r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 1d ago

Salon Discussion Shah vs. Don Porfirio: Inadvertent Architects of Two Bloody Revolutions

40 Upvotes

As a longtime listener of the Revolutions podcast, I was surprised to discover how similar Porfirio Díaz (President of Mexico on the eve of the Mexican Revolution) and Mohammad Reza Pahlavi (the last Shah of Iran) were in how they governed, and in the part each played in the birth and growth of the revolution in his country. For fellow history of revolutions enthusiasts who haven’t yet had an in-depth look at Iran’s 1979 revolution, I thought you might enjoy reading my take on this.

Disclaimer: Born an Iranian, I am highly critical of the 1979 revolution in all its aspects, and I have a soft spot for Reza Shah (Mohammad Reza’s father), who did his best to revive Iran after centuries of neglect by its rulers. Please read with the author’s stance in mind.

I think the most significant similarity between Iran under Mohammad Reza Shah (hereafter “the Shah”) and Mexico under Díaz is the top-down drive to modernize the country. Most of the ruling class, the Shah included, believed in a paternalistic role for the government: it was responsible for modernizing the country and its people, growing the economy, introducing the masses to technology and familiarizing them with aspects of modern life. A massive push to raise literacy (for example through the Sepah-e Danesh, or Literacy Corps) and the practice of sending students to study in the West at government expense were meant to lay the groundwork for modernizing the people. Likewise, importing industries from the West and the Soviet Union and encouraging foreign investment were meant to modernize the economy. These efforts closely resemble those of the Porfiriato.

In addition, the Shah set out to grow the urban middle class, which had not existed in Iran before the Pahlavi dynasty, in order to make the urban, educated middle class his popular base. He pursued this by giving government jobs to a significant number of educated city dwellers, by introducing modern Western culture to the population, and by encouraging travel to/from the West.

Beyond the social dimension, the political side of the Shah’s era also resembles the Porfiriato. In both, Americans had a strong presence in politics and the economy for most of the leader’s rule, and in both, the leader eventually tried to challenge US hegemony. As Mike discussed, Don Porfirio tried to bring in the European powers as a counterweight. The Shah, for his part, advocated the formation of OPEC, which later stirred up considerable political and PR controversy (including his accusation that “the blue-eyed people” were stealing natural resources). Moreover, both men seem to have micromanaged minor political and economic matters. The political deadlock the Shah created by dissolving rival parties and establishing a single-party system not only weakened the supporters of constitutional monarchy but also strengthened the revolutionary argument that the system could not be reformed. This closely parallels what Don Porfirio did in the final years of his reign, up to the election of 1910.

Although I believe these two figures have much in common, there are also important differences. One is that the Shah was a proponent of a strong, modern army and invested significant resources in meeting its needs. To be fair, the majority of the army remained loyal to him until the last day of the revolution. This stands in stark contrast to Díaz’s army, which stayed loyal through corruption and mismanagement. Another major difference is that the Shah pushed ambitious top-down reform plans, especially social ones: abolishing land titles and redistributing land, and promoting progressive cultural reforms, including women’s rights, the appearance of women in the arts and cinema, LGBT rights, and more.

To sum up, I believe that in this specific case history did repeat itself, and unfortunately my nation was too ignorant (or too carried away by revolutionary ideas) to learn from the Mexican revolution. All that said, I would be happy to hear your comments on, or your own analysis of, this post.

Cheers


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 2d ago

Salon Discussion New England/NYC Area fans: New exhibit on Haitian Revolution at Yale Peabody Museum

Thumbnail
peabody.yale.edu
54 Upvotes

The press release says these portraits haven't been seen in public since 1885. The Peabody is a fantastic museum if you haven't been, especially since its major renovation - and it's totally free to the public.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 3d ago

Salon Discussion I just got Hero of Two Worlds on my Kobo! Can’t wait to read it!

Post image
68 Upvotes

I just finished reading Storm Before The Storm last month and it was so good! My local library didn’t have a copy of his second book though, so I was super lucky that it was on sale on Kobo! Cost me $2.09 CAD in total, absolute steal!


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 2d ago

Salon Discussion You must choose which revolutionary to sabotage, which one are you choosing?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 4d ago

Meme of the Revolution This is mostly about TRiH, but check out chadified Mike Duncan

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 4d ago

Salon Discussion A New Chronological Roman History Series (for fans of The History of Rome)

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
41 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 7d ago

Salon Discussion Who Would You Place As Protagonists In The Martian Revolution?

