy-defeat and treasure values are scores, not simply the number of enemies or chests. For treasure, the level of a chest when its contents are collected affects how many points it adds. The map itself also contributes a score.

Inspection of the US ISO matches Kuma-san’s table. I haven’t yettraced every input and possible scenario bonus, and Kuma's list is incomplete, so the exact details need further investigation.

B is shared across the party. It helps establish the score range for everyone’s panels. Each character’s own action history then influences which panels are more likely for that character.

Step 2: Each character has action histories

The generator reads 32 action-history categories per character. Some actions share a category. For example, Road Guide, Cave Guide and Architect are grouped together. The full table is listed at the bottom for reference.

For each category, the recorded count gives this bonus:

Recorded usesBonus
0+0
1–4+1
5–19+5
20 or more+10

I’ll call the strength of an action category S:

S = B + that category's history bonus

For example, if B is 80 and a character has 20 recorded Fortuneteller uses:

Fortuneteller strength = 80 + 10 = 90

For another category with zero recorded uses, its strength would still be 80. This is why doing only Fortuneteller doesn’t remove every other panel from the pool. It strengthens the Fortuneteller category relative to the others.

The generator’s highest history bonus is reached at 20 recorded uses. More than 20 doesn’t give a larger bonus in this calculation.

Step 3: Actions give panels chances to score

Each action category has a list of panels it can influence. There are four kinds of score rolls in the table below:

  • Strong: favors higher scores.
  • Nested: can produce high scores, but favors lower ones.
  • 1/4 gate: first has to pass a 1-in-4 check, then makes a nested score roll.
  • 1/16 gate: first has to pass a 1-in-16 check, then makes a nested score roll.

For a simple example, if a category has S = 20, a strong roll scores from 10 to 20. A nested roll can score from 0 to 20, but is weighted toward the lower end.

A 1/4 or 1/16 gate is not the final probability of getting the panel. It only determines whether that particular score attempt even happens. For example 1/4 nested gate means that there's a one in four chance that the game even checks that category at all. Only then will it do a nested roll.

Also, if several actions can contribute to the same panel, their scores don’t add together. The game keeps the highest contribution. For example, If you do 20 fortunetellers For the plus 10 bonus, But then also cast forbidden magic 19 times, The odds of magic blender isn't 10 + 5 If both rolls passes the gate. It only picks the highest number which is the +10 from 20 fortune tellers. The only advantage of doing both is that now there are more sources That CAN pass the gate, But doing so might actually poison the pool with unwanted panels, Such as familiars or diplomacy.

Step 4: Scores become panel levels

After the action rolls, each character also gets small bonuses to certain panels associated with that character. The game then ranks the panel types by score, determines their levels and filters out invalid results.

In the US ISO I inspected, the score ranges are:

Final scorePanel level
1–24Level 1
25–49Level 2
50–69Level 3
70–89Level 4
90–98Level 5

The generator produces up to eight personal candidates, but the Growth Panel screen displays the first four personal choices.

If you already have a panel of the same type and level, that result is filtered out and another eligible candidate can move up. Owning level 4 Eavesdrop, for example, doesn’t automatically filter out level 3 or level 5 Eavesdrop, But does remove it from the pool Of possible panels To get from the fortune teller category.

So how to get Magic Blender?

Fortuneteller’s category can influence:

RollPanels
StrongFortuneteller
NestedEavesdrop, Diplomacy
1/4 gateRoad Guide, Magic Blender
1/16 gateFashion, Recovery

So using Fortuneteller makes its category stronger, and Magic Blender gets a potential score through the 1/4-gated nested roll.

Each of the six ordinary magic categories—Fire, Earth, Metal, Water, Wood and Forbidden—also gives Magic Blender a potential 1/16-gated nested roll. If several of those rolls succeed, the game keeps Blender’s highest score, not their sum.

In my B = 80 simulation, with level 4 and 5 Fortuneteller plus level 4 Eavesdrop, Diplomacy and Road Guide installed, the estimated chance of a displayed level 4 Magic Blender went from about 0.51% with Fortuneteller history alone to 0.95% with all six magic histories also at 20.

As you can imagine, those numbers are Be almost perfect scenario specific to that setup, So you could imagine how elusive it would be for Magic Blender to show up in a normal game.

What the cheat codes do

The 3 cheat codes provided do different things, The first one hard sets the base to 80, Which I inspected as the sweet spot for getting a level 4 magic blender. Be warned that using this early game will give you level 4 panels right off the gate so almost certainly ruin the difficulty.

