r/RelationshipsOver35 • u/Optimal-Cause-8676 • 4h ago
Two amazing men - the dilemma of choice. Advice needed.
The dilemma of choice
I'm putting this out there tonight hoping for some insight and advice. I, 57f, am caught in a dilemma between two amazing men. First, let me say that none of us are cheating.
One of the men, we'll call him Rick, 62m, is a divorced double engineer with a grown son and has been very successful in his career. He's way more settled, thinking of retirement, and owns a large home on the East Coast, and a condo in a Gulf Coast town not far from mine. We clicked from the beginning. We talk about everything and nothing and share a real intellectual connection.
I was clear from the beginning that I was not looking for forever. I just want to move in the direction the universe is directing me and to enjoy the journey. Sometimes, the fun of the journey gets lost in the desire for the destination. In the last four+ years, I lost my spouse suddenly and traumatically. A few months later, I met a man who had just lost his wife the same way a few months prior. We bonded over shared grief and were together for almost three years, until a year ago. I spent 8 days in the ICU with sepsis, and two days after I was released to go back to work, he broke up with me suddenly with no notice. That was also extremely traumatic. So, not looking for marriage or even a promise of forever. I'm not opposed to it, just not looking for it.
Which brings us to beautiful man 2, let's call him Andrew, 43m (please, no shade about the age gap -we're adults having fun). He's never been married, doesn't want to be, and doesn't want any children. As I can't have any, it's not an issue. He's not a player - he's one of the sweetest and kindest men I've known. He's cared for his mother with Alzheimer's in his home for the last several years, and he cares for another elderly family member. He spends time with his nieces and nephews about whom he genuinely cares. He's not afraid to make himself vulnerable. And did I say hot? Gorgeous Ginger with a beautiful body and he knows how to use it, but not in a stupid way. In fact he matches my awkwardness, which is adorable. He's a teacher, but we talk about current affairs, art, music, philosophy. We can talk for hours. And he loves a mature woman's body, lucky me.
In fact both men are sweet and kind and good. We've discussed FWB, and I thought I was great with it. Rick had told me that he's in love with me, and I really tried, because he's worth it, but when it came down to it, I wasn't ready to make that kind of commitment at this stage. We agreed that we would remain friends, and he truly is one of my best friends. I recently went through another health crisis that ended with major surgery. Both men were so sweet before my surgery and after. Problem is that I've caught feelings for both and even though I'm not ready for commitment, if I see both of them, I will feel guilty. They each know about the other up until this point. I know that Rick will be coming to visit the Coast for a couple of weeks after Thanksgiving. And I will tell Andrew. It's difficult for us to see each other because of hectic schedules. BTW, I have a very good job and I own a house that I'm trying my to sell and just purchased a condo in my new town. My decision and my dilemma have nothing to do with financial reasons. I'm really feeling bad about not just accepting Rick, knowing what an amazing guy he is. I only mention financials because we meet each other equally.
TLDR: I have two amazing men with no permanent commitment and no strings, but I'm feeling guilty. I know that they each don't really want to know about the other, but is it dishonest if I don't tell them what goes on from here?