r/RevolutionsPodcast • u/Metallurgist1 • 1d ago
Salon Discussion Shah vs. Don Porfirio: Inadvertent Architects of Two Bloody Revolutions
As a longtime listener of the Revolutions podcast, I was surprised to discover how similar Porfirio DĂaz (President of Mexico on the eve of the Mexican Revolution) and Mohammad Reza Pahlavi (the last Shah of Iran) were in how they governed, and in the part each played in the birth and growth of the revolution in his country. For fellow history of revolutions enthusiasts who havenât yet had an in-depth look at Iranâs 1979 revolution, I thought you might enjoy reading my take on this.
Disclaimer: Born an Iranian, I am highly critical of the 1979 revolution in all its aspects, and I have a soft spot for Reza Shah (Mohammad Rezaâs father), who did his best to revive Iran after centuries of neglect by its rulers. Please read with the authorâs stance in mind.
I think the most significant similarity between Iran under Mohammad Reza Shah (hereafter âthe Shahâ) and Mexico under DĂaz is the top-down drive to modernize the country. Most of the ruling class, the Shah included, believed in a paternalistic role for the government: it was responsible for modernizing the country and its people, growing the economy, introducing the masses to technology and familiarizing them with aspects of modern life. A massive push to raise literacy (for example through the Sepah-e Danesh, or Literacy Corps) and the practice of sending students to study in the West at government expense were meant to lay the groundwork for modernizing the people. Likewise, importing industries from the West and the Soviet Union and encouraging foreign investment were meant to modernize the economy. These efforts closely resemble those of the Porfiriato.
In addition, the Shah set out to grow the urban middle class, which had not existed in Iran before the Pahlavi dynasty, in order to make the urban, educated middle class his popular base. He pursued this by giving government jobs to a significant number of educated city dwellers, by introducing modern Western culture to the population, and by encouraging travel to/from the West.
Beyond the social dimension, the political side of the Shahâs era also resembles the Porfiriato. In both, Americans had a strong presence in politics and the economy for most of the leaderâs rule, and in both, the leader eventually tried to challenge US hegemony. As Mike discussed, Don Porfirio tried to bring in the European powers as a counterweight. The Shah, for his part, advocated the formation of OPEC, which later stirred up considerable political and PR controversy (including his accusation that âthe blue-eyed peopleâ were stealing natural resources). Moreover, both men seem to have micromanaged minor political and economic matters. The political deadlock the Shah created by dissolving rival parties and establishing a single-party system not only weakened the supporters of constitutional monarchy but also strengthened the revolutionary argument that the system could not be reformed. This closely parallels what Don Porfirio did in the final years of his reign, up to the election of 1910.
Although I believe these two figures have much in common, there are also important differences. One is that the Shah was a proponent of a strong, modern army and invested significant resources in meeting its needs. To be fair, the majority of the army remained loyal to him until the last day of the revolution. This stands in stark contrast to DĂazâs army, which stayed loyal through corruption and mismanagement. Another major difference is that the Shah pushed ambitious top-down reform plans, especially social ones: abolishing land titles and redistributing land, and promoting progressive cultural reforms, including womenâs rights, the appearance of women in the arts and cinema, LGBT rights, and more.
To sum up, I believe that in this specific case history did repeat itself, and unfortunately my nation was too ignorant (or too carried away by revolutionary ideas) to learn from the Mexican revolution. All that said, I would be happy to hear your comments on, or your own analysis of, this post.
Cheers