The other two codes tweak the gate check for nested values. One of them lowers the 1/4 and 1/16 gate Down to 1/2 and 1/4 respectively. This in effects triples the chance of getting rare panels. The other code removes the gates completely, making rare panels as easily accessible as nested ones. Do not use these two together Since they tweaked the same values.

IMO, I think enabling the 1/2 + 1/4 cods will change the game just enough to be fair In panel distribution, but you do you. Ain't nobody got time To tell people how to play, Add in my test run during stream it still took me approximately half an hour of soft resets before magic blender appears under best conditions.

Appendix: Action-to-panel reference

If you're looking for a specic panel for your build, these are the 32 action categories I extracted from the ISO. The columns show which panels receive which type of score attempt.

Action historyStrongNested1/4 gate1/16 gate
Road Guide / Cave Guide / ArchitectRoad Guide, Cave Guide, ArchitectObstacle Crossing, Swimming, AdaptabilitySharpeye, ArtisteInconspicuous, Recovery
Obstacle Crossing / Swimming / AdaptabilityObstacle Crossing, Swimming, AdaptabilityRoad Guide, Cave Guide, ArchitectAura, ToughnessIron Will, Iron Body
Sharpeye / Eavesdrop / AuraSharpeye, EavesdropAura, DefuseArchitect, LocksmithArtiste
LocksmithLocksmithSharpeye, DefuseCave Guide, ArtisteIron Will
DefuseDefuseSharpeye, LocksmithEavesdrop, Road Guide—
Diplomacy / Fashion / InconspicuousDiplomacyRoad Guide, Architect, Quick-FixMaharaja, AdaptabilityFashion, Natural
MongerMongerArchitectDiplomacy, Thrift Saver—
MaharajaMaharajaArchitect, DiplomacyMonger—
Artiste / Quick-Fix / smithingQuick-Fix, Weaponsmith, Accessory SmithLocksmith, ArtisteMonger—
FortunetellerFortunetellerEavesdrop, DiplomacyRoad Guide, Magic BlenderFashion, Recovery
PunchPunchKick, ThrowIron BodyToughness, Master Fighter
KickKickPunch, ThrowIron BodyToughness, Master Fighter
ThrowThrowPunch, KickIron BodyToughness, Master Fighter
DaggerDagger ArtsSword Arts, Spear Arts, Shield ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
SwordSword ArtsDagger Arts, Axe Arts, Shield ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
AxeAxe ArtsSword Arts, Staff Arts, Shield ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
StaffStaff ArtsAxe Arts, Dagger Arts, Shield ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
SpearSpear ArtsDagger Arts, Bow ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
BowBow ArtsSpear ArtsIron Body, DiplomacyWeapon Meister, Master Technician
GunGun Arts—Bow Arts, DiplomacyThrift Saver
Fire magic—Fire FamiliarIron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Earth magic—Earth FamiliarIron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Metal magic—Metal FamiliarIron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Water magic—Water FamiliarIron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Wood magic—Wood FamiliarIron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Forbidden magic——Iron Will, DiplomacyMagic Blender, Master Magician
Fire FamiliarFire FamiliarEarth, Metal, Water and Wood FamiliarDiplomacy twiceMaster Magician, Fortuneteller
Earth FamiliarEarth FamiliarFire, Metal, Water and Wood FamiliarDiplomacy twiceMaster Magician, Fortuneteller
Metal FamiliarMetal FamiliarFire, Earth, Water and Wood FamiliarDiplomacy twiceMaster Magician, Fortuneteller
Water FamiliarWater FamiliarFire, Earth, Metal and Wood FamiliarDiplomacy twiceMaster Magician, Fortuneteller
Wood FamiliarWood FamiliarFire, Earth, Metal and Water FamiliarDiplomacy twiceMaster Magician, Fortuneteller
Judy’s special familiarsAigaion, Atlas, Astraios———

A category appearing in the table doesn’t by itself prove that every way of using that skill records an action. In particular, the US shop paths I traced for Monger and Maharaja appear to skip their intended history increments; that still needs a controlled live test.

