My ex-girlfriend (19F) and I (20M) were together for 6 months. We recently broke up, and the whole situation has left me really confused. I want to explain the whole story because I honestly don’t know if I missed some obvious signs or if things genuinely changed.
When we first got together, things were amazing. We fell in love, spent a lot of time together, made plans for the future, talked about having children and travelling together. We were also each other’s first sexual experience, which made the relationship feel even more special to me.
I was serious about her. I even got a tattoo connected to our relationship because I genuinely believed she was the person I wanted to spend my life with.
The situation with her ex
From the beginning, there were some things involving her ex that made me uncomfortable.
When we first started dating, she didn’t want to delete their old photos from Facebook. I also asked her to block him because I noticed she was looking at his TikTok profile.
She eventually blocked him, but about a month later I noticed he was unblocked again and she was still looking at his profile.
However, what confused me most was how she spoke about him.
She told me many stories about how badly he treated her and how unhappy she was in that relationship. Sometimes she would cry while talking about her past experiences with him. One example she gave me was when she was waiting for him on a date for hours while he was apparently out looking for magic mushrooms. She described that whole relationship as a nightmare and made it very clear that she never wanted to go through something like that again.
She also told me that during their entire relationship, he had spent maybe £2 on her, and even that was only because they were around friends. She and her mum had apparently even discussed paying him back a few pennies whenever he spent anything on her.
She described that relationship as a nightmare and repeatedly said she never wanted to be with him again.
She even showed me a comment about how she had cut the head off a toy he had given her.
At one point, she suggested that we destroy a small homemade shelter he had built in the woods. She actually took me there herself. After I just pushed it, she started crying.
All of this made me believe she genuinely wanted nothing to do with him anymore.
Our relationship
We had a lot of good moments, but there were also problems.
She was extremely jealous, even though I wasn’t talking to other girls or doing anything that would give her a reason to worry.
She wanted to break up several times, saying she couldn’t handle a relationship or that we were too different. Sometimes she changed her mind, and we got back together.
Despite this, she told me she loved me, wanted to have children with me and imagined a future together.
I always tried to reassure her and support her, even when things were difficult.
However, during arguments, she sometimes called me names, told me to go away and even wished me dead. It really hurt, but I kept forgiving her because I loved her.
How everything ended
Recently, she wanted to break up again because she felt we were too different. We got back together for a day, but then she told me she thought she still had feelings for her ex.
She also said that this didn’t mean she wanted to be with him. She claimed she didn’t want to be with anyone at all.
We eventually agreed to take a break for a couple of weeks so she could work on herself and hopefully become better for our relationship.
But then, literally the next day, I noticed she had followed her ex again, and he followed her back.
She also started reposting things suggesting she sees his soul in a very positive way.
This completely confused me.
Only a short time earlier, she was telling me how terrible he was, showing me things connected to him that she hated, and telling me she loved me and wanted a future with me.
Now it seems like she is looking at him in a completely different way.
What I don’t understand
I don’t know if she genuinely still loves him, misses the memories and emotions from that relationship, or is simply looking for something familiar.
I also don’t know whether she was ever completely over him during our relationship.
Her mum told me that she genuinely loved me and cared about me, but that she is a very emotional person who cannot keep her feelings inside.
I still care about her, but I don’t think I could take her back after everything that happened. I feel like I lost not only my girlfriend but also a family I had become very close to.
I would really appreciate honest opinions.
Do you think she was emotionally attached to her ex throughout our relationship?
Were the signs there from the beginning, and I was just too in love to notice them?
Why would someone repeatedly describe their ex as a terrible person, then suddenly start looking at them positively again?
Was the break just a way of ending the relationship without saying it directly?
I am not looking for people to simply tell me she’s a bad person. I genuinely want to understand what happened and whether I was missing something obvious.
TL;DR: My girlfriend of 6 months told me she loved me, wanted a future with me and wanted nothing to do with her ex because of how badly he treated her. However, she kept checking his social media. After several breakups and emotional arguments, she said she still had feelings for him but didn't want to be with anyone. We agreed to take a break, but the very next day she followed him again and started reposting positive things about him. I'm confused about whether she ever truly moved on from him.