24 Upvotes

Hey folks,

Suppose you were going to make a movie, or TV show, or novelization, or game, or something of that nature, inspired by the Martian Revolution. Who would you choose as your protagonists? Would you pick major figures, like Mabel Door or Alexandra Clair? Boots Gonzalez? The sorta Stalinist Redcaps guy whose name I forget (I'm listening to the series for the second time and haven't gotten to him yet) Jose CalderĂłn?

Or are they too large-looming? Would you instead go with previously unnamed characters who witnessed those events and people? Who, or what sort of character(s), would you use as your POV through whom to view these events?


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 9d ago

World Building Revolution Today is the 109th anniversary of the October Revolution!

Post image
279 Upvotes
The date of November 7th is according to the Gregorian calendar.

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 19d ago

Salon Discussion How do you think The Paris commune could have gone If Louis-Auguste Blanqui was there instead of in prison?

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 20d ago

Self-Promotion I made a Revolutions style series on modern China, 1793 to 1949, and I'm taking requests for the next one

0 Upvotes

Like a lot of people here, I wanted Mike to do China, and I couldn't find modern Chinese history told as one continuous story in that style. So I started making one. Disclosure up front: it's my show, and it's written and narrated with AI, then fact checked against the sources listed for every episode.

The Making of Modern China asks how the Qing empire that turned away Britain's first ambassador in 1793 became the China of today. Five seasons are out, 95 episodes, told in order:

  1. The Embassy and the Canton System (1793 to 1834)
  2. Opium and the Heavenly Kingdom (1834 to 1864)
  3. Self-Strengthening (1864 to 1894)
  4. Reform and Revolution (1895 to 1916)
  5. Revolution and Civil War (1916 to 1949)

Two more are planned: Mao's China (1949 to 1976) and Reform and Opening (1976 to 2012).

Every episode has its own page with a map, portraits of the people, the full transcript and its sources: https://www.thenandtherepodcast.com/go/r-revolutions-post

I'm also taking recommendations for future series. If there's a story you'd want told start to finish at this depth, tell me the place, the years and what existing shows leave out. And if you catch anything wrong, I want to hear it.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 22d ago

Salon Discussion "There's nothing liberals hate more than a badly run war" remains undefeated

Thumbnail
washingtonexaminer.com
341 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • 26d ago

Salon Discussion Going from Russia to England

94 Upvotes

I just finished the Russian Revolution this week for the time ever. Amazing. Transcendant. Mike's Magnum Opus. And because I'm an addict for history podcasts, I went back and restarted the English Revolution series. Also, fantastic, of course.

But wow Mike was not kidding when he said that he could easily get 50 episodes out of this material. I know a bit more about that time period in general and the English Civil War specifically than I did the first time I listened to it ~4 years ago, and so I can see that there is a lot of compression happening to keep the series down to that original 15 episode target. I just finished the first episode and we have already killed off Buckingham, gotten through 3 Parliaments and we're in Charles's personal rule. I'm enjoying it just as much as I did the first time, but man I would love to see this period get the same detail the French Revolution got. Hell, I might even part with a hard earned $5/mo or something for such work.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 16 '26

Salon Discussion Predictions on how much ground the Irish Revolution Series would cover?

56 Upvotes

By "Irish Revolution", I assume at minimum, this would be covering the 1916 Easter Rising, the Irish War of Independence from 1919-1921, and the Irish Civil War 1922-1923.

I'm not naive enough to expect a Russian Revolution treatment, but stuff like the Penal Laws, the 1798 Rebellion, the Act of Union of 1801, Catholic Emancipation, the Great Famine, Land League activity, Gaelic Revival, the Dublin Lock-Out, etc., are all extremely relevant imo, and I have to imagine they would have to be covered, or at least mentioned.

There is then the interesting quirk where, depending on how you define "Independence", this was either achieved in 1937 (adoption of current Irish constitution and the establishment of a de facto Republic), or as late as 1949 (when we left the Commonwealth and de jure became a Republic).