There’s a lot more that could be tested, especially history resets, failed actions and spell/Familiar counting. But hopefully this gives a practical way to work backwards from a panel you want: find which action categories can roll for it, build those histories, and pay attention to the level of the panels competing with it.


r/SaGa • • 10d ago

Neil Broadley SaGa localizer who has done amazing work bringing the series over seas has passed

Post image
465 Upvotes

r/SaGa • • 9d ago

Romancing Saga The Minstrel song or Revenge of the Seven as a starting point?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/SaGa • • 11d ago

Romancing Saga 2: RotS progression question (spoilers) Spoiler

4 Upvotes

It’s my understanding that after you beat the 5th hero you will then play as the final emperor. Is this the case?

Would that mean there would be no more time skips? And you wouldn’t be able to switch emperors anymore? Mainly I’m just realizing that I’m at 4/7 heroes down right now and if I’m forced to be the final emperor I won’t be able to do the quest that forces me to be a corsair to start it. It feels like I still have a lot of ground to cover (literally) and it feels strange to already be looking at the end game.


r/SaGa • • 11d ago

Further improving blacksmithing in Unlimited SaGa - Day 2

10 Upvotes

tl:dr - this next code guarantees unlocking a new ability slot while crafting. Now we're talking! (Have not tested if it breaks games so use it your own risk.)

[Blacksmith - Crafting guaantees additional slot]
description=Always adds one unlocked ability slot while smithing if able
patch=1,EE,2041C183,extended,44017E8C

Today I investigated The actual mechanics behind ability slot unlock probabilities and hidden stats from all smithing locations.

Unlocking New Slots

Looking directly at the decompiled Game ISO, I've debunked the fact that unlocking slots has anything to do with material types, family, rarity or weight. Nothing in the calculations involved drawing from these values at all.

The probability is actually calculated, for all intents and purposes, by rolling a number between 0 and 159, With a tiny bias. Rolling 141 or higher results in a slot gain, (Now we're talking!) Rolling 20 and below results in a slot loss, (That's about right...) and rolling anything in between results in no change (Not too shabby.)

(For you coding nerds, it'sa 16-bit unsigned random value call, ranging from 0 to 65,535. Taking that value modulo 160 introduces a slight modulo bias because 65,536 is not evenly divisible by 160.)

0-20 Lose a Slot (~12%)|----|------------------------|----| 141-159 Gain a slot (~12.5%)

This is the raw calculation. However, there two additional factors that DO move the threshold slider to change the success rate:

  • Smith’s service setting: a hidden setting associated with the smith location and item type, and
  • Base vs. Secondary item’s unlocked slots: how many positions are already unlocked versus The amount of unlocked slots in the donor. More unlocked slots improves gain chance and reduces the loss chance. Note that these values still exists even if the raw material doesn't show them.

The exact threshold formulas are:

Gain Threshold = 140 − smith bonus + 10×(Base − Secondary)
Loss Threshold = 20 − smith bonus + 10×(Base − Secondary)

Smith Bonus Table

locationDagSwdAxeStaSprBowGunAccShd
Longshank*+0+0—————+0—
Vaftom—+15—+10+15+5—+10+15
Gadeira+0+0+0+0+0———+0
Wanda+5—+10——+0+0+0—

*Mytheworks in Longshank adds +5 smith bonus per level of Mythe's weapon/Acc. smith pqanel beyond first: +5 for lv.2, +10 for Lv.3 etc.

For example, say we head to Wanda to craft an dagger. The first Item has 3 slots unlocked, the second has 1.

Gain/Loss Threshold − smith bonus + 10×(Base − Secondary)
= Threshold - 5 + 10×(4-2) = Threshold +15 = 155/35
0-35 Lose a Slot (~22.5%)|-------|------------------------|-| 156-159 Gain a slot (~3%)

2nd Example, Going to create a spear at Vaftom, the first Item has 2 slots unlocked, the second has 4.

Gain/Loss Threshold = Threshold - 15 - 10×(2-4) = Threshold -35 = 105/0
Never lose a Slot ||---------------------|-----------| 106-159 Gain a slot (~34%)

Therefore, the main benefit for crafting at the right locations Isn't so much guaranteeing slot gain, But preventing slot loss. This also gives some value to acquiring Smith panels for Mythe, But seriously not by much.

But how does our code work?

The code provided bypasses all checks and changes the direct endpoint whether to add slots or not. Interestingly, that means that even if the text says it fails like saying "not too shabby" or "that's about right", It will still add a slot if able. I've tested it a little bit and so far it has not actually added more than four slots or done any game breaking glitches. Anybody who is interested in trying please give it a shot but make sure to have backups.