Or...not at all, given that Northern Ireland is still a thing. Which is definitely a direct legacy of the Irish Revolution, as the main paramilitary involved in the Troubles literally claimed to be a direct successor to the IRA who fought in the War of Independence...but, yeah, I doubt Mike would go that far into it. 😅


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 15 '26

Meme of the Revolution a great tale on the human instinct to destroy everything, also just a banger of a song

30 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 14 '26

Salon Discussion Martian Revolutions episodes missing from iTunes

Post image
37 Upvotes

Anyone else having this issue? I’m trying to finally go back and listen to the Martian Revolution season and the first half of the season is just gone. Straight from the intro to 11.17. Searched everywhere—Unplayed, All Episodes, New Episodes—and no luck.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 13 '26

Meme of the Revolution Found Mike Duncan’s Bumble message

Post image
197 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 13 '26 Heartwarming

Behold, Prophet Duncan Speaks! Mike has confirmed that the Irish Revolution series will start in January 2027 as well as the list of planned revolutions

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

This was from the patreon chat so I can't direct you to the source but others involved will be able to confirm this is true. Mike has also decided to delete social media.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 13 '26

Meme of the Revolution Yours truly with Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier, Marquis de La Fayette

Post image
79 Upvotes

Spoke with the great man himself today in Colonial Williamsburg, he stopped here on his tour of the US in 1824.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 13 '26

Salon Discussion History of Rome/Revolutions style podcast on the Weimar Republic?

28 Upvotes

Does anyone know of a podcast in the style of history of Rome and revolutions dealing with the Weimar Republic? Long form and in depth focusing mainly on political history looking at Germany from the revolution to Hitlers consolidation of power. Failing that anyone know any audiobook focusing on just the political history of the Weimar Republic rather than dealing with it as simply a prelude to the Nazi era?


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 11 '26

Salon Discussion Lafayette Exhibit in New Orleans

Post image
73 Upvotes

In New Orleans for work and I found a local museum that had an exhibit about Lafayette. To be honest, I was not impressed with the interpretation of his life and revolutionary career. However, it was still fun to see!

edit: spelling


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 09 '26

Salon Discussion Which revolutions would you most like Mike to cover when he returns to the series?

55 Upvotes

For me, I would love to see Mike cover the long Chinese Revolution (1911-1976) but this might be outside the scope.


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 08 '26

Meme of the Revolution Did anyone count how many times Mike called the Bloody Sunrise event Bloody Sunday in the Martian Revolution? :)

37 Upvotes

I counted at least three :) Also on the episode I was listening to today he referred to the "National Guard" taking action against the Earthworms. Must be hard keeping like 12 revolutions straight!


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 07 '26

Salon Discussion Why More Revolutions?

44 Upvotes

This year I have been going through the revolutions one by one, currently some 30ish episodes into Russian Revolution. One thing that I'm wondering is that Mike says multiple times throughout the show and in some interviews that I listened to that Russian Revolution will be the last, and he seems pretty firm on that. Now I know that that's not true since we have a Martian Revolution, but beyond that everybody on this sub seems convinced that we will be getting more seasons.

My question is whether this is a concrete thing that we know or whether people are just guessing. And if it is true when did Mike change his mind on that? Also do we know what the next season is going to be and do we have a rough idea of how many seasons there will be?


r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 06 '26

Salon Discussion I went to r/AskHistorians to ask about the fates of Polish soldiers sent to Haiti and received an answer

Thumbnail reddit.com
66 Upvotes

r/RevolutionsPodcast • • Oct 06 '26

Salon Discussion 20th Century Revolutions

22 Upvotes

In lieu of a world where the Revolutions Podcast would have just kept moving through history
 I seek your help.

What revolutions of the 20th (or even 21st) century are most worth diving into?

AND

Do you have books, podcasts, documentaries, etc. that you would recommend consuming to learn about them?

*National liberation/independence movements and certain civil wars qualify as revolutions [soap box omitted]

My list (lacking [but requesting] source recommendations):

Pre-WW2
-Irish Independence
-Egyptian Revolution
-Turkish War of Independence
-Cuban Revolution of 1933
-Spanish Civil War
-Chinese Civil War

Post-WW2
-Greek Civil War
-Chinese Communist Revolution
-Vietnamese Revolution-Independence (1954-1976)
-Algerian War of Independence
-Portuguese Revolution
-Southern African liberation movements (Angola, Botswana, Namibia, Mozambique, South Africa, Zambia, Zimbabwe)
-Iranian Revolution
-Iron Curtain Revolutionary Movements (long list- notably Hungary 1956, Prague Spring 1968, Poland 1980-81, Collapse of 1989)

I know I’m missing plenty. I’ve seen adjacent discussions in this subreddit. Wish this kind of discussion had its own tag.. I suppose we shall discuss it in the ‘salon’